6 ms·
ImageGlass added malware with this commit
- minerva23 5y agoMicrosoft's "Windows Update Delivery Optimization" steals more bandwidth in a day[1] than this project could hope to steal in its entire lifetime AND this project removed that feature. Let's point our pitchforks in a more productive direction... [1] S.W.A.G.
- spiderwest 5y agoI am the CEO at Spider.com. We vet all of our users, you likely know who our customers are, they are large fortune 500 companies. Businesses that need pricing on Amazon products or positions in Search Engine results. The large enterprises with all this data don't make it easy to gather at scale. So by using a few queries from thousands of different IPs we can use the collective wisdom of the crowd. Secret shoppers have exist for about 500 hundred years and pre-date the Internet. You use this service every time you shop at a grocery store. The price of a bag of rice or can of beans will be reasonable to competing grocery stores. The great news is we are not processor or memory heavy. In fact we don't compute anything local on machines and the bandwidth we use is the equivalent to downloading a few images. We sponsor projects to help developers and keep software free. We all know that software takes hundreds of hours to develop and maintain, so symbiotic relationships are good for the community. We always require disclosure and being upfront with users. We require an informed decision on the part of the software's user. I am happy to answer questions about how Spider works. I can assure you we are GDPR compliant, we don't care about collecting user data we only gather data that is publicly available online about products and companies from public facing websites.
- perihelions 5y agoSome discussion happened here (issue closed by owner): https://github.com/d2phap/ImageGlass/issues/1252 https://github.com/d2phap/ImageGlass/issues/1252 The malware (at the very least) makes the user's machine the exit node of a commercial proxy service, without users' knowledge or consent. In the repo maintainer's own words (in a "privacy" menu setting that was enabled by default): >"Share devide IP with Spider.com customers to pass traffic through your device." >"Learn more about privacy policy at {0}. To opt out an option, you can uncheck it, then click 'Save' or 'Apply' button below. It will be disabled immediately." https://github.com/d2phap/ImageGlass/blob/51f9f5eaa17f6fc42e4c55241e3c3d1081d1a395/Source/Components/ImageGlass.Library/Language/Language.cs#L663-L664 https://github.com/d2phap/ImageGlass/blob/51f9f5eaa17f6fc42e...
- schleck8 5y agoSpider (.) com claims to have access to 70 million residential IPs How is this legal? And who even uses it?
- mdaniel 5y agoOne may often hear the expression "if you're not paying, then you're the product" for websites, but in the case of "free VPN" (or maybe even very low cost ones), it's my understanding that's how they're free to the user: because they're paid by folks who want residential IP egress I'd guess any such VPN can even put in their ToS "you grant $company the ability to send and receive traffic from your device" which wouldn't raise eyebrows in the same way such a clause in an image viewing binary would
- easrng 5y agoI don't know how many VPNs do this but Hola and BrightVPN do, they both make you a Bright Data exit node.
- easrng 5y agoSee also https://brightdata.com/ https://brightdata.com/ (formerly Luminati Networks) which does the same hting but with Chrome Extensions.
- schleck8 5y agoI always tell people to watch out what extensions they install, the webstore is a minefield
- rozenmd 5y agoScrapers - it's hard to detect bot traffic mixed in with a regular residential IP address
- schleck8 5y agoThey sure have a fancy website for such a scummy operation
- Forge36 5y agoAlready reverted. >Very positively surprised by you listening to feedback and changing it, I was about to drop ImageGlass. I'm sure you'll figure out a better way to financially support the project. >One thing you should definitely do is promote the Microsoft Store version more directly, I previously didn't know you could even buy ImageGlass. Now I'll do just that. It's hard to notice on the website, and you could also display something when launching the program the first time. - https://github.com/d2phap/ImageGlass/issues/1252#issuecomment-1018625643 https://github.com/d2phap/ImageGlass/issues/1252#issuecommen... Financial support for a project is hard. Novel approach I've not seen before, not something I'd want.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stedaniels 5y agoThey also _coincidentally_ implemented a feature that autoran ImageGlass as a background service a day before the malware was slipped in.
