11 ms·
Device wraps around hot surfaces, turns wasted heat to electricity
- basicplus2 5y agotechnically Waste heat from pipes is from insufficiently insulated pipes.. The trade of is between the cost of more efficient insulation and making use of leaking heat due to inadequate insulation.
- chipsa 5y agoWell... maybe. If your pipe is carrying waste heat to a radiator of some sort (cooling tower or whatever), insulation doesn't matter, because the heat is going to escape to the environment anyway.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoI like the general idea, but it strikes me as a little poignant that so many of these sources of waste heat could just be wrapped with insulation instead? Certainly pipes and ducts - though in cases where the heat is truly waste (and is being intentionally dumped into a cooler environment, like from refrigeration or heat pumps) it does seem like converting it to electricity is a win, at least.
- hazza_n_dazza 5y agoSome sources, you might want to move the heat away (ie, CPU), maybe these loads of pipes they have are the same. But yes, point taken, insulation first. Ockhams Razor: don't multiply entities beyond necessity.
- jack_riminton 5y agoI suppose though in the case of the CPU the metric you want to maximise is the heat dispersal not electricity produced. Could work well on things like exhaust pipes
- rocqua 5y agoIf it works, I think the waste heat from server farms should be the first target.
- jack_riminton 5y agoYes that'd be good. The figure I'd like to know (maybe I missed it) is how much it reduces the heat by
- rocqua 5y agoIt seems like the devices would insulate the server-farm. That might not be worth it, because you'd need extra cooling to offset the higher insulation.
- rincewind 5y agoBut if you want to move the heat away from a CPU, wouldn't you want to pump more electricity into the Peliter element to move heat away faster?
- dtx1 5y agoOn a High-End Desktop Chip? YES! Intel made such a cooler recently[1]. But on mobile/low power devices it might be worthwhile to have them run a little warmer (within spec) but take the heat energy back via a peltier element. Would be interesting to see such an element directly on die feeding back into the chip directly, sort of an electric rebreather for a chip. [1] https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/support/articles/000057816/processors/processor-utilities-and-programs.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/support/articles/000...
- crackercrews 5y agoOccam's Razor: no need for the K or H. Just double the C.
- kevinstubbs 5y agoOckham is a totally acceptable spelling which requires all three: C, K and H... See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam's_razor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Occam's_razor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_of_Ockham https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_of_Ockham
- idontwantthis 5y agoThis would be worse for efficiency than uninsulated pipes. It would be wrapping them in a conductor to more efficiently take away the heat that is supposed to stay inside.
- toss1 5y agoOf course in the limited cases where the application requires the heat to be transferred to the destination, you wouldn't use this method. Those pipes are likely heavily insulated. But most cases, moving hot waste, the loss of heat is a side effect (the waste material just happens to be hot), and may in fact be an undesirable side-effect that squanders energy. Now, they don't need to squander that energy. Easy example is a chimney - they're only trying to get rid of the exhaust gasses we don't want inside, and DGAF if it is cold or hot. In fact, heat exchangers are often installed to attempt to capture some of the lost heat and minimize losses. Same for waste liquids going for treatment, or actual product exiting a hot process and going into a cold/ambient temp process -- they've got to dump the heat, far better to grab some energy on the way out.
- darkarmani 5y ago> Easy example is a chimney - they're only trying to get rid of the exhaust gasses we don't want inside, and DGAF if it is cold or hot. In fact, heat exchangers are often installed to attempt to capture some of the lost heat and minimize losses. Good example, except that you need a certain amount of heat to carry away the water (steam). I believe the rule of thumb for old-style furnaces is 80% efficiency with the 20% carrying away the water vapor.
- toss1 5y agoYup, and there's the same issue with using these on internal combustion automobile or truck exhausts - the density change of increased cooling could might change the back pressure/suction at the exhaust port and reduce the engine efficiency. It would surely be a consideration on highly tuned race motors, but I have no idea if the magnitude of the effect would be even noticeable on street cars & trucks. It is certainly fairly small, as you can drive through a puddle that soaks the exhaust and billows out clouds of steam, sucking out far more heat vs this thermoelectric system, and the engine doesn't even notice. So, sure if you did it naively, without checking & compensating for secondary effects, you might have a net problem. But I'd be highly confidant that a bit of R&D and engineering design changes would easily take care of it.
