8 ms·
The media's binary separation of populations into vax and unvax is a false dichotomy. More causal factors would be represented by: 1. Covid-recovered 2. V
by walterbell 5y ago
The media's binary separation of populations into vax and unvax is a false dichotomy. More causal factors would be represented by:
1. Covid-recovered
2. Vaccinated
3. Partly-vaccinated (< 14 days after 2nd shot)
4. Covid-naive + Unvaccinated
CDC reporting bundles #3 and #4. UK reports all 4 categories separately.
#1 was already a high percentage in 2021 and is now higher due to Omicron.
Edit: CDC estimated pre-Omicron #1 as 146 million people (as of Oct 2021), https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burden.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/burd...
- ifyoubuildit 5y agoIt is so amazing to me how many people don't seem to recognize this. My (somewhat baseless) speculation on this is that a lot of the people in forums like HN are early adopter types who mostly work from home, and so were able to avoid exposure and got the vaccine relatively early. From this standpoint, I could see it being harder to empathize with folks who were exposed in everyday life (it's just a simple jab, I did it, why can't everyone else? Or maybe even those folks must be bad/lesser people if they didn't stop themselves from being infected). Combine that with the constant onslaught of media time that pointedly ignores the categories that you breakdown above, and maybe it's no wonder that people have the opinions on this that they do.
- hatware 5y agoNot to mention all of the vaccine injuries that do exist but are rarely reported on. It's almost like there's a narrative here.
- tharne 5y ago> Not to mention all of the vaccine injuries that do exist but are rarely reported on. Source?
- twofornone 5y agoConsider for a moment that the "antivaxxers" are correct, that there is enormous bias in our medical, pharmaceutical, and media establishments in favor of vaccine safety. Could you really expect a reliable source on the subject if this were the case? What proportion of people are willing to speak out and risk career and social suicide for being labeled an "antivaxxer"? It is a self reinforcing chilling effect - few people speak out, data does not surface, fewer people look for evidence of adverse events, and over time it becomes riskier and more difficult to convince people that something is amiss. Meanwhile the internet is awash with anecdote of severe symptoms following vaccination, and particularly concerning are frequent reports of doctors who are dismissive and/or refuse to submit reports on adverse effects. And then there are occasional claims of specialists in various neurological or heart related disciplines who claim to be seeing an unprecedented spike in certain normally rare symptoms among vaccinated patients. Yeah, they could all be lying or this could be the nocebo effect or it's an army of bots spreading antivaxx propaganda...or maybe you can't magically accelerate a 5+ year testing and evaluation schedule for a novel technology merely because the president says he wants a vaccine yesterday? Note that the clinical data from pfizer and moderna is not available to the public - we are essentially relying on the manufacturers good faith with respect to the safety data that lead to approval by the FDA (moderna still isn't approved, by the way). https://www.bmj.com/content/375/bmj.n2635 https://www.bmj.com/content/375/bmj.n2635 https://www.bmj.com/content/376/bmj.o102 https://www.bmj.com/content/376/bmj.o102
- joshuamorton 5y agoYou've presented an unfalsifiable story. There's no way to prove it wrong, that's just more evidence of the conspiracy.
- binaryblitz 5y agoA massive global coverup of the vaccine being bad, or conspiracy theorists using facebook to spread their narrative. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam%27s_razor
- allturtles 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nicoburns 5y agoVaccine injuries are reported from official sources just the same as covid-related injuries. There’s not a big media buzz around it because the numbers are so small, and everyone knew going in that there would be a small number of adverse reactions.
- hatware 5y agoWere you used to seeing myocarditis and pericarditis in the news regularly before 2019...?
- FireBeyond 5y agoAre those more likely to be a) a side effect/risk of the vaccine, or b) a known result of the disease, which is present in people who have had COVID, even unvaccinated? I'm not sure what you're trying to imply, but it certainly seems like you're saying it's newsworthy due to the vaccine.
- hatware 5y ago>Are those more likely to be a) a side effect/risk of the vaccine, or b) a known result of the disease I have a more pressing question for you: Do you expect the medical establishment to accurately and honestly attribute the increase in myocarditis and pericarditis as side effects of the vaccine, or purely a result of the disease? I sure as shit don't. I expect the medical establishment to do and say whatever it takes to protect their profits.
- creato 5y agoNo, and after seeing the rates of cases related to both the vaccine and COVID, it probably should have stayed that way.
