17 ms·
The Future of E-Bikes
- entropicgravity 5y agoThere's quite a bit of talk here about the infrastructure for e-bikes and its cost. The most practical way to implement this is to repurpose a curb, car lane in city centers for e-bikes, bikes and small low powered electric vehicles.
- brnt 5y agoElectric scooters exist already, I'm not sure people would like to get rid of the ability to pedal themselves; most electric bikes are designed with the motor in a supporting role in any case. People don't always have the motor on, would like to be able to use the bike even when the battery runs out, and how much weight do pedals add anyway? I surely don't share the observation that the Corolla has been produced yet; it's basically the Gazella Orange (around these parts).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- timbit42 5y agoThese seem closer to being a Corolla: * Organic Transit ELF ( https://organictransit.com/ https://organictransit.com/ ) * Better Bikes Pebl ( https://www.better.bike/ https://www.better.bike/ )
- gerhardhaering 5y agoCloser as in the price? It is certainly a question of volume, but given that I can get an actual combustion car Dacia Sandero for 8.990,00 € - these prices seem ridiculously high!
- Gigachad 5y agoMy city has rental escooters and I find them very convenient. Sometimes I want to go to a restaurant on the other side of the city so I just grab one of the scooters there are usually a few outside my apartment building. Costs me $4, less than food delivery. And a lot more fun. The best part about them imo is I don’t have to worry about stress. The worst part about using a bike or scooter is worrying that when you return, it won’t be there.
- sam_goody 5y agoHe starts off with the presumption that having a mechanical drivetrain is an abomination, rather than an asset. For many, being able to pedal, but not being required to pedal all the time, is one of the main reasons to use an e-bike in the first place. There are little cars and golf carts that could otherwise replace bikes. And as far as the tires - get Kevlar tires. They have tremendous range and it's cheaper than the tires you save, even ignoring the time and hassle of switching tires on an ebike. It adds some drag, but nothing that you feel.
- zik 5y agoOne of the more enjoyable aspects of riding a bike is the direct connection you have between your legs and your motion. Many e-bikes just add power to whatever you're doing but the more premium e-bikes often use the Bosch system which uses crank torque sensors to provide a more direct feeling of control over the bike. Separating the cranks entirely from the drive seems like the exact opposite approach to me - without a direct physical connection between the cranks and the drive I imagine it'd feel spongy and unresponsive to a rider. I don't think people would enjoy riding a bike like that.
- johnwalkr 5y agoI agree. Also, in many jurisdictions, e-bikes cannot have a throttle and must only add power to pedaling to qualify as a bike and not a vehicle that requires a license. And the FreeDrive thing linked looks like a $1000+ component by itself, and bills itself as allowing new bicycle architectures. Most press about it is about high-end cargo bikes. I don't find its existence very compelling as support of the author's claims.
- touisteur 5y agoI can attest the shimano 'steps' and bosch equivalent systems feel very different from 'older' systems. They start helping almost as you put force on the pedal, so e.g. when stop/starting on a hill with 50kg cargo (twin girls or cement bag) it makes a huge difference. The difference between the adhoc 'power on front wheel' and the integrated ones is night and day in comfort. Maintenance is more complicated, but if you're using this as you main vehicle (we don't have a car) you can maybe set aside a small (200-300eur) yearly professional maintenance budget. I'll admit I can't do it myself.
- markvdb 5y agoInteresting and well written. I was pleasantly surprised by the bike-by-wire concept. That looks like it really has the potential to simplify the architecture, do away with a lot of maintenance and increase rider comfort. No more chain, belt or shaft is really a radical simplification.
- bagacrap 5y agoguess it depends on your definition of simple. I think a chain is pretty simple, and low maintenance to boot if you make it sturdier (as you would on an ebike) and enclose it.
- markvdb 5y agoFor exactly the reasons you bring forward, I own a Flevobike Greenmachine [0] recumbent. It has a fully enclosed chain and a Rohloff 14 speed hub. A marvel of mechanical engineering and almost zero maintenance. The perfect muscle power long distance bike. I love it. The Schaeffler/Heinzmann design is one for ebikes though. How do you simplify a hybrid muscle power/electric drivetrain and make it more durable? Converting muscle power into electricity first makes a lot of sense in that case: - does away with so many moving parts, including the chain - can recycle so much more effort from automotive. - more comfortable when cycling - regenerates energy from braking/going downhill [0] https://flevobike.nl/GreenMachine/greenmachine.html https://flevobike.nl/GreenMachine/greenmachine.html
- Tade0 5y ago> Hybrid-electric cars are an engineering abomination. They have both gas and electric powertrains, ensuring they are more expensive and complicated than their competitors. The latter is actually false. Having a high-voltage battery on board means you can get rid of most of the belts which normally power things too large for the 12V battery to handle, like the A/C compressor, power steering etc. Same goes for the powertrain - no need for a typical gearbox when you can just replace that with a planetary gear. Overall hybrids have less mechanical parts than regular ICE vehicles.