- adrianN 5y agoThere are many industrial processes that produce large amounts of waste heat. Capturing some of that can make sense. But I guess unless you're retrofitting existing installations you get better efficiency with different solutions than wrapping stuff around a pipe.
- PinguTS 5y agoBut isn't that "waste" heat already used to heat the office building and other buildings nearby. So there is a use case already. Of course during the year there are times, when heating is not needed. Then it would make sense to use the heat otherwise.
- adrianN 5y agoI think most industrial waste heat is indeed wasted. You don't tend to build for example chemical factories close to where you would have offices or homes.
- alex_duf 5y agoAircon would be a great application for that, assuming this applies at all.
- frederikvs 5y agoNot really : Peltier-based devices like this add (some) resistance to the heat flow. This added resistance means the air conditioner (or any heat pump, e.g. a fridge) gets less efficient. I think the energy captured by the device will always be lower than the extra energy needed for the heat pump. A device like this is not useful in a system where you are actively pumping heat around.
- dskloet 5y agoAircon needs to get rid of its heat to work well. Trying to capture the energy from the temperature difference makes it cool less well.
- kamray23 5y agoAn air conditioner is a heat pump. It uses energy to pump heat from one end to another. One of these thermoelectric generator devices is basically the reverse, it generates energy when heat is pumped through it. There is perhaps an analogy here to a water pump, pumping water from one place to another, and a water wheel, generating energy when water is pumped through it. Take an ordinary house. The default, low-energy state is the one it tends to if we don't mess with it. The inside and outside of the house come to about the same temperature as energy leaks in through the insulation and holes in it, though slowly. Now we put in a heat pump. This changes the system. With a little energy input, we capture the energy in the inside of the house, and we move it to the outside. The energy state of the system changes, it begins to gain energy as we put some in to create the heat differential. Then we attempt to capture this heat differential. We place a heat engine, which one of these devices is, across our temperature differential. Assuming total efficiency for both processes, which we do not in reality have, our heat engine undoes the heat differential and produces for us the exact amount of energy we ourselves put in to create that heat differential. The inside and outside now come to some resting state, possibly with a constant heat differential upheld by the pump and actively sabotaged by the engine. Theoretically, we get net 0 energy and dysfunctional air conditioning, but in practice, we get a net loss of energy to inefficiencies. The same applies to the water analogy. Imagine two tanks of water connected by a porous wall. The state it reaches naturally is that both tanks are at the same level through water seepage, though it is slow. If we place in a pump, we get a pressure differential across the tanks: one tank becomes higher and another lower. Then we place a wheel across the differential to take advantage of that pressure. Energy is generated, and at the same time the height difference is lost. Again net 0, though in reality you will experience a lot of inefficiencies. If the point is to do air conditioning, you cannot recapture energy from the heat. Just running the air conditioner at a lower power achieves the same result more efficiently. Similarly with the water pump, it will in reality be more efficient to just not pump as much water up, and you will reach the same result.
- rocqua 5y agoIn the cases where you are dumping heat, I believe these devices can have the opposite problem of effectively insulating the heat source. I think it might technically be possible to have a very conductive heat-engine. But it seems to me like most options are still less conductive than leaving them out.
- ulrikrasmussen 5y agoWastewater comes to mind. A lot of it is heated, either directly (from e.g. showers, cooking) or indirectly because it was stored in toilets. Edit: But then again, capturing and re-using the heat energy directly and saving the energy cost for heating via e.g. an electric heater would probably be even more efficient than extracting some of the heat as electricity.
- netcan 5y agoPractical applications are circumstantial. Do you have a way of utilising or storing electricity/heat? If so, either are more efficient than not doing so. For example, if it's cold where you live and the heating is usually running... just expelling the heat from your fridge into the house is efficient. If you are cooling, it's not. Electricity would be better... or at least piping the heat out.
