4 ms·
Spotify has played this perfectly. First they spent $100m on a very controversial figure, just to get an exclusive contract. When he acted controversially the
by MBCook 5y ago
Spotify has played this perfectly.
First they spent $100m on a very controversial figure, just to get an exclusive contract.
When he acted controversially they stood up for him, making plenty of people mad and getting others to disassociate themselves from Spotify (Young, Mitchell). Wouldn’t surprise me if they were having some quiet issues with sponsors/ads.
Now they seem to be removing episodes, but reportedly not the controversial ones? This of course goes over poorly with both the pro (why remove them?) and anti (why not the problem ones?) camps.
Hope it was all worth it Spotify. Couldn’t have happened to a nicer company trying to destroy a formerly open ecosystem.
- unmole 5y agoWhat exactly does deleting episodes get Spotify? I'm really not seeing the grand strategy you are alluding to. Edit: I missed the obvious sarcasm. I need coffee.
- blamazon 5y agoThey're alluding to a lack of grand strategy. Edit: Enjoy your coffee!
- enkid 5y agoI'm pretty sure the comment is sarcasm.
- utunga 5y agoUnderstandable given how dry - but you may want to tweak the settings on your sarcasm detector.
- fastball 5y agoPretty sure the first sentence is sarcasm.
- MattGaiser 5y agoI am not sure there is really a winning play in situations like this that does not result in substantial losses either way.
- MBCook 5y agoI agree. They put themselves between a rock and a hard place. The solution was not to hire him, but that’s long past.
- kypro 5y agoYou realise they have some pretty vile artists on their platform too right? I mean if we're objecting to content here they've literally platformed homophobic and xenophobic music for years. Are we honestly arguing that having conversations critical of big pharma and public health policy is now worse than homophobic hate? The only reason this is being discussed by the media is because this time it's impacting the wrong people.
- MBCook 5y agoI disagree. It’s one thing to provide access to a ton of music. Yes there will be some objectionable stuff in there. They can decide to hide it or not. That’s passive. It’s another thing to actively pay to _create_ such content. That’s the big issue here.
- j4yav 5y agoIt is sarcasm.
- MattGaiser 5y agoI know it is sarcasm. I just do not see a clear winning alternative that doesn't lead to someone posting a similar sarcastic response.
- MBCook 5y agoNeither do I. Spotify set themselves up for this and there is no good way out. I think the only way this wouldn’t have happened is if Rogan had made himself less controversial over time before a flare up like this occurred. But I don’t think Spotify wanted a vanilla personality, if so why pay $100m for Rogan?
- echelon 5y agoEvery platform is eventually going to have to deal with this. The correct move is to be a free speech maximalist (in either political direction) until laws are broken. You can also make rules against directed harassment and threats. Tell the detractors that "it could just as easily be your side being silenced", because that's the honest truth. People will complain, but only the fringes will leave.
- sneak 5y agoIdeologically I am a free speech maximalist, but I also personally despise being advertised to nonconsensually. The issue with unadorned free speech maximalism (aside from people legitimately complaining about idiots spewing lies) is that it also dictates a 100% hands-off approach to even the most egregious spamming, as spam is legal.
- 0des 5y agoSpam is not legal I thought
- mrandish 5y agoAs a fellow free speech maximalist, I think it's possible (and fair) to have a distinction between individual opinion and commercial promotion, especially on a commercial platform. Free speech principles don't preclude some reasonable standards for curation of content. The key is to be consistent, regardless of perspective, and completely transparent. Where private, commercial platforms like FB, Reddit and Twitter have erred is in uneven enforcement of arbitrarily shifting rules which are hardly clear even when disclosed. They were pretty much doomed to eventual failure once they started responding to subjective and rapidly changing woke sensibilities. Weirdly, I've read thoughtful posts by both Jack Dorsey and Zuckerberg which clearly show they understand they are being backed into a untenable 'no-win' corner yet still find it impossible to avoid.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MattGaiser 5y ago
- rvz 5y agoI hope that no-one here was surprised about this given that this multi-million 'exclusive contract' was seen by many as a sell-out to a private platform that has the upper hand on what they allow on their platform. It seems that those concerned about him selling out now have a point, but I doubt anyone cares - JR still made his money and that decision was ultimately up to him. But perhaps the big lesson here for others is to run your own company and host your own show.
