4 ms·
There are only two problems with that idea: 1. HIPAA can't be easily pronounced; it is obviously incompatible with the normal rules of English spelling. 2. Pe
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
There are only two problems with that idea:
1. HIPAA can't be easily pronounced; it is obviously incompatible with the normal rules of English spelling.
2. People pronounce CIA letter by letter.
- Dylan16807 5y ago> HIPAA can't be easily pronounced Most people don't seem to agree with you. > People pronounce CIA letter by letter. It's only three letters, it's hard to know what sound the C would make, and pronouncing an acronym with only one consonant is a bit iffy for clarity. Those are small factors but they add up. HIPAA has the double A acting against pronouncing it, but everything else pushes toward pronouncing and not worrying about that part.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> It's only three letters, it's hard to know what sound the C would make, and pronouncing an acronym with only one consonant is a bit iffy for clarity. Those are small factors but they add up. URL? I can't keep this up, but I'm being limited more by my acronym vocabulary than by any tendency for people to avoid pronouncing them letter by letter. >> HIPAA can't be easily pronounced > Most people don't seem to agree with you. This is how we started the thread, by observing that people have enormous problems spelling HIPAA because they believe the spelling should correspond to the pronunciation. A precondition for this observation is that the spelling isn't being pronounced.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> This is how we started the thread, by observing that people have enormous problems spelling HIPAA because they believe the spelling should correspond to the pronunciation People who read HIPAA have no problem pronouncing it. People who hear hɪpɑː sometimes have trouble spelling it, coming up with “HIPPA” instead of “HIPAA” (this often isn’t because it is the most natural read of the phonetics, but because they back-figure the acronym from the best-known focus of the law as “Health Insurance Privacy Protection Act” rather than “Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act”.)
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> People who hear hɪpɑː This is the second time you've claimed that people say /hɪpɑː/. But they don't.
- Dylan16807 5y agoI can't tell what you're suggesting about "URL", can you be specific?
- thaumasiotes 5y agoURL is only three letters, like CIA, but everything else you said about CIA doesn't apply. There is no ambiguity as to how it would sound, and there are multiple consonants. Thus, there is no adding up to be done.
- Dylan16807 5y agoI meant multiple separate consonants. And I very occasionally hear people pronounce it, so it seems like URL is somewhat borderline. Compared to URL, HIPAA is pretty close on effort to pronounce, and double the effort to say the letters.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> HIPAA can’t be easily pronounced; it is obviously incompatible with the normal rules of English spelling. It can be easily pronounced, it is easily pronounced, and its not at all incompatible with the “rules” of English spelling.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThe rules of English spelling don't allow for the sequence "aa" at all. That's why the scrabble list consists of (in small part) onomatopoetic expressions of variable duration, where repeating the "a" shows longer duration, and (mostly) foreign words.