- opwieurposiu 5y agoThis device exists, you replace a vertical section of your sewer pipe with a copper heat exchanger pipe. The HX heats up your incoming cold water when you take a shower. The HX must be vertical because in a vertical sewer pipe, surface tension makes the water spread out and wet the entire inner surface of the pipe for good heat transfer. I looked into the economics at one point. Would be great for a laundromat or hotel, not so much for the average single family home.
- ip26 5y agoThe economics mostly depend on the temperature of the water coming into your house and the ease of install in your house. They are supposedly code on new construction in large parts of Canada now. The economics were also better when copper prices were lower.
- sparselogic 5y agoEven more effective: drain water heat recovery, preheating the incoming water with the outgoing waste heat. Quick overview from one manufacturer here: https://renewability.com https://renewability.com
- goodpoint 5y agoThat's just a heat exchanger. I wonder if it's worth it tho. Perhaps only if you fill a large tub or a pool every day.
- bobchadwick 5y agoThese devices actually require a similar amount of water to be moving through the drain pipe/heat exchanger and the cold water line that's refilling the water heater. So they're really only effective during showers.
- thinkcontext 5y agoDoE says they breakeven is 2.5 - 7 years. That's in the US, imagine how much of a slam dunk it is in countries with carbon prices and higher energy prices. https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/drain-water-heat-recovery https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/drain-water-heat-recovery
- hazza_n_dazza 5y agoOh, a flexible, chained peltier. "The 72-couple device exhibited the highest reported output power and device power density from a single thermoelectric generator, the scientists said" https://www.psu.edu/news/research/story/form-fit-device-wraps-around-hot-surfaces-turns-wasted-heat-electricity/ https://www.psu.edu/news/research/story/form-fit-device-wrap...
- superjan 5y agoMy father in-law once asked me if one could charge a phone using body heat. I did some calculations but the thing is that if the heat difference is small, the conversion efficiency goes down too. As others suggest, insinuating the source is much smarter if you want to save energy losses, and with much simpler (cheaper) technology.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoInsulation is great if your goal is to keep the heat from escaping. With this solution, the goal is usually the exact opposite. For example, you don't wrap your laptop in a blanket to keep it nice and cozy. Likewise you don't wrap insulation around the motor block in an ICE vehicle. And if you pump coolant around through pipes, the whole point is to radiate out the heat so that it cools down. That heat is actually a problem that you are trying to get rid off. The example of a heating pipe in the article is a bit unfortunate of course. Isolating those would be a good idea. Unless they are interior pipes in which case the heating system heating the house would not be that big of a deal.
- jacquesm 5y ago> Likewise you don't wrap insulation around the motor block in an ICE vehicle. Well... for every rule there is an exception I guess, there was a Mercedes demonstration vehicle that used a modified diesel engine without a coolant loop and insulated head to keep the heat in the engine. It never made it to production due to cost but the thing was ridiculously efficient.
- avereveard 5y agoyou still need to radiate the heat you produce; the device cold side heats up during operation, up to the point where the conversio stop, so you're going to have to cool it. besides, water in a ice engine need to be cooled down fast, at the rate these device extract temperature from the sources, you're going to have to need a huge surface area being extracted, or two set of radiators - one to control the circuit temperature, the other to cool the generators. these device application are a lot narrower than one might expect.
- tiku 5y agoA lot of "wasted" heat is not wasted. For example, if you extract the energy on the return channel, my gas boiler has to work harder to re-heat..
- varjag 5y agoThe energy that is radiated/convected away from your return channel never makes it back to your boiler.
- OJFord 5y agoBut if take it away, cooling the pipe, more will make it out of the water and into the pipe (and so not back to the boiler). That's no different to turning up your radiator.
- benlumen 5y agoIt still should radiate into the house, helping to bring the temperature up to the thermostat point. If you're capturing any of that heat and converting it for any reason, your boiler's simply going to have to work harder to do its job. It's the first law of thermodynamics, isn't it? I'm not a physicist.
- cma 5y agoBut if you have a heatpump instead of boiler it maybe doesn't have to work as much harder.
- Firadeoclus 5y agoIt depends on what the converted energy is used for. If you use it to power a device in the house then it's quite likely most of that energy will end up as heat in the house again.
