15 ms·
Imminent merger of a supermassive black hole binary
- perihelions 5y agoFurther discussion and context: https://www.science.org/content/article/crash-titans-imminent-merger-giant-black-holes-predicted https://www.science.org/content/article/crash-titans-imminen...
- dylan604 5y agoJust the other day in another unrelated thread, someone posted a youtube video that introduced me to a new channel. Just today I was watching one of the videos that discusses black hole mergers: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJLtT0QXoPo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJLtT0QXoPo
- dylan604 5y agoAfter reading this article, it sounds like another group of researchers are throwing shade saying there's some jumping to conclusions based on very little observational data. It's funny to see the competitive nature between groups. The one thing I took from this article though was that the instrument we have built specifcally to detect gravitational waves won't even be effective for this level of event as it is "tuned" for different type of events.
- wrycoder 5y agoAstronomers are highly competitive. Read “Einstein’s Shadow”by Seth Fletcher. It’s a current book about the attempt to image a black hole.
- dylan604 5y agoI understand the rush to be first. I was going with funny haha not funny strange as the groups from competing theories just can't stand it when the other theory gets some spotlight attention. I can't imagine picking a theory and making your entire life about proving/solving that theory only to find out you were wrong! Not like move a decimal over wrong, but up the wrong tree wrong.
- wrycoder 5y agoLike CAGW, for example.
- fiter 5y agoIf you mean "Catastrophic Anthropogenic Global Warming", then that's probably the least bad way to be wrong. Because when you're wrong at least the world will be better off. Like betting against your own team: if they lose you win and if they win you don't mind losing.
- dtgriscom 5y ago> it is "tuned" for different type of events. Gravity wave detectors are sensitive to ranges of frequencies, just as electromagnetic wave detectors are. For instance, LIGO is sensitive to gravity waves in the range of 7kHz down to 30Hz. The gravity waves from this merger would be at far lower frequencies/longer wavelengths.
- mlindner 5y agoNot to jump to conclusions too much but I've recently been seeing a lot of "fake science news" out of China lately. Seeing gelatin on the moon, seeing a "house" on the moon, and now this.
- dylan604 5y agoAny time "imminent" is used in astronomy, you have to remember 1 million years is imminient when speaking about the universe. So for them to say "within 3 years" that's like go get the popcorn, you don't want to miss it level warning!
- PaulHoule 5y agoIt's what we call "multi-messenger astronomy" In this case they are going to see gravitational waves but much much more.
- senectus1 5y agonot to mention that its probably already happened :-P
- ridgeguy 5y ago...for certain relative values of "already"...
- jjeaff 5y agoThat's what I thought when I read it. But then on second thought, has it really happened yet if nothing can exceed the speed of light? Time and space are intertwined. So if the light hasn't arrived yet, has reality really arrived yet?
- dreamcompiler 5y agoThis is...exactly right. You could say "it's already happened" as a first approximation but this isn't really true because the statement implicitly assumes there is some kind of universal "now" that can be used as a reference point for timing things. No such universal "now" exists. That's why the question "What's happening right now on Mars?" makes no physical sense. "Now" is a function of both when and where you're standing. The question "What's happening right now on the other side of my living room?" also doesn't make any physical sense. But the difference between reality and our perception of it is less easily detectable in that case.
- stevespang 5y ago
- taneq 5y agoI've been wondering about the "last parsec problem" ever since I read about it but this prompted me to look it up. Turns out the reason it's actually possible for black holes to actually merge instead of just orbiting each other forever is "dynamical friction" (basically as a black hole moves through a bunch of stars or other masses, its gravity pulls them inwards so that the stars it's already passed tend to be more directly behind it than the stars in front of it, so the net force on the black hole is backwards.) The more you know.
- dylan604 5y ago>The more you know. The more questions you have ;-)
- blueprint 5y agoNot necessarily. Besides, if that were the case, you would lose the ability to say you've learned anything at all... which, sadly, is also a self-contradiction. Only someone who knows can make such statements, another self-contradiction, so they wouldn't say them either. If you look in practical cases, people who really master a subject don't seem to have many questions left at all. The real problem is humans have not mastered physics yet.
- dylan604 5y agoThat's like saying you took the first step up a ladder so there's no point in continuing to the next step. That just doesn't follow. Now, you just know you need to know more. The unknown unknowns become the known unknowns so you can learn to make the unknowns known.
- blueprint 5y agoI am saying the precise opposite of that. Saying that you, at your supposed low level, know that you only get more questions the more you learn, is exactly such a statement as you are claiming I am making. From another perspective, the statement sounds like an excuse for not reaching a higher level of mastery that the person admits they don't know humans are capable of. It's a self-contradiction. Thanks for all the downvotes, y'all! Definitely didn't trigger anyone.
- indigodaddy 5y agoTldr anyone? I’m afraid I’m not even nearly smart enough for the abstract..
- Victerius 5y agoScientists predict that a pair of supermassive black holes will merge together sometimes within the next three years.
- yucky 5y ago...and what does that mean for earthlings?
