8 ms·
> I'll repeat this until I'm blue in the face, has been responsible for smallest number of deaths of any form of energy generation and produce the lowest amount
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
> I'll repeat this until I'm blue in the face, has been responsible for smallest number of deaths of any form of energy generation and produce the lowest amount of CO2 (i.e. zero, other than construction).
Will you stop repeating this if I explain why it's false?
So first up, the stat is usually fatalities per TwH, since that skews things in Nuclear's direction, not just number of fatalities which would be won by some obscure but not very successful power source.
Second, even with the correct metric, solar and wind are now beating nuclear and projected to continue to do so, widening the gap over time. Comparing the very start of the renewable rollout gives misleading stats as the total power generated is low, and many stats that get quoted on this are more than a decade out of date.
You can build a wind turbine and ritually sacrifice someone on completion of the build and the fatalities per TwH is infinite as it's not generated any power yet, but with every year of operation it gets lower.
Basically the same applies to carbon output, nuclear does well, but wind/solar/nuclear have been basically tied on both metrics unless you're relying on some very, very old data.
Of course if you have a limited amount of money to spend, then you'll generate more energy and save more lives with whatever the cheaper form of energy is, so we should really take that into consideration too.
https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy
- schnitzelstoat 5y agoBut it doesn't matter anyway - wind and solar should complement to nuclear, not to replace it. This year we saw weaker summer winds in Europe which is part of what has caused the current energy crisis. These weaker winds are expected to become more common as climate change continues.[1] Nuclear has the benefit that it's reliable. If you design a plant to output X gigawatts - it'll still be able to do so regardless of the weather. [1] https://theconversation.com/what-europes-exceptionally-low-winds-mean-for-the-future-energy-grid-170135 https://theconversation.com/what-europes-exceptionally-low-w...
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoNo, nuclear plants are regularly taken offline for weather related reasons. The main problem seems to be that people have invented an entirely ficticious nuclear power that does not and has never existed, just so they can slag off renewables and "elite culture" whatever the heck that is. The real actual nuclear power, which is better than coal, but not particularly competitive with modern renewables is apparently irrelevant to people who have bizarrely joined a one sided culture war on the side of fossil fuel companies and think this makes them cool, well informed and counter-cultural despite reality leaning the other way.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> No, nuclear plants are regularly taken offline for weather related reasons. Do you have a source for this?
- formerly_proven 5y agoEvery summer in France
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwaway894345 5y agoSource? Is this inherent in all nuclear plants, or only in certain designs?
- maccard 5y agoNot OP but I google dit and found this [0] from almost 20 years ago. No mention of it being every summer though, and it was during a heat wave that disproportionately affected france. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2003/aug/12/france.nuclear https://www.theguardian.com/world/2003/aug/12/france.nuclear
- b3orn 5y agoAll designs that take water from rivers and return it there. There usually is a regulation for the maximum water temperature in the rivers, so during the summer they can't heat up the water as much, leading to lowered energy output to the point where they have to shutdown some or all reactors of a plant.
- throwaway894345 5y agoThat doesn’t imply that nuclear plants regularly get close to this threshold nor that it’s common for all nuclear plants of this type (consider 2 identical plants positioned on differently-sized rivers: the larger river will be able to absorb more heat than the smaller river, ergo reliability of this sort varies).
- Gwypaas 5y agoThey don't. They explicitly compete for the same spot, the cheapest most inflexible power generation. Nuclear obviously loses here and are pushed closer to the peaker side and is hampered by the insanely costly initial investment. The closer to peaker you are the more you want the price to only be operating costs.
- caoilte 5y agodunno why this got down voted. Nuclear is a terrible peaker tech and yet pairing it with solar/wind requires it to be flexible and so you end up overproducing. There isn't a perfect scalable peaker / clean generation tech unfortunately but storage does the trick instead.
- Zigurd 5y ago"Do everything" is wrong. This is why: You want the most power per dollar of capex, and you want to have it come on line as fast as possible. Electricity is fungible. You can't tell a coal watt from a solar watt from a nuke watt. If you want to avoid coal, oil, and gas for externalities, you want the thing that costs the least and arrives soonest. That's renewables. Every dollar spend on nuclear would deliver more power sooner if spent on renewables.
