5 ms·
Every platform is eventually going to have to deal with this. The correct move is to be a free speech maximalist (in either political direction) until laws are
by echelon 5y ago
Every platform is eventually going to have to deal with this.
The correct move is to be a free speech maximalist (in either political direction) until laws are broken. You can also make rules against directed harassment and threats.
Tell the detractors that "it could just as easily be your side being silenced", because that's the honest truth.
People will complain, but only the fringes will leave.
- sneak 5y agoIdeologically I am a free speech maximalist, but I also personally despise being advertised to nonconsensually. The issue with unadorned free speech maximalism (aside from people legitimately complaining about idiots spewing lies) is that it also dictates a 100% hands-off approach to even the most egregious spamming, as spam is legal.
- 0des 5y agoSpam is not legal I thought
- mrandish 5y agoAs a fellow free speech maximalist, I think it's possible (and fair) to have a distinction between individual opinion and commercial promotion, especially on a commercial platform. Free speech principles don't preclude some reasonable standards for curation of content. The key is to be consistent, regardless of perspective, and completely transparent. Where private, commercial platforms like FB, Reddit and Twitter have erred is in uneven enforcement of arbitrarily shifting rules which are hardly clear even when disclosed. They were pretty much doomed to eventual failure once they started responding to subjective and rapidly changing woke sensibilities. Weirdly, I've read thoughtful posts by both Jack Dorsey and Zuckerberg which clearly show they understand they are being backed into a untenable 'no-win' corner yet still find it impossible to avoid.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MattGaiser 5y agoThat ends in a cesspool that nobody is willing to spend money on or do business with. See Voat.
- iamstupidsimple 5y agoIt worked fine in the past when the mainstream platforms were also free speech platforms. Scale matters and those websites are only terrible because they're bastions for everybody else who also got banned.
- nyolfen 5y agovoat is a forum, podcast platforms are passive and do not have any kind of direct social interaction. 'free speech until the law is broken' is what appx the entire internet was like until ~6 years ago.
- atrus 5y agoNo, Voat was a cesspool, because Reddit really only pissed of the "unreasonable" people, who all went to Voat, and unsurprisingly made it a cesspool.
- d110af5ccf 5y ago> That ends in a cesspool that nobody is willing to spend money on or do business with. That's not quite right. Voat was populated by the fringe that was evicted from other more mainstream platforms, Reddit in particular. So the primary demographic of their userbase is "people whose content isn't allowed on Reddit". Which given that Reddit is fairly permissive compared with many places results in an incredibly skewed userbase. Without a compelling reason for users that are more mainstream to switch I think this result is unsurprising. The "free speech" side of fedi suffers from this dynamic as well. There's a growing contingent that's there simply because they were removed from Twitter. This is all a great example of why deplatforming doesn't work at all. In seeking to silence various groups they instead get concentrated in specific locations which results in a greater degree of polarization.
- enkid 5y agoFree speech has nothing to do with it. Spotify paid him a $100M to provide a product according to their terms. The idea that this is a free speech issue is ridiculous and makes no sense. If it was a matter of access to the content, what you should be arguing for is not having an exclusive contract with Spotify, but use one of the million other services that allows anyone to download the episode.
- sneak 5y agoFree speech doesn't always mean an issue with the government. Free speech can be seen as the opposite of censorship. This is plainly censorship (within Spotify's rights, but still censorship) and while nobody's 1A rights have been violated, it's still affecting someone's ability to publish to their audience. That's not a legal issue, but a moral one.
- enkid 5y agoSpotify already paid him $100M to make his podcast inaccessible to people. Where was the concern then? If Spotify limiting Joe Rogan from post the podcast to other services was not a concern then, why is Spotify limiting what it hosts now a concern? I see no possible philosophical distinction, but if you have potential justifications, please feel free to share.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wyattpeak 5y agoI think that the fact that's he's been contracted for exclusivity really changes the nature of the free speech argument. Rogan is functionally being hired to Spotify to produce content. I don't expect the ability to freely express myself when representing my employer. I think it's a very different situation, simply sharing your content on a platform, where I think free speech is much more relevant, vs. being contracted to produce content for a platform, where I think it stands to reason that you're expected to produce what the platform want.
- MBCook 5y agoThe fringes will leave. And the advertisers. Because P&G and Fire and Chase Bank do _not_ want to be associated with this kind of stuff. It’s much easier. You don’t need to be a free speech maximalist _on your platform_. Trying to tie up the whole podcast market under your umbrella is what caused this. If Rogan was still doing things himself with a standard podcast RSS feed her could still be heard without issue. Spotify listeners could listen without issue. Spotify wouldn’t be getting dragged in the media. This is 100% Spotify’s fault for trying to control someone controversial and was 100% foreseeable. > Every platform is eventually going to have to deal with this I agree. It’s part and parcel of being a platform. You know what’s better than platforms _allowing_ people to say what they want? What we had before Spotify (etc.) tried to take over: the open world of podcasting.
- commandlinefan 5y agoRadio stations used to deal with this all the time - remember Howard Stern? Rush Limbaugh? Way more divisive than Rogan.