- lvs 5y agoYou need independent motors to run all those things after you removed the belts. You don't save any mechanical complication that way. Those components are now just electrically-driven from their own motors rather than mechanically driven from belts.
- Tade0 5y ago> You don't save any mechanical complication that way. Actually, you do if you count the moving parts. A belt is always at least two pulleys and a belt. A motor is a motor. One moving part vs three. In some cases you don't need anything at all - hybrids don't use alternators, some (like Toyota's HSD) don't even have a stepper motor for throttling and a dedicated starter motor - the two motor-generators perform this function.
- LeonM 5y agoWell, I guess 'it depends'. Generally I agree with hybrid systems being more complex that ICE only systems, but having a high(er) voltage electricity source and powerful electric motor available does remove some complexity. Depending on the setup, the hybrid electric motor also acts a the starter, and generator for the ICE. The hybrid drive may be used to move the vehicle in reverse direction (depending on how the hybrid system is implemented), removing the need for a reverse gear. Electric power steering can powered directly from the hybrid battery, simplifying the steering rack. So it does remove some complexity, but from an engineering point of view, I still think they are just too complex. Manufacturers just should give their customers the option to have full electric models, or fully ICE powered for those living in very remote areas. After having driven some of the supposedly latest and greatest hybrid powered Lexus models (AFAIK Toyota is still king of hybrid drivetrains) I am not convinced. They drive nice, but would have been better if they were fully electric. I just cant believe how badly Toyota missed the EV market.
- unit_circle 5y agoDecent piece. Always glad to see people thinking about infra... IMO refactoring American public spaces will be a key part of remaining relevant on the world stage. I personally hope ebikes come to fill a space between cars and bikes. My dream ebike does 35mph+ for 40mi+ with 50-100w of human input and has some cargo capacity and probably an extra seat. My household has a car (prius-c) and a converted van for longer trips / cargo moving. For me, this would allow me to ditch my car which is primarily used in the city. Though a bike like this would be pretty competent on surface streets mixing with automotive traffic, I would still probably need _some_ infrastructure to make it work well. Secured ground-level storage & parking near stores and points of interest, and streets with appropriate speed limits (<45mph). The climate where I live is mild costal, but I believe this is possible even in more extreme continental climates with spikes, etc. Clothing tech has made staying dry & warm not too hard. I have looked at the Twike but it's just an impractical device. Way too expensive & trying too hard to be a car. Some corrections: - Freewheels don't preclude regen - You'll always need brakes - Some folks need better than 15-20mph ;-)
- TomK32 5y ago45mph is stillu a speed limit I wouldn't want to cycle on on a regular basis. You're right about infrastructure, decent cycle paths is what people need to ride bicycles in the city, the are just too afraid of the heavy car traffic. 15-20mph for a bicycle is plenty of speed, as a matter of fact, bikes with motor support above 25kmh (15.5mph) here in Europe it would be a S-Pedelec and need a license plates and other stuff just like a motor scooter. You wouldn't want to ride at 35mph, it's a scary speed even on a good road bike that's meant to be ridden faster. Regarding winter: Start cycling in summer, cycling is fall and just upgrade your clothes as you go along. I cycle 20km on a work day, no matter how bad, cold or hot the weather is. It's just about getting used to it.
- frankus 5y agoAt this point they're talking about an e-motorcycle that sort of incidentally has an emergency backup pedal drivetrain. Which is fine—most of the energy efficiency advantages of a bike come from being light and (relatively) slow, not from being human-powered, and their small size helps with lane and parking space. But at that point you need real safety gear, and definitely shouldn't be sharing infrastructure (at least at those kinds of speeds) with human-powered bikes. (edit: this is more in reply to the comment the preceding comment replied to. I regret the error)
- pjmlp 5y agoUntil E-Bikes get cheaper than a 125cc motorbike I personally don't see any value in getting one.
- TomK32 5y agoWould you ride a €1000 motorbike and trust it? Also, how good are you at maintaining them to pass the yearly inspections?
- jacquesm 5y agoThat's not all that relevant. Bikes need maintenance too. And indeed, e-bikes are often vastly overpriced.
- TomK32 5y agoYes, especially those batteries. I had to buy a 500Wh for a project bike of mine, cheapest used one I found was refurbisched for just 250 Euros, plus some for the casing to fit it on the bike (don't ask) and new ones go for 700 Euros. I keep saying for years: Unitl someone comes with a totally revolutionary battery that's 10 times better than what we have now, neither e-cars nor e-bikes are worth the hassle.