- flawi 5y agoExcept you can't just invest it all into renewables and expect to have a stable power grid, the equation isn't quite as simple as "avg_power / $ capex". Last analysis I saw of this argued that the amount of "over-provisioning" needed to cover baseline demand with renewables made them prohibitively expensive as the sole solution. Peaker and storage solutions aim to solve that, but you need to build that capacity in addition to renewables.
- Zigurd 5y agoRenewables are nowhere near to running up against the need to buy more grid interconnection, storage, synfuel technology, or other ways of using surplus power and providing power from storage or from other regions. Until renewables displace a lot more fossil fuel power, those costs are not a consideration. That might happen within a decade in places like New Zealand. Still, capex on grid scale storage is up and costs are trending down: https://www.renewableenergyworld.com/storage/investment-trends-in-grid-scale-battery-storage/#gref https://www.renewableenergyworld.com/storage/investment-tren...
- bryanlarsen 5y agoHere's a fully costed plan to green the grid. It only requires over-provisioning of 20%. https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/electrify https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/electrify Here's an anti-renewable paper that quite ironically makes the point quite well that battery storage is quite viable: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-26355-z Take a look at the graphs at the back. It shows a 99.99% reliable grid made up of an optimal mix of solar & wind, 3x over-provisioned along with 3 hours of storage and a continental grid. We don't need 3x over-provisioning because the paper doesn't include hydro or existing nuclear. And 3 hours of storage is a lot of batteries, but it's a lot cheaper than building new nuclear.
- major505 5y agoThe main power grid should be always from a predictable source. wind and solar are far from that. And there's the problem of disposing solar panels and old wind turbines. We came a long way, but there's a lot of space for improvements. Meanwhile, nuclear energy is a stable and mature technology.
- pfdietz 5y agoThere is no need for a base load source to supply a base load of demand. Intermittent sources + storage to fill in the gaps can work just fine. The new thing is that this latter approach is looking like it will be cheaper.
- major505 5y agoIm no expert on batteries, but I don't see giant watery banks working in large scale, in most cities in the world. Today the better way to store energy still is with water reservoirs, and its expensive as hell, and you need a gigantic space that will be flooded.
- FredPret 5y agoThat’s a LOT of batteries…
- pfdietz 5y agoThe world is going to spend maybe a quadrillion dollars on energy over the next century. Big problems have big solutions.
- dmitriid 5y agoPhysics couldn't care less about your "big solutions". All energy storage solutions we have are low capacity, slow to charge, slow to bring online, and often are extremely harmful to the environment to produce. Of course, you can close your eyes, and pretend this will be solved by magic in the nearest future. It won't. And we need solutions now.
- kitkat_new 5y agowell, don't you get more solar power in the summer? seems like that can minimize seasonal storage requirements once higher level of renewables are in the grid
- missedthecue 5y agoSolar panels are less efficient when they get warm.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 5y agoAgree completely. It seems very naive on the one hand to say that climate change is making climate more chaotic and and then turn around and say that we will put all our eggs in the baskets of tech that literally doesn’t work if there isn’t suitable climate (wind and solar).
- hypertele-Xii 5y ago> Nuclear has the benefit that it's reliable. If you design a plant to output X gigawatts - it'll still be able to do so regardless of the weather. Unless, of course, the weather is an earthquake followed by tsunami. Or political weather.
- ThunderSizzle 5y agoAlthough a bunch of solar panels or wind turbines on the coast that are washed away by a tsunami isn't reliable either. Or when there's no wind or sun. If it takes a tsunami to turn off a nuclear plant, it's about as reliable as it can be.
- dmitriid 5y ago> the total power generated Total power generated doesn't matter as much as you think it does. Base load and load following matter never factor into the starry-eyed discussions of renewable power sources. Weak winds at night? Boom, suddenly you require other means of producing energy.
