10 ms·
The thing about Bitcoin specifically, though, is that there are only really 2 possible outcomes: 1. The world decides it's "tulips" at some point, and the valu
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
The thing about Bitcoin specifically, though, is that there are only really 2 possible outcomes:
1. The world decides it's "tulips" at some point, and the value goes to 0.
2. The world decides it will be a major part of the financial system, and it goes to 500k or 1 million.
Basically, anything in between is just a probability calculation of whether it will end up at one end or the other.
The problem with this, though, is that the way proof of work works means that it is impossible that it will ever go to a million. The amount of electricity needed to protect the network is directly tied to the price of BTC. This is not just some small, inconvenient detail. It is inherent to how proof of work functions. So if it takes the electrical output of, say, Argentina to run Bitcoin now, it will take the output of China to run it when it's up around a million, and that obviously is untenable.
Other cryptocurrencies have seen the writing on the wall and are moving to proof of stake (not without other issues). But the politics of Bitcoin mining, and the few large mining groups, makes it hard for me to see how this happens.
- 3np 5y agoWhat makes you assume that only 0 and >500k USD are possible outcomes? Why not 5k or 50k? Why can it not sustain as a niche asset in your book? > anything in between is just a probability calculation of whether it will end up at one end or the other. There is some strong assumption you’re leaving out here.
- asimpletune 5y agoI could be wrong about this, but I don't know if the energy requirements have anything to do with the price (I.e. demand) for the coin, does it? I was under the impression that the problems that you have to solve get predictably more difficult, and they're more of a function of time than price. But yes, with your point overall I agree, like in 10 years or something it doesn't seem workable without major changes. Wasn't that what lightening or side chains were supposed to do? Any way, also, I don't own any crypto and I'm definitely not defending it. Feel free to correct me too if I'm mistaken, anyone.
- 0x0 5y agoI guess if the price of BTC goes up, then it makes it more "worth it" to throw more energy at mounting a double-spend attack, and therefore the energy needed to protect the network against such an attack also goes up?
- rjmunro 5y agoIt's much simpler than that. If the price of BTC goes up, it's worth spending more on electricity to mine it. If 1 coin costs $50,000, and you already own the rig, it's worth spending $49,999 on electricity to mine the next coin and you will make a profit. If you're rig can't do that, you're better off just turning it off.
- 0x0 5y agoSure, but if the BTC prices rise enough then it is in every transaction recipient's benefit that the network is mining even if there aren't any new coins minted, to avoid a "51% attack" / double spend attack.
- ashtonkem 5y ago> I guess if the price of BTC goes up, then it makes it more "worth it" to throw more energy at mounting a double-spend attack Close, but not correct. As the price of BTC goes up, so does the expected reward for mining any given block, making it profitable to spend more electricity in pursuit of the rewards. This results in a net increase in electricity usage as everyone spends more in an attempt to capture the rising value of mining a block successfully. In practice each miner is incentivized to spend an equal amount in electricity per block (at local rates) as the expected reward per block will net them. This results in a 51% attack being inordinately expensive, which was the point of the original design.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoThat's one way of looking at it. Another consideration for each miner is to look for cheaper and more abundant energy sources. Despite what the born-again eco-warriors have to say about consumption and the environment, Bitcoin can actually be an incentive for safe energy sources.
- smoldesu 5y agoI think the bigger issue is that Bitcoin has nothing backing it. It's value (and in turn, volatility) is driven by popular demand for the "asset", so even if there is some insane moonshot scenario where we do adopt it into the financial system, there's a very real chance that the price will collapse with little or no chance for recourse. That's the biggest issue, and it's one that's inherent to Bitcoin's nature as a decentralized currency. You'll hear diamond-hands Redditors complain about how Bitcoin "shouldn't be a fiat" and other such yarns of fiction, but the truth is that it doesn't have any desirable qualities that a centralized currency does. There is no bail-out, if Bitcoin fails then no sane person is going to let the global economy fail with it. Simply put, there's just no path forwards where Bitcoin retains it's value long-term. Other crypto is harder to grok (often intentionally so), but I suspect they'll meet a similar fate once the media attention blows over.
- tobrien6 5y agoIt's backed by mathematics instead of a country. That doesn't make it better or worse, just different, and diversity is generally what people want in their portfolio.
- eli 5y agoIt's not backed by mathematics any more than gold is backed by chemistry.
- toufka 5y agoUh, gold _is_ backed by chemistry. If gold were to change nearly any of its chemical properties, it would instantly lose its value. It is stable, generally non-reactive, non-toxic, lustrous, and of generally low abundance - all properties derived directly from its chemistry. That is actually one of the strongest arguments, to my mind, for why some variant of a cryptocurrency will survive as a store of value. Gold kind of "organically" found its way into value almost precisely because it is backed by the physical laws of nature. Cryptocurrencies went up a level to be backed by the laws of mathematics.
- petters 5y agoWhy is this not a possibility: 3. It continues to be used very little/nothing in the legitimate financial system while being used for blackmail, drug trade, crypto trade etc. Price $1000.
- zarzavat 5y ago> The amount of electricity needed to protect the network is directly tied to the price of BTC This is not how proof of work functions. Hash rate and price are not directly related, they are somewhat correlated because when the price goes up it becomes more profitable to mine. Bitcoin doesn't need more hash rate for the price to go up - the price is the independent variable and the hash rate is the dependent variable.