- zzzeek 5y agocommitting .dll files along with the GPL license violates the license in any case, im sure that's not stopping anyone from doing it but it's frustrating to see the GPL just dropped into repos as some kind of meaningless window dressing.
- klodolph 5y agoCommitting .dll files does not violate the GPL. What would violate the GPL is distributing the compiled result.
- lokar 5y agoUnless you own to the copyright or otherwise have different licensing terms available to you.
- oconnor663 5y agoAre you sure this is literally true? My understanding of the GPL is that it requires you to publish source on request. It doesn't make it an automatic violation to publish, say, a binary-only installer package.
- kadoban 5y agoAssuming the author owns copyright on the code they're releasing, I'm not sure what that would mean, violating the license.
- olalonde 5y agoThe copyright owner can of course violate their own license. I'm not sure how external contributions factor into that however. Maybe you could make the case that he is bound by his own license if he accepted external contributions which were implicitly licensed under it?
- kcb 5y agoThat makes no sense
- cbarrick 5y agoThe viral part of GPL only applies when code is statically linked against other GPL code. Anything statically linked to GPL code becomes GPL. However, distributing GPL code along side proprietary libraries that are dynamically linked together on the user's machine is allowed.
- throwawaynay 5y agoAdding a random dll to a project isn't very quiet
- sxcumxma 5y ago
- fuckcensorship 5y agoFor those of us who would like to find an alternative to ImageGlass, any recommendations? Preferably something lightweight and open source.
- chillstreem 5y agoI've searched long and hard for a fast and gpu-accelerated image viewer for Windows and settled on Pictureflect Photo Viewer last summer. Not open source, but it has both free and paid versions (with not much difference, mainly thumbnails and video playback) and it's available both on Windows Store and from their website.
- guerrilla 5y agoWhat's wrong with EOG or Gwenview?
- smoldesu 5y agoGwenview is pretty great, if there are builds for your platform then I highly recommend it. It's always been the perfect balance of well-designed and feature-filled for my uses.
- YXNjaGVyZWdlbgo 5y agohttps://nomacs.org/ https://nomacs.org/ fast, gpl3, native, multi plattform and sponsored by German universities.
- ancientsofmumu 5y agoIrfanview was always held in very high regard by my Windows using friends, not open source but freeware that's been around for at least a decade; a quick google just now seems to show that people still think it's great. https://www.irfanview.com/ https://www.irfanview.com/
- mdrzn 5y agoAgree, it's a really fast and lightweight software even in folders with thousands of photos. It's definitely on the list of "Must Install" after a fresh OS install, with VLC and a few others.
- Rd6n6 5y agoI’ve been too lazy to update image glass for the last few months, despite the reminders. What a relief
- ValentineC 5y agoHeh, I installed ImageGlass when Windows 10 somehow broke their image preview utility, and I don't think I've ever updated it since (or received any notification to update).
- gruez 5y ago>Heh, I installed ImageGlass when Windows 10 somehow broke their image preview utility The underlying code is still there. You just have to reenable it with a registry tweak. https://www.tenforums.com/tutorials/14312-restore-windows-photo-viewer-windows-10-a.html https://www.tenforums.com/tutorials/14312-restore-windows-ph...
- ValentineC 5y agoNice, thanks! :) If I remember correctly, I still think Windows Photo Viewer was much better than ImageGlass. All I want to do is quickly browse through a couple of photos in a folder.
- smukherjee19 5y agoDISCLAIMER: I am not the developer, nor am in any way involved with ImageGlass. Wow, this thread is like 35 minutes old and people are already jumping to conclusions, bashing the developer, bringing out the torches to burn them at stake. Really disappointed seeing this on HN... Perhaps the title itself is insinuating, and people are not patient enough to dig any deeper. Perhaps someone can add [quickly reverted] or something to the title? That being said, I really wonder why people 100% believe other people act in bad faith. Looking into that Github issue (https://github.com/d2phap/ImageGlass/issues/1252 https://github.com/d2phap/ImageGlass/issues/1252 ), it feels more like the dev was not aware of the issues with the bad actor in question, and was also very quick to revert the issue and pull the affected release from Github. This is the best someone can do under this situation, and I'm sure they must have felt quite stressful... Maybe they are, even now, feeling the stress if they stumble upon this thread. If the dev reads this: You did a great job fixing the issue, congrats! Toxicity like this kills many projects and dreams, by the way. EDIT: My argument rests on the assumption that the dev was acting in good faith. If it is proven to be otherwise, I will gladly retract my statement and apologize.
