26 ms·
Red Light Green Light
- noisy_boy 5y agoI developed a habit of looking at the cross traffic light to be "ready" for the upcoming green. I thought I was being smart and then I started noticing other people doing the same. Now I think just looking at the light directly is the totally fine obvious thing to do instead of this over-eagerness.
- mcv 5y agoI'm glad I'm having these traffic light discussions with my kids on foot or on a bike. That way I can be sure about what they can see. Or when we have it in the car, it's when they're in the front seat at least, but I'm a poor enough driver that I'd rather focus on traffic than try to teach my kid while driving.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- valbaca 5y ago
- aseattledev1234 5y agoHa, fictional stories are so much better right?
- dang 5y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments.
- jonatron 5y agoThe Chinese for traffic light is red-green-light (hónglǜdēng).
- creakingstairs 5y agoInteresting. It's 신호등(shin ho deung) and 信号灯(shin go tou) in Korea and Japan. Both literally meaning signal(信号, 신호) light(등, 灯), so I would have thought Chinese would use something similiar (I can see 灯 is being used). I wonder why that happened. Maybe because red is an auspicious color? Or maybe because the word may have originated from Japan and they wanted a different word? or maybe simply because that's what people started to call it and it stuck?
- Waterluvian 5y agoThis anecdote is a ridiculously great example of something I’ve found to be VERY VERY IMPORTANT with parenting (and probably lots else.) You must be incredibly delicate with “wrong” answers otherwise you might gaslight, discourage, or otherwise mess with your child’s ontology. I’ve learned to ask “why do you think that?” When I get a “confident wrong answer” as I call them. A surprising amount of the time my child has some very rational explanation. Someone once told me, “most arguments among engineers boils down to communication. Usually you’re not arguing about the exact same thing.” These moments with my child really made me grok that. I wish “being wrong with an explanation” was rewarded the way it should be when I was a kid.
- JetAlone 5y agoI think it would be worthwhile to ask "why do you think that?" on some confident correct assertions as well. Will help with collaborating on developing the child's use of rationality in case they're right for the wrong reasons, and also to avoid overly associating being asked why with being wrong.
- RangerScience 5y agoNote that (AFAIK), for adults, "why" can get you the wrong response (puts people on the defensive), so (AFAIK) it's recommended to use "what" instead (which tends to get at the "why" you wanted in the first place) - "why do you think that?" -> "what led to you thinking that?" :shrug: It works, sooooo.
- yazaddaruvala 5y agoI also stay away from second person: "what led to you thinking that?" -> "what led to that thought?" My preferred version: "what was the motivation for choosing that?". It's especially helpful on a team working with legacy software. Because the root cause can sometimes be a historic team decision, no longer attributable to anyone on the current team. Where "led you" can result in the "oh it wasn't my idea" responses, rather than "I think they made that decision because ..." responses.
- 1970-01-01 5y ago>>Now just think about the conversation from his point of view. Bad parents don't do this one simple thing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jds375 5y agoI had a very similar experience as a child. I always wondered how other drivers could tell which way we were turning. My parents told me that they can tell from your turn signal. 6-year-old me just thought turn signals entailed the green flashing arrows on the dash (not also on the car’s taillights). I just assumed all drivers were tall enough to see into the other car and tell from their dash (for at least the next year or so)!
- dgunay 5y agoFunny, I remember as a child wondering how my parents knew how to get where we were going. I saw the green lights on the dash (and couldn't see the signal lever from the backseat) and just thought that the car was smart enough to give them directions.
- LeoPanthera 5y agoYou were right eventually!
- JauntyHatAngle 5y agoThe problem with this analogy (as the author ties it up to the end point) is it implies you're leading a team that simply can't see the reality. More often, the change in perspective allows the person in the back seat to see the car that is about to run a red light and smash into you, rather than it being a question of presenting them a better context.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> it implies you're leading a team that simply can't see the reality If everyone on the team has the same level of visibility into everything, there is insufficient specialization and/or utilization. The child in the analogy wasn't blinded from seeing the light ahead. He could theoretically access that information. But in practice, he didn't, and that lead to a miscommunication.
