9 ms·
I sure hope that's right. It was the best feeling in the world to stand up an Apache server on my Amiga, and later my little FreeBSD server, and see my friends
by kstrauser 5y ago
I sure hope that's right. It was the best feeling in the world to stand up an Apache server on my Amiga, and later my little FreeBSD server, and see my friends viewing the website I was hosting on my dialup connection. It wasn't pretty, it wasn't elegant, and it certainly wasn't fast, but it was mine. I made that. From installing the server to writing the HTML, I owned that service from end to end and had completely freedom to do whatever I wanted with it.
That's what I want the Internet to look like for my younger family and friends. It'll probably never happen exactly this way, but I can picture someone running an IPv6-only service on their phone to impress their friends. I know what their smile would look like because that was once my smile, too.
- pratnala 5y agoYeah no, I wish we don't go back to that. It doesn't scale at all.
- coldtea 5y agoWho the fuck cares if it scales? It's better if it doesn't scale. Scale is what brought us Facebook and monopolies like Google.
- _jal 5y agoWhy does it need to? You are not Amazon. In the unlikely event you become Amazon, you will be able to rearchitect. Trust me, Amazon did.
- gary_0 5y agoNever worry too much about problems you want to have.
- Guest42 5y agoTrue, but I think the point was to be original and random and perhaps be popular as a result, rather than tailor everything for popularity.
- mdoms 5y agoNot everything needs to scale.
- emptybottle 5y agoHTML scales exceptionally well
- adamrezich 5y agonimforum*, which powers the official Nim forums, doesn't scale for shit, yet totally works for the scale of that community. not everything needs to massively scale, and, in fact, I think the mistaken belief that everything has to scale has led to many people being dissuaded from building smaller communities like back in The Old Days. * https://github.com/nim-lang/nimforum https://github.com/nim-lang/nimforum
- ravenstine 5y agoLOL If anything, a more barebones internet scales better. The less data you're sending, the more connections you can handle simultaneously, and the less code you'll need. When communication is more decentralized, there's not much of a need for most sites to need to think that much about scaling. We don't need the next Facebook or the next Reddit. I'd love to go back to more independent forums. Maybe with something better than vBulletin, at least.
- InefficientRed 5y agoI still run a half dozen VMs with genuinely ancient LAMP stacks and CGI code on a 5 year old desktop in my basement. People use those sites. Really the only thing that changed in last couple decades is that Docker makes admining those servers 1000x easier. The old web never went away, and the "new old web" will either fail to become popular or well become the "new new web". Eternal September is a social phenomenon and can't be solved with technology.
- na85 5y agoWho is your ISP?
- InefficientRed 5y agoVerizon FIOS residential fiber. (I've never had an ISP that allowed hosting HTTP servers in its TOS. But I've always hosted HTTP servers, and I've never had any issues. FWIW Gemini servers are also servers.)
- ravenstine 5y agoSame, although I'm no longer doing what you're doing. With today's average bandwidth usage, I don't know why an ISP would seriously give a crap about someone hosting an HTTP server on their home IP unless it was dealing with some insane amount of traffic.
- johannes1234321 5y agosince they want to sell the more expensive business plan. And forbidding something in the terms makes it easy for them to cancel your account in case they have a different reason.
- eppp 5y agoWe make people pay for a business account and extra on top to get a static ip. The amount of support from people that know just enough to think they need to do home hosting is a multiple more than a typical home user. The people that actually know what they are doing have to pay more but I never hear from them.
- fullshark 5y ago> I sure hope that's right. Yeah it's nostalgia speaking here, there's always gonna be hobbyists but the internet is now gonna be what it is today, massive conglomerates fighting for attention/eyeballs and monetizing it either through ads or pay services.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI'm sympathetic. My first personal website (after a couple of, ahem, not personal ones) was about the film "The English Patient", and yes, I know that smile. However, I think you're making a mistake that I also make quite often, of conflating the use and mastery of the technology required with the actual end goal. Lots of people might like to create their own dedicated websites focused on some particular interest of their own. Very few of them have any interest in Apache, Amigas, FreeBSD, servers, operating systems, bandwidth, IPv6 or any of the technology that would underpin them doing this. Hence ... Squarespace ;) We (computer technologists in general, and web folk in specific) failed to make running servers a trivial matter, and as a result in 2022, the honest truth is that running your own website no longer has much to do with any of the skills we might have smiled about back in the day. At least not for 99% of the people who don't already do it but might somehow have an interest in the idea.
- jjgreen 5y agoElaine Benes : [quietly] No. I can't do this any more. I can't. It's too long. Elaine Benes : [yells] Quit telling your stupid story about the stupid desert, and just die already! DIE! J. Peterman : [surprised] Elaine, you don't like the movie? Elaine Benes : [shouts] I hate it! [the audience shushes Elaine] Elaine Benes : [shouts back] Oh, go to hell!