- pfdietz 5y agoYou can back that up with combustion turbines. The cost/watt of a simple cycle combustion turbine powerplant is just 5% of the cost/W of a nuclear power plant (combined cycle, just 10%), so backing up the entire grid this way is cheap (in capital cost) compared to the capital cost of a nuclear-powered grid. If you don't use those turbines very often, the fuel cost is manageable, even if you use non-fossil fuels like "green" hydrogen. To cut down on that fuel cost, you can also add some batteries to reduce the fraction of time the turbines are required to operate.
- dmitriid 5y ago> You can back that up with combustion turbines. So, back that up with burning natural gas. > so backing up the entire grid this way is cheap (in capital cost) compared to the capital cost of a nuclear-powered grid. > To cut down on that fuel cost, you can also add some batteries to reduce the fraction of time the turbines are required to operate. So, the "cheap" is in reality: - many gas powered energy plants (that are not there, and need to be built) - plus many batteries (that are not there, and need to be built) - plus cheap natural gas to burn So much for "green energy already has the capacity to replace something"
- pfdietz 5y ago> So, back that up with burning natural gas. You didn't read my whole comment there. One could use green hydrogen.
- dmitriid 5y ago> One could use green hydrogen. Ah yes. It's a thing that - can be cheaply produced at scale - can be easily transported to large distances - infrastructure can be easily and quickly converted to using it
- shafyy 5y agoExactly this. And even leaving out deaths and the high long-term environmental uncertainties of nuclear waste storage, solar and wind are already cheaper and will continue to get cheaper for the forseeable future. Now, people will say "bUT tHe sUn dOeSn'T sHiNe aT NiGhT", and that's true for the moment. Right now, we cannot shift everything to solar and wind. But if you pay attention to battery development, you don't need to be Einstein to see that pretty soon, we will be able to cost-efficiently store large amounts of energy, distribute it and use it in a way which will solve this intermittency problem. You can look at the data and read more about this here: https://ourworldindata.org/cheap-renewables-growth https://ourworldindata.org/cheap-renewables-growth
- zdragnar 5y agoThere's a solar panel field I go by occasionally. Last time I saw them, all the panels were covered in inches of snow. I guess nobody bothered clearing them off since we can have weeks go by without much if any direct sunshine in the winter, and windy days are equally infrequent. I don't know how many batteries it would take to make up for the losses. I suspect we will have gas and nuclear plants for a long while yet.
- shafyy 5y agoThat's very anecdotal, I'm sure that most solar panels are not usually covered by snow.
- tomp 5y agoYou do realize that there exist countries where it snows regularly? When that happens, even if it’s just 1 week/year, you require battery capacity to cover that one week.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoPanels are black, slick, inclined and warmer than ambient. Snow accumulation is generally not a problem.
- throwawaylinux 5y ago> So first up, the stat is usually fatalities per TwH, since that skews things in Nuclear's direction, not just number of fatalities which would be won by some obscure but not very successful power source. Why wouldn't it be fatalaties per TWh? It's TWh by the way. > Second, even with the correct metric, solar and wind are now beating nuclear and projected to continue to do so, widening the gap over time. Comparing the very start of the renewable rollout gives misleading stats as the total power generated is low, and many stats that get quoted on this are more than a decade out of date. > You can build a wind turbine and ritually sacrifice someone on completion of the build and the fatalities per TwH is infinite as it's not generated any power yet, but with every year of operation it gets lower. No, wind towers don't have infinite generation, require maintenance and decommissioning, and have been well around for long enough that statistics are quite well available throughout the lifecycle. People have been acting like we've been at the very start of the renewable rollout for the past 30 years, which is longer than the operating life of an average wind turbine. > Basically the same applies to carbon output, nuclear does well, but wind/solar/nuclear have been basically tied on both metrics unless you're relying on some very, very old data. Again I've been hearing that renewable energy will solve all this and nothing else can for the past 20 years if not more. Hundreds of nuclear plants could have been built and running in that time now. Funny thing is it keeps getting repeated. Again, and again, and again, by people who don't understand the fundamentals. Coal was doomed, completely on the way out and destroyed by wind and even solar just a couple of years ago according to these very same anti nuclear people. Today, thermal coal prices have been at record highs for the past year. Coal production is ramping in many countries and global consumption is near record highs and will take many decades to drop. Coal plants are being built with 40 year lifespans. Where's wind and solar? Still only make up little more than 10% of global electricity generation. Most of the stats for renewables quoted includes hydro which exceeds both of them combined.
