3 ms·
and all the halfway measures we've taken haven't achieved their stated goals. You have some good points up until this one. Go to your local hospital and ask t
by CamperBob2 5y ago
and all the halfway measures we've taken haven't achieved their stated goals.
You have some good points up until this one. Go to your local hospital and ask them how they'd like it if their case load went up by 2x due to a lack of "halfway measures." In some places, that will be OK, while in others, it will be utterly catastrophic.
Obviously that doesn't justify ridiculous overreactions to unmasked toddlers, as you point out. But it's just as obvious that the inadequate measures being taken are nevertheless helpful on a population-wide basis.
- claytongulick 5y agoAccording to the article, in the only large randomized studies that have been performed, masking showed little, if any benefit. As far as I'm aware, most studies, including WHO, show that lockdowns were counter productive, and could result in increased transmission. I haven't seen a single study that showed school closures resulted in any decrease in transmission, or provided any benefit. I have seen many that showed the harms it imposed, though. These measures were ineffective. So, how do you justify saying that a hospital's case load would increase by 2X if we got rid of them, or had never done them?
- DavidSJ 5y ago> According to the article, in the only large randomized studies that have been performed, masking showed little, if any benefit. From the first one [1] they linked: > odds ratio, 0.82 [CI, 0.54 to 1.23] … Although the difference observed was not statistically significant, the 95% CIs are compatible with a 46% reduction to a 23% increase in infection. … Sounds like the issue is lack of statistical power. We basically can't conclude much at all from that study, but taken "at face value", that was an ~18% reduction in transmission. Presumably this would compound if done for longer or among more people due to exponential spread. Compound an 18% reduction for three generations (about ~15 days) of viral spread and that's about a 45% reduction in case load. Of course it's more complicated than that because a faster-spreading virus will also reach saturation of the susceptible population more quickly, but it does mean lowering peak hospital load, as well as lowering R_0 which means the point of saturation is smaller, etc. From the second one [2] they linked: > Proper mask-wearing increased from 13.3% in the control group to 42.3% in the intervention arm (adjusted percentage point difference = 0.29 [0.26, 0.31]). The intervention reduced symptomatic seroprevalence (adjusted prevalence ratio (aPR) = 0.91 [0.82, 1.00]) So that's a 9% reduction (again, with a wide confidence interval), as a result of increasing mask usage by only 29 percentage points. So if the signal's real, then presumably increasing mask usage further, say up to 85%, would add a very meaningful further reduction. Again, we can assume that would compound if done for longer or among a larger population. ** Furthermore, there have been plenty of lab experiments on masks which show them to be effective at filtering water droplet-bound Covid particles. And Covid is not the first virus we've ever encountered. In the absence of lots of data specific to Covid, we can apply background scientific knowledge about the effectiveness of masks in slowing the spread of respiratory disease. There are also costs to wearing masks, as well as to mask mandates, which I'm not taking into account in this post. But I wouldn't characterize the evidence as you have. ** [1] https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/full/10.7326/M20-6817 https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/full/10.7326/M20-6817 [2] https://www.poverty-action.org/publication/impact-community-masking-covid-19-cluster-randomized-trial-bangladesh https://www.poverty-action.org/publication/impact-community-...
- claytongulick 5y agoI agree that we interpret the results of those studies very differently. I'd also suggest that we only regard lab studies with a bit of intellectual curiosity, rather than a meaningful focus. Lab studies are very different than the real world where my son trades his batman mask for a friend's spiderman mask because it's cooler :D
- DavidSJ 5y agoIn biological sciences we have to integrate multiple kinds of evidence — in vitro (or in larva? — in the mask) lab experiments, animal models, randomized controlled trials in humans, descriptive statistics of human populations, in silico simulation, etc. — because they all have their advantages and disadvantages. Lab/in vitro models are great because they allow for tightly controlled conditions and are clear tests of mechanisms, but they might not represent real-world conditions in living human beings in our social context, with all of the attending quirks and nuances. Animal models are great because they're a complete organism upon which we can still do a whole range of controlled experiments which we can't do in people. But they're not human beings, so there could be differences there. And we can't control them as closely as e.g. an experiment with a few cells or a few viral particles. etc. etc. When all the evidence seems to be pointing in roughly the same direction, I think it's fair to say we know something. That appears to be the case with masks limiting the spread of Covid, even if the confidence intervals on the randomized controlled trials are large. That's very different from "little, if any benefit".
- claytongulick 5y agoMargery Smelkinson (the author), Ph.D., infections disease expert focused on Covid 19 and affiliated with NIH, disagrees with your interpretation.