- pjmlp 5y agoYes, given that is an approximate price for Piaggio and Honda models when one shops around for dealer deals. Additionally, maybe up that price for a proper quality e-bike. E-Bikes also require maintenance by specialized shops and after a certain speed limit constraints similar to motorbikes anyway.
- Markoff 5y agocan you please send me link/country/model to 1000 EUR Honda motorbike? here in Czechia PCX 125 cost like 3000EUR, there is no way you can buy brand new Honda for 1000 EUR
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- po1nt 5y agoReplacement of cars is realistic until it rains, snows, wind blows too much or you need to haul something, have multiple passengers and such. I can't imagine owning ebike as a city daily driver though bikesharing sounds reasonable. The issue is that shared bikes are often gruesome, broken, unhygienic or vandalized. I believe it's time to abandon cars in cities but there is no viable alternative to many scenarios. The best solution I can think of is abandoning traditional city designs where city centers are for shopping, work is highly concentrated either in mega administrative buildings or industrial areas on border of cities. If we could build cities more like cells where everything we could need is within a walking distance and everything we could WANT is within (safe) biking distance, we could eliminate most motivations for travelling.
- geewee 5y agoI think it's true that it depends highly where you are and how your cities are designed. I'm in Denmark and I've never owned a car, and I get by on a (non-e) bike just fine for a daily driver. Certainly sometimes you'll need to do ridesharing in cars or rent a car, but that's less than 10 times a year.
- PierceJoy 5y ago> Replacement of cars is realistic until it rains, snows, wind blows too much or you need to haul something, have multiple passengers and such. Don’t all those things apply to a city like Amsterdam? Granted, there were still a decent number of cars on the road, but I was amazed how many people were doing their daily travels on bikes. I’ve only been there once on vacation, and I didn’t pay attention enough to know whether the city design you mentioned is used.
- stevesimmons 5y agoI do all those things in Amsterdam. I can get everywhere in Amsterdam much quicker by bike than driving or public transport. Cycling in the rain and snow [2] is no problem, you just need the right gear. What non-Amsterdammers don't realise is the city never used to be a cyclist's paradise. In the 1960s, Amsterdam's car-obsessed urban planners had grand visions to drive motorways through the inner city, razing the historical buildings, and constructing Manhattan-like skyscraper clusters. Here's a 3 minute video "Highways Almost Destroyed Amsterdam" [1] about those plans, the fightback in the 1970s, and the resulting bike culture that Amsterdam has today. Enjoy! [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vI5pbDFDZyI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vI5pbDFDZyI [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xB1tgkOM6Bw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xB1tgkOM6Bw
- ulnarkressty 5y ago> What can we do to get a people's e-bike that has 30 miles of range, requires no maintenance, travels 15-20 mph, and retails around $500? These fast eBikes give a false sense of security to the rider because they look like bicycles. You can get hurt quite bad in an accident at 20mph, and I don't see any riders wanting to wear sturdier protection like motorcycle helmets. If you lower the speed requirement to 10-15mph you can get a cheap asian eBike for around that much money (well, could, a couple of years ago, now everything is more expensive).
- PierceJoy 5y agoI wouldn’t call 20mph a fast ebike. Human powered bikes ridden by an average human can easily reach speeds over 20mph.
- fuzzy2 5y agoYeah, sure. But can an average human keep this speed for extended periods? I certainly can't, but granted, my fitness is lower than average. I think the main problem is that with an e-bike your grandma could suddenly be cruising at that speed.
- TomK32 5y agoI can do 20mph for an hour, but need to recover for an hour after that. 20mph is also where the dangerous speed starts for us cyclist because motor traffic isn't used to cyclists going that far and every crossing without lights will become a bit of a gamble for the cyclist.
- codingdave 5y agoHuman powered bikes at 20mph give you an accurate sense of the power behind your velocity because you are personally delivering that power. That also isn't the average human cruising speed, that is speed achieved by experienced riders. Riders with enough experience to control the bike in all kinds of wonky scenarios. But an e-bike can make high speeds feel like a casual stroll, and get someone to that speed when they do not have the experience to control it. I love fast bikes, but I also am acutely (perhaps overly) aware of the safety implications of them, as I have taken a tumble off a bike at high speed. Broken bones, road rash, hospital stays, PT, and years of chronic pain as a result. I still love me fast e-bike, and still ride it (carefully), but I am under no illusion that it isn't fast.
