15 ms·
As I understand it, the reason an HIV vaccine has been so difficult to create is that HIV mutates so easily. I understand the basics behind how mRNA vaccines ar
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
As I understand it, the reason an HIV vaccine has been so difficult to create is that HIV mutates so easily. I understand the basics behind how mRNA vaccines are generated, but I don't understand why this approach would be expected to have any more success in evading the high mutation potential of HIV than other vaccine types. After all, it was even a concern with new coronavirus variants that the original Moderna vaccine would be less effective against them (and, indeed, while the original vaccine is still highly effective against all variants, my understanding is that it is less so than the original variant). And SARS-COV-2 mutates much less easily than HIV.
Can someone with more knowledge explain the thought process behind this?
- helloworld 5y ago"Prof. William Schief explains how the novel #HIV #vaccine being tested in human clinical trials can trigger the right #Bcells of the immune system to achieve the much sought after broadly neutralizing #antibodies." https://twitter.com/scrippsresearch/status/1358120854970912769 https://twitter.com/scrippsresearch/status/13581208549709127...
- dmix 5y agoDirect link to video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BrmXpMmvHWw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BrmXpMmvHWw This explains the background on broadly neutralizing antibodies that the other commenter `mlyle` mentions. Worth the watch.
- spamizbad 5y agoOne reason is that mRNA vaccines can be developed much faster than traditional vaccines. So the idea is you have a better chance of "outrunning" a strain.
- Vrondi 5y ago
- ausudhz 5y agoSo you think for other vaccine you know the "long term effects" What you define as "long term"? Because in my definition, in the "long term" we're all dead. The "long term" effects of many pathologies is also death for example.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> Because in my definition, in the "long term" we're all dead. My wife's studio got a "everyone who takes the vaccine will die!" pamphlet pushed under the door, which gave us a good chuckle.
- mlyle 5y agoThree things: - This isn't really the reason why mRNA is attractive here (see my other comment above). (Though, ability to iterate/try many protein combinations quickly in animal models was helpful). - Almost no drugs or treatments do we really know the long term picture of. Running studies in a way that lets you detect effects far later in life isn't practical. - When we're talking about treatments to prevent severe disease, bounding the consequences to be very, very likely to be well below the consequences of the virus times the likely infection chance is "good enough".
- ausudhz 5y agoNot to mention the long term effects of COVID are known and way worst that what a vaccine can give you. Vaccine are building an immune response, they're not drugs that try to cope the symptoms (eg. Panadol) and they are the safest drugs out there. Is so interesting how people eat Panadol and many other drugs like candies (without reading the KNOWN side effects - which are also nasty), while they focus so much on things they know nothing about thinking that has mysterious "long term effects"
- epgui 5y agoExactly this. I would rather take the "most unsafe" vaccine of the last 30 years than take an Advil. (I am a biochemist)
- f6v 5y agoI think slowly will come the realization that mRNA vaccines aren’t as fast to develop as people thought. Sputnik/AstraZeneca vaccines were released almost at the same time as Moderna/Pfizer. Yes, the latter were first commercial mRNA vaccines, but the technology is nevertheless rather mature. I watched a lecture by the people credited with creating mRNA vaccines and it turns out people have been working on the technology for decades. Now, the thing is that you can’t just sequence a virus, do bioinformatics, synthesize mRNA and package it into a nano particle. I mean, you can, but chances are it’s going to fail like the CureVac vaccine. The mRNA that gets packaged needs to be modified (I believe with alternative bases) to achieve desired effect. If mRNA vaccine was as magical as it was marketed, we wouldn’t be getting 3-4(and soon 5?) doses of the same vaccine with the emergence of new variants. Rather, there would be delta- and omicron-specific vaccine.
- glial 5y ago> Rather, there would be delta- and omicron-specific vaccine. I think there are -- they just haven't made it through the trials and approval processes yet. These are press releases from Pfizer for whatever it's worth: Omicron: https://www.pfizer.com/news/press-release/press-release-detail/pfizer-and-biontech-initiate-study-evaluate-omicron-based https://www.pfizer.com/news/press-release/press-release-deta... Mentions delta: https://cdn.pfizer.com/pfizercom/2021-07/Delta_Variant_Study_Press_Statement_Final_7.8.21.pdf?IPpR1xZjlwvaUMQ9sRn2FkePcBiRPGqw https://cdn.pfizer.com/pfizercom/2021-07/Delta_Variant_Study...
