18 ms·
> These people seem incapable of understanding the existential threat to free society and democracy posed by limiting everyone's ability to communicate private
by kragen 5y ago
> These people seem incapable of understanding the existential threat to free society and democracy posed by limiting everyone's ability to communicate private thoughts.
The existential threat this bill poses to free society and democracy is exactly why they're supporting it. It's not some accidental side effect.
They're opposed to the existence of free society and democracy because it limits government power, which means letting criminals and terrorists run free. They want the police to have all the power they can get because, as far as they're concerned, they're the good guys, and giving the good guys more power helps them win against the bad guys.
Free society means limited government, and the only way for the government to be in favor of that is for the government to vote against its own interests. That requires the people in the government to identify more strongly with the people living under the government than with the government itself. This is precarious at the best of times. Why would the governing party want to make it easy to organize dissenting political parties and alternative centers of power? Power might fall into the wrong hands.
I know that sounds sarcastic, but try to see it from their perspective, even if you don't agree with it.
- treis 5y agoWe had a free society and democracy before the internet.
- kelnos 5y agoIn theory, but often the level of freeness, and your access to democracy, depended on the color of your skin or your gender. (Which is still the case today, to a great extent, but it was even worse 30, 50, 70, 100, etc. years ago.)
- pixl97 5y agoThere were many attempts by the same people to monitor phone and mail communications.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoThe international standards do just fine for enabling spying. Take Call Line Identification (CLI) aka Caller ID. Any device plugged into the ptsn phone system which can display caller id has to have v23 dial up modem protocol facilities. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID#Regional_differences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caller_ID#Regional_differences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITU_V.23 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITU_V.23 This means _anyone_ with access to the ptsn can upload malicious firmware to a telephone, ATA gataway or dialup modem if the hardware is designed to allow it, & firmware space permitting! I do find govt legislation somewhat lacking though, for example porn sites now have to have "are you 18 or over", but social media like reddit or twitter does not and regularly on reddit illegal porn (child & animal) is making the front page of reddit before moderators take it down. Social media sites like reddit or twitter are exempt from the 18year old porn checks because the porn content is not the bulk of their content, it covers many things like jokes, darwin awards, Karens having a psychotic episode and other things like that. So would parents want their kids seeing illegal porn or mental health breakdowns on social media sites like Reddit, Twitter, Facebook/Whatsapp groups because the current legislation allows the "are you 18 or over" checks to not be applied to facebook, reddit, twitter, whatsapp and other social media platforms? I know the flip side argument for illegal content is its supposedly stopping an adult from doing it to a child, but I'm not convinced on that point considering how many parents and siblings are behind child abuse and dont post online, but use fraternal networks like the masons and religious organisations to abuse under the pretence of teaching people life lessons! The religious stance, at least new testament, is to prevent the spread of STD's and to avoid mental health issue when cognitive dissonance sets in during middle age, but Govt's and education needs to tackle this problem to avoid people being exploited through lack of knowledge of the law, because the whole population doesnt even get taught a TLDR of law for life which makes it possible for clever people to exploit less knowledgeable people, which isnt on in my books either.
- tomc1985 5y ago> reddit or twitter does not and regularly on reddit illegal porn (child & animal) is making the front page of reddit before moderators take it down. I am on reddit multiple times a day for years and I have never seen this happen.
- kragen 5y agoYes, intermediating so much of our society through the internet has made it extremely vulnerable. The internet offers would-be totalitarians a temptation of pervasive surveillance that goes far beyond what the Stasi could ever have dreamed of. Free society and democracy are not likely to survive another decade, although they will probably be born again later in a new form.
- whatshisface 5y agoNot really, no, not with the media deciding what everybody heard. We had as much of a free society as convenience combined with the interests of every individual running TV news allowed. It was a complex system and I wouldn't want to describe it all here, but the fact that you and I can talk to each other in front of anyone who wants to listen in, is far ahead of anything that existed then.