- lolc 5y agoIt can make sense to combine stoves used for heating with peltier elements. When the heat is used at lower temperature than the combustion, you can get electricity on the exchange. So you run your boiler at 105% normal capacity and extract 5% electricity. This generates electricity at the price of gas. Of course, your boiler must have the extra capacity, and the additional components are an investment.
- Zenst 5y agoAny effeciency numbers? Mindful how ineffeceint peltiers are and this reads like it is nothing new beyond adding liquid metal heat-pipes and an array of lots of them so you can wrap around a non-flat surface more easily. Also - not aware of many hot pipes of waste heat. beyond some power stations and then they already use that heat for things like heating green houses and other initiatives. Heck even my fridge and freezer's waste heat (probably best source in a home) is only waste in the summer, otherwise is passively warms my home. Then you have heat exchanges. So really would love to see the numbers and the waste heat they are on about and compared to existing less technical solutions - like using it to heat a greenhouse.
- jacquesm 5y agoSteel plants, aluminum plants, oil refineries, glass manufacture. All of these create vast amounts of waste heat.
- IshKebab 5y ago> Any effeciency numbers? Efficiency is pretty irrelevant because the total amount of power available is tiny. The only use cases for this are things like remote pipe monitoring sensors. Nobody is going to use this to generate meaningful amounts of power.
- ya_throw 5y agoHow much electricity does this contraption need to generate, before it's accounted for its own embodied energy (that is, the power needed to manufacture it)? Probably more than anyone would ever actually use one.
- spicybright 5y agoIt reminds me of solar panels on cars. It sounds great if you don't think too hard about it, but a highschool physics course can easily prove how completely useless it would be in practice. Ideas like these end up being nothing but virtue signaling, whether people know it or not.
- ya_throw 5y agoPractically all of our "green" solutions rely on the fact that their energy-intensive manufacturing is done somewhere with lots of cheap (and polluting) energy sources. Show me a wind-powered lithium battery factory and I'll change my mind.
- irthomasthomas 5y agoI had this exact idea of using peltiers to reclaim energy from waste pipes. Think about big industrial systems. I knew from reading the specs that existing peltiers wouldn't cut it. So I decided to let it go until progress in material science (maybe graphene) made it more efficient. There is a theoretical design that is radically more efficient. It uses an S shape design, but it's not possible at the moment. This looks to be using ordinary peltier designs but sliced up. This could be used like a stove-top heat pump that uses a peltier, and the heat from a stove to power a fan that helps circulated the warm air more efficiently. Of course this would add some insulation around the pipe too, so it may not be the free lunch it seems.
- anonymouse008 5y agoI have a prototype of an S Shaped design… supposedly there’s a layered design better than that. My friend is now at the DoE - do you have people with experience that could talk?
- irthomasthomas 5y agoThat sounds great! Can you share anything about the materials and/or performance? I am only an armchair inventor. I once got as far as registering a company, and filing a business plan, but I noped out of it. I just like to follow the science and noodle with the equations, hoping for something interesting. The main problem for this application, I think, is maintaining a temperature gradient. So you add a heat sink to the cold side, but that only gets you so far. And then you have the extra cost and CO2 burden of manufacturing a heat sink (and aluminium is particularly dirty). My plan was to look for places with a sustained temperature gradient. So, I sandwiched a peltier between the hot and cold pipes in my old house, to power some LEDs. As long as the house was occupied, there was always cold running water on one side, and hot tap water on the other. So, if I was building, say, a power station, where cold water is being pumped in. I would arange the cold pipes close to the hot in one spot, insulate the outer surfaces, and stick a peltier generator in between. You can also use heat pipes (like on CPU fans) with coolant, to wrap the source hot/cold pipes, without needing a flexible peltier.
