6 ms·
Twitter expands downvote test worldwide
- Jimmc414 5y agoHidden downvotes are a terrible idea, unless you are looking to censor information without an audit trail.
- rickosborne 5y ago> Hidden downvotes are a terrible idea First and foremost, I agree that this will probably end poorly. However, I could see this being a good idea in the right hands, because it _could_ be used as _part_ of a more comprehensive auto-mod tools, including self-shadow-banning. Imagine you had a human reviewing highly ratioed comments, providing a final judgment on "is this comment actually unhelpful, or is it just being brigaded?". (And let's imagine one judgment option is "unclear, do nothing".) You could then keep a per-user metric of their (mis)alignment with that judgment across all their votes. That metric could then be used to weight the votes of that user. High alignment then classifies that user as a "trustworthy unpaid mod" behind the scenes, which can then be used as a signal to determine future human reviews. Similarly, if someone has an absolutely stellar alignment, you can use the occasional disagreements to do meta-mod reviews of your mods' judgments. If you go really wild and draw some correlation between mis-votes and hashtag/topic/channel/whatever, then you can use that. Low alignment could then be used to devalue votes from that user, leading to a slow shadow ban, and potentially even other more visible effects. All of which can be done regardless of the visibility of the votes, of course. But hiding "down" votes should help to reduce the pile-on effects of brigading ("a ton of other people downvoted it, so I am safe in the crowd") and thus the temptations leading to slowly shadow banning yourself. But unlike completely taking away down votes, like YouTube, you leave enough rope for bad actors to hang themselves. It's equivalent to the system Slashdot has had for decades (IIRC). Do I trust Twitter to put in place something with that amount of utility, feedback, and nuance? Nope. And even if they did, they'd throw away the value of having invisible scores for the opportunity to add "gold checkmarks" or some other BS.
- blakesterz 5y ago> It's equivalent to the system Slashdot has had for decades (IIRC). That's exactly what I thought when I read this too. That system worked really well (not perfect, but did the job) back when Slashdot was super popular. I think your right, good idea in the right hands and if they are careful with how they do it.
- gnicholas 5y agoAgree, and this goes along with Twitter's desire to curate feeds by showing, for example, tweets that were 'liked' by people you follow. By doing this, they broaden the amount of content they can show you and therefore increase the discretion they have in surfacing content they want to spread. (It's also super annoying — I follow someone so I can see what they tweet and RT. I do not care one bit about the things they like.) Hidden downvotes are the flip side of the coin — instead of being used to boost the spread of certain tweets, they can be used as an excuse for why certain information is hidden. Basically, these changes remind me of p-hacking. As more variables are added, you can figure out ways to structure your algorithm so that you promote the information that you already wanted to promote and demote the information that you wanted to hide. This could be for profit-seeking reasons, political reasons, or other reasons. In any event, it decreases transparency and reduces trust in the systems. edit: added last paragraph
- munk-a 5y agoI disagree that hidden downvotes are generally a terrible idea. Downvotes should probably usually be hidden and used as a measure of whether to surface information - except when that information is factual. Twitter contains absolutely nothing except opinions and thus visible downvotes are useless there. There are other platforms (like YouTube) where downvotes make a lot of sense because users post guides and tutorials where the downvote ratio is a good indicator of how accurate or useful that guide is.
- Wronnay 5y agoSo YouTube removes down votes and Twitter adds them? Feels like Social Media Companies don't know what they are doing
- gnicholas 5y agoYT still has downvotes — you're just not allowed to see them anymore.
- munk-a 5y agoWhich is really a shame considering how many informational(ish) videos are on YT. Downvoting was really helpful to tell, when you search for "How do I unblock my sink drain" who is full of crap. Downvoting on opinion, social and gaming videos serves no purpose. Twitter as a platform which has no ability to store and reliably surface informational or factual messages is completely devoid of the types of content where peer feedback is helpful - the only thing tweet scores measure is "hotness" which could be entirely opaque to the user base (both up and down).
- loceng 5y agoThere's an extension to show downvote count again.