- jonnycomputer 5y agoThe child wasn't seeing something that wasn't real. The child was looking at a different light. The miscommunication occurred because neither realized that they were looking at different lights.
- dclowd9901 5y agoI don’t think the story takes a position on who is right at what level (and, in fact, it sounds like the story teller herself concedes that leadership should be digging into why their teams are saying “red light” when it’s a green light). I think the story should be ingested as “we don’t know why someone else can’t obviously see what we see; that problem itself warrants investigations perhaps before any conversation about what to do next.” As it turns out, our company is currently having this problem: the market and employees of my company are screaming at the leadership to not follow through on a business plan, but leadership has their head buried in the sand and are bound and determined to move ahead because all they see is green lights. And sure, there’s enough anecdotes out there about people zagging when everyone else zigs, but I think an unspoken prerequisite to those anecdotes is that you at least made sure you understood why they were zigging.
- pkoird 5y agoI think this highlights the necessity of patience and compassion in everyday interactions. Sure I might be more experienced than my junior devs and sure, often times I have access to the broader picture and direction of the project but if they come up with something that runs to the contrary, the least I should be able to offer them is considerations on my part. As in, sit with them, try to understand why they think that way. This will have two possible effects: 1. I'll know that I have not been communicating enough with them and they are making inferences with limited or distorted assumptions. 2. I have been making incorrect assumptions or inferences. Needless to say, both of these have their own values. I think this is what is necessary in a teacher as well. Lots of time we say that people with genius thinking does not make a good teacher because they automatically arrive at the correct answer and are usually baffled by those who aren't able to do so. The genius required to be a teacher is the ability to predict the different (and not necessarily correct) ways that people can arrive at a conclusion and identify why and which path someone took for a particular problem... and be kind about it.
- aeternum 5y agoSimilar things happen surprisingly often in companies. Many intense arguments can be diffused by first being specific about what we agree upon. Just to add to this, one strategy from the rationalist community that I rarely see practiced is to 'taboo' certain words. For example if two engineers are arguing about a solution not being scalable, taboo the word scalable. They both re-explain their POV without using the word scalable at all. It often works like magic and they quickly reach a shared understanding.
- mdavis6890 5y agoI have never heard of this approach before, but it sounds flipping great. I will now look for arguments that I can start and then later solve with this method. Winners all around!
- Buttons840 5y agoI wish it was a common practice to ban certain words from difficult conversations. But whenever I suggest it people just talk past me as though I've said some weird thing. There's facts and opinions, but also definitions, and too often disagreements boil down to a different definition of a single word. Ban that word and say what you mean and the disagreement may suddenly be gone. Edit: I wrote this before reading the second paragraph. :) I'll leave it as an alternate way of saying the same. Let me ask, has anyone successfully "tabooed" certain words, or do people not understand the purpose of doing so?
- amarshall 5y agoI don’t think the parent commenter’s intent was that the words be universally banned, but instead context-specific words banned for a specific conversation. It’s just trying to remove implicitly differing definitions.
- kqr 5y agoI don't use the "taboo" terminology, but I frequently ask people to operationalise their definitions in arguments. ("What specific steps would I go through to test whether the system is scalable or not?") The first time I ask, people ignore it and/or don't understand it. The second time I ask, people get uncomfortable because generally they haven't thought about what they mean to that level of detail, and they try to weasel out of it. The third time I ask, it diverges. Some people give me a reasonable definition. Some people say "sorry that's not possible" and depending on the subject, I pause the argument at that point to do something else.
- csours 5y agoPoint of View and context are some of the most important things in communication. You can't remove point of view and have a conversation. Some of the hardest work I do is trying to understand what colleagues are saying.