- throwhauser 5y agoHow can a small website cope with GDPR compliance though? The rules that sprang up to constrain the social-media behemoths seem onerous for anyone but them to comply with.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoAll you have to do is not collect any data. Don't set any cookies.
- johannes1234321 5y agoSetting cookies is fine. If they are needed. You need a session cookie for the login function the user uses? - Use a cookie. No banner needed. The user puts something in their shopping basket? - Use a session cookie. No banner needed. You want to store information, not required, in order to identify the user again even though they didn't login, maybe to share the identity with an ad network? - You need a cookie banner where the user can opt out easily.
- MereInterest 5y agoNot only that, but storing information to identify the user again requires affirmative consent. GDPR doesn't just require that the user can opt out of tracking, but that any tracking occurs only after the user has freely given informed consent.
- johannes1234321 5y agoYes. If your users create an account with name and address data they need to agree to that data storage. If your shop just sells them a virtual thing there is no need to collect personal information. If you ask for the address and more or less directly print it on the label and then delete again it is a bit of an edge case where no explicit confirmation might be needed, however having a good data policy is good practice anyways and then having the extra checkbox in the order flow is not a big deal.
- 5y ago
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah. That sense of ownership has been lost. Now corporations own everything. Nobody wants a domain, they want a @name on some social media platform. Nobody wants their own website, they want to post on social media. ISPs have cgNAT now, nobody is directly connected to the internet. Everything is just so boring.
- BlueTemplar 5y agocgNAT is going to go away, even for the rare ISPs that use it, as more connections become IPv6-only.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> That sense of ownership has been lost. Now corporations own everything. Nobody wants a domain, they want a @name on some social media platform. Nobody wants their own website, they want to post on social media. I don't think the self-hosting people with their own domains ever went away. They're all still out there. The difference is that the internet isn't just for those people any more. Everyone is online, and the average person has no intention of learning how to host and maintain and design their own website when they can just as easily post the same content on an easy to use platform. A lot of the nostalgia in this thread isn't so much for the technologies of years past. It's for an internet that was just for us nerds, without the regular people participating.
- jkhdigital 5y ago> A lot of the nostalgia in this thread isn't so much for the technologies of years past. It's for an internet that was just for us nerds, without the regular people participating. Pretty much. It’s painful to watch the mass commodification of a technology you love, but that’s how the world advances.
- throwaway98700k 5y agoA mix of both. When I see a Medium post by a programmer I feel sad.
- sumtechguy 5y ago
- amelius 5y agoThe thing that is missing in the DIY website space is discoverability. Fix that, and you might have a chance of competing with big corporations. (In the old days we had "web rings", but I'm afraid that's not going to work today)
- dvtrn 5y agoWhich is why I wish the webmention had taken off more than it did https://www.w3.org/TR/webmention/ https://www.w3.org/TR/webmention/
- zozbot234 5y agoWe also had curated directories, DMOZ being the most common. Starting a bunch of DMOZ-like, federating (i.e. sharing and trusting one another to provide high-quality links, semi-comprehensive directories might be the quickest and most effective way of bringing "the old Internet" back to life. This might even become an acknowledged part of the Fediverse, if it leveraged the existing Web standards wrt. structured "third-party annotation" of outside Web resources, as issued e.g. by the W3C WebAnnotation Working Group. https://www.w3.org/annotation https://www.w3.org/annotation
- kradeelav 5y agoWhy not, with web-rings? I don't mean that snarkily: I have at least 2-3 webrings on my personal link page, and neocities is home to literally hundreds more.
- warkdarrior 5y agoWeb-rings are linked lists, slow to navigate. Google gives you hashtable access to the web.
- MereInterest 5y agoSlow to navigate, but far less vulnerable to corruption. Each link was intentionally made by a human, vouching for its integrity and usefulness. Each link is followed only if I trust a site enough to believe its recommendation.
- jlarocco 5y agoI think there's some kind of fallacy there. Nothing's really changed, in the sense that there's nothing stopping you (or anybody else) from running your own server that serves up simplehand-written HTML, if that's what you want to do. You can probably even do it on your phone, but I wouldn't hold my breath for the app to get accepted to any official app stores. Personally, I think the UI on phones is atrocious, and would never want to use one for any kind of development work, but to each their own.
- vecinu 5y ago> Personally, I think the UI on phones is atrocious, and would never want to use one for any kind of development work, but to each their own. When the OP said > but I can picture someone running an IPv6-only service on their phone to impress their friends I think he meant actually running the serving of the content from the phone's hardware, not actually doing the development itself on the phone.
