8 ms·
Wisconsin Judge Prevents Nurses from Going to New Employer
- oneoff786 5y agoAfter Slavery was outlawed in the US, southern states were quick to pass laws forbidding black people from changing employers until the growing season was over as a way to keep wages low and enact slavery lite. This is an important right to protect.
- rdtwo 5y ago
- stjohnswarts 5y agoSlavery is over but racism is not. Just look at the new Texas, Georgia, etc voting laws and redistricting which are all meant to discourage people of color from voting. Jim Crow 2.0
- dontcare007 5y agoYeah, how dare those states make voting more secure. My gosh, they even offer better voting than Delaware... Seriously, read the laws, you are just spouting misinformation.
- oneoff786 5y agoRead the studies on the impact those laws have
- backtoyoujim 5y agoSlavery is not over. The US has, like everything else, farmed it out to other nations.
- vsskanth 5y agoThe assymetry of benefits granted by this injunction between the employer and employee is shocking here. The nurses are not allowed to work for the new employer but the current employer isn't required match compensation until the case is resolved. This is on top of Wisconsin being an at-will state and there being no formal employment contract in this case. I'm not even sure how the judge is legally able to do this considering the material harm to employees. There seems to be a lot of discussion on this at r/nursing
- bko 5y ago> The nurses are not allowed to work for the new employer but the current employer isn't required match compensation until the case is resolved. Who cares about matching compensation? This is about the right to end employment and seek employment elsewhere. Right to provide a living for yourself and your family is a fundamental human right. It's appalling that this wasn't thrown out of court immediately. I'm not a fan of non-compete clauses, but at least there is a voluntary contractual component. In a broader sense, it's terrifying that this has even gotten so far and I fear it'll only get worse with more and more liberties being stripped away for [current emergency].
- sjansen 5y agoThey’re not required to stay at the old employer, they’re just not allowed to start at the new employer. Cold comfort for anyone with bills to pay, but they aren’t being targeted by the decision, just the new employer. They’re free to go find a third employer. (Which is probably how the judge sleeps at night after putting so many people in an impossible situation.)
- egberts1 5y ago
- toomuchtodo 5y agoWill the judge file injunctions against the next healthcare system that offers roles to ThedaCare ex employees? Where does it end? This judicial action warrants federal intervention. Otherwise we arguably don't have at will, somewhat free market employment, but instead crony capitalism feudalism ("you will work for who we allow you to work for"). Tangentially, ThedaCare's Level II Trauma accreditation (which hangs in the balance due to the departure of these workers [1]) should be re-evaluated. [1] https://www.wispolitics.com/2022/thedacare-seeks-to-protect-access-to-local-trauma-and-stroke-care/ https://www.wispolitics.com/2022/thedacare-seeks-to-protect-... Additional context: > Timothy Breister, an Appleton resident and one of the seven employees involved in the systems' dispute, submitted a letter to McGinnis Friday before the hearing describing his experience. > One of his colleagues received an offer from Ascension that was attractive "not just in pay but also a better work/life balance," which caused others on his team to apply, Breister wrote. > After approaching ThedaCare with the chance to match the offers they'd been given, Breister wrote that they were told "the long term expense to ThedaCare was not worth the short term cost," and no counter-offer would be made. https://news.yahoo.com/know-battle-over-fox-valley-235851212.html https://news.yahoo.com/know-battle-over-fox-valley-235851212...
- seibelj 5y agoBefore everyone loses their minds that somehow this is the free market run amok, keep in mind that healthcare is one of the most regulated and government-involved industries not only in the USA but on earth. For example, you can't even construct a new healthcare facility in most states unless a group of bureaucrats agrees there is a "need" for one https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/certificate-of-need.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/certificate-of-need.asp Here is an entrepreneurial doctor trying to add MRI machines to his practice, stymied by the glorious government of North Carolina https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/7/31/17629526/mri-cost-certificate-of-need-north-carolina-lawsuit https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2018/7/31/17629526/m...
- ethbr0 5y agoTo be fair, "I've just been in a car accident and require immediate stabilization followed by airlift to a Level I trauma center" is a process most of us don't think about. There's nothing that says a Level I trauma center needs to exist... except planning (largely by states) to try and ensure it does. And a lot of ensuring availability means balancing profitability against access to the market. A VC firm financing a facility across the street, until it loses interest and both implode financially, is of no good to anyone.
- seibelj 5y agoMy point is that before people go crazy about a judge not letting people quit, a judge also won’t let you work in this industry simply because you want to. It’s a highly regulated, government-interfered business so nurses being disallowed from jumping to another hospital is not surprising in the context of all the ways the market is managed.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoRequiring person A to have qualifications to sell something to person B is not comparable to stopping person A from selling something B.
