9 ms·
Understanding the global chip shortages
- papito 5y agoI am also curious as to the chip demand by major cloud providers. COVID accelerated migration to the cloud, I have heard numbers from "cloud people" as much as 5x.
- reactspa 5y ago<deleted>
- silisili 5y agoFor a billion dollars, you're not getting anything latest and greatest. And you're definitely not going to get anything in the timeframe of the chip shortage. I applaud the effort, but feel like it's just going to be people taking advantage of the money for no net benefit.
- throwaway9870 5y agoNot sure $1B is enough to move the needle in this market.
- baybal2 5y ago5 years ago, maybe. Today, no. Even 30-40 years old 2nd hand equipment is completely impossible to find now. Equipment once sold for scrap, or simply thrown away is now sold for more that it was new.
- unmole 5y agoWhy do you think this is relevant?
- bunnie 5y agoI was on a panel with one of the study's authors recently, she's very thoughtful, thorough, and precise. I like how she emphasized that there is no simple TL;DR to explain the situation, and her paper does a good job of covering a lot of ground without taking short cuts. However, one factor not mentioned in the study is that China, which had announced a plan for foundry independence, had its capacity expansion program disrupted by the trade war, as the US restricted China's ability to acquire key equipment to build out fabs. As a result China could not build the plants it needed to meet its own consumption, forcing them to buy chips from the same vendors that everyone else is also trying to buy chips from. This is an additional shock which is hard to estimate in magnitude but it's probably not small as it represents the missing capacity of entire fabs for many months or years as they struggle to be built. Thus while the US trade policy may have effectively hamstrung China's plans for foundry independence in the short term, it may also have contributed to a global shortage of semiconductors and its own inflation problems as collateral damage. Trade wars are tricky: without careful and long term policy planning there is a high risk of even more collateral damage. Another factor that could also be contributing specifically to the difficulties of the automotive supply chain is that China internally had made electric vehicles a strategic technology focus, which means that domestically China's demand for automotive-grade semiconductors was set to surge. Even before the pandemic I was getting tips from buyers that power semiconductors, particularly those in SiC and GaN, were going to be in short supply, due to that shift. edit - emphasized original paper
- topspin 5y agoHow does your view comport with the fact that the supply shortages did not actually begin with the trade war or the pandemic? The problem worsened, certainly, but global stock of components had been tight for years before any of these supposed causes. If fault must be found with the US it is in the consolidation and outsourcing of manufacturing to a small number of manufacturers, removing competitors and excess capacity from the supply chain. China's part has simply been to grow; creating consumers and thus demand for products that it had previously not consumed.
- CamperBob2 5y agoAbsolutely none of this was a problem before the Trump sanctions took effect (which we can now call the "Biden sanctions," as he has done nothing to revert them.) There were occasional shortages of things like MLCC capacitors, some of them severe, but nothing as far-reaching as what we've been seeing. It is fairly clear that we'd still be in trouble absent the "easy to win" trade war against China, though. COVID alone would have been enough to upset the proverbial apple cart.
- OJFord 5y ago> before the Trump sanctions took effect (which we can now call the "Biden sanctions," as he has done nothing to revert them.) Surely at this point if not before you can just call them US sanctions, why party-politicise it? Just my 'two pence' as an outsider!
- the-dude 5y agoI disagree. Some of Trumps policies were ridiculed by the same people who now have the power and choose to continue the exact same policies. In some cases even more extreme. Keeping history within view helps to view current events in perspective. Reagan was ridiculed as well. He did a pretty good job at guiding the end of the cold war into a remarkably non-eventful event ( this could be worded better, not a native speaker ).
- baybal2 5y agoThe biggest skeleton in the room was barely mentioned once. Chip shortage, or, better say, capacity shortage for affordable nodes been there for 5-7 years, and nobody really gave it much notice. Lead times for average 180nm project were 12 months+ for last 5 years. There is still a stratospheric gap in between "common man fab service," and the realm of multi-million dollar semi companies, who can afford service on relatively new, (and not decades old) equipment. All significant chips which went into shortage were using that "common man fab process" on eighties, and nineties era equipment.
