3 ms·
Densification in big cities is a significant source of value. I'm not aware of any evidence that it's occurring at the expense of formerly thriving small towns
by zozbot234 5y ago
Densification in big cities is a significant source of value. I'm not aware of any evidence that it's occurring at the expense of formerly thriving small towns. It's mostly the "boring" suburbs and exurbs that are losing value, but those developments have always lacked jobs and amenities. It's inherent to the model, you can't fix them without substantially changing their very nature.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI'm not aware of any evidence that it's occurring at the expense of formerly thriving small towns. Well I am. And I think such trends do a great deal of harm to the American social fabric.
- stale2002 5y agoAlright, well I don't care about nebulous concepts like "social fabric" and neither do a lot of other people. Way more people would move to big cities if it was affordable, and these people's wishes should be supported. Almost by definition, this is true, as if everyone did not want to move to the city, then prices would be lower. This romanticism for making everyone live in small towns is not something that most people support, given that way more people would leave small towns if they could.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoI don't care about nebulous concepts like "social fabric" and neither do a lot of other people. This is likely true. And yet people bitch plenty about how homeless folks are interfering with their enjoyment of the good life in the downtown areas of big cities. In practical terms you get to pick one. You can care about nebulous concepts like the social fabric and have less feces, discarded needles and the like or you can not care and see people moving out of cities like San Francisco because they are going to hell as all the poor people ruin it for the upper classes who still don't care about those people but hate stepping over the mess.
- renewiltord 5y agoLA is sprawl and has loads of homeless too. So that’s not it.
- stale2002 5y ago> about how homeless folks are interfering with their enjoyment > In practical terms you get to pick one. You can care about nebulous concepts like the social fabric Actually there was the other solution. The other solution compared to yours of "make people live in the small towns.", is instead "Make lots of tall skyscapers, so that big cities are affordable". If we lower the costs of big cities (By making lots and lots of supply, including tall skyscapers), then prices are lower for those who need them, and more people can live here, and take advantage of the big cities, and it can also benefit the poor by actually making it possible for them to live here, instead of on the streets. We don't have to force out the poor from the big cities. Instead we can make the big cities affordable to live in, with lots and lots of tall skyscrapers. > see people moving out of cities like San Francisco Actually, you are the one who is trying to get people to move out of the big cities. I want there to be more supply for everyone, in these big cities, with more skyscapers.
- DoreenMichele 5y agoSkyscrapers are inherently expensive to build, so building more skyscrapers isn't likely to make urban cores affordable for the types of folks who wind up homeless. I know a lot about homelessness. I spent nearly six years homeless and before that had a college class through SFSU called Homelessness and Public Policy and I still run several blogs on the topic, though I update them less than I used to as my focus has shifted to trying to solve the housing shortage that is a root cause of homelessness in the US.
- stale2002 5y ago> so building more skyscrapers isn't likely to make urban cores affordable for the types of folks who wind up homeless. Yes it will. Think of a skyscaper like a Yuppie containment center. For every high end apartment that exists, a Yuppie is no longer filling up an apartment in the mission, that very well could be afforable if they weren't currently full of yuppies. There are lots of yuppies who would love to live in those skyscapers, and if we build more of them, then those people will no longer be taking away afforable housing from other people who need it. Also, historically, this is how housing has worked. Previously high end apartments, become low end, over time, as the rich move out of those places, into other, newer apartments. > Skyscrapers are inherently expensive to build Doesn't matter. Because the goal is to get wealthy individuals, out of the existing apartments. The poor aren't forced to live in those skyscapers, but if the skyscapers exist, then there is less competition for the lower end of the market.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kunai 5y agoDensification doesn't require skyscrapers. Istanbul and Paris are denser than any American city and they're mostly filled with midrises packed closely together with few vacant lots in between. Dubai should not be our model for a sustainable city.
- JeanMeche 5y agoManhattan is denser than Paris.