- tinus_hn 5y agoThese days you have to add ‘eligible for booster and chose not to get it’, ‘got booster shot’ and ‘not eligible yet for booster shot’. In the Netherlands we started the booster campaign on November 18, but we get graphs claiming ‘hardly any people with boosters in hospital!’ with the data including hospitalizations from November 19 onwards.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- srcreigh 5y agoEncouraging natural immunity is asking for hospitals to get filled up by people giving themselves covid on purpose. This affects non covid patients too. I suspect that's why the media doesn't do it.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoRecognizing that naturally acquired immunity exists for tens of millions isn't the same thing as encouraging people to intentionally catch covid to gain natural immunity. Failure to differentiate between the two is just another way the injection maximalists look out of touch or unempathetic.
- smnrchrds 5y agoThat's also why many governments do not accept proof of recovery in lieu of proof of vaccination. Those who do have vaccine-skeptic people catching the virus intentionally and risking death. https://globalnews.ca/news/8524409/hana-horka-czech-singer-covid-death/ https://globalnews.ca/news/8524409/hana-horka-czech-singer-c...
- walterbell 5y agoLet's remember that the best case for vaccinated people is Covid recovery. Wilful ignorance of the best case would be unwise. https://cbs12.com/news/local/new-covid-variant-detected-in-at-least-40-different-countries https://cbs12.com/news/local/new-covid-variant-detected-in-a... > "Omicron is acting like a super booster," Unnasch said. "People who have gotten omicron are going to be really well protected against infection, not just disease moving forward, which is a really good sign."
- smnrchrds 5y agoThe best case is never catching COVID again. Even vaccinated people put themselves at risk (albeit less than non-vaccinated people) if they catch COVID intentionally. No one recommends just going out there and catching COVID. But when proof of vaccination systems allow for it, some people do it anyway and some of them die instead. Relevant xkcd: https://xkcd.com/2557/ https://xkcd.com/2557/
- wallacoloo 5y ago> From this standpoint, I could see [..] there are so many different standpoints you could take from the HN population. - "HN focuses on tech; novel tech tends to be anti-regulation => HN must be anti-mandate." - "HN focuses on engineering; engineering is often an optimization game that involves balancing tradeoffs => HN must believe COVID response relative to all the other risks we face is an over-reaction." - and of course the one you presented. my theory is that opinions within any group are just more divergent than people realize. some groups do a better job than others in (a) understanding that and (b) working with that. it's almost all cultural: do people in your culture publicly voice their non-conforming views, and to what degree do people in your culture update their beliefs when they hear new information?
- xadhominemx 5y agoAt this point, “3” represents a tiny fraction of the population so isn’t even really worth breaking out
- walterbell 5y agoTo the contrary, #3 includes everyone receiving a booster, because immune system suppression/DoS immediately after a vaccine makes it the period of highest risk for both infection (from Covid or anything else) and vaccine injury. If we don't have separate reporting for #3, those negative effects will be attributed to #4. How many people know they should minimize physical exertion and crowds for 14 days post-vax?
- xadhominemx 5y agoOk, that’s different from the definition you just provided but in any event it’s still a very small proportion of the population
- walterbell 5y ago> it’s still a very small proportion of the population At present yes, but this was 100% of the now-vax population at a prior point in time (everyone passes through #3 to enter #2), so it should be separated in the historical record.
- xadhominemx 5y agoEveryone “passes through” the 10 second duration during which the vaccine is actually being collected, but we don’t collect statistics on those people
- walterbell 5y agoIf you're comparing the duration of an injection with the medically and legally mandated 14-day period of exclusion, look into the scientific reasons for the 14-day period.
- xienze 5y agoThere's also a further separation that is veeery relevant: age groups. There are sometimes graphs that split them out if you go digging far enough, but the graphs that make headlines are usually along the lines of "death rate, fully vaccinated versus unvaccinated" (which as you point out has its own issues). Not splitting it out into age groups gives casual readers the impression that mortality is evenly distributed along all age groups, which it most definitely is not.
- thex10 5y agoGood breakdown. I'd propose further breaking out of each category based on whether the person is immunosuppressed (for example from medication given to organ transplant recipients) or otherwise immunocompromised.
- walterbell 5y agoYes, someone else mentioned 7M people in the US. This group is usually prioritized, e.g. for boosters.
- benstrumental 5y agoYou may even split up (1) into omicron-recovered and other-variants-recovered, since recovering from omicron strain seems to give a stronger resistance against reinfection for both omicron and delta, whereas recovering from delta offers little reinfection resistance to omicron[1]. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/28/health/covid-omicron-antibodies-delta.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/28/health/covid-omicron-anti...
- walterbell 5y agoGood point, thanks.