- bsder 5y ago> All significant chips which went into shortage were using that "common man fab process" on eighties, and nineties era equipment. I don't think I agree with that. A LOT of small microcontrollers went into allocation and they were on 120nm, 90nm, and 65nm processes. However, I do agree that there really was a shortage even before Covid and nobody cared. Effectively--nobody builds a line for an older node, ever. And there has been a lot of consolidation and sales of facilities such that very few people have been building fabs below 90nm. The number of fabs built in the 2010's that aren't TSMC, Intel, or Samsung is pretty minimal.
- raverbashing 5y agoNow that the nm race is getting to a halt, I think that maybe there's a point of picking an older node and focusing on that for volume parts 65nm? 90nm? 180nm? I'd argue that the processes can be improved and cost can probably come down compared to the older machines. I'm old enough to remember when 180nm chips were the fastest ones.
- nwiswell 5y ago> 65nm? 90nm? 180nm? I'd argue that the processes can be improved and cost can probably come down compared to the older machines. This is really dubious for two reasons. First, you can do a die shrink and fit many, many more equivalent chips onto a single wafer at a modern node. This is somewhat mitigated by the high cost of mask sets at modern nodes -- but there's just no way it would ever make economic sense to build capacity at 180nm. Second, the equipment for old nodes is not made anymore. It's cheap, but that's only because there's ample supply on the secondary market. If fabs began to get restarted in earnest at old nodes, that supply would quickly evaporate. Then you would have to buy modern (expensive!) equipment -- at which point why not take advantage of its full potential? Wafer throughput is the same regardless of whether you're making 100 chips per wafer at 180nm or 10,000 at 22nm.
- leptoniscool 5y agoAccording to standard economic theory, shortages only happen when pricing mechanisms fail. If prices rise, then demand would lower and shortage will be resolved (?)..
- mtsr 5y agoThat only works for non-essentials. So this could mean that many essential products have come to depend on chips and so demand can only drop so far.
- fivea 5y ago> According to standard economic theory, shortages only happen when pricing mechanisms fail. No, not it isn't. That assertion is fundamentally wrong at many levels. It seems you're confusing the intro to economics definition of equilibrium between supply and demand with your own definition of shortage. However, in the process you're making the mistake of believing somehow that pricing out demand from the market and being unable to scale up production to meet demand does not involve any shortages of any kind. Think about it for a second: I'd suddenly food prices skyrocketed to the point a single 1kg bag of rice sold for over €100, and most of the world was thus unable to buy food for being priced out of the market, would that represent a shortage even if some people could still afford it?
- leptoniscool 5y agoWhen prices "skyrocket", it becomes profitable to use a lot more expensive means to produce (eg: using nuclear energy to grow rice indoors), this will quickly increase supply. For microchips, it's likely the prices have not increased enough to kickstart this increase in supply.
- JoachimS 5y agoThe prices may be there, but that does not mean supply is able to pick up. There are non-monetary barriers to entry the market. Knowledge, access to tools and materials, permits from gov agencies, source of water, power etc. And the time scale to establish new capacity from scratch is many years to a decade or more. Look at the capacity build up in China. It has taken decades, and that is with all the power of the nation, and in some cases loose on regulations regarding IP rights.
- Kliment 5y agoI work in this industry. Nobody is producing significantly more as a result of covid or anything else. Aggregate demand for electronics products has increased a bit, but it's not a significant change. The "skyrocketing demand" mentioned in this paper is not for electronics products, but for their components, and it's happening entirely due to a lack of visibility into future availability and demand, or, to put it more simply, a lack of confidence in the market. Device manufacturers are buying as much as they can because they don't know when they'll be able to buy again. Component manufacturers are not expanding production because they don't know when the rush buying will end and everyone will produce from stockpiled material. This is primarily a confidence problem (caused primarily by automotive manufacturers being absolute shits to their suppliers). The total production volumes of electronic devices have not increased by any significant amount. Many manufacturers are actually producing less now than pre-pandemic, simply because they can't produce more due to shortages.
- rocqua 5y agoI have read, regarding the GPU shortage, that silicon wafers are in short supply. Is that true? If so, how does it square with actual component production not rising? Are people that high in the supply-chain stockpiling silicon?