- f6v 5y agoYes, but what I meant was those would be already approved.
- copperx 5y agoWhat's the rationale behind your assertion?
- jsharpe 5y agoRegulation will take time to catch up. We manage to create and approve a flu vaccine every year, and that's likely because the general process has been approved, and so each iteration is fast tracked. I don't think that's the case with mRNA vaccines yet.
- mpalczewski 5y agoWe get a new flu vaccine every year, is this much different?
- driverdan 5y agoYes. It takes a long time to generate the flu vaccine. The strains need to be selected long before the season starts so it's a bit of guess work. That's why effectiveness varies from year to year. mRNA vaccines can be produced in high volumes much faster than traditional vaccines. It would allow the flu vaccine strains to be selected at a better time.
- trompetenaccoun 5y agoWorks great with the sars-cov-2 vaccine so far. That's why there are fewer symptomatic infections since the vaccines are out. /s
- selcuka 5y agoWhy the /s? I don't think there is a sure way to estimate what the number of total symptomatic infections would be if there weren't any vaccines, but the fact that unvaccinated are overrepresented in case statistics indicate that the vaccines are working as expected.
- driverdan 5y agoThere are far fewer symptomatic infections and deaths than there would have been otherwise.
- xienze 5y ago> One reason is that mRNA vaccines can be developed much faster than traditional vaccines. So the idea is you have a better chance of "outrunning" a strain. Is that why the response to Delta was "just take another dose of the original formulation" and the response to Omicron was "just take another dose of the original formulation until we have the new one made up in a few months"? And who doesn't see another strain taking over in the next few months, rendering this new formulation less effective than originally promised? My math may be off but there's been exactly one new Covid vaccine formulation in a little over a year, which is about how fast we crank out new flu vaccine formulations. Why exactly did we need to use mRNA tech to crank out new vaccines at the same speed as we did with traditional vaccines?
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y ago> Why exactly did we need to use mRNA tech to crank out new vaccines at the same speed as we did with traditional vaccines? mRNA tech is a lot newer than "traditional vaccines". I do not expect that the mRNA process is run at the same speed with the same degree of confidence at the same number of facilities. Yet.
- asveikau 5y agoI suspect the fact that we're in the middle of a pandemic has something to do with this, though. In particular, the demand is such that we urgently need hundreds of millions (or billions?) of doses. That takes a lot of effort to roll out. Most vaccines probably don't see use at that scale and speed. An HIV vaccine, for example, would probably initially only go out to communities with higher risk.
- selcuka 5y agoThey have trialled variant specific vaccines for both Delta and Omicron. It turned out that the original vaccine is as effective for Delta, so that work was shelved. Omicron, on the other hand, seems to be evading the immunity created by the Alpha vaccine, so they are actually planning to start producing an Omicron specific booster (or more correctly Alpha+Omicron) after FDA approval.
- 5y ago
- cdtwigg 5y agoI am not an expert, but there has been a lot of hope recently that because we have much better understanding of protein structure (e.g. https://cen.acs.org/pharmaceuticals/vaccines/tiny-tweak-behind-COVID-19/98/i38 https://cen.acs.org/pharmaceuticals/vaccines/tiny-tweak-behi...) and because mRNA allows us to tightly control the genetic sequence, there is hope we could target some part of the virus that _is_ well-conserved across variants. e.g.: https://pharmaceutical-journal.com/article/feature/preventing-the-next-pandemic-the-search-for-a-universal-flu-vaccine https://pharmaceutical-journal.com/article/feature/preventin...
- mlyle 5y agoThere's some known HIV "bnAbs", or broadly neutralizing antibodies. The thing is, these are not the antibodies most humans develop in response to HIV. Previous HIV vaccine attempts have only done a fair job at eliciting these broadly neutralizing responses. e.g. SAV001, a "whole killed" HIV vaccine, only produces broadly neutralizing antibodies in about a third of recipients (and less broadly neutralizing response in a much bigger fraction). The mRNA approach, like some recombinant approaches, seeks to generate just portions of envelope protein to tailor the response to produce these bnAbs.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThank you! Just the kind of explanation I was looking for, most appreciated.
