6 ms·
>that GPs in particular would be replaced by a lower-cost Watson descendant It is happening. They are called physician assistants and nurse practitioners, "su
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
>that GPs in particular would be replaced by a lower-cost Watson descendant
It is happening. They are called physician assistants and nurse practitioners, "supervised" by a doctor. I assume going forward, they will take more and more of the usual pink eye/ear infection/flu and other common work that does not require 6 to 8 years of post bachelor education.
- tryptophan 5y agoIt's happening because hospital corporations love them. Corps can pay less, and since they have a tenth of the education, they order tons of profitable tests, consults, and scans because they don't know otherwise.
- plucas 5y agoThis is a mischaracterization of P.A.s (well, not the being-paid-less bit). Do you know any personally?
- SkyPuncher 5y agoHe's exaggerating significantly, but the core point is true. pAs and NPs will be the future of hospital care.
- jac241 5y agoIt's a mischaracterization for PAs because doctors only have ~7.5x minimum more clinical training and not 10x, 15000 clinical hours (for med school + family medicine, the shortest residency program) vs 2000hrs. Ask any radiologist you know what they think about the imaging orders from NPs and PAs and that will give you your answer.
- RHSeeger 5y agoIt's worth noting that the higher tiers of nurses have at least a masters degree, and like more time working than a doctor spends in residency. They are highly trained/skilled professionals.
- jac241 5y agoI would guess that most people entering NP programs at this point have less than 3 years of work experience as a nurse, a job where you are not diagnosing, coming up with treatment plans, performing procedures or doing any other physician tasks. I don't know if 500hrs of shadowing after a 2yr part-time online only program that you don't need any nursing degree or experience to enter would count as highly trained or skilled. Here's a list of direct entry nursing masters programs - https://nursinglicensemap.com/nursing-degrees/masters-in-nursing/direct-entry-programs/ https://nursinglicensemap.com/nursing-degrees/masters-in-nur... Here's Johns Hopkins doctor of nursing practice program's curriculum - https://nursing.jhu.edu/academics/programs/doctoral/msn-dnp/dnp-adult-acute/index.html https://nursing.jhu.edu/academics/programs/doctoral/msn-dnp/... - where more than half of your classes are not medicine related and which requires an astounding 1000 clinical hours and less than 10 credits a semester before you can call yourself "doctor". Most medical students will have 1000hrs after 3 months in 3rd year, where they will be expected to diagnose and come up with treatment plans vs just shadowing, and they still have 9 more months of 3rd year, 4th year, and a minimum of 3 more years in residency. Doctors will likely end up with a minimum of 15000 hours of training. The difference really is that large, and I feel bad for the patients and for the NPs who have no idea how deficient their education is. PAs have 2000hrs of clinical experience. Here's a chart - https://i.imgur.com/Cj5z4f8.jpg https://i.imgur.com/Cj5z4f8.jpg
- nradov 5y agoIs there any evidence that patients of NPs actually have worse outcomes? Given the current physician shortage would it be better to wait to see one, or get an appointment with a NP right away?
- RHSeeger 5y agoMy expectation is that the outcomes would be similar for the common issues, and would start to deviate as you got into more uncommon problems. A doctor will have a lot more "background knowledge" to be able to consider things that are outside the every day. At least in my mind, it's not unlike someone in software development with a degree in it vs not. For most things, the person without a degree will do a fine job; but for some things, they won't be able to consider many of the possible options/tools, because they just haven't been exposed to them.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>Corps can pay less, and since they have a tenth of the education, they order tons of profitable tests, consults, and scans because they don't know otherwise. Hence the purpose of managed care organizations (MCOs, health insurance companies) employing people to approve and deny (or design systems that approve or deny) payment for unnecessary tests, consults, and scans. And in a taxpayer funded system, the government employs people to performs the same roles.
- colinmhayes 5y agoThis is why insurances are moving toward capitated plans. Instead of paying for services provided health care providers get paid per patient they care for. That way the perverse incentive created by asymmetric information is removed.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI thought it was the opposite, that everything is moving towards value based payment, or at least it seems to be for government funded healthcare: https://www.chcs.org/its-not-just-risk-why-the-shift-to-value-based-payment-is-also-about-provider-flexibility/ https://www.chcs.org/its-not-just-risk-why-the-shift-to-valu...
- colinmhayes 5y agoWell implemented capitated plans are value based. Value based just means there are incentives for better than expected health outcomes and disincentives for bad outcomes. If you have a non-value based capitated plan health care providers would reduce the quality of care, so value based strategies were implemented to ensure patients receive good care even though providing it costs money.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoOh, thanks for the clarification. I thought they were not compatible.
- goodells 5y agoYep. The midlevels are supported by automatic protocols in Epic (e.g. sepsis, DKA -> put these dozens of orders in with 5 clicks) that physicians decide on and approve. They also rely more heavily on imaging instead of a physical exam and history. When unsure, they can consult a physician, even a specialist. It’s a very polarizing topic in medicine that patients generally aren’t privy to. Especially for resident physicians who often make half as much as these midlevels yet have more education, there’s a lot of bitterness. The federal government is ultimately to blame… having a fixed number of residency spots to artificially limit the supply of new physicians is terrible, and this is the predictable result. I think hospitals support inefficient midlevels because they can bill patients for the increased resource usage, but it’s not good for the system overall when unnecessary scans and consults are done, and more complex patients don’t get comprehensive care. Many foresee a two-tiered system developing, where the rich see physicians, and the poor see midlevels.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago>Many foresee a two-tiered system developing, where the rich see physicians, and the poor see midlevels. There already was a tiered system, with rich people being able to buy concierge medicine and getting preferred treatment based on who knows who on the hospital's board or if their name is on a wing of the hospital. The change now is a more visible and more granular price segmentation.
- jac241 5y agoThere’s no price segmentation. You pay the same for a visit with a PA or NP as for one with a physician, so why see someone with less than a tenth the experience who may have gone to an online only school with 100% acceptance rate and shadowed for 500hrs of “clinical experience“ right out of nursing school?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIt will happen via in network and out of network agreements. Healthcare providers with greater proportion of NP/PA will be selling for cheaper, so MCO will sell access to only them in their lower price plans, and healthcare providers where you get to see doctors will be in higher price plans. This already happens, especially with many healthcare providers not accepting lower reimbursed Medicaid patients.