- Aeolun 5y ago> Still only make up little more than 10% of global electricity generation Only? Not very long ago that stat was less than a percent, if it was mentioned at all.
- 5y ago
- causi 5y agoSecond, even with the correct metric, solar and wind are now beating nuclear and projected to continue to do so, widening the gap over time. This is true but not very significant since nuclear is still forty times safer than the next safest energy source, natural gas. Solar, nuclear, and wind all have a niche in a green future. Nuclear fits in locations with insufficient wind and solar resources and provides reliable base supply.
- pfdietz 5y agoWhy does nuclear have a niche in a green future? I don't see it surviving. Locations with insufficient wind/solar will be supplied externally, either by grid or by transport of synthetic chemical fuels. Places like very high latitudes (where wind is often very good, btw) are so sparsely populated they cannot by themselves sustain a nuclear industry.
- Aeolun 5y agoIf we string solar plants all around the planet, the sunny side can always supply the night side.
- kalleboo 5y agoThat would require world peace
- rekoil 5y agoAnd lossless energy transmission. And several large floating sea cities full of engineers to maintain it all.
- throw0101a 5y ago> If we string solar plants all around the planet, the sunny side can always supply the night side. Does this include stringing them across the Pacific Ocean, which covers thirty percent of the Earth's surface?
- 5y ago
- slothtrop 5y ago> solar and wind are now beating nuclear and projected to continue to do so Projected is the operative word. One useful concept that was introduced a decade ago is a "cubic mile of oil", or CMO. To yield the equivalent power, one would need to produce 250,000 roof-top solar systems a day for 50 years, or 1200 turbines a week for 50 years, or 1 nuclear power plant a week for 50 years. Innovation is still desperately needed here. Nuclear has been unfairly sluggish in this department.
- Aeolun 5y agoOr, to give a counterexample. You would need ~1.4 million barrels of oil per day for 50 years.
- slothtrop 5y agoGuess what? - https://www.worldometers.info/oil/ https://www.worldometers.info/oil/ edit: it is still weird to see Venezuela at the top spot and just how badly they squandered it
- StillBored 5y agoOne nuke plant a week for 50 years sounds like a lot, but they aren't really that complex, and 52 a year isn't really that many construction projects worldwide. Your talking 2600 plants. If every mid sized+ city in the world started building one today, and it took 5 years to construct, and they started a new one every other year (so they were being built in parallel). The problem would be solved within a decade. A year or so ago, I looked at the cost of South Texas Project in Texas, and how much power it generates and figured out that for roughly a single year's state budget one could build 10x those plants, which would remove all natural gas, and coal electric production in the state. Do it a second time, and there would be enough to actually move a significant part of the cars to electric too.
- throwaway894345 5y ago> So first up, the stat is usually fatalities per TwH, since that skews things in Nuclear's direction, not just number of fatalities which would be won by some obscure but not very successful power source. We aren’t debating obscure energy sources anyway, so I don’t see what the point is. This is absolutely the correct unit. > solar and wind are now beating nuclear and projected to continue to do so, widening the gap over time Rooftop solar is still losing, but yes renewables in general are still competitive. If the anti-nuclear lobby would allow nuclear to advance beyond 70s tech we could probably see a lot of advances on the nuclear side as well, especially with smaller mass-produced reactors. It’s pretty crumby to criticize nuclear when you’re putting your thumb on the scales. Moreover, are these figures measuring the actual production or just the capacity? You need a lot more than 1TW of solar or wind capacity to produce 24TWh of energy in a 24 hour period because these energy sources aren’t reliable. You also need something to store the energy (or transmit excess energy to places that can use it)—the construction of which increases the cost, carbon footprint, and fatality count. Frankly, all of these sources blow fossil fuels out of the water so I don’t much care which of them we use, but we should have a diverse mix for reliability and we should prioritize what works rather than waiting for a technological miracle for economically storing renewable energy.