- tobrien6 5y agoTruth. Parent comment is deeply misinformed. BTC already has more than enough hash rate, and it is entirely independent of price.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoThat does not make sense. The whole point of proof of work is that it is proof that someone has spent the value in electricity validating a block. As the price of bitcoin rises, naturally more and more miners will beef up their rigs (that is, spend more money in infrastructure and electricity) to mine BTC, because the rewards and fees are worth more. Note if they didn't do this, anyone could easily have a "free money" arbitrage play, and basic economics says that discrepancy in prices (i.e. the value of a BTC on the market and the cost to mine one) must be arbitraged away. Think of it this way, if hash rate is independent of price, why does it take the electricity output of Argentina to run the network? It certainly didn't take that much years ago. The reason being that as BTC becomes more valuable there is more reward and thus more competition for miners to mine. As that happens, the hash rate will rise as more power is added to the network.
- piva00 5y agoNot directly related but not "somewhat" correlated either, it's deeply correlated exactly due to profitability, a point you actually mention but somehow don't consider a deep correlation.
- zarzavat 5y agoMining profitability is subject to conditions besides the price of a Bitcoin, for example: energy prices, block reward changes, regulation, hardware availability and pricing, etc. It's really not as simple as hash rate = price. It's more so that they are correlated in direction of change.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> The amount of electricity needed to protect the network is directly tied to the price of BTC. Why? I keep seeing this claim and it makes no sense to me.
- eli 5y agoI assume because the higher the price the greater the incentive for one entity to take over 51% of the network and start stealing transactions.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoIf the price of bitcoin rose to $1 million, but the price to mine one and associated transaction fees stayed at, say, just $20k in electricity costs, don't you think lots of other miners would beef up their rigs to mine bitcoin now? After all, that's like $980k in free money! Of course, they would beef up their rigs (spending commensurately more in electricity), and the required hash difficulty would go up to keep the mining speed at a block per 10 minutes. Another way to think of it, is why do you think the electricity requirements of Bitcoin are now the output of Argentina? Years ago they were a teeny fraction of that. As Bitcoin became more valuable, the competition for mining increased, so the hash difficulty adjusted to ensure the new block rate matched the higher wattage miners were willing to put in to increase their hash rates.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoThat's a big assumption. Same assumption made in the study which provides the 0.5% world energy consumption figure that everyone is citing. No actual evidence that it is true is provided. The same study shows minimum consumption estimates which are much more reasonable.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI'm not assuming anything. There is a guaranteed deep correlation between BTC price and amount of electricity needed to run the BTC network. That is the way proof of work is designed to function. I.e the whole way it protects against a 51% attack. There is simply no getting around this.
- eli 5y agoCouldn't you say that about basically anything? That it will eventually be really big or go away? Seems to me like bitcoin could keep seesawing on the fringes of relevance for a while. And people still buy tulips and beanie babies, albeit not anywhere near the prices at their height.
- danaris 5y agoBut that's because tulips and beanie babies have inherent value. Tulips are pretty flowers. Beanie babies are cute toys that you can play with. Bitcoin is a purely virtual financial instrument. It has no purpose other than to be worth money.
- eli 5y agoIt created an entire industry of ransomware!
- lukifer 5y agoI think it's functionally impossible for Bitcoin to hit literal zero. It could someday run on a network of ten hipster tech-history enthusiasts, worth micro-pennies like DOGE in the early days, but it still wouldn't hit zero. I agree that Proof of Work has a severe scaling problem; which is why I expect Proof of Stake to outcompete PoW (a token with lower transaction costs being inherently more desirable as a store of value). AFAICT PoS scales linearly: as the market cap goes up, the opportunity cost of locking tokens, and the mining rewards, both go up proportionally. It'll be interesting to see if BTC maxi culture sees the writing on the wall, or sticks to their guns to the bitter end; even if they're right that it's a better security model (I'm doubtful), it wouldn't be the first time that "good enough" won the market. I suppose the biggest reason that we'll never see PoW vanish completely, even if carbon-taxed or outlawed by most states, is the massive capital outlay in ASIC mining hardware, which literally has no other use. There'll always be a desire to recoup that investment, and an incentive to foster "true believers" to maintain demand.
- dfghdfhs 5y ago> 2. The world decides it will be a major part of the financial system, and it goes to 500k or 1 million. Where does this belief come from? Dollars are also a major part of the financial system, at yet each dollar is only worth $1.
- lippel82 5y agoThe supply of Dollars is not limited to 21 million.
- lamontcg 5y ago3. both 2, then 1
- tim333 5y agoThe way the system works is a block reward is paid every 10 minutes, currently 6.25 bitcoin worth about US$220k. This money then gets spend on mining costs, mostly electricity and mining hardware. The reward drops in half every 4 years so in 16 years it'll be 1/16 as much in bitcoin terms and if at that point bitcoin is around $500k the money spent on mining will be around the same as now.
- louloulou 5y agoYou're missing a few pieces. The amount of electricity needed to protect the network is directly tied to the value of the block reward. This depends on the value of bitcoin, true, but also the amount users are paying in fees and the reward era we are in (see https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Controlled_supply https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Controlled_supply).