7 ms·
So let's say everyone on earth gets my search history and purchase history. What bad things will happen to me?
by jrockway 15y ago
So let's say everyone on earth gets my search history and purchase history. What bad things will happen to me?
- thaumaturgy 15y agoIt's interesting, isn't it? Not very long ago, it was important to people to maintain certain kinds of privacy, a "healthy paranoia", a division between the lives they led at work and at home and elsewhere. Now, there are a lot of people asking that same question: so what if an advertiser knows more about my habits than I do? So what if someone from work sees my vacation photos? And, maybe, if everyone sort of agrees that all this is OK, then it really will be. Some people are still clinging on to their healthy paranoia, though. I don't trust any company, large or small, not to harm me if it suits their bottom line -- even if I'm not imaginative enough to guess how they might do that.
- swombat 15y agoThat works just fine until a totalitarian government takes power. See my other comment for details...
- Symmetry 15y agoIsn't the fact that more people have more to lose in the event of totalitarianism sort of a good thing, in that it makes totalitarianism less likely?
- pavel_lishin 15y agoAre you certain that it makes totalitarianism less likely?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- netcan 15y agoIn fact, maybe this separation between work "you," private "you" and other yous is a problem.
- shabda 15y agoAh, the Eric Shcmidt defence: "If you have something that you don't want anyone to know, maybe you shouldn't be doing it in the first place."
- mapleoin 15y agoLet's say you like tomato sauce very much and you buy too much of it. Your neighbor three doors down from where you live is found dead one day in his bathtub. He was drowned in tomato sauce which the bathtub is full of. You're the prime suspect, even though you didn't even know your neighbor, you've never spoken to him in your life and didn't even know he existed. The only incriminating evidence the police have found on anyone so far is your purchase history (or maybe you also googled for "death by tomato sauce drowning" once when you were in high-school?). If everything turns out alright you enjoy being interrogated for a few days and have a good story to tell for the rest of your life.
- Tyrannosaurs 15y agoThat depends what you've been buying. Off the top of my head the big advantage to Google is the ability to track behaviour patterns before spending (and match them to similar patterns that didn't result in a purchase and look to modify that behaviour). While I don't think that's a big deal, I also don't see the benefit to me in giving it to Google. Maybe that will change when I see the full service offering but from what I know at the moment this feels like I have a potential loss (privacy) and little or no potential gain. On that assessment I wouldn't go near it.
- 0x12 15y agoYou could get arrested if the mix of stuff you buy accidentally matches a list of ingredients on a watch list. Sometimes it doesn't even take a mix but just a single ingredient: http://consumerist.com/2009/09/grandmother-arrested-for-buying-cold-medicine-twice-in-one-week.html http://consumerist.com/2009/09/grandmother-arrested-for-buyi... You argument is the same as the "I've got nothing to hide, why should I be worried" argument in another dress. The flip side of that coin is that your imagination should not be the deciding factor in whether or not you care about your privacy. What bad things you can or can not envision today isn't all that important, it is simply that an expectation of privacy is something that should be yours without having to ask for it.
- tonfa 15y agoThe shrinking of privacy when buying stuff isn't new. Everything is already there with credit card payment. Most governments/judiciary system can already ask for this data (and it is tied to a real life identity). Edit: and since like many people I already lost that battle (I use CC for most purchases), I might as well get some benefits out of it. My CC company doesn't offer me any fancy spending tracking, and I don't trust companies like mint.com as much as I trust google to deal with my data (and I'm not sure if Mint works outside of the US).
- rjd 15y agoHooker at 10 pm, roll of carpet and shovel at 2am... who knows maybe you went out for some fun and saw a discount at 24 hour importer store... maybe something else... Silliness aside its the mistakes which are more scary than big brother actually watching, because theres just to many people to watch... but its real easy to make a mistake. My favourite take on this scenario is the movie Brazil, the long and short of it is a guy gets pinned for a crime he didn't commit thanks to a bureaucracy error. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0088846/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0088846/
- tzs 15y agoOn the plus side, that timeline will help you if you want to claim murdering the hooker wasn't premeditated. Claim you killed her because she pulled a knife or threatened you or it was an accident during agreed-upon rough sex, and you panicked and decided to hide the body, and plea bargain to something that won't get you too much jail time. Without a record of when you purchased the roll of carpet and the shovel, you'd have a much harder time selling that story. And thanks...now I'm getting a little paranoid wondering if that time I decided I needed an area rug at 2 AM and so went to an all-night Walmart is ever going to come back and hurt me.
- 0x12 15y agoThat's not how it works. If that was how it worked you could go and buy a roll of carpet and a shovel just to help your case. It doesn't prove that you pre-meditated the murder but it also doesn't prove that you didn't. Premeditation goes for everything, also for ways to get you off the hook.
- pointyhat 15y agoSome exaggeration for you... You buy a Casio watch, a camping knife and a plane ticket to New York on September the 11th 2021 [1]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Guantanamo_Bay_detainees_accused_of_possessing_Casio_watches http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Guantanamo_Bay_detainee...
- iand 15y agoYour credit card company knows about these purchases already. What does does linking it to your search history make different?
- pointyhat 15y agoMore context = higher probability of tripping any algorithms?
- Symmetry 15y agoWouldn't more context mean that less people trip their algorithms, since then they'll be more accurate? Of course, it could be that if 10,000 trip their algorithms they won't do anything but if only 100 do they'll investigate each of them. I think that's still a different sort of thing, though.