- StillBored 5y ago<i>Rooftop solar is still losing, but yes renewables in general are still competitive</i> They aren't though, how many people do you know with an electric car, solar panels, a battery, without a grit tie? AKA they get all their power from renewables? I personally don't know anyone like that, although I know plenty of people with solar, an electric car, or even a small solar+battery setup. Why is that, because its super expensive, the tesla will be the cheapest part of the equation when your done. And that applies to PV and wind at grid scale too, because for every MW of PV+Wind being installed there is a MW of natural gas plants being installed. So the actual cost of a wind turbine isn't just the turbine/panel, its the gas plant and its fuel. Which means that until we get magic pixie dust batteries that are less expensive than a gas plant, the price of wind or PV will never really go lower than whatever the cheapest backup source is. And that is the fundamental issue with the economics of solar/wind. Worse, battery costs can't just be added in because one has to take the duty cycle of the renewable source and multiply it enough (maybe 5x-10x) to get a 100% average duty cycle sufficient to charge those batteries. So, at this point to get a rough approximation of the price of wind + PV needed to compare it fairly against the legacy power generation one needs to multiply by maybe 10x. And that is why every random person with a farm isn't covering turning their land into power generation. So, maybe solar thermal solves the battery problem, but AFAIK its crazy expensive at this point too. So, we keep pumping carbon out our tailpipes because we can't even get renewables to grow significantly, nevermind actually dealing with the impact of doubling or tripling the electric production needed to heat peoples houses and charge their cars. The only question is how many more decades we will pump C02 into the atmosphere before we say enough, and either dump massive amounts of money into renewables, deal with grid instability, and try to "conserve" out way out of a crisis, or just get out of the way and start reprocessing the "waste" we have sitting around into new plants that can for a small fraction of the construction costs actually solve the problem.
- DrBazza 5y agoWhy is it false? I'm talking about absolute numbers here, not TWh, and I'm comparing to fossil fuels, but even if we talk about just wind: > In England, there were 163 wind turbine accidents that killed 14 people in 2011. Wind produced about 15 billion kWhrs that year, so using a capacity factor of 25%, that translates to about 1,000 deaths per trillion kWhrs produced (the world produces 15 trillion kWhrs per year from all sources). > These are pretty low numbers. By contrast, in 2011 coal produced about 180 billion kWhrs in England with about 3,000 related deaths. Nuclear energy produced over 90 billion kWhrs in England with no deaths. In that same year, America produced about 800 billion kWhrs from nuclear with no deaths. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2013/09/29/forget-eagle-deaths-wind-turbines-kill-humans/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2013/09/29/forget-ea... I'm sure deaths are going to increase in the production, erection, and servicing of tens of thousands of wind turbines, by tens of thousands of employees. But you can simply tally up all the deaths for nuclear accidents, direct or indirect, and they're still less than other forms of energy generation. Presumably you're disputing the deaths, but the link you gave is deaths per TWh is lower. Except by absolute deaths it's.... higher. Which was my point, and is reinforced in the quote above. > Second, even with the correct metric, solar and wind are now beating nuclear and projected to continue to do so, widening the gap over time. Yes, deaths per TWh will go down, but power generation will go up, as there is more solar/wind, but so will deaths as more people build, install, and maintain those systems. Those absolute deaths keep rising.
- vanusa 5y agoI'm talking about absolute numbers here, not TWh, and I'm comparing to fossil fuels, "Of any form of energy generation" you said.
- throwaway0a5e 5y ago>Second, even with the correct metric, solar and wind are now beating nuclear and projected to continue to do so, widening the gap over time There is no way in even napkin math for this checks out. The amount of construction per generation capacity is orders of magnitude lower for nuclear. For nuclear you build one fancy concrete box and then feed it a fairly minimal amount of fuel for 50+yr. With wind and solar you need far more expansive facilities for equivalent generation capacity and you need to replace them far more often. Even if you assume a zero carbon supply chain the larger supply chain means that solar and wind have a far larger environmental impact (more mines, more factories, more roads, etc, etc, etc). Considering the amount of lip services paid to externalities in these sorts of conversations I don't know why this point keeps getting missed but I will note that is is very convenient for some people to miss it.