- gnicholas 5y agoThat's amazing. Link is here for others who are interested: https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/return-youtube-dislike/gebbhagfogifgggkldgodflihgfeippi https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/return-youtube-dis...
- GauntletWizard 5y agoIt's only going to work for a couple of months, because YouTube has promised that the API will start returning zero for that number fairly soon. They have not committed to a date, and I doubt they will, simply roll it out when they feel they can.
- FalconSensei 5y agoNow the ONE thing I loved about Twitter is going to be gone?
- parineum 5y agoI left Facebook shortly after they removed the chronological feed on your wall because it made it so I kept seeing the same few posts over and over again and missed a bunch of smaller posts that weren't high interaction. In retrospect, that was a necessary precursor to all the dark patterns they would later implement to the feed. It empowers the company to decide what users see and that's an incredibly valuable thing for a company with billions of eyeballs. The temptation to monetize that power will be irresistible. At the very least, "Sponsored Posts" incoming.
- gnicholas 5y agoTechnically, FB still allows you to view a chronological feed, but for much of the past several years this mode has been broken. It shows me posts from 3 days ago at the top of the feed, even though I know that there are posts that are just a few hours old. I guess they moved fast and broke things.
- Buttons840 5y agoTechnically, what you described is not a chronological feed then.
- gnicholas 5y agoWhen it works, it is chronological. It was just broken for a few years there (seems to work OK these days, at least for me). In the behavioral science parlance, I think this is called a 'nudge'.
- mminer237 5y agohttps://www.facebook.com/?sk=h_chr https://www.facebook.com/?sk=h_chr still works fine for me. Everything neatly increments up from 7 minutes old to 30 minutes old a couple pages down.
- llbeansandrice 5y agoI don't see how downvotes can be effectively implemented online without extensive action from community moderators/admins. In particular, you need people with platform-wide scope and permissions to prevent communities from brigading and such. As a small-community moderator on reddit, we get blamed all the time for "downvotes from our community" by new users which is something we neither have insight into nor control over. I don't see how this goes well. At least Reddit has managed to build a [propaganda death star](https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/sdcsx3/testing_reddits_new_block_feature_and_its_effects/ https://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/sdcsx3/test...) with their new features associated with blocking accounts. Will people be able to downvote tweets from official accounts for heads of state? What will Twitter do about downvote bot groups?
- loceng 5y agoThat added dopamine hit for downvotes and intensify the bubbles for users is only way they can compete better with Facebook's engagement.
- josefresco 5y ago> In particular, you need people with platform-wide scope and permissions to prevent communities from brigading and such. Do they also have teams that identify "brigading" in order to boost a tweet? What does Twitter do about upvote bots?
- llbeansandrice 5y agoI'm not sure, and I suppose it largely depends on what the results are for different actions. On Reddit, posts and comments that get upvoted get more views and engagement because the entire site is more or less stack-ranked on /r/all, /r/popular, and any given user's home feed. Downvoted posts and comments get sent straight to the bottom, and really don't get seen or engaged with. Hearts, retweets, replies, etc. on Twitter I presume have a slightly similar result but I suspect it's not the same as "reaching #1 on /r/all" on reddit. The way Twitter works is fundamentally different. So whether Twitter really needs to care about people "getting ratio'd" or buying likes is different than the concern on Reddit. What happens to mass-downvoted tweets will determine how important it is to make sure all downvotes are "real" or "in good faith" or whatever.
- micromacrofoot 5y ago> Presumably, this is instead of muting a conversation or flagging it as spam or irrelevant Wow I hope not. Conflating these concepts sounds terrible.
- ludamad 5y agoI think they have a problem with hated content that's technically allowed - "buy AnimalCoin" etc. I would hate to just be brigaded against, though, Twitter already feels like a wild west of getting unwelcome replies
- munk-a 5y agoBut "buy my newest stable coin" is precisely what the spam button exists to report - "grass roots advertising" is a blight on humanity.
