4 ms·
The things that would help most with the Karikó Problem are: 1. Open access to research. Wikipedia, Sci-Hub, PLoS, Library Genesis, GitLab, MDPI, arXiv, PubMe
by kragen 5y ago
The things that would help most with the Karikó Problem are:
1. Open access to research. Wikipedia, Sci-Hub, PLoS, Library Genesis, GitLab, MDPI, arXiv, PubMed, GitHub, BitTorrent, medRxiv, bioRxiv, and Tor. It's unconscionable that today professional societies like ACM and IEEE are using copyright to impede access to knowledge as if they were for-profit corporations.
2. Universal basic income, so today's Karikós don't have to choose between research and food. Conceivably some kind of reform is needed to prevent landlords from skimming off the UBI and returning us to zero, as the Georgists claim.
3. Reducing the cost of apparatus through initiatives like Foldscope and Paperfuge. We need not just one Manu Prakash but ten thousand Manu Prakashes, because Edmund Scientific is just never going to fulfill the needs of shoestring labs in Ghana.
4. Freedom from persecution for researchers. For example, where I live, buying acetone gets you Put On A List, and the hardware stores now label their lye simply as "drain opener" to evade the same regulations. California recently prohibited the sale of basic supplies like xylene under an extremely far-fetched interpretation of anti-air-pollution laws. Only recently did Texas repeal its prohibition on sales of lab glassware to unlicensed individuals. Hennig Brand discovered phosphorus by isolating it from a massive amount of his own urine; in South Carolina today you can get arrested for possessing a bottle of urine: https://www.avvo.com/legal-answers/a-friend-was-charged-with-having-a-bottle-of-urine-5082892.html https://www.avvo.com/legal-answers/a-friend-was-charged-with.... Critical Art Ensemble founder Steve Kurtz was famously arrested for "bioterrorism," then indicted for wire fraud and mail fraud, because he and his wife were culturing non-pathogenic bacteria in Petri dishes. This sort of thing should be unthinkable.
This will probably require ending drug prohibition; I don't see a reasonable way to protect researchers' freedom to synthesize arbitrary materials while prohibiting the possession of a large and constantly growing list of materials. But I don't think it's reasonable to prioritize the needs of drug addicts, drug traffickers, and empire-builders in law enforcement over the needs of innovators.
5. Going beyond freedom from active persecution, it's important to cultivate a social attitude that basic research is not only not harmful, but an important and worthwhile activity. This is the opposite of the attitude cultivated by Hollywood, which considers anything scientific to be inherently scary and antihuman.
- keithalewis 5y ago6. And a pony. A pretty one with fluffy hair you can comb.
- kragen 5y agoYou seem to be saying that it's unlikely that we'll achieve all of this. And that's true: it's a lot of social change, and social change is very difficult. But every incremental step in the direction of these goals will improve the situation for high-risk basic research like Karikó's. Except for ponies. Those are pleasant but they're too resource-intensive to be much of a force for advancing basic research.
- BlueTemplar 5y agoThe pony problem is a tough one. Though maybe we can find a self-reinforcing loop by funding research into breeding prettier and fluffier poneys ?
- pvaldes 5y agoSo, we need vaccines to not die, and she wants a pony to comb its hair?. Seems like a really easy decision to make... "I will save you five million dollars, if you give me three hundred dollars?". Just take my money and the damned horse is a gift.
- zozbot234 5y agoYour average Karikó would not benefit directly from Universal Basic Income. Not that solving extreme poverty/deprivation while preserving economic freedom and efficiency isn't a good idea for plenty of other reasons, but it's not a free lunch either. The modal UBI recipient will probably be expending their time and effort on training for productive work, not long-term research with no immediate benefits for themselves.
- kragen 5y agoThe modal UBI recipient is not your average Karikó; the modal UBI recipient will probably sit around beating their children and watching music videos on whatever the equivalent of MTV or YouTube is in 02039. No conceivable intervention will turn the majority of the population into inventors and scientists, so we shouldn't try unless it's a low-risk effort. But we can certainly aspire to liberate science from bibliometrics, dollar-auction postdoc rat races, grantwriting, mandatory reporting requirements, and especially prosecution, so that the people who do want to spend their time on advancing human knowledge have the opportunity to do so. And we can work to change the public perception of innovation and research from Frankenstein and Walter White to Edison, Tesla, and Einstein.