9 ms·
Turning back time with epigenetic clocks
- habitmelon 5y agoAll these measures of biological age might be useful, but the real test is just waiting and seeing how long people end up living.
- robbedpeter 5y agoSpecifically, watch Bill Gates, Bezos, Branson, Thiel, and Musk. They're first in line with all the influence and resources needed, so if current life extension efforts pan out, we should see it happen. If it happens soon, the Putin situation could get weird.
- tagoregrtst 5y agoHow so? Are you implying that the only way out of the current West-East impasse is through the death of its leaders? This is not how it panned out in Cuba, China, North Korea, Venezuela, etc.
- robbedpeter 5y agoNo - Putin is currently dictator for life. A more or less immortal dictator would be an entirely novel, and truly weird, situation on the world stage.
- mythrwy 5y agoThere would be a lot to stay current on to stay in power. How much information can a brain hold assuming it lives forever? Does it run out of space at one point?
- tasty_freeze 5y agoMuch of the information we collect has a half life, or situations change and that information, while still valid, is not applicable to the issues we are facing currently. The vast majority of things we learn end up getting discarded at some point. Think of the most recent book you read. How many of the details actually stuck with you at the moment you closed it. Now think of a book you read 10 years ago. How much of that do you remember? I took years of mathematics and was able to do well on tests, but 40 years later I only recall the "shape" of PDE solutions and couldn't actually solve anything anymore. Instead my brain is stuffed full of arcane knowledge I need to do my job, and if I don't use it within a year, I probably need to learn it all over again.
- robbedpeter 5y agoThis is a valid question for different reasons, too. I have a problem with the speech and behavior of immortal characters in books - why would a 300 year old powerful vampire behave like an immature emo teenager? There's a reason we associate wisdom with age. The more times anyone of reasonable intelligence makes mistakes, the more opportunities they have to learn, and their behavior changes according to the degree to which they take on the lessons of life. One big danger of immortal dictators is the simple fact that they'll stop learning. Through wealth and power they shield themselves from the consequences of mistakes, getting themselves and their people stuck in a local minima. Imagine immortal Mitch McConnell, ever increasingly wealthy through passive income, maintaining power and privilege for his constituents and thus his hold on a senate seat. If life extension pans out, liberal societies will have to impose term limits in a serious and well considered way. Humans aren't ready for the existing pace of technological development, and we're going to encounter an exponentially increasing number of problems, like the politics of immortality. The best thing we could do would be to maximize freedom of expression and minimize the duration of social institutions to achieve sufficient maneuverability to adapt to modern life.
- robbedpeter 5y agoIt wouldn't be a limitation for centuries, or possibly millenia. The brain very efficiently packs information, and integrates with external storage. We'll be able to digitally augment brains directly long before temporal memory capacity becomes a problem.
- tagoregrtst 5y agoIs Putin popular with Russians? It seems like an important consideration.
- TeeMassive 5y agoI think a better question would be not how long but how well people live their end of life. Most people would trade living up to 90 fully aware and mostly active instead of up to 100 in misery and dementia.
- atleta 5y agoWell, they could measure the biological ages of people who die (or maybe who have terminal illness) and compare it to people who continue to live on. If they can get the price of the measurement low enough (which Sinclair claims to happen soon), then we can just wait and see: by doing a large number of measurements we'll have people who end up dying pretty quickly. (Yet another way to do it would be just to collect a large number of samples and measure those who die and compare it with some who do not, during the experiment.)
- inglor_cz 5y agoYou can approximate this somewhat by watching their blood tests, kidney function, pulmonary function, grip strength, state of their arteries, strength of their immune systems etc. People start deteriorating in these parameters long before they develop actual life threatening diseases.
- f38zf5vdt 5y ago> In 2019, a small study raised the tantalizing prospect that ageing could be reversed. Scientists in California gave 9 men aged 51 to 65 a growth hormone and two diabetes medications for a year. The drugs seemed to rejuvenate the men’s thymus glands and immune function. They also shaved 2.5 years off the men’s biological age, as measured by one of the most talked-about technologies in ageing research: epigenetic clocks. It's also worth nothing that another study shaved "3.2 years" off the "epigenetic clock" simply with lifestyle changes over 2 months. [1] [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8064200/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8064200/
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoI really wish they had a group that had the DHEA and metformin without growth hormone. I can get those easily and cheaply on the internet. I’d like to see how much of the effect they saw was just those two.
- jml78 5y agoOne of the issues with metformin is how many times it has gotten recall for cancer causing contamination. Buying on the internet, you are never going to get notified
- DeWilde 5y agoMetformin is not ideal for some if not most men. It wipes out testosterone levels. After a few weeks of taking it my T levels were below average and free-T levels were that of 100 year old men. This was a huge drop from the above average levels, for men in 20s, that I usually have.
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoI’ve had the same experience. Feel like shit every time I get hopped up on the latest paper and try it again. I don’t want to live forever with T levels of an old man. I thought maybe I was the only one feeling this way, although I had seen the papers about it lowering testosterone.
