3 ms·
It feels fundamentally wrong that my employer cares at all about where I live when determining my 100% remote salary. Can anyone offer me rational arguments fo
by Waterluvian 5y ago
It feels fundamentally wrong that my employer cares at all about where I live when determining my 100% remote salary.
Can anyone offer me rational arguments for why they shouldn’t just pay people based on what they offer the job rather than where they choose to live?
Because it makes me salty to be paid half of what a colleague does because I’m in rural Canada and not San Francisco.
- mehphp 5y agoThe simple answer is because they can and people still accept the positions. Why would they pay you twice as much when you accepted half?
- Waterluvian 5y agoYup. Because I didn’t have all the information such as what others were being paid. I only knew that they were offering double what my current employer was offering to keep me.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 5y agoSo at that moment, all parties involved made rational decisions. Now that more information has come to light, you're fighting for what you feel is equal compensation. Sounds like the "system" working.
- vlozko 5y agoI think it comes down to an ability for a company to recruit. They can't recruit someone in SF with a salary based on rural Canada's cost of living. The justification is that it's in the company's best interest to reduce costs as much as it's in yours to get top dollar. A somewhat parallel example is whenever someone tries getting a car repaired or plumbing work done. They may all charge their own flat rate for labor but they almost always exorbitantly overcharge for parts. Why? Because if everyone else does it, they can too. It's money on the table they would be missing out on otherwise. It's an infuriating situation (I was charged $30 for 2 $4 gaskets on my repair yesterday) but it's a pattern that's been quite commonplace.
- francisofascii 5y agoA better question is, why do they continue to pay the colleague in SF, when they can get another rural Canadian for half the price?
- Ekaros 5y agoOr Indian, Eastern-European or African? Why not actually lower the prices to the global level? Wouldn't that be fair for everyone?
- Waterluvian 5y agoIf a company can actually get what they need, both short and long term, for much cheaper in the international market, then it should. Buyer beware, though.
- rr808 5y ago> Because it makes me salty to be paid half of what a colleague does because I’m in rural Canada and not San Francisco. Sure but you're paid multiples of someone in Mexico. Can you explain that?
- BoorishBears 5y agoTheir example is bad because they used a different country, if you want US wages live in the US. But within the US it's pretty ridiculous. Not all of how you spend your pay is scaled by your cost of living for example... My employer can't predict where I want to retire, yet by scaling my entire pay by cost of living where I currently am they'd be limiting how much I can save. You can live in a high cost of living area and decide you're ok with living with roommates and ramen noodles. That results in the same living expenditure as someone in a low cost of living area with significantly more room to save.
- triceratops 5y ago> if you want US wages live in the US. But within the US it's pretty ridiculous What are "US wages"? A police officer in SF or NYC makes substantially more than a police officer in Oklahoma City or Topeka. Even the US has large regional variations in wages, standards of living, and economic productivity.
- BoorishBears 5y ago> Even the US has large regional variations in wages, standards of living, and economic productivity ... and you think Canada doesn't? They have HCOL cities too, yet on average people in Canadian HCOL cities make less than their US counterparts. US wages. Plural. Wages in the US in across multiple locales vs wages in Canada across comparable locales.
- the_gipsy 5y ago> why they shouldn’t just pay people based on what they offer the job rather than where they choose to live? Your salary is determined by what a competitor would offer you. Nothing else, forget about your output, adding value, increasing profits, your cost of living, or whatever. When you are in SF and most importantly, are willing to physically into the office, then there can be only so many available workers. This means high competition from companies for workers. When you are remote, there may be many more available workers, so less competition from companies. Naturally, companies / managers try to bend the negotiation in their favor by trying to convince you that your cost of living is lower (happened to me). My advice is to shut this argument down immediately, be willing to get up and leave (for one of the many other real companies willing to hire you). IMHO it's OK to get a different salary when not in a big city, after all, both sides play the negotiation game. You get access to a bigger pool of companies too, you just have to share it with more workers (probably). On a society-level it's absurd that a SF dweller gets a million dollar mortgage subsidy, and you in rural Canada get (let's say) a 100k mortgage only - for the same productive output. All while crying about city/countryside inequality.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]