5 ms·
> It's 90% genes , 10% other factors. Do you have evidence to support these numbers, or the more general claim of genetic supremacy?
by klyrs 5y ago
> It's 90% genes , 10% other factors.
Do you have evidence to support these numbers, or the more general claim of genetic supremacy?
- paulpauper 5y agoHe was a demonstrating adult level math ability even at the age of 5. Also, he was genius level at other subjects too. How would it not be genetic. Think of how hard parents push their kids in today's super-competitive economy and high-stakes higher ed system, how many turn out even close to as talented as him?
- lordnacho 5y agoNot sure why you think the split is so tilted towards genetics. If TT had been born in some 3rd world country with poor nutrition and crappy education system, how would he be exposed to all the higher level math topics? It's clear you need that exposure, you aren't just going to know things about what mathematicians have thought about and consider important without coming into contact with some.
- paulpauper 5y agoWe have a sample size of 600 + million ppl between the US and Western Europe with full access to food, electricity, and other modern necessities, not third world countries. How many are as smart as him.
- lordnacho 5y agoAnd how many of them were able to dust up a person who could explain to them not only how algebra works, but why one should study it? At the age where they can actually do it and not get bored? Math education comes up here regularly, and we have lots of smart math people here, but the story is often that some commentator was simply never shown anything interesting in their whole schooling. I'd never have given it much thought were it not for one particular math teacher who put a lot of effort into me and a few other interested kids. I still keep in touch with him.
- klyrs 5y ago> How many are as smart as him. I'll accept that nobody is, but his mom was a math teacher. Few of us get that kind of leg up, certainly not 600m+. When I was 5, "don't get shot" was already getting a significant share of my brain's power, and I had it better than most. Sure, he's got a brain like gasoline, but don't discount the spark and oxygen that allowed the genius to deflagrate. And don't just throw numbers around like that if you don't have proof. If you respect the mathematics, act like it.
- contravariant 5y agoMarkedly fewer than people with similar genes I imagine.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- j7ake 5y agoIf you’re asking about math talent as in child prodigies, then one can browse previous winners of the math Olympiad. But I have a feeling his success as a professional mathematician involves the interaction of such math talent with hard work and good mathematical taste. One can read his PhD qualifying exams to observe he was actually not an outlier amongst his peers in his early career.
- BeetleB 5y agoSo in other words, the answer to your parent's question is "No, you don't have any evidence." You are providing questions as a substitute for actual evidence. Your questions are worthy of being asked, but they are still questions. Basically a variant of "I cannot explain ... therefore it must be Y! How could it not be Y?" Just because people don't have adequate explanations for nurture doesn't make it an automatic "genetics". All it means is that they don't have adequate explanations. This does not make your stance any stronger or more likely to be correct. (Disclaimer: I can easily believe genetics is the answer. I won't, however, be sure of it).
- geodel 5y agoReally? Do you have proof of this is result of extraordinary nurture. Because nurture would be far more easy to see/document and match against against other examples.
- BeetleB 5y ago> Really? Do you have proof of this is result of extraordinary nurture. > Just because people don't have adequate explanations for nurture doesn't make it an automatic "genetics". All it means is that they don't have adequate explanations. Your question is the equivalent of "Since you cannot provide evidence, I must be right." This is a fallacy. The other party's lack of evidence does not strengthen your position.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Think of how hard parents push their kids in today's super-competitive economy and high-stakes higher ed system, how many turn out even close to as talented as him? Maybe they don't know how to do it. Maybe TT got lucky.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoGenes must have something to do with it. Take the case of Srinivasa Ramanujan No formal training in math. Made insane contributions to mathematics including solving "unsolvable" problems. > A child prodigy by age 11, he had exhausted the mathematical knowledge of two college students who were lodgers at his home. He was later lent a book written by S. L. Loney on advanced trigonometry.[18][19] He mastered this by the age of 13 while discovering sophisticated theorems on his own. By 14, he received merit certificates and academic awards that continued throughout his school career, and he assisted the school in the logistics of assigning its 1,200 students (each with differing needs) to its approximately 35 teachers.[14]: 27 He completed mathematical exams in half the allotted time, and showed a familiarity with geometry and infinite series. Ramanujan was shown how to solve cubic equations in 1902; he developed his own method to solve the quartic. In the following year, he tried to solve the quintic, not knowing that it could not be solved by radicals. If there was a method of raising kids like this "scientifically" , I bet a good portion of the worlds GDP would be put into this field of research
- paulpauper 5y agoPeople will delay a dental procedure but they will not delay making their kids #1.
- barry-cotter 5y agoI wish I lived in a world where that was true.
- nefitty 5y agoI'm not sure why people feel so allergic to the idea of a genetic intelligence boost. Our genes encode the layout of physical race tracks on which marbles of matter and information travel. Some people's bodies have a bunch of muscle tracks, so as they grow, their body benefits from the activity on those. They grow up to find it easier to gain muscle than other people. For geniuses, I imagine that the brain is a perfectly laid out super highway. Any information that comes in gets to where it needs to go because there's signs and signals and traffic cops patrolling. If some piece of information can't find where to go, well, damned if we don't have a construction worker and a navigator jumping in the passenger seat with you to help out. Ultimately, I think the brain is so plastic that each of us can one day decide to elect a new mayor to our body town. The new mayor can decide to tear up roads and fix potholes etc. Yeah, it would have been great if we had founded the town with a plan and hadn't had that college riot but here we are. Time to pave some roads.
- hackinthebochs 5y agoThe genetic model for the occurrence of supreme levels of ability more accurately matches reality than an environmental model. We know that polygentic traits in a population follow a normal distribution[1], which entails a regression to the mean for traits in offspring[2]. This means the occurrence of extreme ability is a function of the ability of the parents. While being rare, it becomes more likely if the parents themselves have some extreme traits. This dynamic matches what we see in the case of Terrence Tao and his brothers, the Polgar sisters, and other cases of savants/virtuosos that come to mind. Usually one child has extraordinary ability while their siblings are much less remarkable. If the environmental model were accurate, we should see many cases where families produce more than one extreme talent of equal skill. But we don't see that in practice. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygene#Trait_distribution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polygene#Trait_distribution [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_toward_the_mean#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regression_toward_the_mean#His...