4 ms·
The UK and especially Japan have significantly higher population densities. You would expect them to have less square footage of retail space. Meanwhile, a rea
by HWR_14 5y ago
The UK and especially Japan have significantly higher population densities. You would expect them to have less square footage of retail space.
Meanwhile, a reason for the mall explosion was because real estate developments, especially commercial malls were heavily subsidized by taxpayers in the 1980s (might have the decade off). Those still exist at a smaller scale, but not enough to justify their levels, even back before 2008.
- JCharante 5y agoIs it not possible that such a large retail industry is only possible in high population density area?
- HWR_14 5y agoMy point is that extra space to move (wide aisles that can handle multiple carts across or space around an in store display or other empty space) is much cheaper in the US, so you can just afford it. But the cost of devoting 100's of sq ft of space to mannequins on pedestals might not fly in a Japan (Walmart equivalent)
- ant6n 5y agoDo suburban Americans not drive to Buy'n'Large to shop? It's the high density Americans in New York City who go shop in tiny supermarkets.
- chii 5y agosquare footage per capita is a misleading metric, coz it assumes that each square foot is equivalent in each country - and that a higher area equates to a higher spending and cost. I think profit per-capita is a better metric. It's harder obtain that metric of course...
- achow 5y agoHmm.. per sqft seems to be reasonable. Whichever country (given income equality and ignoring cultural disposition to consumption patterns) a human would need approx' same amount of goods, whether grocery, clothing or other such, and those items would occupy exact same space in all countries.
- thereisnospork 5y ago>those items would occupy exact same space Not at all. Consider a toy store in Manhattan(or Tokyo) vs. one in Des Moines. The former would be naturally compact due to the expensive real estate while the latter could be far more expansive. By extension country-wide retail square footage can be expected to vary by density (in addition to other cultural factors).
- ethbr0 5y agoBecause I was curious, it looks like FAO Schwarz currently has a flagship store in NYC again, since November 2018, after some troubles and owner bankruptcies. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/FAO_Schwarz https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/FAO_Schwarz I still remember visiting one of the Fifth Avenue ones as a kid. Because yes, apparently you can build something as big as a department store, but all toys. :)
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI heard the Rockefeller Plaza store is considerably smaller than the previous store across from the Plaza Hotel next to Apple.
- unwind 5y agoHamley's in London (UK) is the world's largest toy store. It is seven floors. I have visited it once I think, but that was way before having kids. Feels like it would be a two-day exploration marathon now with our two boys. Hopefully travel will make sense at some point again. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamleys https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hamleys
- Broken_Hippo 5y agoSure, they take the same space. That doesn't mean you need a sprawling store with an eatery to buy them in, nor do you need 12ft (3.6 meters) of a single laundry soap nor a full shelf of one type of ketchup. Store layout and the space allotted for each product differs between places, in other words. I'm going to assume things like shelf height does as well. When these things are in the back room, they don't take up space in the same way as the sales floor. Also, it is quite possible that many retailers simply do not have the same sort of selection as they do elsewhere: If you sell fewer things, you don't need so much space.
- bobthepanda 5y agoProfit per sq foot is really the golden metric here. The problem is that profits, generally, are a lot harder to data collect into a metric like that, and a lot of the private equity activity that doomed many retail chains in the US were designed to artificially inflate profits. The three are all more or less related though.
- jasonkester 5y agoIt also depends on whether those numbers include the whole mall or just the area within the shops themselves. Because in the UK, there’s something that looks suspiciously like a giant American mall in the center of nearly every town. They just call it the High Street. If you included all the sidewalks, road surface and parking for every downtown in the UK, you’d probably get a number that looks like the USA in the table above.
- Vrondi 5y agoWhen did the UK roof over the high streets?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tialaramex 5y agoMost UK towns have a mall, my city has typically had three, although it can't support three, what happens is they build a new mall, the oldest one loses all its occupants and takes on desperate clients like e.g. an entire floor is just discount no-brand furniture, or a factory seconds outlet, eventually it goes bankrupt, closes, they tear it down and... build another mall, rinse and repeat. The last decade or so though they realised ah, that's not actually a sane plan, and the city council started demanding they provide a plan that can actually work before issuing permission, so e.g. the big mall in the city centre had originally planned a huge extension full of new stores, they realised there is zero demand for that, so they pivoted to it's a nice cinema, plus restaurants, and some residential on the side. Meanwhile the last mall site went from "We're building a new mall" to "A new mall... and residential space" and then "A residential block, also there's some retail on the ground floor" as they realised that retail space is not going to move. Residential isn't as profitable, but "£5k profit selling a £200k new home" is a better deal than "Ongoing loss on a £1M retail space you can't sell". The UK government changed planning laws some years back to encourage commercial to residential conversion. If you wanted to build a new residential building with shitty paper walls between homes, third rate insulation and not enough elevators, you'd get told "No". But if you want to convert an office block that is now useless or a shop that hasn't been rented for years, that already exists so the planning restrictions are fewer, maybe you put a little bit of extra insulation in, you run some extra plumbing, but you don't need to meet new home standards, and people get a "new" home that kinda sucks. The result is that a lot of what you're talking about as "High Street" (the US has "Main Street" filling the same role) was converted to housing. There's a row of shops not far from me, ten years ago the upper floors once used as office space or for storage became housing, this year the shops closed and are boarded up, they'll tear that out and make them into more housing. A pub I used to go to regularly was converted to nasty poorly put together flats in the same period.