- bediger4000 5y agoThis is grotesquely anti-free market. Labor has to be able to pick and choose employers freely for a free market to work. This Judge is actively anti-capitalist. I can only conclude that the Judge is a closet socialist, or worse, a communist.
- diob 5y agoThis is the actually the result of a free market. In the end, everything gets captured by whoever has the most capital / power.
- Natsu 5y agoI think GP is talking about the ruling, not about people leaving for another employer.
- diob 5y agoI know, what I said applies to courts / rulings as well. Unfortunately capitalism has been allowed to run amok so much that our entire society here is capitalist controlled. Hence why the judge has ruled so that the capitalists can have their cake (they know the peasants can't not work, as they own no capital). Every time something goes wrong in capitalism, folks like to claim socialism or communism. This is literally capitalism.
- Natsu 5y agoI don't think capitalists or communists like this one. This is very much a place that would (and should) go out of business but for this government intervention. But I quoted the ruling well above, it doesn't say that they can't work for the new employer, just that the new guy has to either make one person available so the other can continue to operate or it can choose to cease hiring more staff. So they can be employed by the new employer for more money, they just have to help this place limp along until it can find people to work there (which... I can't imagine anyone wanting to after this). Presumably this isn't so much for the employer's benefit as for the public so that they don't lose access to a medical facility with the particular licenses it has. But yeah, I don't think anyone argues that this business isn't too dumb to survive after it rejected their counter-offers when they had a new job in hand, what the hell did they think was going to happen?
- BooneJS 5y agoAt-will employment. I don’t see how anything outweighs that. Former employer didn’t want to raise salaries nor did they want to lose people. They chose to go to court instead. The traitorous 7?
- msbarnett 5y ago
- ngngngng 5y agoCan someone steelman this judges reasoning here for me? I just can’t see it. This seems like insanity to me in at at will state. The worst part is that the damage has already been done. Employees that would have left their job to find better work will now be terrified of this happening to them unless we make laws explicitly forbidding this. It’s just like non competes. They’re mostly unenforceable but employers don’t want to risk someone trying to enforce it so they just won’t hire you.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- afiori 5y agoJust reposting another comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30040209 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30040209 > The point of the injunction isn't to come up with a perfectly fair solution. It's to prevent irreparable harm, as might be caused if the only level 2 trauma center in the area can no longer function. Any claims for compensation that the nurses have are still valid and can be settled later. As someone whose only law training is watching law review channels on YouTube I agree. Basically getting paid at the same rate rather than an increased rate is repairable harm (by paying money if the nurses win), forcing downtime at their clinic is not. This assumes that the old employers have some kind of legal standing to make their victory at least plausible.
- vsskanth 5y agoI don’t understand how encroaching on the civil liberties of citizens is legally allowed for keeping a medical center staffed (however necessary it is deemed to be). For example, is it legal for a town to, let’s say, select 5 people and say they can only work as firemen for the local fire station and no one else is allowed to employ them because we absolutely need a fire station ?
- MattGaiser 5y agoYou can do so for law enforcement in some ways or at least historically could. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posse_comitatus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posse_comitatus
- js2 5y agoThis judge is a piece of work: https://urbanmilwaukee.com/2018/10/08/court-watch-42-days-in-jail-for-rolling-his-eyes/ https://urbanmilwaukee.com/2018/10/08/court-watch-42-days-in... https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/outagamie-county-justice-the-fbomb-and-insults-from-judge-mark-mcginnis-part-ii https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/outagamie-county-justice-the-fbo... https://www.postcrescent.com/story/news/2018/12/20/reviewer-recommends-removing-judge-mark-mcginnis-truancy-court/2369276002/ https://www.postcrescent.com/story/news/2018/12/20/reviewer-... https://www.postcrescent.com/story/news/education/2018/12/11/appleton-residents-sound-off-truancy-court-judge-mark-mcginnis/2272079002/ https://www.postcrescent.com/story/news/education/2018/12/11...
- danhab99 5y agoThis guy is a menace
- jleyank 5y agoI don’t see what the problem is because the courts and government can’t get involved in private matters (vaccines, mandates). Conversely, the courts and governments can get involved in private matters (abortions, vaccines, mandates). It’s all perfectly clear - do what those in control want and everything will be fine. Unfortunately, this isn’t really sarcasm anymore.
- yorwba 5y agoFound the case: https://wcca.wicourts.gov/caseDetail.html?caseNo=2022CV000068&countyNo=44&index=0 https://wcca.wicourts.gov/caseDetail.html?caseNo=2022CV00006... Unfortunately, seems like none of the documents are available for download.
- pbourke 5y agoDo the hospital executives of ThedaCare (the original employer) think this will improve their chances of recruiting anyone 2 years from now? Irrespective of the insanity of the ruling, it’s an abject failure of leadership to pursue this course in the first place.