- kulor 5y agoSeems like a good application would be on GPUs & CPUs, especially in data centers
- xxs 5y agoabsolutely not; that would make them unable to dissipate heat. Trying to use a peltier element to them to recover energy is just futile, it'd be better to have an peltier that cools it off by wasting energy instead.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoOften these kinds of things collide with the laws of thermodynamics and end up decreasing the energy the system provides to its endpoint by the same amount that is extracted. Not always, just often. A classical example would be putting some thing to collect the energy generated by turning a rotating door to power lights in a lobby, it is probable that this will end up causing the people using the rotating door to expend the exact amount of extra energy that is captured by the system (probably because the easiest way to collect the energy is to put some extra resistance on turning the door) So why do it? Well in the case of the rotating door it is easy to see why, because by having everyone give just a little extra of their personal energy (like two extra spoonfuls of cereal in the morning, and a sip of orange juice) the company manages to externalize the cost of lighting their fancy lobby and nobody even notices that the energy was taken from someone else to do it. Put a notice about how the lobby is powered by green energy, that's really the icing on the cake.
- ekanes 5y agoIt’s a good example actually - people would like it and we could all use a little more physical challenge in our environment!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bigbillheck 5y ago> we could all use a little more physical challenge in our environment! The disabled and frail do not.
- dguest 5y agoComplete aside: Has anyone actually implemented this classical example? I've heard it mentioned a few times but always assumed the people floating it hadn't thought about orders of magnitude enough: a "sip" of orange juice is indeed a lot of energy, about 80 kJ [1], and if you could extract that much energy from one person every 10 seconds you'd get 8 kW, which could power a decent sized lobby if the lighting is efficient. But to extract 80 kJ over 1 m... you have to push with 80 kN, or 17 thousand pounds (or 1.4 TRex bites worth of force [2]). More realistically, if we have everyone push with an annoying but manageable 50 N (about 10 pounds), we'd get 5 W, which might power a single (dim) LED bulb. As I said, this is a bit off topic for the original post, but the common theme is that people tend to confuse "extracting some energy" with "extracting a useful amount of energy in a cost effective way" (they also tend to overestimate mechanical energy). This on top of the thermodynamic constraints you mention to start with. [1]: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=energy+in+40+grams+of+orange+juice https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=energy+in+40+grams+of+... [2]: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=80+kN https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=80+kN
- nisegami 5y agoThough not directly related, this does remind me of an idea I once had. I live in the Caribbean. My house effectively has a few heat pumps running most of the time (split air conditioning units) as well as a dryer and a water heater. Why can't the heat moved by those units be used to heat water or to dry clothes? By using the heat directly, there wouldn't be a need to use a Peltier unit or deal with the associated losses.
- andreareina 5y agoA combination of interface (how do you get the water heater to use the excess heat?), quality (a/c waste heat isn't that hot), and matching generation with demand. There are power plants that use excess heat for heating. The term is cogeneration or combined heat and power.
- nattaylor 5y agoRheem manufactures a heat pump HW heater that could use the exhaust of the AC heat pumps and dry with a fan in the AC. Maybe a set up like that?
- serpix 5y agoIn the Caribbean you get unlimited free energy from the sun, considering that solar panels are very cheap you could just rig the system to dump all excess power to the water heater, but considering you already get unlimited solar power you could just place the water tank in the sun to heat water. If that is not enough a home made aluminum can heat pipe plus water pump or just a long black hose with a water pump would nearly boil your water during the day.
- nisegami 5y agoUsing solar panels to generate electricity is nominally illegal here actually. I know other Caribbean islands use solar water heating pretty extensively, but it's never been a thing here. I suspect it's a matter of lack of Government and business incentives as we've always been a fossil fuel based economy with relatively affordable electricity.
- IshKebab 5y ago> That version exhibited a total power output of 56.6 watts when placed on the hot surface, the scientists said. > “Think about an industrial power plant with pipes hundreds of feet long,” Priya said. “If you can wrap these devices around an area that large, you could generate kilowatts of energy from wasted heat that’s normally just being thrown away. You could convert discarded heat into something useful.” Whole kilowatts! And it would only cost a few hundred thousand pounds in expensive peltier materials!
