11 ms·
What in the world? I have a hard time seeing this as anything but a racket, or possibly a legal maneuver to increase standing to sue Sci-Hub or something ("Look
by tomrod 5y ago
What in the world? I have a hard time seeing this as anything but a racket, or possibly a legal maneuver to increase standing to sue Sci-Hub or something ("Look, we've offered free access already!")
How much did Nature Neuroscience pay to produce these articles? Do they pay their editors? Their reviewers? The authors?
Do they pay their typesetters?
Do they offer their print journal for free?
Do they have expensive contracts for cloud hosting?
Is the expected lifetime value of any article, let alone every article, anywhere close to $11,390?
Most journals already allow authors to distribute copies by request. This is nuts.
- scottcodie 5y agoPrice has more to do with willingness to pay than with cost. Nature is a prestigious intuition so people are willing to pay to get published there. It also sets a barrier to get a paper reviewed. I hear you that it shouldn't be this way but they are a profit seeking entity so they are behaving like one.
- sometimeshuman 5y ago"Most journals already allow authors to distribute copies by request." Does anyone know how this works in practice ? I'd like to ask a few of my favorite researchers for a copy of their papers but I am a hobbyist and don't want to take their time and add to their likely overflowing inbox. BTW, "this is nuts" isn't a claim you can make if you don't know the answer to questions you posted. From their website: "an article is submitted and is assessed by our editors. If suitable it will be put through Peer Review". That peer review process could quickly exceed the $11.4k for example. [edited] added the BTW paragraphs after responses were received to the question in my first paragraph.
- Brian-Puccio 5y agoFor a sample size of one, go ahead and ask them: https://twitter.com/hwitteman/status/1015049411276300289 https://twitter.com/hwitteman/status/1015049411276300289
- kanaffa12345 5y agohow ironic that her blog post on how to access paywalled articles is currently "Access Denied" https://holly.witteman.ca/index.php/2017/12/11/getting-access-to-paywalled-papers/ https://holly.witteman.ca/index.php/2017/12/11/getting-acces...
- xmprt 5y agoThe path has changed (link rot) but the article is still searchable and viewable: https://holly.witteman.ca/getting-access-to-paywalled-papers/ https://holly.witteman.ca/getting-access-to-paywalled-papers...
- throwaway2037 5y agoI sent her an email about it. I hope she can fix it. :)
- joatmon-snoo 5y agoFind their email address, write them, and ask. They're more likely than most people realize to respond.
- kentlyons 5y agoAgree with the others - find the email address and ask. Especially if the lead author is a student / post doc, they are usually very excited to help. Profs often have an overflowing inbox and might be more hit or miss.
- guerrilla 5y agoAs a hobbyist, I just email the author, thank them for their work, maybe ask a question about or comment on their work and ask if they have the specific paper I can't get. Nobody's ever said no and I've asked dozens if times in CS, linguistics and for some climate and geography stuff. Academics are pretty accessible and even willing to chat about their work as long as you're not a crank.
- kragen 5y agoI was super surprised the first time I emailed a researcher and asked them a question about their work while mentioning I didn't have access to their paper. A week later an envelope arrived at my office with the paper in it. This was last millennium.
- netizen-936824 5y agoThis works in almost any field. Researchers generally love to hear from people, will usually answer whatever questions you might have about their work, and will happily give you a copy for free
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jinto36 5y agoPeer reviewers are all volunteers, the journal only pays the staff that coordinate the reviews- email a bunch of people and ask if they'll do a review (and often that's semi-automated now), and the editor that makes the decision after looking briefly at the feedback from the reviewers. The editors don't actually even do any proofreading or anything like that anymore, they just make executive decisions as to what articles to accept.
- leemailll 5y agoThis is your experience with nature neuroscience? I doubt it
- esyir 5y agoHahahahaha. I'm sorry, but that was a pretty incredible claim. The journals sure as hell aren't paying for peer review, or at least nobody I know has gotten paid for it. Peer review is basically a gratis service done by other researchers in the same field.
- robwwilliams 5y agoJust send contact author a request for a reprint. This has been standard operating procedure for hundreds of years—the only new angle, the ubiquitous and annoying PDF format.
