6 ms·
I think a threat of violence or something could be worthwhile. But “grossly offensive”, man that’s absurd.
by duxup 5y ago
I think a threat of violence or something could be worthwhile.
But “grossly offensive”, man that’s absurd.
- capableweb 5y agoAbsolutely, we should not hold back in punishing people who are threatening violence against others, or otherwise try to get other people to commit acts of violence. But that someone tweeting “the only good Brit soldier is a deed one, burn auld fella buuuuurn” is guilty of anything besides being lame, is beyond what I can understand. It seems like this is about something more than just being "grossly offensive", did this somehow make someone in the military upset or something? Surely it can't be illegal to be offensive now can it? > The 72-year-old [Janet Hunter Jess], whose family served in the armed forces, said: “To see someone wishing British soldiers dead, it still hurts me. It still hurts me that anybody would disrespect someone that had given their live for the country.” > Ms Jeffrey, 51, stated: “First of all, the gentleman in question had done so much to raise awareness and funds for the NHS in England and became a bit of a national hero at the time, but then the fact it referred to British soldiers as well. It seems indeed this is more about that people in the military, or related to those with people in the military, was offended by the tweet. I wonder if the irony around that this fellow fought in the second world war for freedom of speech for everyone is hitting any of these people offended at the tweet.
- version_five 5y agoThe judges explanation makes the ruling sound even more ridiculous This is a man who had become known as a national hero, who stood for the resilience of the people of a country struggling with a pandemic and the services trying to protect them.
- jackvalentine 5y ago> I wonder if the irony around that this fellow fought in the second world war for freedom of speech for everyone is hitting any of these people offended at the tweet. I'm not aware of WW2 being about freedom of speech.
- mlyle 5y ago> I'm not aware of WW2 being about freedom of speech. I'm pretty sure if Britain had ended up being occupied, they'd have had less freedom of speech than they enjoy today.
- jackvalentine 5y agoI expected this reply. It doesn’t make the war about freedom of speech, it makes the war about resisting invasion (for Britain). The Britain of the time had a tremendous desire to censor things they deemed unseemly which lasted long past the end of the war - see for example various obscenity trials regarding the publication of books in the 60s and 70s.
- mlyle 5y ago> It doesn’t make the war about freedom of speech, it makes the war about resisting invasion (for Britain). Yah, but fighting to resist invasion also means fighting to preserve values and legal protections. [which may not have been the best in the world then, or interpreted as we'd interpret those values now, but still were better than the alternative].
- jackvalentine 5y agoYes, values and legal protections which didn’t include freedom of speech.
- tsimionescu 5y ago> Yah, but fighting to resist invasion also means fighting to preserve values and legal protections. An invasion is the same whether you are being invaded by people who believe in free speech or by people who don't. WWII was in no way about free speech. Germany was invading other countries not to impose their values and compelled speech, but to create "living space" and take their resources for the "German people". People war opposing this because they didn't want to be killed, nor did they want to serve the "German people" nor did they want their resources to belong to Germany. Nothing much would have changed in the opposition to German occupation if Germany had been a democracy with equality for all and deep protection for free speech, but still hell bent on conquering and controlling all of Europe.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago> "To see someone wishing British/Russian/Chinese soldiers dead, it still hurts me. It still hurts me that anybody would disrespect someone that had given their live for the country.” Given that soldiers typically kill people, it seems inevitable that someone will hate them, whether justified or not. If you look at countries that demand unconditional patriotism, they are usually flirting with dictatorship or outright fashism. It's not something a free society should emulate.
- racl101 5y agoAgreed. On a side note, Ari Shaffir better clean up his act. He said some bad shit about Kobe after he died.
- djbusby 5y agoStraight to jail, right?