- DavidSJ 5y agoI think we should either evaluate arguments for ourselves, or rely on a broad consensus of experts in the field in question. If we resort to argument from authority, but cherry pick our authorities to be those which agree with our preexisting views, then that won't get us very far epistemically. In this case, I think both the broad consensus of experts as well as the balance of evidence/argumentation supports the efficacy of masks.
- kareemm 5y ago> According to the article, in the only large randomized studies that have been performed, masking showed little, if any benefit. I have this open in another tab. It links to three studies that show masks in school do work: https://yourlocalepidemiologist.substack.com/p/mask-requirements-in-school-work https://yourlocalepidemiologist.substack.com/p/mask-requirem... > most studies, including WHO, show that lockdowns were counter productive, and could result in increased transmission. Do you have a source for this?
- benbenolson 5y agoThe author of that blog post sees that states like Tennessee and Texas had a high number of school closures, but that plot is simply plotting raw numbers of school closures. Not only are those numbers affected by a plethora of variables (for example, population density, population number, vaccination rates, number of schools, closure policies...), but how could you possibly compare raw numbers of school closures in individual states? Then, they use this incredibly skewed plot to draw the conclusion that "Public health mitigation measures in schools, like mask requirements, work." Talk about jumping to conclusions. For the first two studies, these kinds of probabilities are extremely dangerous and prone to "playing with the data." Given the exact same dataset, one could draw nearly any conclusion with such disparate and varied data, especially when attempting to control for other factors. Could these increased "change in daily number of cases per 100,000 children" be due to other factors; for example, a correlation between a mask policy and other policies, such as closure and a decrease in class size? I'm not saying that I know the answer, either, but plots like this should be taken with a pinch of salt.
- ngngngng 5y ago> In some places, that will be OK, while in others, it will be utterly catastrophic. Maybe? But I already live in a place that did away with all COVID restrictions some time ago (not to mention they were never as harsh as elsewhere to begin with), and the situation here is barely worse than places with prohibitive restrictions.
- throwawaygh 5y ago> and the situation here is barely worse than places with prohibitive restrictions. Are you sure about this? I lived in a metro area in the middle of anti-COVID restriction land for a portion of the pandemic. Our hospitals were slammed during every surge, mostly with COVID cases from outlying counties. Tiny rural hospitals didn't have case spikes, but really only because they functioned purely as funnels to the metro hospital systems. In one case, a county never had more than a single digit number of ICU admissions! Of course, the dashboard failed to mention that the sole hospital in that county only had a single digit number of ICU beds... guess where their overflow patients ended up? At least in our case, if you looked at statistics on dashboards you got one story, but if you paid attention to the actual source of cases -- as opposed to which ICU the patient was sent to -- you got a very different story.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- champagnois 5y agoThere is no evidence that I am aware of which would indicate places with strict mandates (Boston or LA) did significantly better or worse than places that made such mandates illegal (Texas). The outbreak curves and percentages are basically the same, especially when you account for the population differences in age, obeasity, diabetes, etc. A red state might do worse at times, but is also more easily explained as a result of a more vulnerable population. Be scientific about it rather than political. There are a lot of ways to analyze the data.
- kareemm 5y ago> The outbreak curves and percentages are basically the same, especially when you account for the population differences in age, obeasity, diabetes, etc. Can you cite a source for this claim?
- nradov 5y agoYou can start here for age adjusted death rates by US state. https://www.bioinformaticscro.com/blog/states-ranked-by-age-adjusted-covid-deaths/ https://www.bioinformaticscro.com/blog/states-ranked-by-age-...
- another_story 5y agoTry looking at places in the world where people actually followed the mandates versus places that didn't. How come Taiwan, which has cases of Omicrom right now, is not seeing exponential spread?
- dahfizz 5y ago> Go to your local hospital and ask them how they'd like it if their case load went up by 2x due to a lack of "halfway measures." I love this argument. "Just imagine how much worse things could have been! The observed outcome is better than a worst case scenario I made up!" "Just imagine if I didn't wear my lucky socks to the game. We would have lost even worse!" The data does not bear out your position. Places with less / no mandates did not have measurably worse outcomes.
- CamperBob2 5y agoPlaces with less / no mandates did not have measurably worse outcomes. A meaningless statement without context. Places with different levels of mandates also tend to be disparate in terms of population density and demographics. A cherry-picked study showing that masks weren't needed to conserve hospital utilization in Bumfark, Oklahoma will tell us nothing about what to expect in crowded urban areas. Then there's the easily-justified suspicion that officials in right-leaning areas are rigging the data they report ("Stop testing so much, it makes us look bad!") These debates always seem to turn into perpetual playground games where duelling studies are whipped out like Magic cards. For every one you cite, I'll cite one that says something else. Consensus is the only way to make good decisions in such an epistemic environment. I'll continue to look to public health authorities for that, not bloggers, podcasters, politicians, celebrities, or HN commenters.