- skeletron 5y agoWhy are you defending him? He infected potentially thousands of people with malware to make a quick buck. That he reluctantly reverted the change only when people noticed and called him out on it is not particularly honourable or worthy of praise.
- kevmo314 5y agoBecause people make mistakes
- kadoban 5y agoAnd those mistakes affect others. If your mistake was infecting people with malware, you're not going to be a popular person.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 5y ago
- remram 5y ago/// <summary> /// Checks if Blueswan service is running. /// </summary> /// <returns></returns> What fresh hell is this?
- easrng 5y agoFrom a quick search, looks like a software testing framework: https://www.cigniti.com/blueswan/ https://www.cigniti.com/blueswan/ Edit: see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30038085 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30038085
- remram 5y agoI meant the formatting, turning one line of pretty useless comment into 4 lines of garbage boilerplate.
- stefan_ 5y agoThe malware DLL has "https://locator.blueswan.io https://locator.blueswan.io" in it, and various texts referring to "bs-worker" or Blueswan-worker. It's more like an internal codename. Fun fact: the DLL also has various "C:\Users\akabos" strings, that being the "CTO" of this enterprise: https://ru.linkedin.com/in/akabos https://ru.linkedin.com/in/akabos Russian malware writers don't care much for CI.
- akabos 5y ago
- stephc_int13 5y agoWell... When I install a new software I am always a bit uncomfortable about the potential trojan. The only thing that prevent it is if the software owner has more to gain by keeping it clean, and this is, unfortunately, not always obvious. I used ImageGlass in the past, I'll think twice before installing it again, and that will probably never happen as there not a huge utility or value there.
- dane-pgp 5y agoI'm surprised I haven't seen more people point out that the licence says "THERE IS NO WARRANTY FOR THE PROGRAM" and therefore "he can do whatever he wants to (your computer with) his software!?!1". That argument wasn't convincing when it was made in support of the recent vulnerability added to the "colors" NPM package, but I can still imagine people claiming that hijacking users' IP addresses is not harmful enough to count as malware.
- domador 5y agoIt's one thing to say "there is no warranty" in order to free oneself from the burdens of maintenance and onerous, abusive liability that could arise from the product one is giving to others. It's quite another thing to say "there is no warranty" under the idea that you shouldn't trust me, since I could suddenly decide to turn around and start taking advantage of you and your naïve trust in me. I find the first kind of attitude acceptable and reasonable. The second is basically an anti-good-will, pro-aggressor view of the world, which I emphatically reject and hope becomes increasingly unpopular.
- domador 5y agoI'm reminded of the recent incident where the developer of the NPM "colors" and "faker" libraries put show-stopping bugs in those libraries in order to cry out for people to give him money. Both incidents reinforce my opinion that it's very hard to make a living making free software. Maybe a takeaway for free software developers is the need to have clear, realistic plan of how they're going to earn money and if it's going to be through their free software, to be very upfront about that with users. These two developers' attempts to get money may have been born out of frustration, yet their methods were underhanded and abused users' trust in them and their products.
- 1_player 5y agoSorry for being unable to sympathise with these developers but: if you want to make money out of it, make your users pay for it. How is this rocket science? It's not even incompatible with the principle of open source. One thing is adding a paid plan after you decide you want to monetise your software, it's unpopular but understandable, another is bundling malware or adding malicious logic to get some money or "protest" because companies aren't paying you. They knew this is how open source worked, and being a twat because they don't like those terms anymore just ruins their reputation and all the goodwill they've built.