- Kliment 5y agoComponent production cannot profitably increase because there is no increased total demand. Everyone is buying everything they can just to make sure they can produce, but they're not actually producing more. Component producers know this and that at some point this artificial demand due to stockpiling will fall off a cliff, and they'll be left sitting on underutilized massively expensive production equipment if they increase volumes. Besides, with the current stockpile-driven demand they can ask higher prices. This is why component production is not, and will not, rise. GPU shortages are driven by a number of factors, and almost none of them are to do with component production (or wafers). There's a big scalper problem for GPUs, where some assholes will buy every GPU they can find and then resell them at a huge markup to either (increasingly desperate) end users and system integrators, or, increasingly, to cryptofuckers who will pay much more than legitimate users to ride their bubble. This means that even if there's plenty of production, unless the production can outspend the scalpers' total capital, it's all going to be swallowed up. There's no general wafer shortage, but the highest grade wafers that get used in the highest end production have long lead times (because the fabs that use them reserve them way ahead of time). Wafer availability is not a bottleneck since the smallest nodes have such low capacity to start with. What has happened is that wafers have gone up in price in response to the general stockpiling behavior, but the high end stuff (including high-end GPUs) don't care as the wafer cost is basically negligible to them compared to all the process costs.
- lbriner 5y agoIsn't the way to bolster the market to avoid the crazy 8nm stuff and just buy into the industry at the large scales. I can't imagine that buying or building machines to build op amps or voltage regulators isn't within the reach of lots of manufacturers. I assume that this would allow the advanced manufacturers to concentrate on the newest tech unless the shortages are only at the cutting edge? I once heard a major blockage was also the number of companies who had the skill to build machines that build semiconductors was low and therefore prices and leadtimes are high but again, someone who already makes high precision stuff building the lower size fabs must be doable?
- mschuster91 5y ago> I can't imagine that buying or building machines to build op amps or voltage regulators isn't within the reach of lots of manufacturers. The thing is, these things used to be built all over the place. However, consolidation, environmental concerns (the Silicon Valley is one of the US' most polluted areas due to decades of semiconductor manufacture) and market forces have destroyed lots of the capacity that used to exist, and now everyone is stuck and waiting. Not to mention that the people who operated the old fabs are gone for good, either in pension or in completely different careers. Bringing the old fabs back or constructing new ones will take years. Capitalism is great for driving down costs in peace times, but usually the cost-saving comes at the cost (sic) of losing resilience in crisis times, and forget about "perfect storm" events like the one we're currently seeing with corona, coin miners, the shift towards electric mobility and the Chinese saber-rattling against Taiwan.
- dinnozaoor 5y agoShorter version why there is shortage of everything right now, including chips: https://schiffgold.com/peters-podcast/peter-schiff-too-much-money-not-enough-stuff/ https://schiffgold.com/peters-podcast/peter-schiff-too-much-...
- evancoop 5y agoSeems like an issue of incentives at varying scales. A private business has an incentive to produce the quantity demanded and nothing more. Surplus is a cost, and capacity should be designed to meet, not exceed demand. Then, a stress appears on the system, and shortages occur. A government has an incentive to avoid shortages of specific products and resources. In some industries, this leads to, essentially, a promise to purchase the supply the market does not (agriculture). Does a similar model need to apply hereafter to certain technological inputs?
- bluGill 5y agoActually capacity is designed to meet the highest demand and scale down for slow times. My company has seen lines go from 100% capacity and turning away customers one year to 20% capacity filling all orders. It is murder on our suppliers and so the most important question we ask when sourcing a new part is can the supplier keep their doors open if we make no orders for two years, yet still meet our peek demand? The reality of the business cycle is on everyone, though some see it worse than others.
- xadhominemx 5y agoI can’t download the pdf but PCs are 15% of global semiconductor demand and the second largest electronics end market (after smartphones). After a decade of stagnant growth, PC sales are are now 40% above pre-pandemic levels. The semiconductor industry does not operate with a lot of slack, and this sort of step-change demand in a single large end market sucks up a lot of that slack capacity by itself. Then of course you have elevated demand and improved mix of overall goods, strong corporate investment cycle, low inventories entering the pandemic, and delayed semiconductor capacity investments from the trade war / inventory downcycle in early 2019 through to late 2020…