- ummonk 5y agoIt's weird it took her so long to realize what was happening - I knew as soon as I read the first paragraph what was going on. I suppose it's because I am younger (and thus have memories of being a kid) and was rather short as a kid, so I know what sorts of limited visibility you can have as a kid, and more recently I'm also used to driving at confusing intersections where it's not clear which light applies.
- PebblesRox 5y agoI still remember the moment I realized (maybe at age 5 or so?) that even the cars coming toward us on the left side of the road were driving on the right side of the road from their perspective.
- lucb1e 5y agoYour comment was the top one and it encouraged me to just click through to the article and... I just don't get it after the first paragraph. Indeed, colour blindness? But that doesn't make you "know" it wrong, that makes you not be able to tell (afaik). So then... the kid was either joking, had learned it the wrong way around, or tied the name 'red' to the bottom position perhaps. ... turns out it's a localization problem. If you're sitting too low at the front of the queue, you'd see the overhead traffic light often better than the drivers do. I didn't think that this must, of course, be another USA-localization story and the traffic lights are elsewhere over there (across the crossing I guess). > used to driving at confusing intersections where it's not clear which light applies and I guess that explains why there are different systems. Why not change them around in the USA as well? It's not as if people could be confused and look at the wrong lights, as the others' lights are simply not visible when the lights are all on the side nearest to the lane(s) they apply to.
- nkurz 5y agoI'm not sure if you caught this or not, but I think the actual key to the story is that the child in the rear seat of the car and looking out the side window at the light for the stopped crossing traffic. Unfortunately for the anecdote, the "rear seat" part isn't mentioned until the 4th paragraph: "So I was in the back seat sitting next to Ben". I think the issue is that in the US, all children below some age must be in a car seat, and in some US states, that car seat must be in the back of the car. The author presumed that by mentioning her son was 3 at the time, that her audience would automatically understand that he was in the rear of the car. Even as an American, I didn't. I think it would make a better story if this was made explicit.
- adamredwoods 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blind_men_and_an_elephant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blind_men_and_an_elephant
- maximilianroos 5y agoLots of people are taking away "be kind when you listen to others' perspectives", which is right. But another point we can take away from this is: finding & amplifying the people who see colors that other people can't see — is a really valuable thing we can do, both for those people and your team.
- makeitdouble 5y ago> perhaps the problem has nothing to do with communication Going for experiments and research and never further discuss the situation with the kid feels to me like it has everything to do with communication...
- butwhywhyoh 5y ago
- metadat 5y ago> This woman comes off as incredibly weird and arrogant. Her first instinct is that her son is color blind, and then her next immediate instinct is to assign blame to her husband for that? She then goes on to run "experiments" on her child _FOR THREE WEEKS_ rather than just ask him a few simple questions that likely would have eliminated the confusion. Why so judgemental on the mom, butwhywhyoh? Being a parent is a difficult challenge in the best of circumstances. She's not claiming to have been an adept empath-of-children, so I don't understand where this is coming from. Is it possible this speaks more about you and your parental relationships? Half-joking here, if at all. This is an extremely common behavioral-baggage pattern that most of us hu-mans carry with us one way or another.
- serverlessmom 5y agoAn excellent post that illustrates a common problem of perception. For those questioning some of the statements being made I just wanted to point out that the storyteller is probably engaging in hyperbole in order to help bake her point clear and persuasive.
- civeng 5y agoThe book "Difficult Conversations" coauthored by Sheila Heen and referenced here is an incredible read. If the OP is interesting, I highly recommend you read the book. It seems it was written for people with analytical minds. I have memorized the steps and am in the process of internalizing the self awareness required to be effective in this area. Hard but seems really worth it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- youssefabdelm 5y agoFor those interested in this, you may also enjoy exploring the field of General Semantics: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLaoJIXlyLvLkMQUtbiTi17-cL09m7LRnm https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLaoJIXlyLvLkMQUtbiTi1...
