4 ms·
Race-Based Rationing Is Real–and Dangerous
- docdeek 5y ago> Based on this scoring system, a 40-year-old Hispanic male in perfect health would receive priority over an obese, diabetic 40-year-old white woman with asthma and hypertension. This seems out of whack - shouldn’t a person with multiple co-morbidities get priority for a treatment? Is the gender important here, too?
- kragen 5y agoIt should be; men have twice the risk of death from covid. I'm guessing Shadi needed to add "male" because it turned out that male + Hispanic > obese + diabetic + asthma + hypertension > Hispanic.
- gaius_baltar 5y agoThe article links to this one, which has a screenshot of a table from the official document: https://freebeacon.com/coronavirus/hospital-system-backs-off-race-based-treatment-policy-after-legal-threat/ https://freebeacon.com/coronavirus/hospital-system-backs-off... Obesity, asthma, hypertension is worth 1 pt each. Man have 2 pts, Diabetes 3 pts. "Non-White or Hispanic" gives 7 points. So a White person with obesity, diabetes, asthma and hypertension will still be denied treatment, when it will be given to a Non-White person of the same gender and age with no comorbidity at all.
- treeman79 5y agoLook for deeper reasons. This is a way to divide people and put them against each other.
- WithinReason 5y ago"Meanwhile, Minnesota’s Department of Health used a scoring calculator that counted “BIPOC status” as equivalent to being 65 years and older [...]" Based on this sentence alone it might be hard to tell if the policy is inspired by the far-left or the far-right. Is it about excluding white people from treatment, or proclaiming the superiority of the white race? Is the political spectrum actually a circle? Or could this actually be reasonable in a way that I don't see?
- kragen 5y agoPresumably they were prioritizing treatment for those 65 or older over treatment for younger people, who will almost all get better without treatment, rather than leaving those over 65 to die. Even on the far right I don't think mass killing of retirees is a popular policy. In that context, being categorized as "equivalent to being 65 years and older" would be an advantage, not a disadvantage. I don't think affirmative action is a "far-left" policy in general, but rather a policy that enjoys broad popular support, at least when it comes to things like employment and education rather than immediate lifesaving treatment.
- CheezeIt 5y agoIt has majority opposition in California.
- WithinReason 5y agoSure, it was a tongue-in-cheek comment on how it could be interpreted both ways. I would say though that prioritising a 20 year old BIPOC person over a 64 year old would be quite a disadvantage to the older person...
- kragen 5y agoConcur.
- rayiner 5y agoIf by “affirmative action” you mean racial preferences, then no, it’s extremely unpopular both for employment and education: https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2019/05/08/americans-see-advantages-and-challenges-in-countrys-growing-racial-and-ethnic-diversity/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2019/05/08/america...; https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/02/25/most-americans-say-colleges-should-not-consider-race-or-ethnicity-in-admissions/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/02/25/most-americ... A majority of every minority group opposes expressly considering race in hiring and education. The prevalence of these policies is the result of its popularity among the white social liberals who increasingly run the country’s businesses and institutions.
- parkingrift 5y agoThe thing about race is that it isn’t all that scientific or verifiable. I can check whichever box I want. Just because I look a certain way doesn’t mean I am a certain way. Maybe in the future my race will ebb and flow with whatever absurd nonsense the “woke elite” is yelling about. Who are you to call me a liar, you bigot.
- rayiner 5y agoOh it’s even worse than that. What Americans call “race” is a mish-mash of race, ethnicity, and nationality. As a Bangladeshi immigrant kid, I was deeply confused about what “race” box I was supposed to check. While race is arbitrary, ethnicity and nationality are not. Bangladeshis have a definable culture and we make efforts to enforce cultural norms within the community. The “self-identification” trend is bizarre in that context as well—you have young south Asians “celebrating their racial identity” by acting indistinguishably from white Americans. Ok kids.
- Ourgon 5y ago> “celebrating their racial identity” by acting indistinguishably from white Americans. Ok kids. Now you make the same mistake as all those other race baiters by referring to "white Americans" as a group which acts in a specific way. Would that be white Americans from Portland, Oregon, white Americans from Ketchikan, Alaska, white Americans from San Mateo, California or white Americans from the Ozarks? I'm of Dutch heritage but I live in Sweden. The Netherlands is about 350km north to south, give or take a bit. There is a marked difference in culture between someone from Groningen (the northern-most province) and Limburg (the southern-most), so much so that I (who come from Utrecht, somewhere in the middle) was told in a carnival-parade that "I do not speak to 'Hollanders' (people from anywhere but the southern-most provinces)" by an older woman in Limburg. She was as "white" as I am but she clearly felt we did not have much in common. All that because she heard by my accent that I'm not from Limburg. She would not have said that to an Asian-looking man who spoke Limburgs - and all that within a span of 350 km north to south.
- rayiner 5y ago
- rayiner 5y agoShadi Hamid is one of the smartest people writing in media today. His sub stack has great articles not only on race, but religion and international affairs: https://wisdomofcrowds.substack.com/people/3785359-shadi-hamid https://wisdomofcrowds.substack.com/people/3785359-shadi-ham.... He’s rare among left-leaning American thinkers in that he’s actually religious and approaches issues regarding Islam and Muslims, and religion generally, with a perspective that’s otherwise mostly absent between secular liberals and Christian conservatives.
- mcherm 5y agoThe same policy for assigning housing or employment would run afoul of federal racial discrimination laws. I propose that those laws should be extended to make racial factors in medical treatment illegal as well. Just as employment discrimination has exceptions (is permitted) in the case of bona fide job requirements (eg. it is permissible to hire an actress to play a historical character with a requirement that the actress be able to visually match the race of the historical individual), so too would we need exceptions for bona fide medical relevance. For instance, it makes no sense to give people-of-color preference in screening for sickle cell anemia, but it does make sense to give preference to people whose ancestors are from a group known to carry the gene.
- rayiner 5y agoInsofar as government agencies are involved in this, it’s a layup for some enterprising lawyer.
- desktopninja 5y agoWith all the scientific knowledge we have somehow we still cling on to the fantastical construct that is race. Really its just tribalism. Its not biological by any means. There are two entities that can eliminate this ... mainstream media and politicians but neither will because both profit from it.