- polote 5y agoJust a bunch of opinions without any data
- bArray 5y ago> What can we do to get a people's e-bike that has 30 miles of range, requires no maintenance, travels 15-20 mph, and retails around $500? I agree, we need a "people's" e-bike. Bare in mind it's not unreasonable to pick up a used human-powered bike for less than $100. It needs to be cheap, safe and serviceable. I always thought the best way forwards for such a thing is to use existing mountain bikes, use the existing gearing, brakes and chain drive and add a motor/battery/control system to this. Do away with the pedals entirely, most e-bikes are far too heavy/hard to pedal to do any kind of serious cycling. If you have no intention of pedalling the thing, weight is not so much an issue. > DC motors have fallen out of favor for "brushless DC motors." BLDC motors have a longer life, better low-end torque, and are easy to control electronically. These are a good solution, but improvements in motor technology driven by automotive R+D should trickle down. I would still opt for a DC motor. Sure they are less efficient, have less torque, etc - but they are incredibly simple to drive. I imagine it might even be possible to build a reliable mechanical based controller. > Bicycles are already absurdly efficient. E-bike battery packs are small as a result. Their small size means a less energy-dense battery might be better if it obviates the need for a more complex battery management system (BMS). If you're not doing hills and rolling resistance is not so much an issue, lead acid batteries are cheap and pack a reasonable punch. They are incredibly easy to charge and have an excellent charge cycle life time.
- fuzzy2 5y agoLead acid batteries are heavy, they are large, they don't like heat, they don't provide as high currents, they can't take as many cycles. They are not an option here. E-Bikes are already too heavy and bulky.
- mft_ 5y agoAgree - the e-bike is one of the minor revolutions that was enabled/driven by the accompanying revolution in battery technology.
- bArray 5y ago> They are not an option here. And yet they are still the battery of choice by the automotive industry who are also weary of each of your concerns. There are very good reasons as to why cars do not have LiPos. > [..] they don't like heat, [..] In terms of thermals they far much better than LiPos (you don't need a heating/cooling system for your lead acid battery). > [..] they don't provide as high currents, [..] The starter motor in your car will sink hundreds of amps during initial turnover, something you will need just a fraction of for an e-bike. Assuming your 12V lead acid battery sags to 9V under load and you're powering a 1kW motor, you're looking at a draw of about 111A, compared to 600A+ from a start motor. Share this across multiple batteries and this also reduces sag. > [..] they can't take as many cycles. In terms of cycles, I've personally found that my car's battery takes 10 years or so to stop turning over the car or holding a decent charge. Given that lead acid batteries are significantly cheaper and can be maintained, exist all over, can be easily recycled and are about to be in massive surplus when we see mass adoption of EVs, they make a lot of sense for a cheap e-bike revolution. > [..] Lead acid batteries are heavy, they are large, [..] > E-Bikes are already too heavy and bulky. As I said, the purpose would not be to cycle the thing. A motorbike for example would be a lot more heavy, yet nobody claims they are non-rideable. Also bare in mind that we are not looking to build the carbon nano tube $100k e-bike of dreams. This is just meant to be a working horse.
- cianmm 5y agoI’m a total convert to ebikes and use a VanMoof (mentioned in this article as an example of vertical integration - its a great bike when it works, but it has a high failure rate. My parents use more traditional brands with a much lower failure rate but about twice the price) to move around my fairly bike unfriendly city. This article gets a lot of points right, but a few important ones wrong. Firstly, I find it pretty surprising that the author would want to remove the drivetrain. I frequently do 75km (47 miles) in a weekend on a single charge on my bike, and I imagine that a lot of that range is due to the power that I’m providing to the bike rather than relying entirely on the inbuilt motor. The ability to go far is central to the goal of replacing as many car journeys as possible with sustainable transport such as bikes. In addition, bikes provide decent exercise with relatively little effort, built into day to day. Cycling makes us healthier. Also, if you run out of battery then you’ll just have to push the bike, rather than cycle a bike roughly the weight of a city-share bike back home, which isn’t a particularly difficult task for most. I do however see the benefit of this type of bike for some who use bikes as an accessibility tool, although maybe in those cases a scooter with a seat would be more convenient since it’s smaller. The second idea in the article which made me double-take is the idea of removing direct mechanical brakes from the bike. As somebody who commutes around a busy city on a daily basis, this had me wondering if the writer actually cycles in a city or not. As a bike commuter I need to deal with drivers who want to kill me, pedestrians who jump out from behind obstructions with no warning, and other cyclists are too indifferent to their surroundings that they’re likely to injure the both of us. I need to fully trust that when I squeeze that brake lever that my bike will come to a stop in the exact way that I intend. Including if the electricals fail for some reason. Finally, not bike related, the writer demonises the idea of making specific streets bike and pedestrian only, banning cars, and even seems to dislike the idea of the 15 minute city, where you aren’t required to leave your local neighbourhood on a day to day basis. This might be coming from the perspective of living in American city where the car is king, but it seems incomprehensible to me that somebody wouldn’t want to have all of their daily necessities easily accessible by foot, and be able to bike, or scoot, or take public transport to pretty much anything else they could need within a 15 minute window. There are both social and economic benefits to this, as it increases neighbourliness as people get to know each other, and also moves away from a small number of big box shops to a much greater number of local green grocers, butchers, book shops, and so on. Reduction of emissions is another huge benefit of course. Overall I agree with the article directionally but think it gets a few pretty important things wrong.