- 6LLvveMx2koXfwn 5y agoMy child perspective story; When we were young we watched a TV program called Play School. We always watched it when we got home from normal school. Mum put on the TV and on came Play School. I didn't understand until much later that the act of turning on the TV didn't 'start' the program, so if, for whatever reason, we got home early I used to get super frustrated with my mum for not turning on the TV and letting me watch Play School straight away. Mum never took the time to understand why I was frustrated.
- el_benhameen 5y agoThe amount of on-demand kids content these days makes this even trickier now. I frequently have to explain to my kids that no, I can't play that song again because this is the radio and we can't control what it plays.
- PaulHoule 5y agoIt makes me think of the first slide in the first episode of Sliders where Quinn Mallory slides, thinks his machine failed, then realizes he slid into a world where the red light means go and the green light means stop and someone yells at him "Don't you know you're supposed to stop at a green light?"
- mulmen 5y agoGreat story but what's with the fixation on fault? It's nobody's fault if a genetic trait is inherited, there's no control over that.
- eurekin 5y agoIt was the first thing I noticed as well, the blame. It was like "blame the husband" was the terminal state of sorts, solving the issue somehow. Of course the anecdote is about changing the perspective, but I think there's an obvious elephant in this room as well
- ajuc 5y agoYou could argue if incest is morally bad then so is procreation when you have negative inheritable traits and know about them. It gets ugly pretty quickly from there though.
- Terry_Roll 5y agoThis seems like an external real world Schrodinger's cat.
- bricemo 5y agoI’m more impressed that James was able to just write up an excerpt from someone else’s podcast and make it to the top of hacker news
- martin_a 5y agoYes, this seems like a really "low-effort" post for an otherwise very technical and demanding audience.
- MichaelDickens 5y agoThe post adds value because it's significantly easier to consume than a timestamped link to a podcast.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gmiller123456 5y agoAs a kid my mom ran out of gas several times, and it was always on the same road, which had a gravel shoulder. We'd be riding along, she'd pull off into (what I call "the rocks"), the car would stop and she'd say "we're out of gas". Since the car was moving along fine before pulling off the road, and I had no concept of how cars worked, I made the connection that pulling into "the rocks" caused the car to run out of gas. After making that connection, I used to scream not to pull into the rocks when she ran out of gas. My parents eventually made the connection as to what I was thinking, and instead explaining how it worked used to tease me with it well into my adult years.
- dylan604 5y agoI got a similar teasing because I used the word "lightricity". Too too long ago to really know where/why my brain locked into that word. Lights=>electricity=>lightning, it all gloms together.
- mweatherill 5y agoWhen my daughter was 5 she told me off for driving too fast to school. She was annoyed that whenever I drove fast she would be late for school.
- GreenWatermelon 5y agoIn a sense, she was telling you to stop being late to school :)
- jmharvey 5y agoEarlier today I mentioned to my first grader that when I was a kid we didn't have an ice maker in our freezer, and we just used ice cube trays, instead. He sat there for a minute, stumped, and finally asked, "so what made the freezer cold?" It took me a minute to figure out what he meant, but finally I realized that he thought the way our freezer worked was that we had a machine that made ice, and the freezer was cold because it was full of ice. It's really easy to reverse cause and effect when you can't see what's happening.
- imgabe 5y agoWhen my brother was very young, maybe 4 or 5, he wanted to get McDonald's one day. My mom, for whatever reason, didn't want to and told him McDonald's food was too greasy. He insisted that it wasn't greasy at all. My mom told him it was. This went back and forth with him getting more and more upset until he finally screamed "GREASE IS WHAT DAD PUTS ON THE WHEELS OF THE CAR". My Dad always did all his own oil changes and lubed the wheels with a grease gun. My brother had watched him do this and was furious that he thought my mom was insisting that the thick axle grease that came out of the grease gun was what was on McDonald's food.
