3 ms·
This is the second revolutionary ICE I have seen recently. There was another that was also sort of like a Wankel. In it the triangular Wankel rotor is static,
by ncmncm 5y ago
This is the second revolutionary ICE I have seen recently.
There was another that was also sort of like a Wankel. In it the triangular Wankel rotor is static, and the combustion chambers rotate around it. They have a working model with transparent parts so you can watch how it works.
Nothing in the Omega 1 presentation seemed to offer any clue how it works or why it is better.
These engines both seem like viable general-avition engines to replace Lycomings and Continentals, because electric is not really up to the job. FAA should take initiative to get these approved and deployed, because nobody can afford to do it privately.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThere are lots of interesting engine designs, but they almost always are either too difficult/expensive to make or unreliable outside of a dynamometer stand.
- FL410 5y agoEven better, these could be generation systems hooked up to an electric motor and energy buffer (battery). Put the prop on the motor, keep the whole transmission system electric, and stick one or more of these somewhere else making power.
- ncmncm 5y agoYou could put a little turbine in a Cessna or Beechcraft driving a generator and little-ish battery, and an electric motor driving the prop, and get the same benefit, but the cost and maybe weight would be higher in a place where both are critical. Still, FAA probably should look into pre-approving such a configuration, too.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoOr you can just do what's already done: drive a propeller off the turbine. Which is what's done in turboprop engines, the most efficient airplane propulsion system available. Nothing is more efficient under power; turbines are only inefficient at low power settings (descents, taxiing, etc.)
- sokoloff 5y agoThere’s no concept of a pre-approval in FAA land. You build an airplane and flight test it in experimental category to gather real-world performance numbers to put into the required format for the operating limitations and pilot operating handbook and get certification of the package based on demonstrated data.
- ncmncm 5y agoThat is surely fixable. I.e., there is no constitutional restriction against Congress assigning such a task to some agency. NASA might be best organized, of federal apparatus, to do the work, maybe under a future "General Aviation Revitalization Initiative" authorization, maybe letting contracts for actual development. The problem to be overcome is that nobody private seems to be rich enough to jump through all the regulatory hoops to get a modern engine approved to build modern small aircraft around, no matter how much better one could be. I don't know why a Cessna-size turboprop mill never got to market. Is periodic maintenance and inspection of turbines prohibitively expensive?
- sokoloff 5y agoThere’s no real reason to pre-approve something (IMO). You want to certify an airplane? Build and fly a prototype. If you’re capable to build an airplane manufacturing company, you’re capable to make and fly a prototype. For small aircraft turbines: Cessna makes the 208 Caravan. If the 208 is too big, Quest makes the Kodiak and Socata makes the TBM. If someone’s going to pay all the purchase and operating costs to run a PT6 turbine, they might as well drag around a medium-sized airframe. Maintenance and inspection of turbines isn’t prohibitive. Initial purchase price and specific fuel consumption at low altitude is a far greater concern for private operations. Pistons are way more popular simply because of economics. Virtually everything else about turbines is better. If I could afford a turbine, I’d switch to one immediately.
- ncmncm 5y agoIf it were that easy, we would not still be flying 70-year-old Lycoming and Continental designs. I interpret the facts on the ground to mean qualifying a new light-aircraft power plant is in practice prohibitively difficult and/or expensive, and needs assistance, maybe even statutory assistance.
- nradov 5y agoThat sounds heavy. How much would it weigh?
- ncmncm 5y agoIt doesn't need to weigh much. Idea is that if you can use a battery to boost output power for takeoff and climb out, for that few minutes, you can get along with a much smaller turbine just for cruising than you would need for a turboprop, so is cheaper. And, if the turbine drives a generator directly, it doesn't need the step-down gearing you would need to drive a prop, and you can run the turbine at a constant speed any time it runs at all, more efficiently for that and without gear-train loss. And, it can run on jet-A fuel, which is cheaper per kWh than Avgas. I don't know where a turbine of the right size is in use, that could be re-purposed.
- elihu 5y agoYou might be thinking of LiquidPiston's engine.
- ncmncm 5y agoYes, that seems to be it. It seems to avoid the expensive fabrication a turbine needs for all those blades.