4 ms·
A magazine called The Economist should understand why we use almost all of our arable land for farming. It's because that's the cheapest way to do it. We coul
by bryanlarsen 5y ago
A magazine called The Economist should understand why we use almost all of our arable land for farming. It's because that's the cheapest way to do it.
We could grow all of our food in greenhouses and return 99.9% of our farmland to nature. We don't do that because that would be more expensive and cheaper alternatives make growing wheat & corn in greenhouses highly unprofitable.
Conversely, if suddenly 75% of the arable land came onto the market, it would drive the price of land down dramatically, making it profitable to farm it less intensively (aka more cheaply). In other words, we'd still farm about the same amount of land, but we'd use less fertilizer and herbicide and the price of food would go down. Those are awesome results, but land usage would not be significantly different.
- kiba 5y agoIf our government subsidizes investment in greenhouse, would that be sustainable?
- teaearlgraycold 5y agoI don’t think so. Subsidies are good when they get a market over a small initial cost. They pull you out of a local minimum. Greenhouses will never be cheaper than using the Earth as well always have.
- thecolorblue 5y ago> Greenhouses will never be cheaper than using the Earth as well always have. This needs to be tested. There are a lot of expenses in bare field farming including transportation, pest control, low yield from weather, etc.
- kiba 5y agoObviously, greenhouse makes sense, but only for relatively high value crops. My question was merely about the government not going bankrupt through large scale subsidization. But maybe I should consider research & development too.
- treesrule 5y agoI wonder if there are other things we'd do with land if the price of land came down Maybe we'd see more communes (or charter cities)? I know for a fact there are people constantly looking for places to buy and if things were cheap enough they'd jump on it.
- aerostable_slug 5y agoThere are still swaths of cheap land, even in California. They also sometimes have water issues and often have a rather disagreeable climate to many. Plus meth and illegal marijuana grow ops, the latter of which are so endemic and use so much water that local authorities have just removed fire hydrants from entire areas.
- pharke 5y agoAvailable land is not the limiting factor on new cities or communes. Look at the chart in the article and compare the amount of land used for urban development. Starting a new city or commune is the same as starting a new social media platform, why should I move from my current platform/city to your new one? How do you get your first 1000 subscribers/residents? What do you offer that other places don't already have 10x of? I'm not going to move to your commune/app unless all of my friends and family do too. etc.
- hackeraccount 5y agoThis gets at a question in my mind about what it'd be like if we were all rich enough to be able to afford that - growing all of our food in greenhouses or something like that.
- nradov 5y agoWhat's the point? Even if we were richer why would we waste resources by growing staple crops in greenhouses? It's tough to drive a big tractor or combine harvester through a greenhouse.
- wbsss4412 5y agoYields aren’t going to suddenly drop 75% simply because land is cheaper and less inputs are used.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoOn my father-in-law's land a normal wheat crop is 50 bu/acre and the neighboring organic farm averages about 10. Even more relevantly, it wasn't long ago that 25 bu/acre was a good crop. But the price of wheat and the price of land have gone up a lot in the last 25 years, so farmers have responded by using a lot more inputs.
- wbsss4412 5y agoYou definitely know more about wheat farming than I do so I’ll defer to you on that. However, the graphic shows at that the principle reduction would be in rangeland, not crop land. Is any of that land suitable for growing wheat if it’s not longer being used for cattle?
- bryanlarsen 5y agoA good chunk of rangeland is quite arable, but in traditional cattle country most of it is marginal. If you're willing to destroy the marginal land and willing to accept a high risk of crop failure, then most if it can grow wheat. In other words, sort of but not really.