- mgarciaisaia 5y ago"A change in perspective is worth 80 IQ points" - Alan Kay
- danboarder 5y agoThis story highlights the value of putting yourself in the mindset and perspective of the "other" that you disagree with, to see things their way, for your own benefit. The entire Tim Ferris podcast episode (from which the quoted story was told - https://tim.blog/2021/09/09/sheila-heen/ https://tim.blog/2021/09/09/sheila-heen/ ) is good, and brought to mind an EconTalk podcast episode that explores how seeing and doing things in the interest of others is many times in one's own best interest in the long run: https://www.econtalk.org/michael-munger-on-desires-morality-and-self-interest/ https://www.econtalk.org/michael-munger-on-desires-morality-...
- QuadrupleA 5y agoSorry to be a curmudgeon, it's a poetic little story - but isn't the takeaway a little banal? "Different people have different perspectives." Well sure. "Consider things from others' viewpoints." Of course. I don't know, it rings a little of management-ese, or something overpaid consultants might present in the boardroom that gets everybody nodding their head and feeling like they've received great wisdom, but is a little hollow or obvious when you really break it down. It's a good takeaway, even if commonsensical I guess.
- bartvk 5y agoMaybe she meant that there was a lot more research needed before she understood him.
- whoisburbansky 5y agoI mean, it’s obvious in retrospect. If you’re the type of person who read the first half of this story and immediately went “Ah, I know what the problem is, the kid’s looking at the other signal!” then kudos to you for not needing this advice ever again, but I suspect the vast majority of folks could do with being reminded of common sense things from time to time.
- iforgotpassword 5y ago> If you’re the type of person who read the first half of this story and immediately went “Ah, I know what the problem is, the kid’s looking at the other signal!” I'm that person! :) But admittedly only because a friend experienced a similar thing when she worked as a kindergarten teacher for three months in Bolivia; a few days in she had a conversation with a little girl who seemed very bright to her in general, but then they talked about how you properly cross the street, and when she asked the girl about traffic lights, she insisted you walk when it's red. Turned out the town they were in didn't have signals for pedestrians, and since the signals for traffic are positioned like in Europe (ie not the other side of the junction) you had to check the signal for the cars and start walking when it turns red.
- atulatul 5y ago
- Stratoscope 5y agoWhen I was very young I couldn't say "milk". I called it "momo". But I could say "homogenized". So I'd ask my mom, "Can I have some homogenized momo?" She would reply "Do you mean homogenized milk?" I answered "Mom! I can't say milk!"
- jedberg 5y agoMy four year old just did this to me yesterday. I went through an intersection and he said, "daddy you just went through a red light". I got freaked out because it was an empty intersection but then I saw someone else go through and realized it was looking out the side window!
- eurekin 5y agoI love that the first reflex is to blame the husband.
- mihaic 5y agoI often realize that I'm caught in a conversation where we don't use the same terms/concepts. The hard part becomes getting the other person to slow down and actually explain their basic premise. People can get defensive no matter how you ask them "What do you mean by X?", and worst of all they sometimes have a fixed route they want to take and are just giving some pretext to justify their actions. I do my best, but I've never seen any framework that consistently works here (has anyone?), so I honestly think we need to work on this on a socio-cultural level. It might help with couples as well.
- eXpl0it3r 5y agoWhat often helps is if you frame it in a way that shows you as the less knowledgeable person, that way people tend to feel less "attacked". For example: "I didn't understand X, could you explain (again) what you mean by that?" But in the end, I guess the more important thing is to build up enough trust between the teams, that one isn't constantly driving the attack/defense line, but can openly talk about ideas and see questions as clarifying, rather than attacking.
- arketyp 5y agoRather than a lesson about perspective, my take away is about the resilience of the self-supervised signal, i.e. the child relying on sense data, even when the strongest of supervised signals is contradicting it, i.e. the mother/teacher.