- creato 5y agoThis, along with a large number of other trends related to COVID (including vaccine effectiveness), can be simply explained by immunity just not being very long lasting (4-6 months?). The Delta wave predates Omicron by around that much time. I think when all the dust settles around COVID, we're going to learn that both vaccines and "natural immunity" last 3-6 months, and that explains almost all of the noise and confusion about what "works" and what doesn't. And that also suggests that "herd immunity" was never a realistic goal, whether by vaccines or infection. Maybe some future vaccine can be developed which targets a different signal and can last longer.
- chaostheory 5y agoI feel that you need to include the people for masks and those against it. Unlike vaccines, masks do not lose efficacy over time or due to new variants. Both anti-vax and pro-vaccine supporters can fall into the anti-mask category. I don’t understand why people in the West are so anti-mask. It's been two years since I've gotten sick with anything. 1. Covid-recovered and Vaccinated + pro-mask 2. Covid-recovered and Partly-vaccinated + pro-mask 3. Covid-recovered + pro-mask 4. Vaccinated + pro-mask 5. Partly-vaccinated (< 14 days after 2nd shot) + pro-mask 6. Covid-recovered and Vaccinated + anti-mask 7. Covid-recovered and Partly-vaccinated + anti-mask 8. Covid-recovered + anti-mask 9. Vaccinated + anti-mask 10. Partly-vaccinated (< 14 days after 2nd shot) + anti-mask 11. Covid-naive + Unvaccinated + anti-mask
- wallacoloo 5y ago> I don’t understand why people in the West are so anti-mask. "anti-mask" has an implicit spin where it sounds like you're claiming a person is against the idea of anyone wearing a mask, but then often apply the label to a person who is perfectly fine with masks so long as the person wearing the mask is doing so of their own volition. so i say split that category, and then the major categories might be more like "pro-universal-masking", "anti-universal-masking" (i.e. "individual choice"), and "anti-mask-wearing-in-public" (not only doesn't want to wear a mask, but doesn't want the people around them to be wearing a mask).
- nomel 5y ago> in the West are so anti-mask. It's been two years since I've gotten sick with anything. For one data point, I'm vaccinated, had Omicron, and am now "anti-mask", as in, I think they are more harmful to me than not wearing a mask. The vaccines/boosters only target one protein, of 28. I want periodic exposure to all the proteins, to keep my immunity up and minimize my risk for now and future variants. Of course, I wear a mask as a courtesy for others. But, if nobody around me has a mask, I will remove mine.
- chaostheory 5y ago> I want periodic exposure to all the proteins, to keep my immunity up and minimize my risk for now and future variants. I think this makes sense to say now that the new variants are becoming less and less lethal. At the same time, this sounds similar to anti-vaccine arguments.
- benjaminwootton 5y agoThe other thing that needs bringing into the discussion is vulnerability. The average of death with Covid in the US is 80. If every healthy 30 year old and under in the US declined the vaccine, this would barely move the needle. They personally are not vulnerable and are not likely to end up in hospital. Reading this discussion, you would think that vaccinated = safe, unvaccinated = certain doom. Age is a much stronger predicter than vaccine status.
- partiallypro 5y agoAge and also just health status in general, people with diabetes or heart issues are vulnerable; but to your point most of those vulnerable are now vaccinated.
- benjaminwootton 5y agoMy point was that triple jabbing the worlds healthy 5-30 year olds will not move the needle on hospital demand. They are simply not vulnerable to the disease in a significant way. So sure, let’s discuss unvaxxed/1 shot/2 shot/boosted splits, but in the relevant population. To focus on 20 year olds is a red herring.
- Daishiman 5y agoCOVID vaccines reduce the incidence of long COVID symptoms, which most definitely affect young people.
- nomel 5y agoDo you have a reference? It seems "long COVID" isn't completely understood, especially in the young: https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/young-people-less-likely-to-have-long-covid-than-early-studies-suggested https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/young-people-less-...
- thebigspacefuck 5y ago“In theory, every citizen makes up his mind on public questions and matters of private conduct. In practice, if all men had to study for themselves the abstruse economic, political, and ethical data involved in every question, they would find it impossible to come to a conclusion about anything. We have voluntarily agreed to let an invisible government sift the data and high-spot the outstanding issues so that our field of choice shall be narrowed to practical proportions.” - Edward Bernays, “Propaganda”
- ls15 5y ago> The media's binary separation of populations into vax and unvax is a false dichotomy. More causal factors would be represented by: > 1. Covid-recovered > 2. Vaccinated > 3. Partly-vaccinated (< 14 days after 2nd shot) > 4. Covid-naive + Unvaccinated And my group: 5. Vaccinated and Covid-recovered I consider this as the gold standard of SARS-CoV-2 immunization.