5 ms·
These numbers can be further separated by "with Covid" and "from Covid" causality, as well as co-morbidities and expected lifetime. E.g. if someone was soon to
by walterbell 5y ago
These numbers can be further separated by "with Covid" and "from Covid" causality, as well as co-morbidities and expected lifetime. E.g. if someone was soon to die from illness A, but died 3 months earlier from complications induced by Covid, and the hospital received a financial payment for classifying this as Covid-related treatment, that should be broken out into a separate reporting category. Such deaths would not much change all-cause mortality for the year.
- xadhominemx 5y agoExcess mortality is higher than reported COVID deaths. Australia contained the virus in 2020 and saw negative excess mortality. Official COVID deaths understate the true toll.
- argvargc 5y ago...of lockdowns?
- xadhominemx 5y agoCOVID denialists often attribute excess deaths to lockdowns as opposed to undercounting of deaths from COVID. I was just preempting that line by pointing out Australia had severe lockdowns but negative excess deaths.
- argvargc 5y agoCOVID what-ists? You mean all manner of people who have all manner of opinions and reasons for them that just so happen to differ from the views presented as scientific consensus by government, media and celebrities? Here is a summary of over 400 studies demonstrating lockdowns are ineffective or harmful: https://brownstone.org/articles/more-than-400-studies-on-the-failure-of-compulsory-covid-interventions/ https://brownstone.org/articles/more-than-400-studies-on-the... Prepare a sufficiently convincing argument against each and every one of them, and against the credentials of each and every author, before using the term "denialist" in application to anyone other than yourself.
- FabHK 5y ago
- argvargc 5y agoWon't even examine 400 counter-claims? That's "denialism". Lockdowns working/not-working and/or causing collateral damage potentially eliminating other gains is not even remotely on par with astrology. Lockdowns used in this manner are entirely unprecedented, and the long-term results cannot be known by anyone, only guessed at. Your rigid adherence to them as beacons of purity only demonstrates your religious-like faith in them, which strikes me as having far more in common with astrology than well-evidenced arguments by well-credentialed individuals that they might not work or be counterproductive.
- squeaky-clean 5y agoYou just said it's been proven that lockdowns are harmful. Now you're saying the longterm results can't be known by anyone, only guessed at.
- argvargc 5y agoNo, I didn't. I said: > Here is a summary of over 400 studies demonstrating lockdowns are ineffective or harmful: You're welcome to present studies demonstrating the opposite, but even if you can find 400 of them (and I doubt you can), the best we'd have arrived at would be equal uncertainty either way. The longterm results of anything for which a long term has not yet elapsed can indeed only be guessed at. The fact I need to point this out to many people is striking in its resemblance to some kind of mass delusion on their part.
- squeaky-clean 5y agoBut then you also said > Lockdowns used in this manner are entirely unprecedented, and the long-term results cannot be known by anyone, only guessed at. So which one is it? Are your studies useful, or can the results only be guessed at, and so what's the point of your 400 studies? > The longterm results of anything for which a long term has not yet elapsed can indeed only be guessed at. The fact I need to point this out to many people is striking in its resemblance to some kind of mass delusion on their part. It's amazing that you tell other people this yet don't seem to understand it yourself.
- ggy5567 5y agoAs I recall the basis of the argument against lockdowns (which yes was made by legitimate epidemeologists before covid made everything so politicized and tribal) is that the disease eventually comes right back and infects everyone once the lockdown ends. I do think there is a good argument about allowing vaccines to be developed and delivered though. But benefits like preventing hospitals from being overwhelmed were believed to already be achievable with social distancing alone. So one must be careful to not give to much credit to the lockdowns alone. As for excess deaths, it presumably depends on how well the country can endure the self-inflicted downsides (such as a recession) that comes with it. Countries where it causes severe problems probably are the very ones who didn't have the political will to maintain the lockdowns, leading to some biased conclusions. We also have lots of other issues caused by covid response such as shortages and spiking prices all over. Being outright dodged by pointing blame at some indermediate actor like "corporate supply chains" or "hoarders" or whatever. The point is there are arguments that can be made on all sides. No need to insult and dismiss people.
- Izkata 5y agoLeading cause of death in the US, 2015-2020: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2778234 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2778234 (see table a few paragraphs down) Heart disease, unintentional injuries, Alzheimer disease, and diabetes all jumped more than the expected trend. 2021 numbers I don't think will be finalized for another month or so.
- xadhominemx 5y agoYes so it seems if anything COVID deaths are being misclassified as Alzheimer’s, diabetes, etc
- acdha 5y agoOne thing I've heard multiple doctors comment on is that they are seeing more patients who were successfully managing a condition have significant declines after a bout of COVID, even a mild one. That's definitely a bit of a philosophical question trying to assign fractional responsibility but you can also side-step this to some extent by looking at it as years of life lost — e.g. if someone with a manageable heart disease where patients tend to die 10 years older dies after having COVID, that's something like a decade where they could have been around their friends and family.
- notahacker 5y agoIn places with good nationwide data like the UK and national level lockdowns, the excess mortality spikes also line up very well with the case outbreaks (especially pre vaccination), and considerably less well with other plausible causes of excess mortality (lockdown and unemployment induced stress, [long term effects of] reductions in access to treatment for chronic conditions)
- barbazoo 5y ago> the hospital received a financial payment for classifying this as Covid-related treatment Can you explain this more? Surely a hospital doesn't just get money for simply classifying it. How does a hospital benefit from classifying someone's treatment as Covid related other than being paid for the necessary treatment?
- walterbell 5y agoThere are probably better sources, https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/cdc-director-acknowledges-hospitals-have-a-monetary-incentive-to-overcount-coronavirus-deaths https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/cdc-director-acknowl... (Aug 2020) > U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Director Robert Redfield agreed that some hospitals have a monetary incentive to overcount coronavirus deaths as they do deaths for other diseases. “I think you’re correct in that we’ve seen this in other disease processes, too. Really, in the HIV epidemic, somebody may have a heart attack but also have HIV — the hospital would prefer the [classification] for HIV because there’s greater reimbursement,” Redfield said during a House panel hearing Friday when asked by Rep. Blaine Luetkemeyer about potential “perverse incentives.” For families, Covid classification for a death enabled up to $9000 for funeral expenses, https://www.cnet.com/personal-finance/covid-funeral-reimbursement-now-9000-heres-how-to-apply-today/ https://www.cnet.com/personal-finance/covid-funeral-reimburs...
- barbazoo 5y agoThere is very little substance on that page plus it's 18 months old and the other fact you posted isn't an incentive for hospitals. I really wonder if that's actually a thing.
- walterbell 5y agoU.S. Congressional testimony by a CDC Director is not substantive? The 2nd point offers a financial incentive for families to agree with hospital (mis)classification, i.e. it aligns the financial incentives of family and hospital towards Covid attribution.
- 5y ago