- f6v 5y agoI’m not familiar with vaccine tech. Can’t you grow the peptide of interest and package it in a traditional vaccine?
- mlyle 5y ago> Can’t you grow the peptide of interest and package it in a traditional vaccine? Traditional way to do this is recombinant approaches (mentioned). These are also in progress. mRNA is much quicker to iterate, though. They tried a few candidate sequences in sHIV to guide their human vaccine development. mRNA vaccines are kind of neat in the way that they create a few day long pulse of new virus-like particles showing up, to ensure the immune system gets really annoyed.
- throwaway2037 5y agoWhen you wrote <<sHIV>>, did you mean <<Simian immunodeficiency virus (SIV)>>? Ref: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simian_immunodeficiency_virus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simian_immunodeficiency_virus
- 5y ago
- emiliobumachar 5y agoI definitely don't have any knowledge on the topic. Here are my crackpot opinions: 1) Maybe many or most infected have a single strain each, and a targeted vaccine to each's strain could work as a treatment, similarly to the tetanus and rabies vaccines. Even if not a full cure, could be a way to halt the disease progression with lower cost and side effects than the current treatments available. 2) HIV spreads relatively slowly, so maybe flu-style annual vaccinations to at-risk groups for hot strains could be enough to actually revert the epidemic over decades.
- f6v 5y agoRegarding your second point, isn’t HIV a preventable disease? In the areas where the prevalence is in double digits, people don’t seem to be using condoms or taking other precautions. Why would they be taking vaccine every year?
- arcticbull 5y agoIt's a lot easier to get folks to agree to one or two shots one time than to convince them to change their sexual practices, one would imagine.
- f6v 5y agoI somewhat agree, but condoms aren’t just for HIV and save from other potentially lethal diseases. So the benefit is just enormous, yet folks still don’t use them. At the same time, look the vaccination rates in the Eastern Europe. I suspect it’s somewhat hard to get people vaccinated against the disease they don’t take seriously. I mean, HIV is horrible. Yet so many people ignore protection.
- vineyardmike 5y ago> I mean, HIV is horrible. Yet so many people ignore protection. Because sex is good. And sometimes spontaneous. And often combined with other drugs (booze) and people make bad decisions.
- hcarvalhoalves 5y agoIf there's less spread of any given variant (because of vaccines), you indirectly decrease the chance of mutation no? A virus doesn't mutate outside a host.
- macilacilove 5y ago> As I understand it, the reason an HIV vaccine has been so difficult to create is that HIV mutates so easily. Nope. There are exactly two species of HIV since at least the '80s. HIV-1 and HIV-2. HIV however can trick the immune system into creating non-neutralizing antibodies, that can't fully prevent the progression of the infection. If you run a large pharma company you probably already make a lot of money from long-term HIV/AIDS treatment. From the CEO's perspective developing a HIV vaccine may shrink the antiretroviral market if at-risk groups vaccinate themselves. Therefore you prioritize more lucrative projects. HIV vaccine makes sense if: 1. You can hope for a general mandate of your product, or: 2. You are a small pharma company looking to make a name for yourselves. Regarding the benefit of mRNA vaccines over non-mRNA vaccines for HIV, I don't know. I have yet to learn if there is significant medical benefit to mRNA other than reduced cost and TTM. AFAIK mRNA does not enable producing new types of proteins, only this time they are produced by your body, right?
- copo233 5y agoYou're gonna need a citation or two for all of that.
- bluGill 5y agoThis conspiracy theory missed something important: competition. There are other companies with their own treatments either one the market or in development trying to take away your customers. If you can find a better treatment and roll it out you get all that money, if you don't you risk someone else finding it first and taking away all your sales anyway.
- macilacilove 5y agoThe more effective treatment will shrink the market, therefore market forces incentivize competitors to cooperate. It is the same reason that the OPEC exists. It is called game theory, not conspiracy theory.