- 0x12 15y agoThat's a fallacy of datamining. More data does not equate better algorithms, it equates more false positives. As an extreme example, imagine using just random data. Any pattern you look for will occur sooner or later in pure random data. The rarity of the pattern is offset by the amount of data you generate. More data -> more patterns. That doesn't mean the incidence of the real thing increased at all.
- pointyhat 15y agoThis in electrical engineering at least is SNR (signal to noise ratio). Noise is filtered, however the intent is to recover the signal cleanly. Anything which is self-detrimental is likely to be part of the signal, not the noise.
- the_gws 15y agoAll the examples of "bad" things that can happen reported here can already happen today because credit card companies already log all your transactions. The key point Jacques makes in his article is the the novelty will be in associating purchase history with web search history. It would interesting if somebody comes up with an example related to this new combination - I can't think of any top of my head. And while I don't blindly trust Google I surely trust them more than the financial companies that already have my purchase data.
- swombat 15y agoYou buy some gay sex toys, search for gay sex info, etc. Maybe you try out gay sex, because you're sort of curious. It's not for you, but oh well. Ten years later, homosexuality is made illegal. Five years after that, they make homosexual practices retroactively illegal. They look through your profile and found evidence of gay activity. You go to the internment camp, never to be seen again. If the above scenario sounds unrealistic to you, you haven't studied history well enough. To expand the topic a bit, imagine a government like Nazi Germany or any of the communist dictatorships, but with all this information at their disposal. The Red Khmers mass-murdered people who wore glasses, on the basis that they were intellectuals. Imagine such a regime with the tools to figure out, via mass, automated profiling, exactly who all the potentially subversive elements might be, and execute them all ahead of time, leaving a population consisting mostly of nice obedient types who never read any other book than the Da Vinci Code.
- spot 15y agoas noted by the original article, just using your credit card already gives you that problem.
- iand 15y agoDisregarding the likelihood of this scenario panning out, what is special about the combination of purchase and search history? In your scenario just having purchased some toys or searched for gay sex is enough to incriminate you, they don't have to be pre-linked by Google.
- swombat 15y agoI guess the difference is the "one stop shop" nature of it. With everything linked onto one site, all you need is for that future oppressive government to have access to Google's archives to know everything about you - whether it was in the form of a purchase, a search, an email, a calendar item, a shared document subsequently deleted, a visit on a site with doubleclick or google ads, etc. It's a totalitarian regime's wet dream come true. "I don't like X anymore, give me all the dirt on him." "Here you go." Or even, criticising the bundling together of any multiple services: "The town of X is too libertarian. Send everyone a file outlining the illegal things each of them has done over the last 20 years online which would make them liable to immediate internment." Even just the fact that google owns AdSense could be a problem from this point of view: "Round up all those who ever arrived on a google-monitored page via hacker-news links. People from that place are 98% more likely to be subversive. I want them all shot." It's not paranoia if they really are out to get you. And history shows that sometimes, they are.
- chrischen 15y agoPeople might prematurely judge you based on the incomplete snapshot of your activities. That is probably the fundamental reason why it's bad. It's either everything open, and everyone understands everybody, or complete privacy and disclosure of information on your terms. The former is impossible to attain. If you have something in the middle where random snapshots of yourself leak out like that, the data should be useless since no one can form 100% certain conclusions from it. But people will no doubt try to form conclusions from that incomplete data anyways. This could be accusing you of a crime, or simply thinking less of you. The only right way is to ask you and for you to reply honestly. We probably can't achieve a totally honest world like that either, but we should strive for one where we depend less on privacy leaks and more on direct honest communication.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>People might prematurely judge you based on the incomplete snapshot of your activities. // They do that now.
- chrischen 15y agoAnd that's not a good thing which is why we should strive to minimize it, however impossible it is to achieve perfection.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoYou have to make judgements about a person to interact with them, what level of understanding they have on the subject, what sort of vocabulary they'll understand, whether they are likely to judge you harshly, how to make them feel comfortable with you, etc.. Either you have incomplete information, you have all information or you have no information and presumably then avoid interaction. To be practical I think that it is actually a necessary part of social interaction, at present, to judge others based on incomplete data. However, I could see the point where interactions would start by exchange of a data file, giving far more information than we ever normally get from even an acquaintance, which would aid interactions. On the contrary I can't see how things can work without making judgements about people (what language to start a conversation in for example) when interacting.
- watty 15y agoOut of all the ridiculous responses, the one I believe is "nothing".
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- tintin 15y agoA criminal can base his activities around your profile leading all tracks to you.
- Symmetry 15y agoWell, I don't think you're any worse off than you are with credit cards now (and having a good search of my own purchase history sounds sort of cool), but the problem is that you might buy something that nobody but 3 guys in some corner of a federal agency know is a felony, like import lobsters from Honduras in plastic bags. http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/rightsandfreedoms/a/alobsterstail.htm http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/rightsandfreedoms/a/alobsterst...
- naner 15y agoSo let's say everyone on earth gets my search history and purchase history. What bad things will happen to me? Privacy is valuable because is respects human dignity, not because it protects you from bad things. I imagine nothing bad would happen to you if I rifled through your underwear drawer and read all your text messages but it isn't really a respectful thing to do.