- Fomite 5y agoAs a researcher, someone writing me to say they're interested in my work and would like a copy of my paper will: 1) Result in a PDF attachment with a short note. 2) Probably be the highlight of my day.
- a3_nm 5y agoSure, in most cases, you can ask authors for a copy of their paper. However, that's not a reasonable way to distribute science. Most research requires you to skim through many different articles, so introducing a latency of a few hours/days each time you want to open an article makes the process unreasonable. See also: Sci-Hub https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sci-Hub https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sci-Hub
- cossatot 5y agoNature pays their editors, unlike most society journals. But they are a for-profit business, and are clearly just looking for more profit. The expected lifetime value of any article in Nature Neuroscience for the authors is well above $11,390, as that is probably 1% of the typical grant that will produce the article, and getting published in this venue makes it much easier to continue to get grants funded, to get top PhD students and postdocs, and to get promoted. To be clear, though, the authors are not paying for this out of pocket. The funding agencies (i.e. the national government that supports the authors' research) is paying for it. Because many funding agencies now require authors to publish open-acess, Nature can more or less ask whatever price they want.
- namlem 5y agoIs the typical grant for a Nature Neuroscience study really over $1.1 million?
- Fomite 5y agoIf we assume that most studies that get into Nature Neuroscience are NIH R01s, which have a cap before you need to start fleshing out the budget in exacting detail of $125,000 in direct costs per year, and we assume a 50% overhead rate... We get $937,500. That's not far off, and center grants, large cooperative agreements, etc. probably give the distribution a decently long tail.
- oceliker 5y agoGraduate student in a neuroscience lab at a tier 1 institution in the US here. $1.1 million for a grant is very normal. I cost my advisor over $100k per year in tuition and stipend, not including the costs of any equipment and reagents that I use.
- tomrod 5y agoTier 1 - dedicated channel for funding, right? Is ground-breaking neuroscience research only performed at tier 1 universities?
- jrockway 5y agoI am not sure there is any requirement that your price be based on the cost of your bill of materials. Would shut down a lot of companies that are like "$30,000 per year for SSO". It probably costs them less to let you log in with Google than it does to store your password hashes, and yet it's always the "no, you have to pay us more" option. The thing with these journals is that they have name recognition that makes people want their research to be published in them. Getting published is good for their career. Combine that with a desire to support open access, and you have a product that you can charge for. It's doubly good, because it's not like authors are using their own personal funds to pay this fee. It just comes out of their grant. Whenever someone buys something with someone else's money, you know you're going to be ripped off. See also, Wifi at businessey hotels. Anyway, if the taxpayers are paying for this, we should ask authors to just host the papers on their websites. If you need the $5 for a VPS or whatever, I'll give you the $5 personally.
- CiPHPerCoder 5y agoIncidentally, https://sso.tax https://sso.tax
- dibujante 5y agoIn a well-functioning market, the price of goods should eventually shrink to their cost of production. If they do not, that's a monopoly.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoThe point is that by publishing in nature, one of the things you're paying for is prestige. Prestige has a very high market value.
- otherme123 5y agoAnother point is who pays. If the paper is submitted by a huge Consortium that received more than 2 millions for a given research, all the interests are aligned to pay 10K in publishing fees: Nature is very interested in publishing a less-than-perfect work if they pay 10K. The Consortium is very interested in publishing in Nature and Open Access to give the work a maybe undeserved push. And the money comes from other pockets.
- Aeolun 5y ago> Do they pay their editors? Yes > Their reviewers? No, not as far as I’m aware. > The authors? No, not as far as I’m aware. > Do they pay their typesetters? Yes > Do they offer their print journal for free? No, but in most of the world it is pretty cheap. > Do they have expensive contracts for cloud hosting? Yes. Well, yes and no. They mostly have a lot of expensive on-premise servers. At least as of 3.5 years ago. I think partially it’s that they can get away with it, but there’s certainly a lot of work going into this on the Nature side as well (mostly for print publishing). And these articles are never going away. They stay online forever.
- jaystraw 5y agoI think you hit it on the head. Value is subjective, and they'll charge whatever they can get away with. People will stop paying when it's no longer worth it to them (which will hopefully be soon as other models are embraced)