3 ms·
> So I'm saying that a lot of this ethnic, "blood and soil" stuff seems to exist quite happily on what Westerners currently consider "the left". And then it gro
by bitwize 5y ago
> So I'm saying that a lot of this ethnic, "blood and soil" stuff seems to exist quite happily on what Westerners currently consider "the left". And then it grows, and then it gets powerful, and then later, retroactively, they go, "oh, I guess that was bad (== right)".
That's because it's non-Western ethnic blood-and-soil stuff. Marxism was a critique of economic capitalism; the Frankfurt School pivoted that to a critique of Western civilization as a whole, as a social complex based on domination which secured capitalism against revolutionary overthrow by means of a form of psychic domination -- domination of consciousness. This is the puzzle that Gramsci considered and started to solve: why hasn't Western civilization gotten with the program and chosen communism over the chains of capitalism? And if your entire civilization is standing in the way of that revolution, then hey hey, ho, ho, Western Civ has got to go.
See, the intelligentsia have already chosen Marxian socialism as the successor to the liberal democratic system. It's like X11 vs. Wayland. Whether what exists works for your use case doesn't matter: the people who Really Know A Lot About This Sort Of Thing have chosen the clearly superior option, and you should too. Gramsci, Adorno, Marcuse, and Horkheimer were all addressing the problem of: why hasn't everybody chosen the clearly superior option? And the answer they arrived at is that Western civilization is fundamentally, thoroughly oppressive, and it brainwashes people and keeps then from realizing that there's a path to freedom through socialism and that's where nationalism in a Western context comes from, giving rise to fascism.
But the Africans and indigenous South Americans, all those peoples that Western Civ oppresses because it's in its nature to oppress, those are fine. There is no need to worry about tribalism, nationalism, or hostility to outsiders from those groups because they don't have the domination and rationalization impulse that Westerners do. Which is why the "stolen land" myth persists. It's partially true, but it's not the whole story. Native Americans were not peaceniks, and the land occupied by a tribe was, likely as not, conquered by that tribe's ancestors from a displaced or now-unknown other tribe.
But in the mythos of the new left, Westerners are uniquely prone to want to conquer and colonize, so that pre-Western-contact history needs to be, and often is, elided.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoIt might be worth pointing out that when the New Left arrived on the scene in the late 60s people like Marcuse (who wrote in the 50s early 60s mainly) were seen as overtly pessimistic and not terribly useful theoretically. Adorno and the Frankfurt School was never a darling of actual activists, just academics. Marcuse was booed at the Free University of Berlin in 1968.
- nomadpenguin 5y agoAn important piece of context is that many of the New Left thinkers you mentioned are responding directly to the horrors of WWII and the Holocaust. While yes, tribalism, brutality, and oppression are all present in non-Western cultures, I don't think it's an absurd claim that it is only Western rationality that can produce mass suffering at the scale of the Holocaust.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoThe Khmer Rouge in the 70s, and the Japanese in the early 20th century would like a word with you.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andrewjl 5y ago> See, the intelligentsia have already chosen Marxian socialism as the successor to the liberal democratic system. From the article > Although he sustained a seldom-stated bond with Marxism he was not primarily interested in political economy, nor did he have any real talent for the topic. Instead he was drawn to the inspection of lived experience in all of its exquisite detail. I'm not sure what "intelligentsia" means in your phrasing but your assertion does not apply to Adorno. His writing is generally skeptical of anything that is systematizing or totalizing. Reality has depth and is complex. Systems elide much of that depth and complexity, replacing it with shallowness and false simplicity. What I wrote is a limited summary, for sure, but more accurate than implying endorsement of a particular ideology.
- raxxorrax 5y agoYou always have to make yourself aware about the time members of the Frankfurt School lived through and how it influenced their views on western civilization. But it is a cynicism that may not be adequate. Embracing that for a second can still be helpful to become aware of many problems though. Marxism did not supply people with more freedom than capitalism. Capitalism is an expression of human greed and a method how we can deal with it constructively. Marxism just denies negative but human traits. There still is room for criticism on capitalism, plenty of it, there are excesses that are not excusable. But people that prefer the totalitarian model of society to liberal democracies should never be called intellectuals. Maybe intellectuals with a death wish, but I guess those are an exception.