3 ms·
You're basically asking the question of what is the minimum sufficient level of general intelligence required to allow self-driving cars to go forward. I inste
by dekhn 5y ago
You're basically asking the question of what is the minimum sufficient level of general intelligence required to allow self-driving cars to go forward.
I instead have a different criteria. If somebody could show that their self-driving car can drive 250 million miles without a person (pedestrian, driver, or passenger) across a fleet and range of conditions, then that's good enough for me (currently, people drive 100 million miles before somebody gets killed).
I figure 2.5X more safe than the average human would lead to an enormous savings in lives and one might even make the argument, at that point, that there was a moral imperative to disallow people driving!
(BTW I live next to an elementary school and people drive past exceeding the posted limit all the time. I struggle to move my car safely through all the distractions. The one thing that helps the most is the radar which hits the breaks if it thinks I'm gonna back into a person or car.)
- Barrin92 5y agothe roads self-driving cars drive on at this point are heavily self-selected as well. I want see a few thousand self-driving cars interact on the streets of Delhi or see one go through a snowy mountain pass with barely any signs when people make these safety stat comparisons nowadays seems to be often ignored under how much more ambiguous conditions humans still drive safely.
- dekhn 5y agoI don't think either the Delhi Street or Snowy Mountain Pass are really required to deploy self-driving cars to 65% of the drivers in the world.
- Barrin92 5y agosnowy mountain pass maybe not but your average traffic in the world is closer to the cities of India, China, Indonesia or Brazil than a grid system in the suburbs of Phoenix Arizona. Keep in mind the US and Europe account for 10% of the world's population, and I wouldn't even have a lot of confidence in self-driving in your average traffic situation in Rome Tbh I'm not even sure if self-driving as it is covers 65% of the American population. Has anyone ever tried to use a self-driving car on a rural American road?
- dekhn 5y agoyes, people ride teslas in some sort of automated mode on rural roads. I see your point about the larger driving population, but self driving will roll out in wealthy countries with new car models first, and I think solving the problem there will predate a large solution, for many different reasons. All my comments about self driving are basically limited to urban and semi-urban wealthy countries since those are the groups subsidizing the research now.
- 9935c101ab17a66 5y agoThe counterpoint is that places and culture can change. I’m sure there was a huge kerfuffle when cars started sharing roads with horse-drawn carriages in London, and I’m sure some people thought cars would never have a place, but here we are. If self-driving cars hit the mainstream in North America and Europe, I guarantee seemingly unfit cities will adjust because truly autonomous vehicles have sooooo many benefits.
- brokenmachine 5y agoHow about Nigeria, lol! I'd love to see FSD handle this... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=umBS-HEUImM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=umBS-HEUImM
- dekhn 5y agoI do not expect FSD to handle that. Nor would I consider it an explicit design goal. However, I was just driving in my neighborhood in northern CA and saw conditions very much like that (I live next to a school and I was driving right when school let out).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]