- insickness 5y agoThere wasn't enough anger and vitriol on Twitter. At least now the mobs have some recourse against individuals who express undesirable opinions. /s
- amatecha 5y agoIMO, use Twitter less and join a community that you want to participate in on a Mastodon instance: https://joinmastodon.org/ https://joinmastodon.org/
- josefresco 5y agoKeep in mind HN junkies: We're debating this on a site that allows downvotes. It seems many think this will be a terrible decision yet, here we are. I find downvotes on HN to be very effective at guiding the discussion, maybe it's because the culture here is still homogeneous.
- gnicholas 5y agoOn HN, downvotes are reflected by greyed out comments. The main thing people are complaining about in this thread is that the Twitter downvotes will be opaque.
- caddemon 5y agoAlso an account can only downvote once it has amassed a certain level of upvotes. It sounds like the Twitter downvote will be open to everyone when it is fully released, which would make it a lot easier to abuse.
- gnicholas 5y agoYes, although it would be trivial for Twitter to ignore or downweight downvotes from new accounts. It would be interesting if one of the main reasons for adding opaque downvotes is to give users the feeling that they had expressed an opinion without giving that expression any weight whatsoever. I guess this would be called 'downvote shadow-banning'.
- kzrdude 5y agoIn what way does it guide discussion? I think the discussion climate is pretty good here, but in some other communities I see that downvotes only allow one kind of opinion to be heard - and this is not about politics or something controversial, it's anything, including sports. People upvote what they want to hear.
- bnralt 5y agoThey still drown out opposing opinions here for specific issues. I think it's more the case that those topics don't come up as often. One of the issues is that places like Hacker News and Reddit use an aggregate vote count. You can't tell if a comment that has a score of -10 is a comment where ten people saw it and decided to downvote it, or where 100 people saw it, 55 downvoted it and 45 upvoted it. This leads to situations where it can seem like a community rejects a point of view, even whe the point of view is shared by almost half the community. Further exacerbating this is that, with an infinite number of votes allowed, someone who is less restrained about their votes is going to have a greater impact than someone who reserves them for only exceptional comments. For example, say 60% of the community likes Coke and 40% likes Pepsi. However, the Coke supporters are relatively calm and only occasionally vote for comments about soda, while Pepsi supporters are zealots who will downvote any comment that's supportive of Coke and upvote any comment supportive of Pepsi. A user is just going to see a lot of highly downvoted/greyed out Coke posts and a lot of highly upvoted Pepsi posts, and assume that the community is highly supportive of Pepsi while hating Coke. That's more of a problem with voting in general (and a larger problem with how time = speech on the internet), but downvoting can certainly exacerbate the problem.
- thisisnotatest1 5y ago
- jonstaab 5y agoComment/like ratios are a great way to handle this already. It makes up/downvote incentive asymmetric, which makes getting ratio'd high signal.
- spideymans 5y agoDownvotes are awful. People on Reddit will downvote posts merely because it doesn't fit a particular narrative. This will be even worse on Twitter.
- everfree 5y agoI agree completely with this comment under the article: > I really don’t like the idea of downvotes, just makes it easier to make sure there’s only one train of thought under a tweet. So if a tweet is aimed at a certain subsection of people, the replies will all be full of upvoted replies agreeing with it while all dissent is downvoted. Followers of a user will downvote to silence opposing opinions in the replies, pigeonholing the reply section into a bunch of posts that agree with the original poster.
- ranieuwe 5y agoMore echo chambers that we don’t need and no one is asking for.
- gruez 5y agoNo one asks for "echo chambers", but people do ask for a space where they can interact with like minded individuals and push out "trolls".
- everfree 5y agoI want more spaces that push out trolls, but where I can interact with non-like-minded individuals. If I only interact with like-minded individuals, that means the internet has failed its use case for me, which is to broaden my world view by seeking out opinions that oppose my own. Of course if by "like-minded" you mean "polite and rule-abiding," then I agree.
- gruez 5y agoThat's why I put "trolls" in quotes. The amount of people who self-sort themselves into echo chambers is far more than the people who would freely admit they want to be in an echo chamber.