- sam_lowry_ 5y ago> The market is still lacking a Toyota Corolla equivalent. Here is Europe Rad Power Bikes are everywhere. That's the closest to the people's e-bike I can see.
- johnwalkr 5y agoIn Japan Panasonic and Bridgestone e-bikes are ubiquitous. Definitely Corolla-like. Those and various folding e-bikes make up practically the entire market. You don’t see many people on high-end e-bikes at all.
- bambax 5y agoWhere in Europe? I'm in Paris and never heard of them. They seem pretty expensive at around €2,000 too.
- sam_lowry_ 5y agoBenelux, but I saw them in Germany as well. Rad Wagon is the most popular, I guess this is because it can be used to transport kids but still costs under 2000€ while bakfietsen usually cost three times that.
- noahtallen 5y ago> The mayor has a vision for a "15-minute city" where you rarely leave your neighborhood. The concept offends my American sensibilities of wanting to roam free over wide ranges. Interesting comment, but I think a better take is that 15-minute neighborhoods don’t force you to leave your neighborhood for short trips. Is it really American to be forced into traveling outside of your neighborhood to go to things? I think it’s more free (and therefore “American?”) to have more local options, which of course doesn’t preclude distant options if you desire.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bouzouk 5y agoAmerican cities had this (“unamerican”??) idea already: https://www.portlandonline.com/portlandplan/index.cfm?a=288098&c=52256 https://www.portlandonline.com/portlandplan/index.cfm?a=2880...
- TomK32 5y agoHe's not getting why the 15-minute city/town/village is what we need to live and work in: It puts an end to those absurdly long commutes and have everything you need daily close to you: schools, work, living and shopping all within a short distance is how we lived before we surrendered our cities and landscapes to the car. You can still road freely into the wider country your holidays and weekends, but then you'd just rent a car or take public transport.
- rowanajmarshall 5y agoThis is pretty much how I live in London, and it's great! * Several small shops and small-ish supermarkets in a 5 min walk, with bigger ones maybe 15 mins walk away * Doctors, dentists, even a hospital within 10 mins walk * Ditto for co-working spaces * Gyms, swimming pool, coffee shops, even some theatres and a cinema within 5 mins walk too
- fassssst 5y ago
- gorgoiler 5y agoI’ve been an ebike rider for a month now. My initial impressions are first, that this is amazing. Being able to commute a long distance in full winter clothing without needing to shower at either end is game changing. Secondly, the mass of my bike is worrying huge. With a hub motor and a battery on the seat tube, it is very easy to injure oneself doing “normal bike stuff”. I’m very used to being able to just put the nose of the bike into a space and then lift the tail across to park the bike. I’ve done that a few times with the ebike and come very close to doing my back some serious damage. Thirdly, in terms of social acceptability it feels like the transport equivalent of vaping. People seem openly interested in the bike but it’s always with a light undertone of something between skepticism and you’re an asshole. Maybe that will change when these become as affordable as push bikes. Until then, in a world where cyclists are already outsiders (the way you have to shut out the world in order to concentrate on the big road picture as a cyclist, while being so physically present in other people’s personal space, always seems to upset non-cyclists) ebike riders are the outsiders’ outsider. Related to this point, 25km/h — the speed limit for ebikes in my jurisdiction — is too fast for mixed pedestrian/cyclist paths and too slow for roads. I would love to see that limit raised to 30km/h aka 20mph and have all urban routes limited to 20mph for all vehicles. Then I wouldn’t be constantly annoying road traffic for “not using the bike lane” when it’s clogged up with prams, people, and push bikes trundling uphill at walking pace. I’ve always been the kind of cyclist who is quite comfortable bloody mindedly asserting their right to use anything a car is allowed to use, occupying the whole lane as a car would, much to the irritation of car drivers who 110% of the time would rather I didn’t. When I’m driving my car I also find this kind of “I’m a car too!” cyclist both within their rights and also somewhat selfish. With ebikes it feels you have to use the “fast” lane of share-with-cars rather than share-with-pedestrians, so maybe the upside is that this will nudge transport policy towards genuine bicycle lanes as opposed to these mixed bike/people abominations. People are ultra lightweight vehicles unencumbered by metal frames and they are (and have the right to be) highly manoeuvrable. They can switch direction at any moment — they should be given dedicated lanes where they can be as chaotic as they want to be. Same for bikes, if slightly heavier. Same for cars, if quite a lot heavier.
