3 ms·
In another thread about JWT there’s a discussion about how the Soviets tried to copy the design of the space shuttle because “the Americans must have had some r
by vlovich123 5y ago
In another thread about JWT there’s a discussion about how the Soviets tried to copy the design of the space shuttle because “the Americans must have had some reason we can’t see yet for that design”. Turns out the design was largely motivated by a secret military operation only relevant to the Americans (which never materialized either apparently).
> The article makes the point that people do not build fences for no reason
Sure. That doesn’t mean that the reasons are good or accessible to you to make that decision. Now when the reason is obviously apparent and widely known, that’s a totally different thing with the caveat being that conditions change and you may not have realized that in a complex system.
- dekhn 5y agoThe shuttle carried out multiple classified military missions, although fewer than planned. It had capabilities unique to its design. The difference is that the Soviets didn't have the economic base to support such an inefficient design.
- vlovich123 5y agoAnd yet the Russians, in this case, would have been better served ignoring the Chesterton fence. It's a neat analogy but it has limited utility as a general rule for either side.
- dekhn 5y agoyes, I have a lot of respect for soyuz.
- _-david-_ 5y agoChesterton's Fence does not say you should build a fence 100 feet from your house because your neighbor has a fence 100 feet from their house.
- mark-r 5y agoI think you're mixing up Chesterton's fence with cargo culting.
- strawhatguy 5y agoChesterton's fence is about attempting understanding. If the Russians were blindly copying the space shuttle design, how is that attempting understanding?
- vlovich123 5y agoChesterton’s fence is about keeping the status quo unless you have a deeper understanding. From my perspective, copying an existing design of your competitor is the status quo. Innovating would be tearing down the fence.