- wolpoli 5y agoThe barrier of entry was actually lower than that. We didn't need to stand up an Apache server. We could just sign up for a Geocities/Xoom/Tripod account and upload HTML or use the built in site editor to create content. Somewhere along the way, people stopped building well organized sites and started producing chronologically organized writings and content. These chronologically organized articles and content have dominated web content and social media ever since.
- BlueTemplar 5y agoYeah, I found it weird that the article called blogs "Web 1.0", I'm pretty sure that it was them that were first hailed as the new "Web 2.0" ?
- eitland 5y agoAgree. As far as I remember web 2.0 was all about user generated content spruced up with Ajax experiences: Blogs (chronological as opposed to more freeform web sites) were arguably the first. The comments, follows ("blog rolls"), tagging, ratings and third party sites providing the same like del.ico.us and digg. RSS also was a web 2.0 thing in my mind at least. I think most people classify Facebook as web 2.0 as well but in my mind they aren't as much web as a silo built on web technology.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> The barrier of entry was actually lower than that. We didn't need to stand up an Apache server. We could just sign up for a Geocities/Xoom/Tripod account and upload HTML or use the built in site editor to create content. Reading this thread feels like everyone is anchored to whatever methods were popular at the time they entered the internet as being the peak. The BBS people think it was all downhill after BBS declined. The self-hosting people think it was all downhill after sites like Geocities/Tripod/Xoom became popular. The Geocities people think it was all downhill after blogging platforms became popular. The blogging people think it was all downhill when social media became popular. I think there's a heavy dose of nostalgia coloring the opinions in this thread. What people really yearn for isn't Geocities or Usenet or whatever. It's the feeling of excitement that came from first getting immersed in the internet when it was all new to you. > Somewhere along the way, people stopped building well organized sites and started producing chronologically organized writings and content. These chronologically organized articles and content have dominated web content and social media ever since. I don't see the problem with chronological ordering. Most of those platforms and sites make it easy to search for related posts. Worst case, the author can just drop some hyperlinks into the posts to tie them together. Curated and organized websites tend to fall out relevancy and decay very rapidly. Might as well just let people post as they see fit and then we can find it by searching.
- SMAAART 5y agoI want my BBS! <blink>This text could blink</blink>
- partomniscient 5y agoI remember some boards where you had to wait for what seemed like ages to get to the actual main page because you had to wait for some fancy ANSI art to do its thing.
- FpUser 5y ago>"It wasn't pretty, it wasn't elegant, and it certainly wasn't fast, but it was mine. I made that." I know the feeling. Even though I use Hetzner and OVH I also host stuff in my home office. Ordered business 1gbps fiber line with static IP for $120 CDN per month for that.
- d0gsg0w00f 5y ago> I can picture someone running an IPv6-only service on their phone to impress their friends. I know what their smile would look like because that was once my smile, too. Wow. Do you know if there's any enthusiasts out there doing this? A phone would actually be a great hosting device for tinkerers. It's always on, always connected, and supports IPv6.
- zozbot234 5y agoA phone is a poor hosting device in a conventional sense, because it's battery powered and keeping the connection up will drain the battery. If you want to P2P-host something via your phone, it should be a service that can somehow piggyback on the ephemeral network connection strategy that mobile devices are already using. The closest thing I've seen to that might be SecureScuttlebutt, but even then it's not ideal. IPFS hosting might also work, but again only on a highly ephemeral basis.
- miyuru 5y agoI tested this with my old phone and it certainly worked even on non rooted android but I do not deployed it full time. There is however this starlink dashboard hosted by awlnx on starlink and its IPv6 only. https://starlink.awlnx.space https://starlink.awlnx.space
- vmception 5y ago(blockchain, smart contracts, people are experiencing this same feeling again there, many for the first time. they release something on a public utility that others can interact with, and a GUI behind a domain name)
- lpcvoid 5y agoIt's just that there is nothing of value in regards to blockchain or smart contracts. They are a solution in search for a nonexistent problem, while heating up the planet.
- vmception 5y agoVery few blockchains cause carbon emissions more than say browsers. A smart contract deployed on one that uses a proof of work system with a lot of competition can be deployed on another that does not, vote with your code
- LAC-Tech 5y agosure hope that's right. It was the best feeling in the world to stand up an Apache server on my Amiga, and later my little FreeBSD server, and see my friends viewing the website I was hosting on my dialup connection. It wasn't pretty, it wasn't elegant, and it certainly wasn't fast, but it was mine. I made that. From installing the server to writing the HTML, I owned that service from end to end and had completely freedom to do whatever I wanted with it. Isn't this easier to this than it ever was? Granted, my 'server' is a VM in a server farm thousands of kilometres away, but I installed the server and wrote the HTML. What's even better is that he server was caddy and the html is html5 - both a marked improvement!