2 ms·
> Yes, having someone champion a Flat Earth is a good thing. Groupthink is a very real danger. Just because someone thinks of absurd stuff, doesn't mean this f
by chii 5y ago
> Yes, having someone champion a Flat Earth is a good thing. Groupthink is a very real danger.
Just because someone thinks of absurd stuff, doesn't mean this fixes groupthink.
To combat groupthink requires critical analysis, and safety - that is, the group must allow for people who make different (but still logical) points that go against the grain. However, flat earthers do not fall into this category, because they are denying evidence, rather than imagining an alternative theory. Plate tectonics is different, since there's no evidence denying that theory!
I think the populous, in general, really just need to learn the scientific method, and how one discerns truths using evidence (and not fall prey to confirmation bias etc). This requires work, and i feel many do not get taught nor learn themselves.
- kavalg 5y ago> I think the populous, in general, really just need to learn the scientific method, and how one discerns truths using evidence (and not fall prey to confirmation bias etc) Good luck with that. Even at the university where I teach this looks like an uphill battle.
- marcus_holmes 5y agoThere was an article on HN recently about how science is moving past the scientific method by using models rather than testing hypotheses with experiments. I'm not sure I consider this "science", but still. There was no evidence for plate tectonics either, until they started looking for it. And, obviously, the burden was on the new hypothesis to prove itself. I'm not saying we should encourage Flat Earthers to present at Astronomy conferences. I'm saying we should not try to shut them up. That "safety" you're talking about has to be boundless, because if there are bounds then they will shrink. Are shrinking.