5 ms·
this is not what astronomers or physicists think is mysterious. Just unexpected, and within the bounds of normal physical science. Everybody who is complainin
by dekhn 5y ago
this is not what astronomers or physicists think is mysterious. Just unexpected, and within the bounds of normal physical science.
Everybody who is complaining that the PR about the paper is clickbait is right. The PR is just clickbait. The paper is not.
- idiotsecant 5y agoIf I saw a bright pink duck I would wonder how that duck came to be. If someone called it's origins mysterious I wouldn't write a string of angry HN posts about it, I don't think.
- dekhn 5y agoIf I saw a bright pink duck I would expect that a neighbor's kid had painted the duck. Horses, not zebras, unless you're on the african savannah.
- isaacimagine 5y agoDid the kid paint the radio waves too? In all seriousness, why is it brighter than expected? What's the expected brightness for such an object, and how many error bars is it away from this value?
- dekhn 5y agoSee the text after Figure 4, https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-04272-x https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-021-04272-x Since I am not an expert astronomer (just a helpful computational person who has worked in the field) I can't give you a detailed ELI5, but they talk a lot about how it looks different from existing examples, and how to find more examples of this type (so you can do surveys; modern astronomers don't like to study one-offs, as they are biased, and instead prefer to accumulate a larger sample of instances).
- me_me_me 5y agoYour analogy is incorrect. The existence of this megastar was falls under theoretically possible but never discovered. Analogous would be an albino duck, existence inferred from albinos existing in every animal, but say an albino duck was not observed before. Discovering bright pink duck would be akin to discovering something that our models cannot account for or explain.
- ceejayoz 5y agoAgain, from the article. > “But nobody expected to directly detect one like this because we didn’t expect them to be so bright. “Somehow it’s converting magnetic energy to radio waves much more effectively than anything we’ve seen before.” That's interesting, and apparently unexpected.
- c22 5y agoI've seen pink flamingos so I think my existing model of "bird things" could accommodate a pink duck.
- dekhn 5y agoFlamingos are pink because they eat pink shrimp. The difference is that pinkness in animals is specific to species and we have explanations for why they are pink. And we also have explanations for albinism, but it's not limited to specific species- it's found widely, across the complex life domain. Find a pink duck? OK, the neighbor painted a duck. Find a population of pink ducks that reproduce and their children are all pink? OK, now we have an interesting situation.
- ceejayoz 5y agoCool. Now: > “But nobody expected to directly detect one like this because we didn’t expect them to be so bright. “Somehow it’s converting magnetic energy to radio waves much more effectively than anything we’ve seen before.” Why is this magnetar brighter than expected, and how does it convert energy more efficiently?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ehnto 5y agoThere is value to pop-sci's romantic relationship with new discoveries in science. I don't think it hurts anyone in the target demographic to enable their sense of curiosity and wonder. Clickbait is hardly a fair term, as this article hardly shares a floor with true clickbait like false death rumours, hate and fear mongering, and outright falsehoods.
- dekhn 5y agoOf all the replies to my comments, this is the best one I've seen. You're right that science reporting should instill wonder, it probably isn't that excessive to say it's mysterious or bizarre (my complaint is more the "we've never seen something like this so far" but let's not get into the semiotics of unsupervised clustering), and it's unfair to lump this in with Really Bad Clickbait. I just have a strong aversion to the science->PR->news hype cycle and that's what happened here.