- treis 5y ago>Not really, no, What? You're really arguing that, to put a year on it, in 1990 we didn't have a free society and democracy?
- pessimizer 5y agoYes. I don't even know what you're talking about when you say "free society." It sounds like a weird mantra. edit: maybe if you say it 3x fast I wouldn't have had to have vaccinations to attend public school when I was a kid?
- whatshisface 5y agoI don't think we have ever had the kind of free society or democracy people think of when they say "we have a free society and a democracy." From jailing anti-war protestors (WWI) to jailing anti-war protestors (Vietnam) to allowing corporations to put serious, nearly life-ruining heat on whistleblowers, to the way the media largely operates by uncritically republishing press releases and communiques, I would say it's pretty clear that we're living in a closely managed society with a severely manipulated democratic process.
- kragen 5y agoIt's a continuum. Just because Gary Webb "committed suicide" with multiple gunshot wounds to the head doesn't mean the CIA in the 01990s was just as unaccountable as Beria's NKVD, much less just as oppressive. Dan Rather's CBS Evening News was no Wikileaks, much less Wikipedia, but it wasn't Pravda either. Serpico got shot in the face for being the first honest cop in the US, but you could still do business in New York without paying all your profits out to the cops. People in Peoria had enormous freedom in 01930, 01960, and even 01990 that people in Minsk, Shanghai, and Alexandria just didn't. Today we enjoy many freedoms nobody had in 01990, largely thanks to the internet, but those freedoms are probably not going to last much longer, also thanks to the internet.
- nirav72 5y agoYou must not have been around when the government was pushing for backdoors on Telecom products in the 1990s. Before the internet was a thing for most people.
- oceanghost 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipper_chip https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipper_chip
- nirav72 5y agoThank you. I was trying recall the technology being pushed at the time that would have allowed the NSA to have a backdoor.
- kragen 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Assistance_for_Law_Enforcement_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communications_Assistance_for_... actually passed in 01994.
- omeze 5y agoSort of. Look up Western Unions role in the 1876 US election[1]. Stolen communications to support a specific candidate and a compromise between political parties on military presence sounds like a very precarious position for free society to be in. [1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/05/how-the-robber-barons-hijacked-the-victorian-internet/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2011/05/how-the-robber-b... (also referenced in Tim Wu’s The Master Switch)
- cnelsenmilt 5y agoOne way to look at it then is that we have dealt with similar issues before and survived.
- pooper 5y agoNot really. I mean logically would you also play Russian roulette repeatedly with no payout just because you haven't died yet?
- BurningFrog 5y agoActually, no one involved in the 1876 US election survived.
- vore 5y agoWell, as they say, "past performance is no guarantee of future returns".
- pyuser583 5y agoI heard a story that at the 1864 National Union (Republican) Convention, there was a bunch of haggling about who would be Abraham Lincolns VP. A telegram was sent offering the position to a well liked military officer named William Rosecrans. Roseceans agreed, and sent a telegram back. But the telegram never made it. It’s assumed the Secretary of War used his censorship powers to prevent it from reaching its destination. The result 18 months later was President Andrew Johnson.
- pessimizer 5y agoIs this sarcasm?
- vkou 5y agoDepends on whether or not one believes that we live in a free, democratic society today. In many ways, yes, we do, in many others, no, we don't.
- EarlKing 5y agoWe had a society in which all media was controlled by a handful of corporations who dictated what people saw and thought. That is not by any means a free society. Then along came Bulletin Board Systems and then the Internet, and all that changed. Legislation like the EARN IT Act is meant to turn back the clock to silence the voice of the people so that, once again, only the voice of the bourgeoisie can be heard.
- CRConrad 5y ago> We had a society in which all media was controlled by a handful of corporations who dictated what people saw and thought. And we still do. Some of the corporations have changed, some are the same. What else is new? > That is not by any means a free society. And it still isn't. No "EARN IT Act" needed for that.