- TomK32 5y agoNot sure where you from, but 25km/h here in Austria (and most of the EU) is not the speed limit, just the limit to which the motor will assist you. Anything beyond that and you're either on your own or you buy a S-Pedelec that needs a license plate, horn, helmet, and even license plate lights. Thanks for occupying the whole lane, that's how we should ride bicycles for our own safety.
- wiredfool 5y agoEliminating the front brake is a non starter from a safety POV for a powered bike used for transport. In a threshold braking/ emergency stop situation, all of your stopping power comes from it. Coaster brake bikes have a limit of about 20% of the braking performance simply from the geometry, before getting into heat dissipation and the loss of control from skidding. (LWB Recumbents and tandems are different, they’ll skid the front wheel before overturning)
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>Eliminating the front brake is a non starter from a safety POV for a powered bike used for transport. It's also illegal in some(most?) EU countries, at least in Germany and the UK, AFAIK.
- maxwell86 5y agoIt's illegal cause it will kill you. Independently of whether this is legal or illegal wherever you live, you should care about _why_ it is illegal in some places.
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoNo, it's illegal because you can also kill or hurt someone else, not just yourself.
- tromp 5y agoSince you mentioned LWB Recumbents, here's one that that has replaced a mechanical drivetrain by an electric one, and features regenerative breaking: https://www.recumbent.news/2021/05/23/the-ultimate-tilting-solar-powered-serial-hybrid-delta-trike/ https://www.recumbent.news/2021/05/23/the-ultimate-tilting-s...
- wiredfool 5y agoThat's quite a niche of a niche vehicle. Pretty cool, but at 70kg, and 500W, I wonder how it's legal in Europe without being registered as a motor vehicle.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI agree with most of this (apart from the weirdly American bit about not wanting to design cities well because that would not be "freedom"). I got hooked on cycle commuting years ago, and although they were basically impractical at that point I vowed that if a job was out of range of my own power I would definitely get an e-bike rather than use a car. I never needed to, but that decision has only become easier as evokes have improved. I looked at buying an e-bike recently, and for me and my needs, they still don't make sense. The extra cost, weight and complexity don't offer sufficient benefits over a cheap light, reliable non e-bike over the (short) distances I cycle. But I've been following the same developments as the author and think they're definitely going to change the world, and for the better. America will lag, but I'd look to places where 2 stroke engines are currently popular to see the future. E-mopeds and e-tuktuks are going to be built for non cyclists, and that's where the new transport ideas will arrive in mass manufactured form.
- TomK32 5y agoAs an ex-programmer, now bicycle mechanic working mostly on e-bikes I'd like to add a few things: People love ebikes not because of barely having to pedal, but because they can reach places with the bicycles that are out of their reach with a regular bike. It can be long weekend rides for some, but it can also be living/working on a hill. It's like owning a horse in olden times when all you had before were your own two legs. No idea what the author means with "lacking a Toyota Corolla equivalent". (E-)Bikes come in wide range of price and range, often from the same manufacturer. It's the components that dictate the final price, barely the frame, motor or battery where less choice exists than with the other components. Drive by wire will be exotic for a long time, I can see it taking over certain niches like recumbent bike where you have an extremely long drive train. Everybody else will run on cheap mechanical drive trains for a long time to come. Never ever will we see electronic or even wireless braking, it's just madness and illegal everywhere. We will though see ABS from Bosch soon, not sure if that's such a good idea or even necessary at the low speeds of a <20mph ebike. >> Most bikes are sold as toys or as overcomplicated hobbyist contraptions. This is probably the US-centric view, but with a certain threshold of cyclists the wide middle of bike sales is practical bikes for short rides in the city with a hub dynamo a basket or rack for you shopping. Certainly not toys or sporty bikes. The author shortly mentions removing batteries as optional, I must insist that removing and replacing a battery is a must-have to ensure the bike to be usable for a long time as many decent bikes do get ridden for 10, 20 or even 30 years.
- analog31 5y agoI don't think it's fully appreciated that automotive brakes are highly engineered and evolve very slowly. And a car can absorb the weight penalty of a failsafe braking system. Also, two wheel electric braking would require two electric actuators.
- bambax 5y ago> People love ebikes not because of barely having to pedal, but because they can reach places with the bicycles that are out of their reach with a regular bike. It can be long weekend rides for some, but it can also be living/working on a hill. Yes! That's what drove me towards the ebike. I live on top of a 10% slope and using a regular bike was simply impossible (for me). Having an ebike changed my life completely. I now never use my motorbike anymore (at all) and the car, extremely rarely.