- DeWilde 5y ago[0] might be relevant to you, seen other papers that I found when I discovered this issue. From what I gathered the reason for this is that metformin reduces blood cholesterol levels which are important for testosterone production. [0]: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11707532/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11707532/
- cantrevealname 5y ago> Scientists in California gave 9 men aged 51 to 65 a growth hormone and two diabetes medications for a year. The drugs seemed to rejuvenate the men’s thymus glands and immune function. They also shaved 2.5 years off the men’s biological age The study itself says: During the first week of the trial, rhGH alone (0.015 mg/kg) was administered to obtain an initial insulin response, and during the second week, rhGH was combined with 50 mg DHEA to evaluate insulin suppression by DHEA alone. During the third week, the same doses of rhGH and DHEA were combined with 500 mg metformin. Beginning at the fourth week, all doses were individualized based on each volunteer's particular responses.[1] So the meds in question are: - recombinant human growth hormone (rhGH) [2] - dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) [3] - metformin [4] If you wanted to have this treatment for yourself, how could you proceed? I assume that it would be just about impossible to convince your family doctor to prescribe this drug regimen for you? If you were to do-it-yourself, what would be the best way? It seems that metformin is widely available but I don't know about the availability and cost of rhGH and DHEA. [1] https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/acel.13028 https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/acel.13028 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_hormone_therapy#Recombinant_human_growth_hormone_(rHGH) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growth_hormone_therapy#Recombi... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehydroepiandrosterone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dehydroepiandrosterone [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metformin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metformin
- bleachedsleet 5y agoAgelessRX will prescribe metformin [1], DHEA is legally OTC in the US, and any kind of HGH is probably readily available at your local gym (also a number of hormone doctors online will prescribe it easily) [1] https://www.agelessrx.com/metformin https://www.agelessrx.com/metformin
- aaaaaaaaaaab 5y ago>I don't know about the availability and cost of rhGH and DHEA. DHEA: available over-the-counter in the US rhGH: go to your local gym and ask the biggest guy
- hourislate 5y agoFor a more thorough dive into this topic, Dr Brad Stanfield on Youtube. I haven't found anyone better in breaking down the latest scientific studies on Longevity. https://www.youtube.com/c/DrBradStanfield https://www.youtube.com/c/DrBradStanfield There is evidence that Metformin doesn't extend the life of healthy people but does extend the life of Type II diabetics. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iByaqfmWfHQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iByaqfmWfHQ I would also caution HGH for men since it can enlarge the prostate gland. David Sinclair had mentioned in a podcast that we use to be cold and hungry and now we're warm and fat all the time. Need to be cold and hungry more often. https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCwD5YYkbYmN2iFHON9FyDXg https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCwD5YYkbYmN2iFHON9FyDXg Peter Attia has said that the number one thing he believes will extend healthspan/lifespan (if you did nothing else) is exercise. He wish he could prescribe as a medication. https://www.youtube.com/c/PeterAttiaMD https://www.youtube.com/c/PeterAttiaMD
- czbond 5y agoAlso, a drug free option is intermittent water fasting for 6 consecutive days a month. [Disclaimer: do your own research, consult a doctor, blah blah]
- NavinF 5y ago6 days a month!? Even if an RCT comes out proving this works, I’d prefer to die a little sooner rather than do that my whole life lol The way I see it, you’re burning something like (6/30)/2 = 10% of your quality-adjusted life years. Fasting had better increase lifespan by 7-8 years to be even close to worth it
- czbond 5y agoYou really can do it in much smaller amounts.
- cruelty2 5y ago
- peteradio 5y ago2 days per week I do a coffee and beer only fast. I can guarantee no toxins survive the resulting torrent. I like to know I'm starting the week with a totally blank slate.
- inglor_cz 5y agoI practice IF as well, but I suspect it won't regenerate my thymus.
- mrfusion 5y agoDoesn’t fasting and possibly IF radically raise hgh?
- ineedasername 5y ago>unblinded study with no placebo control arm. “If you have nine people,” says Horvath, “and you get a statistically significant result, it means there’s a strong effect.” Wow, no. Just... No. It doesn't. That is so wrong that, from a researcher with a doctorate in biostatistics, it's very difficult not to infer deliberate misinformation on their part. To give some benefit of the doubt though, maybe it was just a very poor choice of words. Statistical significance with 9 samples is suggestive at best. It just barely qualifies as a pilot study. They even say that significance means there's a large effect, which again... No. Significance in small sample indicates practically nothing by itself. What was the actual effect size? Though even at 0.8, with 9 samples I would be be very cautious in my optimistic.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI wonder if, read charitably, the intent is to say with a strong enough effect a small statistic size doesn’t necessarily mean useless. For example, if I removed the hearts from 9 living people and they all died, I can conclude people need their hearts to live.