- markdown 5y ago> But perhaps the big lesson here is to run your own company and host your own show. And give up $100M? LOL why on earth would that be the big lesson?
- TOMDM 5y agoIf anything the lesson here is to blow up harder and faster after you've taken the $100M so you can go back to doing your own thing with your massive and loyal fanbase. Don't bite the hand that feeds you, tear it off. How Spotify ever thought this was a good idea still eludes me
- MBCook 5y agoGuess it depends on what you value more: your editorial control or the cash. We know what he chose. I’d argue it’s what the vast majority would choose. But they both (Spotify and Rogan) knew what they were choosing.
- lamontcg 5y agoSpotify also has very little user stickiness. I switched pretty painlessly to Tidal and now I get better quality audio and the artists get more royalties and I don't have to have JRE and Peterson staring at me every time I login.
- mkj 5y agoTotally agree how painless it is switching services - Tidal paying tunemymusic for music library imports was a good idea. I wonder if that is part of why Spotify started pushing podcasts so hard - they can get exclusive content easier that way vs going with "commodity" music artists which will be available at all their competitors.
- MBCook 5y agoIt 100% is. It’s very hard to get an exclusive with any recording artists, let alone enough big ones to meaningfully move the needle. With other good services around Spotify is basically a commodity player in the streaming market. But exclusive audio content (Podcasts, audio books, etc) is something they can do to keep people from switching. Whether it’s only on Spotify or maybe just comes out a week early and ad free, it’s additional value the other services can’t provide. Plus Spotify has made all the streaming money they will. They’re not going to grow another 100m users on music alone. But wall street wants more and podcasts driving subscriptions and podcast advertising is a real growth opportunity to make Wallstreet happy. Of course none of this is good for Frank and Sally podcast listener. But when did that ever matter? The big companies have decided how things will work.
- Gigachad 5y agoThis is my thinking. Unless Spotify builds up a library of exclusive content, they will be destroyed as soon as apple and google stop doing such a shit job at music.
- bmarquez 5y ago> Now they seem to be removing episodes, but reportedly not the controversial ones? Yeah I don't get this part. While I could understand why they'd want to remove Alex Jones, there are uncontroversial names like Tim Ferriss who were also removed.
- enkid 5y agoBaseless speculation, but maybe the guests are asking for their episodes to be removed so they aren't associated with the podcast?
- scruple 5y agoI really doubt that. Many of the episodes that were removed were fellow comedians like Theo Von and Tom Segura who are in Joe Rogan's peer group.
- robbedpeter 5y agoNumerous affected guests have made videos and spoken about it. Only Rogan and Spotify know why. We get to find out if Rogan actually has principles or if he just talks a good game. I'm hoping he's not a sellout and this situation results in his move to some decentralized platform. 80% of his audience will follow, and the ones he lost to YouTube will come back. It'd be awesome if he dragged all his podcaster buddies along with him, and the comics and musicians followed. Uninstalled Spotify, guess no more jre podcast until Joe moves. If he doesn't, I'm not interested in whatever kind of person sells out like that after taking such a powerful stand on censorship.
- MBCook 5y ago> I'm hoping he's not a sellout and this situation results in his move to some decentralized platform. What platform? Why do you need a platform? Podcasts were already 100% open. No platform necessary.
- donmcronald 5y agoI was absolutely stunned when Spotify did the Joe Rogan deal. You could already tell at that point that he was a divisive kind of person and I just couldn't understand why anyone would want that headache. I was already wondering how YouTube was going to deal with him and even joked to people I knew that the staff at YouTube were probably high fiving each other and planning a big party as soon as they heard the news.
- iancmceachern 5y agoAnd more than that, like Howard Stern before, some of his popularity comes from that edginess. So it's both the thing people came for, and the thing others are trying to get away from.
- khana 5y ago
- ballenf 5y agoThe really weird thing is that the media keeps saying Rogan's "controversial", but almost no one cares. It doesn't show up in polling -- your average person has about 15 things of a higher priority right now. Almost feels like the point of many articles is to tell people the correct thoughts on a topic, instead of actually finding out and reporting how people feel.