- c_o_n_v_e_x 5y agoOne use case not being discussed here is that by using these types of devices, you can power a device/sensor out in the field without a really expensive installation. You can run these off of a motor housing, compressor discharge, steam line, etc. It is about being able to provide power where it is very costly to bring. To install a sensor/instrument in a plant,refinery,etc., you have to set up scaffolding and/or use a cherry picker, run cable (usually armored) through cable trays, bend and install conduit, have all of the right junction boxes, glands, etc. You've already spent 10's of thousands just to get power out to your device. Solar is not really an option in some places. Either you've got no sunlight because you're in a pipe rack and you've got to route a cable from a PV panel (go back to installation cost) or you're in a hazardous rated area of the plant where you have explosive atmospheres and need special Ex rated equipment.
- Normal_gaussian 5y agoThis of course brings in its own failure modes which can often go undetected - sensor stopped reporting because the motor broke / was replaced with a cooler model / was used less by a production change / doesn't get as hot in winter / not enough diff in summer. Not reasons to not use it, but edge cases = bugs.
- alexpotato 5y agoWouldn't a heartbeat function help identify most of the above?
- Normal_gaussian 5y agoYes, I was a bit hasty with undetected. The situation is complex. I have a site which has sensors that go off for various reasons. I add heartbeats to detect this. Now I have a site with sensors that may go off for a number of reasons, and an alert panel telling me they are off all the time. As the alerts aren't actionable (ie, I expect sensor Y to go off every day in the winter around midnight and come back again when it warms up) I add a filter to ignore the alert from it around midnight. I now have to make sure I handle all the other edge cases - how long is it safe to have this sensor off? 50% of the sensors off? Every third sensor off? What if there is a really cold/hot snap lasting through the day or several days? All of these questions are edge cases, and they require complexity to solve them. Complexity means bugs. The most common bug by far is that situation X was detected by the sensor, but didn't make its way to us for edge cases.
- Sosh101 5y agoWould an approach like this generate a useful amount of electricity if used in a power plant setting? I.e. From the steam/condensed-but-still-hot water after it leaves the turbine?
- writeslowly 5y agoGas turbines in power plants can get very complicated when it comes to recovering waste heat. Some of them can hit something over 60% efficiency (vs cars where I think a typical ICE gets somewhere over 20%?). I think it’s mainly comes down to being worth the additinoal cost and complexity in a large power plant but not so much in an office building or road vehicle. Wikipedia has a list of some of the devices in use https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waste_heat_recovery_unit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waste_heat_recovery_unit
- mlindner 5y agoThermodynamics requires temperature gradients, unless the object you're taking energy from is much hotter than it's surroundings then any energy extracted will be minimal and could be offset by the extra energy needed to run the collecting device.
- thehappypm 5y agoThis is true and so the solution isn’t really like some magic free power system, it’s more a tool we can use a niche applications where it might be more straightforward to just wrap something around a hot pipe and get a few watts of power than to run electrical wiring.
- nkingsy 5y agoWhat’s the theoretical limit of heat -> electricity + hydrolysis? It seems if we could capture electricity from a space shuttle reentry and make hydrogen/methane during descent, this would enable less energy intensive launches. I’d imagine this would be done if it were possible, but the extreme burst of energy likely isn’t conducive to being absorbed by hydrolysis.
- mrfusion 5y agoThey neglect to mention the one number that matters. The thermal efficiency versus existing heat recovery tech in use.
- elif 5y agoit is hilarious to me that this is coming out in the same year that Formula 1, who has tried to pioneer this technology for the last decade, has given up on its potential and removed it from the regulations.
- chipsa 5y agoThe MGU-H that is being removed from F1 is based on entirely different technology, and has a much higher grade of waste heat to work with (being that it works with ICE exhaust gases. It's being removed mostly because of cost, though I would be unsurprised to find that it returns in a few years, if F1 stays ICE powered, simply because it is a really good thing for a hybrid car (minimized turbo lag, and it can recover extra electrical power).
- elif 5y agoF1 is required to stay ICE. Formula E has exclusivity into 2030's I believe.
- stormcode 5y agoReminds me a bit of the PowerPot. I got one on Kickstarter years back. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/david-toledo/the-powerpot https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/david-toledo/the-powerp... It didn't work very well, to be honest, but it's a really cool concept.