4 ms·
Yeah, sub out boobs with genitals in your argument, and replace men/man with women/woman and see if your argument is still sensible[1] when women complain that
by lelanthran 5y ago
Yeah, sub out boobs with genitals in your argument, and replace men/man with women/woman and see if your argument is still sensible[1] when women complain that they have no wish to see male genitalia.
You're complaining that men are the problem because women are the target, but I'm pretty certain a significant number of women also complain when a venue has unexpected partial female nudity.
[1] Every culture draws the line at different points. Turning it into a "men are the problem" conclusion, while being wildly incorrect, is also hilariously sexist to both sexes. Edit your post to demean non-binaries as well and you'll have a hat-trick!
- op00to 5y agoBreasts are not genitalia. At least where I live in the US, there is no law against women being topless.
- sriram_malhar 5y agoMost states in the US have indecent exposure laws. Some explicitly speak of breasts, others coyly cover them under "private parts". https://www.findlaw.com/state/criminal-laws/indecent-exposure-laws-by-state.html https://www.findlaw.com/state/criminal-laws/indecent-exposur...
- chrischen 5y agoYea but those laws are the manifestation of cultural mores. It used to be illegal for black people to vote so laws shouldn't be held up as universal rules of what should be right. I think the important bit is that breasts are not genitalia, and men can expose their breasts. At least for actual genitalia, no humans of any gender can legally expose them in public! That is at least fair.
- jraph 5y agoBut it is still sensible with the replacement. In an environment where it's normal, there are no problems. I experienced such an environment myself, I was (surprisingly?) not bothered by this in such a setting and women there neither. Women may complain that they have no wish to see male genitalia in a setting where it is not normal / can be seen as / is an assault. Intents matter, too. If you point your middle finger, the finger is still a body part but you are doing something offensive because you intend to insult someone.
- chrischen 5y agoI address that point that some woman want to wear burkas, just as some women don't want to show their boobs. Just because most men don't want to be tempted by seeing boobs, some women don't want to see boobs either. But regardless of men or women neither should be dictating how some woman want to show their body. Also, while I use the term "men" I really mean "any person that sexualizes a woman over their physical appearance."
- DaltonCoffee 5y agoIdk, I think he's got you with the "sub out for dick" thing. We live in an (I hope) egalitarian democracy and what's acceptable to display is dictated by our polis. Can this same be said regarding women wearing burkas in Afghanistan. >most men don't want to be tempted by seeing boobs Just lol
- chrischen 5y agoA woman's boob is not equivalent to a man's penis. If anything, a vagina is is the equivalent to a penis, as both organs are used as part of sex. A boob is not normally used as part of sex. That being said, if we all agree that no genders can show their sexual organs then that's fine. That's at least an equally applied rule. However the issue here is that some men, and some women too, find it bothers them to see boobs, but only female boobs. It's irrelevant if some woman happen to agree, because a woman can still oppress woman, just as a Chinese person can still be racist towards Chinese people. If a women dressing sexy (but otherwise within the generally accepted constraints of not showing genitalia or nipples) and then gets raped by a person (man or woman), is it her fault or the person's fault? Is she asking for it by dressing sexy? Sexy here is in the eye of the rapist, and whether the women thinks she is dressing sexy herself is irrelevant, so I would argue that it is the rapist's fault. If a woman does something to her outward appearance such as enlarging her breasts or dressing "immodestly" and it causes weird feelings or urges in some people, those feelings are wholly the fault of the person feeling them.
- pseudalopex 5y agoIt wasn't even her breasts. It was a cardboard dummy shaped like her torso.
- numpad0 5y agoWhy is it always genitals…? I just don’t get this argument. It sounds like a straw man constructed from what would be the part they prefer not to stare at.
- smaryjerry 5y agoImagine if men or women showed up to work completely naked. For one it might not be the most sanitary, but let’s assume we don’t leave any mess or smell from those lower regions. People would not care because it would become normal. As the previous poster identifies, different cultures have different levels of normal and it is a great comparison of face to boob. In my opinion the fact you hide something makes it more sexual, not less, because then it is no longer normal and it is now rare. From a economic perspective there is not scarcity causing its value to increase.
- mbrodersen 5y agoThere will always be somebody complaining about everything. That doesn’t mean that it should be banned. I don’t like loud people in restaurants. I don’t like people drinking in the streets. I don’t like noisy souped up cars. I don’t like people playing loud music in their cars. I don’t like rich assholes. So should we ban all of that? Of course not. We all have to compromise to some degree to make society work. It used to be the case that woman were not allowed to show their ankles in public. I am sure back then you would agree with this because conservative types always disagree with anything that changes status quo. Especially when it comes to woman.