6 ms·
A well written article. I am looking at a copy of Minima Moralia on my bookshelf that I don't think I've opened since I was in my early 20s, 25+ years ago, and
by cmrdporcupine 5y ago
A well written article. I am looking at a copy of Minima Moralia on my bookshelf that I don't think I've opened since I was in my early 20s, 25+ years ago, and I might spend some time today flipping through it.
What I remember from it -- and the pieces of his book "Negative Dialectics" that I think it shares some content with -- is a deep and profound critique of Martin Heidegger, German pre-war existentialism, Romanticism, holism philosophy which left themselves open to impregnation by fascism. In Germany in the the 20s and 30s right wing authoritarianism freely absorbed adherents of the equivalent of today's "wellness" and "natural health" movements, who became allies in their opposition to modernism, communism, and the chaos of democracy. Heidegger himself was beguiled by the mystical quasi-spiritual language of the fatherland and blood and soil. Adorno saw this as it was happening and was disgusted.
So there are definitely parallels with today that are worth paying close attention to.
- user-the-name 5y agoFar-right ideology is ripping through those groups again today as well.
- zwkrt 5y agoIt makes sense to me. Natural health is enticing because it simplifies the problem of solving your health issues to adjust understanding how certain herbs, mushrooms, etc. affect the balance of your health. Real biology is incredibly complicated and full of unsatisfying answers. Natural health is full of sure answers (with dubious effects) Facism is exactly the same except instead of the health of the body it is about the health of the state.
- jcelerier 5y agoYep: http://www.autodidactproject.org/other/adornocc.html http://www.autodidactproject.org/other/adornocc.html
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoIf I recall, Adorno diagnoses it as the willful ignorance of seeing actual real world internal contradictions that is inherent in various "holistic" philosophies. Papering over conflict and disagreement with hand waving about oneness which actually masks an authoritarian imposition of unitary identity or aesthetic vision -- an ideology of "natural balance", which sees certain groups (Jews, socialist radicals, intellectuals, scientists, doctors, whatever) as disrupting this equilibrium. Obviously vaccine opposition is one of the penultimate forms of this.
- bitwize 5y agoI've seen natural health, antivax, and related woo gain currency among both the left and the right. If you're so radicalized as to distrust anything mainstream because it's mainstream, you are more likely to reject the medical establishment regardless of your ideological particulars.
- zwkrt 5y agoDon’t forget bitcoin!
- FooBarBizBazz 5y ago> today's "wellness" and "natural health" movements, who became allies in their opposition to modernism, communism, and the chaos of democracy. First of all, lumping "modernism, communism, and [...] democracy" together in opposition to "right wing authoritarianism" makes little sense. Fascism had strong modernist currents (hence V2s, autobahnen, and Rube-Goldberg deathcamps (the Khmer Rouge didn't need all that)). And both it and Communism are illiberal and undemocratic in practice. Second, the minute you translate these things outside "the West", the script flips 180. "Wellness", "natural health", and the rejection of "modernity" become "indigenous knowledge" (say, "ayurveda") and "anticolonialist". I just don't think these free-associational patterns are terribly useful, because they don't actually work.
- pessimizer 5y agoAbsolutely agree with your first point (ahem, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Futurism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Futurism), but your second point doesn't flip the script at all, it's completely consistent with it. edit: India's anticolonialism is revanchist at this point, the British have been gone for a long time; Indians own India, and ayurveda is literally part of state religion. The BJP was openly patterned after European fascist movements.
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoSo, "we" might currently view the BJP that way. But at what point did Western consensus about "what nationalism in India is" change? I'm thinking about the Intermediate Value Theorem here. I think it started with, "anti-imperialism, yay!" Or -- another example, because I don't want to pick on India. "We" now tend to view China as a Han-supremacist ethnostate (I think?), despite the Communist trappings. Nevertheless, at a point not long in the past, French students were carrying Mao's "Little Red Book". North Korean "communism" is supposedly like this too -- very ethno-nationalist in character -- if you believe the analysis in The Impossible State. Somewhat likewise, Soviet Internationalism turned into Soviet Imperialism and Russian Nationalism. Somehow now it's Putinism and the Orthodox Church is involved. So then you move to other "leftist" and "indigenous" movements in South America, and, sure, there might be some red stars, but it seems to me that the force actually binding people together is ethnic nationalism. This is especially true for "indigenous" tribal identities. It's hard to get more "blood and soil" than their rhetoric. Hell, "#LandBack" is literal revanchism. And every country that "fought (Ottoman) imperialism" in the Balkans, under the banner of "self-determination" (pop-quiz: What is the collective "self"?) did so using nationalism, which, half the time, quickly turned on local minorities. So I am deeply skeptical of claims, by anyone, to be "on the left", or, even more than that, an "anti-imperialist". I think it's just a temporary and contingent thing, representing instantaneous balances of power, not fundamental principles. I am much more comfortable with liberal universalism. Even the Nazis themselves marketed themselves as anti-imperialists to the left. Lots of people fell for it. People as smart as the ones in Robert Oppenheimer's social circles. "Yeah, we don't like the Nazis, but we'll use them to break the back of the British!" So when, say, well-meaning white people go "Yeah! Africa for Africans!" I go: "Wait a minute. I mean, I get it. But have you really thought about this principle?" I think they cheer because, subliminally, they think the place isn't worth going to; they don't feel they're losing anything. They are also unaware that this means "expropriation without compensation" from a large class of South-Asians. So I'm saying that a lot of this ethnic, "blood and soil" stuff seems to exist quite happily on what Westerners currently consider "the left". And then it grows, and then it gets powerful, and then later, retroactively, they go, "oh, I guess that was bad (== right)". There's a blindness to this that I get tired of. So to finally get back to my point, not only is there modernism on the right; there's anti-modernism, and even (barely-concealed) ethnic nationalism, on the left. And then I worry about these centrifugal forces.
- raxxorrax 5y ago> In Germany in the the 20s and 30s right wing authoritarianism freely absorbed adherents of the equivalent of today's "wellness" and "natural health" movements Those movements are not the source of fascism and I don't think existentialism and romanticism leaves one particularly open to it. Modernism was established when WW2 broke out which probably ended it. I doubt that any philosophy is vulnerable to it because then it would not resurface. Fascism and communism as well judged capitalism. Maybe that is easier to admit than being responsible for it ourselves. I do believe however that there are fascist tendencies in those that quickly diagnose it in others just because it is something abhorrent. That Adorno suspected it everywhere would be understandable, except that he did no such thing even with the pessimism he often espoused.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoNowhere in my comment did I say those things were "the source" nor did I say that Adorno claimed they were; I said they are/were susceptible which is something else entirely. Find another strawman, maybe.
- raxxorrax 5y agoAlright, alright, it was not an accusation...
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoI'm a little sensitive given what's going on on the streets of Ottawa and other Canadian cities up here right now.