- ineedasername 5y agoYes, I try to allow some benefit of the doubt in my comment, but from a doctorate is statistics it's a bit harder to excuse. He doesn't have to make an argument from logical implication, there are perfectly good measures of effect size he could use that would allow him to say something like "not only was this statistically significant but it demonstrated a large effect size as well." My hope is he said something like "We not only saw a P value of < 0.04 but a Cohen's D of 0.7." and then the reporter was like, "yeah I'm gonna need you to dumb that down for our readers"
- naasking 5y ago> That is so wrong that, from a researcher with a doctorate in biostatistics, it's very difficult not to infer deliberate misinformation on their part. We don't really know the context for that statement. The journalist could have easily misunderstood something and used quoted him in a totally wrong context.
- axg11 5y agoI used to work in genomics. I think the quest to have a universal epigenetic measure of ageing will end up in a dead end. Ageing is relative to a starting point and the variability between people in terms of phenotype is huge. By way of analogy, would it be possible to come up with a universal measure of ageing for cars? Cars are a complex system made of thousands of components, each of which can age differently over time. Each car make and model will age in a different way. Some of the components even slightly improve in performance over time as they “break in”. The best way to measure epigenetic ageing is relative to a starting point. There are few studies that follow the same people over time (longitudinal) because it’s difficult and expensive to pull off. We’ll eventually get there though.
- kkoncevicius 5y agoCounterpoints: - The accuracy of current epigenetic clocks suggests it might not be a dead-end with average error of 2-3 years, across multiple tissues (and even Chimpanzees). - The variability of an aging phenotype is not that high. We all loose bone density, loose teeth, hair turns white, memory degrades, wrinkles appear, etc. In other words - aging follows a pattern. - The car analogy assumes that aging is caused by damage over time. But there is an alternative explanation: aging provides and evolutionary advantage for a species and hence is predetermined.
- echelon 5y ago> The variability of an aging phenotype is not that high. We all loose bone density, loose teeth, hair turns white, memory degrades, wrinkles appear, etc. People age at different rates depending on a wide variety of factors. Progeria, over consumption of alcohol, too much stress, too much radiation from sunlight, etc. The things you point to are measures of a biological age, not a wall clock age. While they do correlate, they're not 1:1. Some people age faster. > But there is an alternative explanation: aging provides and evolutionary advantage for a species and hence is predetermined. I don't buy this. We don't have a pre-programmed death. It's rather that we haven't had any genetic pressure to live beyond our current lifespan as it doesn't increase our offspring's chances of success. There's little pressure from competing with children for resources. Look at how many people there are in the world today - the world supports billions of humans. There are far greater pressures being exerted in other ways.
- Metacelsus 5y agoStem cell biologist here. Note that different cell types have different epigenetics. Most of these studies are looking at white blood cells. Effects on these cells may be different from elsewhere (brain, muscle, etc.)
- kkoncevicius 5y agoThe epigenetic clock by one of the people quoted in the article - S. Horvath, is notable for working across different tissues, with a few exceptions like germ cells.
- black_13 5y ago
- monkeycantype 5y agoI believe we have a genetically determined lifespan. There is a reason lifespan has been optimised to this duration. As we age we accumulate viruses, mutations. The tissues that were positioned and differentiated during development accumulate damage. From the perspective of the species the only feasible way to get back to a healthy state isn't to eradicate the viruses and repair the tissues, its to jettison the withered husk and repeat the development process with a fresh new body. I we 'reset the clock' we're not removing the damage, the mutations, we're just overclocking the body. If overclocking can get me another 20%, I'll take it. Hell 3%, we'll take it. But what I want I really want is the full factory refurb, with a little extra ram please.
- pishpash 5y agoMany species can regenerate, especially plants.
- monkeycantype 5y agoThis is a good example, because plants don't typically have a predetermined body plan, so they are able to repeat development of complex tissues in new growth.
- inglor_cz 5y agoOur maximum lifespan has probably been the same since the Stone Age, so we are "optimised" to a world that we no longer inhabit.
- T-A 5y agoAKA disposable soma theory: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposable_soma_theory_of_aging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposable_soma_theory_of_agin...
- 3D25157725 5y agoFor those interested, here's a discussion hosted by Peter Attia, MD featuring Matt Kaeberlein, Ph.D. Biomarkers of aging and epigenetic clocks[1] Description: The biology of aging, rapamycin, and other interventions that target the aging process. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukGZpByD1RQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukGZpByD1RQ
- Gatsky 5y ago> An alternative is to look at interventions that extend the lifespan of other animals. Some, such as calorie restriction, do seem to reduce epigenetic age in mice. Nevertheless, Kaeberlein wants to see all such manipulations systematically investigated — and the proposition that clock scores can predict lifespans at the individual level tested. > He stresses the importance of reporting negative results, and determining whether all treatments that extend lifespan or improve late-life functionality decrease epigenetic age — as well as whether all interventions that decrease clock scores increase longevity. This is it, test the theory properly in mice. Forget doing poorly designed human trials until then.