- biorach 5y agoOPEC is not terribly effective and suffers from constant bickering behind closed doors. The same motives apply - even if there was a "HIV vaccine cartel" there would be a massive incentive to undercut it.
- thebradbain 5y agoI’m not a doctor, but as a gay man: it’s my understanding HIV doesn’t mutate in the same way a disease like Covid does, at least not in the sense that there’s as many opportunities to spread (i.e. not airborne), so while HIV may actually mutate more in theory, it gets less chances to spread, so less completely-different variants become widespread. Also, as part of “stopping the spread” PrEP has existed for years. It’s still proven to be effective protection against contracting HIV even if directly exposed (though it’s a pill that must be taken every day rather than a vaccine). There’s also PEP that helps make you undetectable (untransmissable) if you do contract it (and as such, it’s no longer what many people still mistakenly regard as a death sentence). I honestly don’t know why everyone who is sexually active isn’t on PrEP (the federal government even mandates it be free to those without insurance in most cases)— it should be as common practice as wearing a condom and birth control, yet its existence isn’t even known to many people (especially among straight people).
- wan23 5y agoSmall correction: PrEP (pre-exposure prophylaxis) and PEP (post-exposure prophylaxis) are both protocols for using drugs to prevent infection. You generally take PrEP drugs every day if you think you're in danger of being exposed, or alternatively take PEP if you think you have been exposed to HIV without any kind of protection, sort of like a morning after pill (but every day for a whole month).
- Drdrdrq 5y ago> ...sort of like a morning after pill (but every day for a whole month). Does this mean that there is a cure, but it only works if taken shortly after exposure (and for a whole month)?
- tragictrash 5y agoNot a cure, as that implies recovery from a full infection. It's preventing your body from becoming fully infected.
- whizzter 5y ago
- ampdepolymerase 5y agoI haven't looked into the Moderna vaccine but in general there are many ways to get rid of a virus. Using the typical B cell + viral glycoprotein is the most obvious way as viral activity is hard to detect when replicating inside a cell but there are many stages in the viral replication process which can be inhibited. Inhibiting protease cleavage of the viral polyprotein or preventing polymerase formation are all possible solutions. They don't really count as vaccines though.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIs this related to the concept of original antigenic sin?
- throw895389 5y ago[flagged]
- oblio 5y ago> Here's my take. This is the long term "mRNA platform" product plan slowly coming to fruition. Cool! When am I getting my free 5G?
- ismail 5y agoYour comment insinuates a conspiracy theory, equating OP comment with theories of 5g causing COVID. It does not add much to the discussion and comes across as dismissive. My experience is that as soon as we make a judgement call about someone, and put them in a pre-conceived box that we do agree with, we are unable to learn. I went and re-read OP post. nothing in it is close to what you are insinuating. Yes there may be some unsubstantiated claims, or calling out faucci but shutting down discussions with comments like yours are unhelpful.
- oblio 5y agoThe video they linked contains a cherry picked selection of quotes from Faucci and presumably pharma execs about accelerating vaccine approvals and arguing that a pandemic would help with that. Considering the rest of the comment and the throwaway account, yeah, for sure the comment was in conspiracy-land. My comment was useless, yes. Flagging it was probably much more impactful.
- balaji1 5y agoso everybody gets it soon?
- Justsignedup 5y agoLast I heard unless you can perfectly destroy it, any vaccine triggers a immune system response, which causes your body to bring more food right up to the virus. If we can attack the spike protein of the virus, and it can't mutate around it, then the t-cells can still kill it vs just getting consumed faster.
- trhway 5y ago>HIV mutates so easily. I understand the basics behind how mRNA vaccines are generated, but I don't understand why this approach would be expected to have any more success in evading the high mutation potential of HIV than other vaccine types. you buy not an mRNA vaccine shot, you buy subscription. We already getting a preview of it with the 3rd, 4th, ... Covid boosters. Allowing for cheap and fast vaccine development the mRNA tech is changing the business of vaccination. Add to that that in near future you'll be able to get personally customized mRNA vaccine. You'll just be getting your monthly/weekly vaccine subscription box. And why limit to vaccines? The mRNA can make your cells produce any protein. Imagine a subscription business possible here.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]