- mgerdts 5y agoI believe that the period you refer to had local newspapers, tv stations, and radio stations that were largely independent from this handful of corporations (ABC, CBS, NBC?). During this period, there was limited opportunity to perform population-wide surveillance on the discussion of this coverage. In those days your TV tended not to be equipped with technology that could report what you watched.
- ipaddr 5y agoIn those local markets you had reporters who were friends with those in power and very little got reported.
- jackcosgrove 5y agoI think it's fair to say that pre-internet, there were fewer media voices but there were a lot, lot fewer attempts at surveillance.
- thomassmith65 5y agoThen along came Bulletin Board Systems and then the Internet, and all that changed. No BBS ever changed diddly squat. Even the internet had minimal impact on politics until the 2000's. The entire comment just sounds like speculation about a time that is, in fact, fairly recent history. We had a society in which all media was controlled by a handful of corporations who dictated what people saw and thought. That only makes sense if you ignore all sorts of pivotal historical events (eg: uprisings and revolutions). Not that I disagree that populist internet media are really contributing to the betterment of mankind /s
- notriddle 5y agoIf the government has the benefits of the internet, and no one else does, isn’t society less free than if no one has it?
- throwhauser 5y ago> We had a free society and democracy before the internet. But if the internet had been developed earlier, we would have debated something like this in the past.
- wayoutthere 5y agoSome of us did. America has never been a free and Democratic society for all, and we’re actually closer to achieving that than ever if you’re not white/straight/upper-middle class, which is why they’re so desperate to push this bill through. The government had de-facto control of all mass media before the internet. They could control the narrative to a degree they didn’t need tight surveillance. They lost control of that with the internet and are desperate to get it back.
- defiUs88 5y ago
- stjohnswarts 5y agoYes, but if you shut down the most "free" information platform, and make it only free to those who are rich enough to pay for anonymity then you are doing aggregious harm to democracy and freedom. Perhaps moreso that anyone has ever done in human history. Look no further than China to see the wrong way of doing things and that is precisely what this bill seeks to do. It is not to "protect the children" it is to protect the elite power centers from criticism and transparency by forcing you to open up all your secrets and communications to them to judge and eliminate the challenges and criticisms of their power under the guise of "law and order".
- akomtu 5y agoThe gov isnt worried about criminals or terrorists: those guys are easy to deal with. The gov is worried about organised protests, like those canadian truckers, because protesters are protected by laws. Encrypted communications is an obvious enabler of such protests.
- pessimizer 5y agoThe individuals in the government are worried about all threats. Canadian truckers are certainly one of them, but not a very important one other than they gum up commerce and may eventually develop into a riot.
- withinboredom 5y agoCriminals and terrorists don’t use public comms to communicate (at least the smart ones). They use dead drops, trusted couriers, and in-person talking. Protestors by default must communicate in the open, and to each other. They are much more disorganized.
- kragen 5y agoThe smart criminals and terrorists are generally the ones working for the government.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kragen 5y agoOf course they're worried about criminals and terrorists, as well as protests; nobody wants to watch their children die in a home invasion or a burning skyscraper, not even politicians, and nobody wants habitual violent criminals to repeatedly victimize innocent people (unless they identify strongly with the criminals). Peaceful protests can be a powerful instrument for change, including taking away government power, but only when the protestors are willing to die for their cause. Every day, police officers and prosecutors go to work and spend much of the day worrying about criminals, and a few of them are assigned to worry about terrorists too. When they go home, they have to keep worrying about criminals, too, because their job makes them tempting targets for revenge. I'm not saying people don't seek employment as police officers and prosecutors in order to have free reign for their sadistic urges --- they do --- but that's not the majority and it's never the whole story. Terrorism can have extremely large effects, just not desirable ones. When the people think the government is doing a bad enough job of protecting them from criminals, terrorists, and protests, that government is at high risk of losing its power entirely, which is something almost nobody in the government wants. Even anarchists often don't want it, because there's no guarantee that what replaces the government will be better. You may not like the FBI, but if the alternative is the Proud Boys, better the devil you know. Remember who won the elections after the overthrows of Mubarak, the Shah, and the Tsar.