- pfdietz 5y agoThe problem is the nuclear construction is much more finicky. You screw up 1% of the modules in a solar field, your output is down 1%. You screw up 1% of the welds or concrete pours in your nuclear plant, it's time for enormous pain.
- throw0101a 5y agoHow about: * stop shutting down current nuclear electrical generation capacity * build more solar and wind capacity * as more renewable capacity comes online use it retire fossil fuel generators Once all the carbon-emitting stuff is offline then perhaps look at shutting down current nuclear. You know: the opposite of what Germany is doing.
- b3orn 5y agoGermany is shutting down coal power plants, not just nuclear. Last year eight lignite fired plants and ten hard coal fired plants were shut down. A total of 7.6 GW, compare that to the 4.3 GW of nuclear that was also shut down last year. Source: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ausstieg_aus_der_Kohleverstromung_in_Deutschland#Stilllegung https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ausstieg_aus_der_Kohleverstrom...
- throw0101a 5y agoWould they have been able to shutdown coal/gas faster if the nukes were kept running? If the 4.3 GW of nuclear was still around, how many more plants—with their corresponding CO2 emissions—could have been eliminated? Could Germany reduce its dependency on Russian gas with more nuclear?
- rekoil 5y agoProbably, but they like gas, Germany have decided that gas is somehow renewable.
- VyperCard 5y agoThe plan is to replace it with electrolyzed Hydrogen
- b3orn 5y ago> Would they have been able to shutdown coal/gas faster if the nukes were kept running? Probably, but it's not just the politicians and the population who don't want nuclear power, it's also the operators. They're not interested anymore as they can't plan ahead. If the current government decided that the nuclear power plants should run longer they would all need to get modernised first, meaning the operators would have to invest and who says the next government won't shut down them down again. Nobody is going to invest in building a new nuclear power plant that may or may not enter operation in 15-20 years. > Could Germany reduce its dependency on Russian gas with more nuclear? Short answer: No. Germany mostly relies on gas for heating, not for electricity.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hypertele-Xii 5y ago> You can build a wind turbine and ritually sacrifice someone on completion of the build and the fatalities per TwH is infinite as it's not generated any power yet, Only for the first wind turbine. For your Nth wind turbine, you sum all the TwH generated by all previous turbines as well as their deaths, including those ritual sacrifices.
- funklute 5y ago> So first up, the stat is usually fatalities per TwH, since that skews things in Nuclear's direction Isn't this precisely the metric you want? If you want to convince me (and perhaps others as well), I think you need to go a little more into the details why this is a bad thing. It's not obvious to me. > You can build a wind turbine and ritually sacrifice someone on completion of the build and the fatalities per TwH is infinite as it's not generated any power yet, but with every year of operation it gets lower. Related to my above point, should it not be expected fatalities over the projected lifetime of whatever plant/turbine/etc.?
- GuB-42 5y agoI have conflicting data about deaths per TWh https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldwide-by-energy-source/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/494425/death-rate-worldw... Most other sources repeat either numbers. And it is not surprising, because we are talking about very different things. Solar-related deaths are mostly people falling from rooftops, Hydro-related deaths mostly come from a single event: the Banqiao dam failure, and Nuclear-related deaths depend a lot on how you count Chernobyl and Fukushima. Coal goes through the roof, mostly because of pollution. We simply don't know how many people die from the Chernobyl disaster, from 31 to hundreds of thousands, yes, it is that fuzzy. I think the most official number is around 4000, but who knows what number they used to make these numbers? It is probably in the fine print somewhere if really look for it. Mining operations are also taken into account, but how deep shall we go into the supply chain? Do we count the fatalities related to the raw materials that make the plant? What about the guy who dies in a car accident going to work at the power plant? Do these numbers even make sense or are they just politics? By carefully picking my metrics, I could probably make coal looks very safe and solar very dangerous if I wanted to.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoIts not conflicting data, its just the decade old numbers I mentioned in my comment. The link I used used those numbers before they updated them with newer data.