- bambax 5y agoMany affirmations in that article are either false or ludicrous: that "e-bikes might not need braking" (!!), that gears are a problem or that tires wear out too fast; and especially this: > The current bicycle supply chain optimizes for producing poor-quality bikes in small lots (<500). Our bikes need mass-produced automotive-grade parts that will last a lifetime instead. That's absolutely not true. There are mass-produced bikes that are cheap and last a very long time. (Decathlon bikes for example.) I have built a couple of e-bikes by fitting a Bafang engine on a regular bike; it's a wonderful solution, so much so that I don't use anything else (I used to ride a motorbike, but it's now rotting in my garage). That said, the fact that e-bikes are currently too expensive is true. The Bafang solution still costs €750+, in addition to the cost of the bike itself (which may be zero if you already have a bike, or around 350-500 if not). But the main cost is the battery; if there is a breakthrough that drives battery costs down then suddenly e-bikes will become super affordable.
- upofadown 5y ago>The best feeling on a bike is cruising down a hill, barely pedaling, and taking in the surroundings. E-bikes are like that all the time. It only feels better because of the contrast to the upward side of the hill. Bicycles are primarily about reducing friction to basically nothing so that the rider can go ridiculously fast for little effort. The downside is that the rider really notices hills and wind. If you take away the agony you don't get to experience the ecstasy.
- Dave_Rosenthal 5y agoI love climbing bikes but if my ride starts with a fun descent it's still enjoyable even though I haven't paid for it yet :) But I appreciate your point about the high efficiency of bikes. On flats or downhill even a casual peddler hardly needs an e-bike to cruise around at a 'much faster than walking' speed (say, 12-15 mph). It's the uphills (or, as you say, headwinds) where most people feel like they are going too slowly ('I could be walking!') and really appreciate the boost of an e-bike.
- bagacrap 5y agoI would agree with this personally, and probably most fans of traditional bikes feel the same, but I don't think it's true for the other 95% that agony is a prerequisite for enjoyment.
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoThere is a nice steep hill near me which I would "enjoy" once every week or two. Since I got my e-bike I'll ride up it two or three times a week. This has been the general pattern since I got the e-bike, my mileage has trippled over my road bike. I ride further and faster than I otherwise would.
- mwattsun 5y agoI love my eBike but the biggest scam about them are the proprietary batteries. Imagine if there weren't AA, AA D, and C batteries but every electrical device you purchased had it's own battery shape and size at marked up prices that you had to purchase from that manufacturer. I would love to buy a second battery to extend my range but I refuse to pay $700 for a battery that only fits on my bike. The company that standardizes batteries will do well I think, because I can't be the alone one who wants this.
- glogla 5y agoSadly, the manufacturers (Bosch, mostly) managed to convince various governments that the proprietary batteries with DRM are there to prevent tampering and this safety. So I'm not sure if it's going away.
- FpUser 5y agoDepends what eBike you are buying. There are currently many with the batteries you could get from Amazon / Ali.
- mwattsun 5y agoYou're not joking. The third link on Google for "bosch battery drm" is Hacker News talking about this. I'm surprised I missed this. "These bikes are DRM'd to the hilt and any attempt at hacking them will cause the bike to brick itself which you can only reset at the dealership. You can do that three times and then it's permanent." user jacquesm 71 days ago https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29201673 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29201673
- throw64748 5y agoI mean Bosch left the battery business years ago. What the manufacturers care about is to limit risk under the constraint of government regulations. That said the E-Bike business is too small to come up with a bold move there but in electric driving there seems a lot of experimentation going.
- yardie 5y ago
- samatman 5y agoBig thumbs up for all the advocacy and city planning aspects of this prospectus. I'm going to go out on a limb and say the future of E-Bikes technology wise is a smooth progression from what we have now. Rifle is fine. Mid-drive motor built into an Omafiets is fine. Why? All the other parts are the same. There are factories all over the world making bike stuff. This is that, with a motor in place of the bottom bracket. They're already comfortable and bombproof, and designed to get you somewhere in the clothes you plan to wear when you arrive. Feel free to use any combination of market, mixed market, and democratic-socialist methods to make this affordable, I'm open-minded.
- kumarvvr 5y agoThe link to "Free Drive" is very intriguing. A bicycle chain is very efficient [0]. Most generators, even in low power applications are about 96% efficient. So are motors. Roundtrip efficiencies of batteries are in the order of 80 - 90 % [1] Combined efficiency of a motor-generator-battery system at best is 82%. Its a significant reduction in efficiency of the system. This configuration has the convenience of constant pedal resistance, at the cost of increased weight, complexity and cost. The future of e-Bikes, is, in my view, ditch the mechanical system, install fast recharging batteries (or have user swappable modules) and have a design that allows you to walk the bike in case the battery dies. Toshiba manufactures SCiB cells, that they claim, have very fast recharging times and long lives. Perfect for eBikes. [2] [0] - https://pages.jh.edu/news_info/news/home99/aug99/bike.html https://pages.jh.edu/news_info/news/home99/aug99/bike.html [1] - https://energymag.net/round-trip-efficiency/ https://energymag.net/round-trip-efficiency/ [2] - https://www.global.toshiba/ww/products-solutions/battery/scib.html https://www.global.toshiba/ww/products-solutions/battery/sci...