- emmelaich 5y agoWith the paranoidal view you're placing yourself outside the realms of sensible discussion. You can't really think that some politicians are knowingly and deliberating proposing an existential threat to "free society and democracy."
- beebeepka 5y agoInteresting. How would you describe the situation?
- t-3 5y ago> You can't really think that some politicians are knowingly and deliberating proposing an existential threat to "free society and democracy." Why not? Many people oppose free society, and democracy has never been popular among elites.
- emmelaich 5y agoOK I should have changed 'some politicians' to 'most of those politicians proposing this law'
- dotnet00 5y agoIf you mean to say that the ones who aren't knowingly doing this to weaken democracy are simply useful idiots, yeah, you're right. Most of them probably aren't malicious, they're likely just entirely ignorant and easily manipulated, making them just as bad as the malicious ones, given their job is supposed to be to make informed decisions for the benefit of their constituents.
- bejelentkezni 5y agoWhy not?
- rgbrenner 5y agoThere are politicians that support the overthrow of US democracy and the instatement of a dictator. A really obvious example: Michael Flynn, the former national security advisor. He's said the US military should overthrow the government. Literally.. those are the words from his mouth. Im not going to list a bunch of politicians... but Flynn will say it outright. So your assumption is clearly wrong.
- guy98238710 5y ago> They want the police to have all the power they can get because, as far as they're concerned, they're the good guys, and giving the good guys more power helps them win against the bad guys. But we all know that giving excessive power to good guys turns them rather reliably into bad guys.
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoYeah but it always looks different if that power is going to be in your hands. Or maybe it doesn't and they just don't care, but I'd like to think it's the former.
- netizen-936824 5y agoNobody ever said politicians were smart
- kragen 5y agoEverybody thinks they're incorruptible, and they often extend that to institutions they identify with. Very, very few people have ever honestly grappled with their shadow side. Even if you do, you may still prefer your own shadow side to that of whoever your opponents are.
- wutbrodo 5y ago> Everybody thinks they're incorruptible It chafes me a little to see this so often phrased as something "everybody" thinks. There are enough people who feel otherwise in my social circles that it's pretty easy for me to consider this as a shockingly dumb assumption for a person to hold. Though I do acknowledge that you're probably close to right from a purely numerical perspective.
- joelbondurant0 5y ago
- kragen 5y agoI agree.
- Joeri 5y agoFree society means limited government, and the only way for the government to be in favor of that is for the government to vote against its own interests. I would argue that a free society protects people’s rights, and this is impossible without a strong government. As for voting against its own interests, the government in a true democracy is quite literally the will of the people. We get what we vote for. So if people in general are unhappy with the outcome it is democracy itself that has broken down. The solution to a broken democratic process is not to limit the consequences of that process by shrinking government, it is to fix what’s broken in the first place. In a healthy democracy the government will take up only the responsibilities people want it to take up, and no more than that.
- mantas 5y agoDepends on definition of „people’s rights“. If you want to ensure very basic rights, small government is fine. If you want affirmative action and all that jazz, then you’ll need big government. That will likely abuse tools meant for good to make society not free anymore.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- roenxi 5y agoMy government has just spent 2 years - a pretty significant percentage of a lifetime - working to keep me from travelling more than 5km from my home and made it illegal for me to see my friends. And I'm not even going to have a sympathetic audience if I try to claim this is against my wishes or wellbeing. Run me through, in simple terms, how much worse it could get? I suppose they aren't trying to kill me, which is a nice minimum standard? These people have no respect for my rights. They don't think my rights rate on the scale of their objectives. And they want to spy on my mail - possibly to figure out from my phone if I've gone 6km from my home? I would quite like strong encryption by default and a weak government, please.
- robbiep 5y ago
- bambax 5y ago> Free society means limited government Strong disagree. A good government protects freedom from big private companies that feast on it. Antitrust laws cannot be enforced by a weak government, and without those, there can't really be freedom.