7 ms·
Covid-19 Cases and Hospitalizations by Vaccination Status and Previous Diagnosis
- dredmorbius 5y agoTitle shortened from "COVID-19 Cases and Hospitalizations by COVID-19 Vaccination Status and Previous COVID-19 Diagnosis — California and New York, May–November 2021". Context here is concerning conferred immunity from natural infection. From the abstract: During May–November 2021, case and hospitalization rates were highest among persons who were unvaccinated without a previous diagnosis. Before Delta became the predominant variant in June, case rates were higher among persons who survived a previous infection than persons who were vaccinated alone. By early October, persons who survived a previous infection had lower case rates than persons who were vaccinated alone. Implications: [V]accination remains the safest strategy for averting future SARS-CoV-2 infections, hospitalizations, long-term sequelae, and death. Primary vaccination, additional doses, and booster doses are recommended for all eligible persons. The results speak more to the likely epidemiological consequences of widespread exposures due to the Omicron variant than any changes to existing guidelines. Note that the study does not cover the period in which the Omicron variant was pervasive, instead focusing on Delta and earlier variants of the SARS-COV-2 virus. That said, if the findings hold, where Omicron has been widespread most people will end up with exposure and probable improved immune response. It is still advisable to get vaccinated and boosted, but there's some increased hope that the worst of the COVID-19 global pandemic may finally be passing, if not now then in the near future, after the wave has passed in more parts of the world. Continued mutations and variants of the SARS-COV-2 virus remain a concern, and so long as the virus is extant in human and animal populations, such mutations are all but inevitable. Their implications are exceedingly difficult to predict.
- Izkata 5y agoHowever: > Four cohorts of adults aged ≥18 years were considered: persons who were 1) unvaccinated with no previous laboratory-confirmed COVID-19 diagnosis, 2) vaccinated (14 days after completion of a primary COVID-19 vaccination series) with no previous COVID-19 diagnosis, 3) unvaccinated with a previous COVID-19 diagnosis, and 4) vaccinated with a previous COVID-19 diagnosis. Note that "14 days" gap in point 2. Having completed vaccinations but not yet past those 14 days is a sort of dead zone that either ends up grouped in with "unvaccinated" or, I suppose, could be just dropped altogether. That group really needs to be broken out into its own thing, as that's (one of) the thing(s) the people who are straight against these vaccines are concerned about. They're saying that for those 14 days, you're more prone to infection than someone who is actually unvaccinated, and end up counted in the unvaccinated stats if you are infected.
- lukev 5y agoOf course one would like to see the data broken down more granularly. That said, nothing we know about how vaccines or the immune system works should lead us to believe someone is more susceptible to a disease immediately after being vaccinated. Although, if we're already talking about "people straight up agains these vaccines", then it's pretty evident they already don't give two shits about the science and it's just some weird sociopolitical agenda or conspiracy theory.
- tasogare 5y ago
- tomohawk 5y agoWhat happened to all the other states? Not including them seems like cherry picking.
- rsfern 5y agoI don’t think it’s cherry picking so much as maybe working with the limitations of merging 50 datasets vs 2? They at least acknowledge the dataset bias in the discussion section, and they cite a couple similar findings from other countries, and also they start with this: > By November 30, 2021, approximately 130,781 COVID-19– associated deaths, one in six of all U.S. deaths from COVID-19, had occurred in California and New York
- tomohawk 5y agoCDC is a federal institution. They have one dataset.
- rsfern 5y agoI guess, but it’s a heterogeneous dataset. They even discuss in this manuscript differences between how CA reports stuff compared with NY. (This is kind of a separate issue where CDC could have lead on data standardization, but not everyone in the US agrees about the Feds playing that role in this case; kind of a separate issue) The CDC also has covidnet, which doesn’t have the data heterogeneity problem so much, but I’m not sure it has the vaccination status breakdown needed for this study. CDC has famously not done a good job breaking that down… https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/covid-data/covid-net/purpose-methods.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/covid-data/covid-n... Anyway, none of this is to say that they’re definitely not doing a cherry picking exercise, but at least one should read the paper and decide if the choices they make about data sources and analysis are reasonable. Not super productive to just immediately assume bad faith, IMO. Especially since the conclusions are consistent with research from other institutions/countries
- dredmorbius 5y agoFalse, as is specifically noted in TFA discussing data sources. Those are: Statewide immunization databases in California are the California Immunization Registry, Regional Immunization Data Exchange, and San Diego Immunization Registry; the laboratory system is the California COVID Reporting System (CCRS). In New York, immunization information systems include Citywide Immunization Registry and the New York State Immunization Information System; the laboratory system is the Electronic Clinical Laboratory Reporting System (ECLRS). California data were matched between the immunization and case registries using a probabilistic algorithm with exact match for zip code and date of birth and fuzzy match on first name and last name. New York data were matched to the ECLRS with the use of a deterministic algorithm based on first name, last name, and date of birth. In California, person-level hospitalization data from CCRS and supplementary hospitalization reports were used to identify COVID-19–associated hospitalizations. Specifically acknowledged are: Dana Jaffe, California Department of Public Health; Rebecca Hoen, Meng Wu, New York State Department of Health; Citywide Immunization Registry Program, New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene. From whom those data were likely in substantial part obtained.