- krapp 5y agoThat's one use case, but not every platform or forum can or should be expected to traffic in free-form controversy. If I'm on a car forum, I expect an "echo chamber" about cars with individuals interested in discussing cars, not to have a confrontational debate about race science or vaccines or Christian apologetics, at least not in the car threads.
- cdelsolar 5y agoI am in several Twitter antivaxxer "bubbles", mainly so that I can argue against them. Any time I post any cogent argument against their _constant_ stream of misinformation, I get heavily "ratioed" by people who can barely spell or put a sentence together. Similarly, in other more scientific bubbles, anyone who posts a dumb antivaxxer argument gets ratioed and ridiculed as well. I don't think this downvoting is going to do anything to combat misinformation.
- salmonellaeater 5y agoThe problems with brigading, and in general using downvotes for manipulating what other people see, can be mitigated by doing personalized ranking (which Twitter already does - this is just a tweak). For your personalized ranking, the downvotes of people similar to you would count much more than those from people different from you. So if a group comes in and brigades a thread, their votes won't do anything to your view if they're not similar to you. This opens a question, though, of whether the person who started a thread should have any control over the conversation other people see. In the extreme, it could be almost like those browser extensions where your group has a parallel conversation about a website, unrelated to the comments on the site itself. In the other extreme, the OP of a thread is curator of their personal walled garden, where their enemies' replies are all auto-hidden.
- thrower123 5y agoFortunately, you can still get a fairly decent twitter experience by curating your follows into private Lists. You get a chronological timeline of those users' posts, and you actually see all of them, rather than whatever subset the algorithm has decided it wants to show you.
- bargl 5y agoI think both upvoting and downvoting are... a poor form of signal on content, but maybe the best one we have. There can be some pretty good indicators that come out of the combination of up and down votes that you can't get from just up. Purely upvoted content is (generally) less offensive to the readers. Purely downvoted content is (generally) more offensive to the readers. Mixed content 50/50 up/down is typically more controversial and so isn't purely offensive, but instead depends on who the reader is. Assuming a wide spread of audience (not a pre-silo'd audience). I'm speculating here but I guess this is a tool twitter plans to use to reinforce silos, find content that's only "mildly offensive (I.E. Pimple Popping threads) and let people who want that to get it. Alternatively, they could find content that's downvoted by people who have a good "donwvoting trend" and upscale those downvotes. It's just more signal in their learning algorithms toolboxes. IMO it neither helps nor hurts twitter's users to have downvotes it really depends on how they use it. I suspect people who are opposed to downvotes don't trust that Twitter will use the signal well. For example, the fact that YouTube took away "displaying" downvotes but not actually downvoting takes away power from users. They still get the signal but users don't. You no longer get signal on what YouTube is recommending to you.
- nathanaldensr 5y ago> and are used to surface relevant replies I think what they really mean to say is "all non-echo-chamber replies will be censored." Any other interpretation assumes something that isn't true: that all Twitter users are calm, rational, thinking individuals.
- elforce002 5y agoFinally! Now let see the worst tweet of all time.
- mrhands556 5y agoDownvoting gives more ways to manipulate a conversation and promote a narrative.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoBetter than an algorithm that prioritizes posts based on how much interaction they receive. The manipulation of a conversation can instead be a democratic process where each participant (even each lurker) gets to decide what comments should be seen first by each new participant. I'm actually really impressed by HN's distributed moderation, the fact that members with more reputation (higher score) get to flag and vouch comments lets HN dodge reddit's curse of having weird power-tripping volunteers with a monopoly on bans. Conversations need to be manipulated one way or another, I mean maybe 4chan gets by unmoderated, but don't they kick spammers too? So someone has power to shape the conversation, question is how the power is distributed.
- d23 5y agoAll voting is censorship. The delivery of every piece of content should be completely randomized regardless of source, quality, heinousness, coherence, or relevance. All knowledge and reason is fundamentally flawed and thus should never be presented. Words are meaningless. All is void.
- passerby1 5y agoAs account lock on most social nets happens without stating which ToS paragraph was violated, adding such a feedback as downvoting could lead to more easy account termination process.