- dak1 5y agoscience will happen
- perihelions 5y agoDo you own stock in any industry near the galactic core of SDSSJ1430+2303? You might want to sell that while we're still outside the causal lightcone. Unfortunately this is probably all mostly priced in by now. The opposite of HFT is ULFT: stock trading on a gigayear timescale outliving the typical planetary civilization. Its biggest enemy is inflation -- meaning cosmological inflation, that nasty phenomenon tearing the universe apart and doing a number on intergalactic shipping indices. To quote an extremely recent earthling philosopher: intergalactic trade grows strong when elderly hominids plant {untranslatable #32} in whose {untranslatable #993} they know they shall never {untranslatable #440}.
- cmckn 5y agoTo save you a click: ~3 years.
- riskneutral 5y agoThe "imminent" event actually took place 1.2 billion years ago, which is how many light years away the the galaxy in question is (SDSSJ1430+2303).
- josephagoss 5y agoThis is insane! Between 100 days and 3 years we will record what will be the single largest energy release we have ever recorded. To give an idea of our records so far: our detection of black hole mergers around the 100-150 solar masses scale are just behind a couple gamma ray bursts as the single largest energy release ever. How big are the black hole mergers around 150 solar masses and the two largest gamma ray bursts? The energy release converted the mass of between 1-6 solar masses into energy. With black hole mergers this energy release/conversion is in the form of gravitational waves that we then detect! So imagine the sun, times 6, every atom, converted into that energy. That’s what we have already recorded. This predicted one is not even in the same ballpark. Those 1-6 sun matter into energy conversions are ants compared to what’s coming. These supermassive black holes are thousands to tens of thousands of times the mass of our sun. (Not sure if the ones in this paper are in the billion solar masses class. Yes they do exist) This event will convert the mass of perhaps a hundred or a thousand suns worth of matter into energy in an instant. (Not sure if the paper gives any accurate predictions I’m lazy!)
- dylan604 5y ago>This is insane! You say insane, these guys say, "no, perfectly sane and expected. We have a model predicting it." But I know what you actually meant! ;-)
- ______-_-______ 5y agoWill any of this energy be visible to the naked eye from Earth?
- TheDesolate0 5y ago
- dylan604 5y agoDepends on where it is located for line of sight. If it's on the other side of the center of our Milky Way galactic core, then it won't be visible in visible light (awkwardly stated). The overall brightness and/or the thick bands of dust prohibit us from seeing some things in the visible spectrum on that side of the galaxy. However, some things can be viewed with other wavelengths.
- gammarator 5y agoSome caution is warranted here. AGN have “red-noise” variability that can produce signals that look periodic. There have been lots of similar claims that fizzled. Thankfully this one will become clear soon.
- gmuslera 5y agoThe headline looked like something taken from Greg Egan's Diaspora, but what happened there was far closer and with just neutron stars. Anyway, it was pretty dramatic for the not-so-nearby solar systems, I wonder what means an event like this for good part of the galaxy where it happens.
- labster 5y agoThese mergers are getting ridiculous. Where is the antitrust investigation? Surely some heavenly body should have oversight.
- mdrzn 5y agoMade me chuckle. Reading the title I was half sure this was about galaxies, it could have easily been a "merger" of "binaries" from different companies lol
- ur-whale 5y agoWhich constellation will that take place in?
- aruggirello 5y agoBoötes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SDSS_J1430%2B2303 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SDSS_J1430%2B2303
- saargrin 5y agosounds like one of those events that wipe out civilizations across a multi thousand light years sphere its scary to even imagine a disaster of this scale
- dylan604 5y agoIt's not like there hasn't be warnings for like millions of years. However, just like on Earth where there are people with plenty of advanced notice about hurricanes that decide they are just going to ride it out, I could see some ignoring these warnings as well. "I've lived next to this volcano/merging black holes for my entire life, as my family before me. Nothing has ever happened." Until it does.
- aruggirello 5y ago“There’s no point in acting surprised about it. All the planning charts and demolition orders have been on display at your local planning department in Alpha Centauri for 50 of your Earth years, so you’ve had plenty of time to lodge any formal complaint and it’s far too late to start making a fuss about it now. … What do you mean you’ve never been to Alpha Centauri? Oh, for heaven’s sake, mankind, it’s only four light years away, you know. I’m sorry, but if you can’t be bothered to take an interest in local affairs, that’s your own lookout. Energize the demolition beams.”
- MikeDelta 5y agoNot sure what the distance is to the source, but it is good to realize that us observing the event is only imminent; the event itself happened already many years ago (thousands, millions?) and the signal has been travelling all those years to its very curious audience.
- amelius 5y agoIs the FTC ok with this merger?
- aruggirello 5y ago> SDSSJ143016.05+230344.4 (hereafter SDSSJ1430+2303) is known as a Seyfert 1 galaxy at redshift 0.08105 https://astro.ucla.edu/~wright/CosmoCalc.html https://astro.ucla.edu/~wright/CosmoCalc.html says this galaxy is ~1.1 Gly, so "not exactly close" whatever that means on a cosmic scale. Intriguingly, this event took place when life on Earth barely existed at all... Edit: at 1,5x10¹¹ solar masses, the galaxy is not at all small (and neither are the BH involved!!!) it's in the same ballpark of the Milky Way.