- onnnon 5y agoConclusion: Natural immunity with or without the vaccine provides strong protection against hospitalization. There wasn't much difference between the two. This study took place during Delta (May–November 2021).
- rsfern 5y agoThey also found that pre-delta (when a lot of the US was getting their primary series) vaccine immunity was more protective against hospitalization with alpha or whatever it was at the time in the US I’m not sure if there is a good study that can distinguish the change point as due to waning immunity from the vaccines or if it’s because of vaccine escape, or if infection-mediated immunity from delta is just better… The data I’ve seen from omicron suggest that a primary vaccine series offers about equal protection as infection with delta, FWIW
- JPKab 5y agoAs a person who was infected in February 2021, before I was eligible to get vaccinated, we now know that there was minimal to zero medical benefit to me getting this vaccine. I had a family tragedy with the vaccine in May that I commented on at the time here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27467803 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27467803 The tragedy detailed above made me realize that there was a risk, albeit small, to getting vaccinated. If I didn't have natural immunity, the risk was worth it. But since I did, I chose to not get vaccinated, only after weeks of research and poring through large N studies. Here is a comment I made 5 months ago that got downvoted for citing multiple studies that had informed my decision: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28170099 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28170099 The arrogant, smug hive minders deemed it misinformation. I was harassed by coworkers for not having the shot, and they dismissed my claim of natural immunity as a conspiracy theory. Some of them deliberately selected a restaurant that required proof of vaccination to rub it in my face. They knew I had recovered in February. They knew my family was grieving over my mother-in-law (she lived with my wife and I for ten years until 2 years before her death) but they didn't care. They dehumanized me. I then had to face a federal government mandate for a shot I wouldn't benefit from. I am beyond bitter. They were wrong. The feds were wrong. Most HNers we're wrong. The censors deleting my posts were wrong. And I know I will never get an apology. I now have attitudes towards centralized authority I never had before. All due to smug, self righteous people throwing away their principles and cheering on as the US government threatened my livelihood as a cudgel to violate my rights. To those of you who went along, you are cowards, and I hope you reconsider your arrogance in the future.
- lukev 5y agoNote that the data for this study is entirely pre-Omicron, which is known to have higher breakthrough rates (both for vaccines and for prior infection.) Given that Omicron is now the dominant strain everywhere, unfortunately this study isn't particularly informative regarding a decision to vaccinate or not or for epidemiological purposes.
- nradov 5y agoOmicron is now 99.5% of cases in the USA. Other variants are nearly extinct. https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#variant-proportions https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#variant-proportion...
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe article is informative on whether or not to vaccinate: you should vaccinate, particularly if you've not already had Covid-19. Severity and mortality for vaccinated individuals is far lower than for unvaccinated. For those who have had Covid-19, the vaccination ... provides little noticeable additional benefit. In discussion of this article on YouTube, John Campbell, a nurse-trainer PhD (retired) suggests that targeting vaccines to those who have not yet had Covid-19 might be supportable, but that recommendation carries the costs of determinng and tracking this status. As an epidemiological practice, ensuring a full course of vaccinations for all might well be the most effective and logistically-viable option.
- throwaway_4ever 5y ago
- lukev 5y agoThat isn't the whole picture either, though, which is why I said someone shouldn't use this article to govern their choice about vaccination. Someone who has already had Delta is susceptible to Omicron infection. Probably not a severe case, but it's a possibility. More recent data indicates that adding a vaccination on top of a prior infection takes the risk of severe infection way way down.
- splittingTimes 5y agoJohn Campbell has a nice (but a bit lengthy) break down about it. https://youtu.be/25-iJKPA1CA https://youtu.be/25-iJKPA1CA
- dredmorbius 5y agoThat's actually where I ran across the bulletin. The description and discussion are excellent, and I'd meant to link to them myself for those having issues following the MMWR text. (I'm the submitter.) John Campbell's commentary on the Covid pandemic has been excellent and a source I've returned to repeatedly since I discovered it fairly early on. Clear-spoken, understated, research and facts based, tends to usually go along with concensus, though he will break on occasion where newer evidence or experience suggests advice is flawed, and there he's typically been right. If he flubs a fact or point, he typically addresses that at the top of the next video. Not selling anything.