- candiodari 5y agoIf they can threaten a judge into doing this, they can threaten government to get people to work for them. Once you do this, where does it stop?
- rdtwo 5y agoWow man that’s crazy. I thought you had to at least go to prison to become a slave in this country but I guess you can become hospital property too if you work for one.
- supernova87a 5y agoI hope this gets rapidly overturned/reviewed. I don't understand how one company can be granted an injunction against another for hiring people who have left that company (based on the claim that it would hurt the previous company). I liken it to being able to sue your competitor for buying the last widget in the open market that you also needed to manufacture your product. In what way is that an enjoin-able action? But maybe my legal understanding is poor.
- 882542F3884314B 5y agoInteresting email from the ThedaCare CEO earlier this week. https://reddit.com/r/nursing/comments/s8tdki/shots_fired_our_ceo_is_out_for_blood/ https://reddit.com/r/nursing/comments/s8tdki/shots_fired_our...
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI guess this judge didn't get the memo about indentured servitude being over by a couple centuries or so
- gilrain 5y agoIt is the citizenry who missed the memo: one the parties in your two party system is trying to enslave you. Resist them.
- justin66 5y agoIn case it is not obvious, ample evidence already exists that this judge is an idiot. https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/outagamie-county-justice-the-fbomb-and-insults-from-judge-mark-mcginnis-part-ii https://www.wjiinc.org/blog/outagamie-county-justice-the-fbo...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jbeaud 5y agoNone of those nurses can be compelled to work for ThedaCare by the court. If I were any one of those employees, I would quit effective immediately and not work a day more in the old facility. It serves ThedaCare right! They made poor business decisions by declining to pay each of those employees fair compensation. Losing them is the consequence. Their case against Ascension will not hold water. More American workers should take note and follow suit. Do not accept poor work conditions and low wages. Collectivize. Refuse to work for bad employers and take everybody else with you. This is our power to make change.
- jeasley1 5y agoThere is a go fund me fund started for the 7 involved health care professionals. called "Thedacare Seven-ExEmployee Support fund." on the Go Fund Me website.
- raisim 5y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/24/us/thedacare-lawsuit-wisconsin.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/24/us/thedacare-lawsuit-wisc... Judge reversed the ruling!!!
- tiltmd 5y agoI would love to try passive resistance. Wearing scrubs stating "Thedacare supports communism", "indentured servant", "serf". Walking by the administrator's office repeatedly and calling him pinhead. Singing nursery tune over and over again. Putting post its with insult all over the admin staff's care. During my own down time, going by executive's houses with signs and chanting. Or talk to the new hospital ask for 3 months and work for a 3rd company and then quit after 90 days.
- DamnYuppie 5y agoCan a lawyer please weigh in on this? I don't believe there is anyway this should be legal. I don't have to wait for my employer to find my replacement before I leave. This isn't the feudal system where we peasants are tied to the lords land. Also if I were one of these employees I would simply not show up to the old employer, they can go f#ck themselves.
- hffftz 5y ago
- jeasley1 5y agoMy feelings exactly!!
- syki 5y agoI believe this ruling has to do with unfair competitive advantage. The employees are not prohibited from quitting or working elsewhere. The company attempting to hire the employees is prohibited from hiring the employees. It’s a temporary measure until the court system works out the legality of everything. Imagine this scenario. There are two heart centers in a city. One of them decides to hire the doctors and nurses from the other heart center and does so and then massively increases prices. I’m not a lawyer but I think this sort of thing is not permitted (or desirable).
- vsskanth 5y ago> Imagine this scenario. There are two heart centers in a city. One of them decides to hire the doctors and nurses from the other heart center and does so and then massively increases prices. I’m not a lawyer but I think this sort of thing is not permitted (or desirable). Would be nice to know what state or federal law doesn't allow this type of behavior.
- tiltmd 5y agoI agree but think of how much choice you have in emergencies. A person is passed out or has a stroke and 911 is called. Some cities have multiple ambulance companies and the patient has no choice. The ambulance decides that Alpha is the best hospital, its not the closest but is good for strokes. Spouse shows up and is told what procedures is best. Price is never mentioned, no talk about how Alpha and Beta is compared in skill or price. The stroke victim is at Alpha and after the initial treatment, only an idiot would transfer them now. BTW, this is based off personal experience. I did not select the ambulance for my wife, they transported her 15 miles instead of 2 and 5. She died and because I waited a week, the hospital would not allow me to see the bill, instead I got over ten different doctor groups sending me bills. I did not get any choice if they used Charlie or Delta anesthesiologists who worked for two different companies or other brain surgeons. In fact, by the end the hospital explained that I couldn't pay there but had to deal with the different services individually. The last doctor's bill led to me stating what part of my wife's death did they play. Considering they were trying to get over $5000 from me instead of going through my insurance, boy did they drop their request quickly.