- matsemann 5y agoMy take after reading this is a bit different than the others. I think it's absolutely insane that a three year old has to learn traffic rules to not be mauled to death by passing cars. What a fail of society.
- altacc 5y agoEven in countries with zero child deaths due to traffic, children need to have some traffic sense, and that's part of what helps keep the accident rate low. Cars exist and a child running into the road unexpectedly can still be injured by the safest possible car driven by the safest possible driver. Learning to cross the road is a basic skill children benefit from learning. Having traffic sense also gives them more freedom and a better roaming range. My son was very traffic conscious from a young age, so I could let him run ahead on the pavement and freely run around small parks near roads. Other parents held their kids close because they were constantly worried they would run into the road. My son started walking to school at age 7 as he knew how to cross roads. These things gave him a lot of trust & freedom early on than other kids don't have.
- hvusslax 5y agoThis is the norm in many places in Europe and elsewhere. 6 year olds walking to school by themselves and crossing multiple roads on the way. America is a bit different. It is also built completely differently when it comes to car-oriented infrastructure.
- afandian 5y agoAs someone with a child the same age, I see it very differenly. The way I explain it is that traffic lights, roads, crossings, etc, are a mechanism by which society co-operates. Everyone's trying to do something a little different, and if we work together and buy into a shared understanding then we can all do what we want to do. That's a really positive thing. We can all get on with what we need to without resorting to ideology which isn't relevant to the task at hand. Also, I think it's important for children to learn about everything around them, to see how the world works. It's irresponsible to leave a black hole of knowledge. Especially for things that can be dangerous. Mine knows all about volcanoes, dinosaurs, power tools, chisels, hammers, etc. And he's learned how to interact with at least some of those safely. Otherwise it's quite literally learned helplessness!
- teekert 5y agoI wish I wrote down all these kinds of things my kids have said. One thing I remember is my daughter explaining, full of confidence, to her brother that in summer the ice sinks to the bottom of the canal and it comes up in winter. Which is a very good hypothesis if you don’t know about phase changes in matter. Kids always say these kinds of things because the models of the world in their little heads are incomplete. But then, for who are they complete, really?
- eurekin 5y agoI'm always amazed at kids ability to quickly build hypotheses and communicate them. The one you mentioned is actually a great one and I wish people wouldn't stop doing that after they grow up. I find it very similar to what actual scientist do on the frontiers of knowledge, where no one really knows, what correct really is - yet. I wonder how the kid would react, if they saw the bottom of the canal in summer somehow -- missing the ice
- teekert 5y agoYeah exactly, I always try to (make them) come up with an experiment that would show if they’re right or not. Honestly it’s a challenge and my wife always points out that the kids have stopped listening. I need to learn to stay brief… It just happens so little that I get too excited when it does.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hyperbole 5y agoThat's cute, I have no idea what window the GOP is looking out of...
- emmelaich 5y agoI immediately guessed why, but for a slightly different reason. Some people when driving (e.g. me) have an unfortunate habit of looking at the other lights, to anticipate the green. I thought perhaps that the kid was watching the parent's head direction. In fact I suspect that this is the real answer. Lights aren't typically that hard to see ahead, even from the back seat.
- kubanczyk 5y ago> maybe he’s color blind, which then that would be my husband’s fault I've just discovered a huge deficiency in English. In my native language I've got a perfect response: I'm not guilty as I didn't broke any law. Which goes along with both classical nullum crimen sine lege and with UN's Universal Declaration of Human Rights no less: > No one shall be held guilty of any penal offence on account of any act or omission which did not constitute a penal offence, under national or international law, at the time when it was committed. The problem in English is the word "fault", which can mean both "a physical or intellectual imperfection" and "responsibility for wrongdoing" among its many meanings. Phew, try to defend against that, accusation of not being perfect.
- woodpanel 5y agoNever miss an opportunity to quote Marx: "Being determines consciousness!" ;-)