- 05 5y agoSCiB are half the energy density of lipos, a nonstarter
- elastic 5y agodisagree on the pedaling backwards for e-bikes. Backwards braking is a kiddie bike thing, most experienced riders are used to the brake set up on the handlebars and would much prefer that.
- geofft 5y agoI think the author is imagining a market segment containing a lot more new riders (who may, in fact, have learned biking as a kid and never touched a bike again) than existing riders. A lot of people legitimately need cars right now, given the options realistically available to them; e-bikes can carve away at that. (To be clear, I don't see why we actually need to pedal backwards. Assuming we're otherwise comfortable with a bike-by-wire system as the author advocates, a a brake-by-wire lever should be super cheap and has none of the maintenance complexity of physical brakes.)
- pawptart 5y agoNot as common on road bikes but backpedaling is used sometimes to set up cornering position/reduce pedal strikes on mountain bikes. E-bikes are still road bikes, and the last thing you would want is the fundamental behavior of an e-bike to be drastically different from a normal road bike. Unexpected braking is just as dangerous as going fast. Honestly, from this point alone it makes me think the author isn't very experienced with the mechanics of higher end road bicycles. This behavior is normal and expected for kids and big box store bikes, but on a road bike at speed, this would not be considered normal operation.
- analog31 5y agoI'm a dedicated cyclist in the upper Midwest. Many of my friends have gotten e-bikes. Some of them are already on their second e-bike, as the technology has improved quite rapidly towards more of a "light hybrid motorcycle" design. So far as the cost is concerned, you can get an affordable e-bike by shopping for a used one. Repairiable might be a different story. The main question I get is: "When are you going to get an e-bike?" I don't have a good justification for riding a human powered bike, other than just the fact that it's what I enjoy. I happen to live within cycling distance of most things that I need. I also play an alcohol powered musical instrument that was replaced by an electric version 70 years ago. Don't ask me why. Of course since it takes me longer to get places, I have more time to think. About how e-bike technology could be improved. Making it ride "just like a bike" imposes a lot of subtle requirements on the controls -- exactly why my friends have stopped riding their early generation e-bikes. But what if that's not a requirement. The simplest thing I could think of is a motorized front wheel with a switch that applies a fixed amount of torque. You push the button when you want help. That would take care of any reason why I might want an e-bike, for instance when I get old. In the future, conventional bikes might be seen as the exception to the rule, but I don't see them going away completely. For instance I don't expect the thousands of bikes parked around the nearby university campus being replaced by electrics in any practical way. I don't expect the homeless to ride e-bikes. Also, for people who are blessed with short distances and good legs, a conventional bike is still more convenient to manage.
- ravenstine 5y ago> I also play an alcohol powered musical instrument that was replaced by an electric version 70 years ago. Don't ask me why. An alcohol powered musical instrument? This I've gotta see!
- analog31 5y agoIt's an old musician joke -- it means a human powered instrument. ;-)
- allo37 5y agoYeah, I'm with you - I just got an e-bike for riding in the winter and it comes with a lot of constraints you don't have to think about with a regular bike: - It's way more expensive so I'm worried about theft. - You can't leave it out in the harsh weather, or shouldn't. - It's much heavier (70lbs, though it is a beefcake of an e-bike). So I can't, say, just bring it up the stairs to an appartment. - It has a $600 battery and a bunch of fancy electronics which are nice, but probably will require more of an investment to maintain/replace. I think there will always be a place for conventional, unpowered bikes.
- simonebrunozzi 5y ago> Hybrid-electric cars are an engineering abomination. No they're not. You have to take any type of innovation in context. Hybrid-electric is actually better for the environment, if implemented correctly. Why? Because the average daily commute is between 25 and 40 miles (40 to 60 kilometers), depending on where you live; which means a good hybrid-electric could use just electric for most of its total mileage, and occasionally an ICE for longer trips (weekends). You would need much less battery capacity to enable a bigger eco-friendly fleet of cars.
- Matthias247 5y agoI think e-bikes did the important job of making bike rides more enjoyable for the masses. And the next important changes are maybe not on the bikes themselves but infrastructure. Would be great to have more safe bike routes which are fully separated from traffic. And it would be great to have more opportunities to safely store and park those expensive bikes. It’s annoying if something is definitely within biking distance but be one can’t leave a bike on the area without having to worry it might be gone shortly after.