7 ms·
> Perhaps I'm biased, but calling religious organizations non-profits has always struck me as suspect. Yes, you are biased. Non profit means "not to make a pro
by ars 15y ago
> Perhaps I'm biased, but calling religious organizations non-profits has always struck me as suspect.
Yes, you are biased. Non profit means "not to make a profit", and that fits religious organizations quite well. None of them try to make a profit, therefor they are non-profit. It's not really that complicated.
> If they're proselytizing, then they are functionally no different from self-help gurus who charge people to attend conferences.
Except that they don't charge. Which of course does make them different.
You are biased because you (presumably) don't like what they do, but that's your opinion, and you should not assume everyone shares it.
And it's interesting you find the only organization in the world that claims to be a for-profit religion (Scientology) and use that to paint the rest of them. (Again barring fraud, which obviously does happen.)
Scientology is for profit because they charge money for their services, no other religion does that. Other religions ask for donations, sure, but the services are not conditional on the donations.
Just because an organization has a message does not make them for profit, anymore than a secular organization with a message ("don't eat meat" for example) automatically becomes for profit.
Your post sounds like you want to be the arbiter of which messages are for profit and which are not.
- redthrowaway 15y ago>Yes, you are biased. Non profit means "not to make a profit", and that fits religious organizations quite well. None of them try to make a profit, therefor they are non-profit. It's not really that complicated. Most religious organizations turn large profits. That they are used to build more churches, mosques, and temples does not detract from the fact that it's a profit. >Except that they don't charge. Which of course does make them different. Again, this is false. There isn't a cover charge, but there's an expectation of donation. It's no different from a tip. Waiters aren't non-profit, and neither are churches. >You are biased because you (presumably) don't like what they do, but that's your opinion, and you should not assume everyone shares it. A) I don't assume everyone shares it. B) I like a great deal of what many religious organizations do and have done, and dislike a great deal they do as well. >And it's interesting you find the only organization in the world that claims to be a for-profit religion (Scientology) and use that to paint the rest of them. (Again barring fraud, which obviously does happen.) This is patently false. From the Catholic Church, to Evangelical preachers, to most other organized religions, they all turn a profit. >Your post sounds like you want to be the arbiter of which messages are for profit and which are not. Message has nothing to do with turning a profit. That is determined by the money you take in minus the money you spend. I count money spent on growing the organization, through the building of additional churches and missionary works, as an investment in future profits, and hence not deductible from profits (to the extent it would make an organization a non-profit). I've clearly stepped on your toes. I apologize for the offense I've caused, but not for the words that caused it, which I stand by.
- ars 15y ago> I've clearly stepped on your toes. I apologize for the offense I've caused, but not for the words that caused it, which I stand by. No, my toes are fine, and I am not offended. You are just wrong, which is a different thing entirely. > but there's an expectation of donation. It's no different from a tip. A tip is given in proportion to services rendered. A donation is not. > I count money spent on growing the organization .... not deductible from profits You might do that. No one else does. If you remove this clause then this: > .... to most other organized religions, they all turn a profit. Is no longer true as well (I assume you agree). So lets talk about the clause. Growing the organization simply makes them more effective in spreading the message. But the message is the goal, not the money. In a for profit the money is the goal and is used for other purposes. > as an investment in future profits No, it's an investment is furthering the message.
- PakG1 15y ago>Most religious organizations turn large profits. That they are used to build more churches, mosques, and temples does not detract from the fact that it's a profit. Many non-profits are the same. I think the easiest way to differentiate between profits and non-profits is that profits have shareholders who benefit from the profits through dividends, rise in share price, etc. They have the potential to get a financial return on their investment. You can't say the same for donors to non-profits. Many religious organizations would easily be counted as non-profits when looking at what makes a non-profit a non-profit.
- vacri 15y agoNone of them try to make a profit, therefor they are non-profit. This is outright willful ignorance. There are plenty of religious organisations whose purpose is to line the leaders' pockets with money. Then you conflate 'religious organisation' with 'religion', which are two separate things. Yes, "Christianity" is nominally a "non-profit religion", but there are plenty of christian religious organisations that have fleeced their flock.
- ars 15y agoJust because there are charlatans of that sort (which is undisputed) does not make what I said wrong.
- richardw 15y agoThere is a long continuum between charlatan and saint. A vanishingly small number of organisations are more occupied with their original reasons for being than with ensuring their leaders have a reasonable lifestyle. A friend of mine, a priest, did some research that included how many priests still believe in a god. He wasn't allowed to release his findings. (edit - didn't down-vote you, btw) (2nd edit. He continues to be a priest and has enormous integrity, so you can assume that he does believe in what he's doing. But he is pretty cynical about the institution.)
- vacri 15y agoI heard a couple of priests-cum-public-atheists on the radio, saying that when they did their doctorates in divinity, where you learn a hell of a lot more of the history and politics of christianity, the running joke was "if you still believe in a god after learning all that, it just shows you weren't listening"
- tincholio 15y agoThe very fact that you can do a doctorate in 'divinty' or theology is a joke...
- 15y ago
- dalke 15y agoChurches are exempt from many non-discrimination rules. They can exclude people who are not members of their faith, and may decide to kick someone out of the church should they divorce. The Salvation Army is anti-gay and actively lobbies against gay rights, as does the Mormon church. If a company has the policy of not discriminating based on faith, creed, skin color, marital status, veteran status, etc. then it wouldn't be appropriate to support another organization which DOES so discriminate. I have no idea if this is Google's reasoning, but it seems like perfectly ethical reasoning of why they may not want to extend non-profit discount to churches. BTW, it isn't hard to set up a non-profit subsidiary. A church which wanted to could start one and use that to receive donations. There's some paperwork, but it isn't much - and most churches already have someone to manage their own paperwork. The new non-profit, of course, would be subject to non-discrimination laws.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>The Salvation Army is anti-gay The Salvation Army I'm sure considered themselves to be extremely for people who express themselves as "gay": this is what they say on the point. http://www.salvationarmy.org/ind%5Cwww_ind.nsf/vw-sublinks/80256E520050A2E280256CBA0028A203?openDocument http://www.salvationarmy.org/ind%5Cwww_ind.nsf/vw-sublinks/8... It's a moral judgement. Arguing that opposing the Salvation Army's position is somehow neutral would be wrong. Considering that, I can't see how they're position impacts on me at the point of need if I get warmth, compassion, food and clothing regardless of who I am.
- dalke 15y agoThat document says that all homosexual conduct is misconduct, and therefore not appropriate to "Salvation Army soldiership." That is the definition of discrimination based on sexual orientation. The Salvation Army even refuses money from the City of San Francisco, because the city requires "any business that holds city contracts and provides spousal health insurance to married couples must do the same for the gay or unmarried partners of its employees." http://www.skeptictank.org/hs/s-army.htm http://www.skeptictank.org/hs/s-army.htm The way I read it, it's more important for them to discriminate against gay people then it is to provide "warmth, compassion, food and clothing."
- donw 15y ago> Yes, you are biased. Non profit means "not to make a profit", and that fits religious organizations quite well. None of them try to make a profit, therefor they are non-profit. It's not really that complicated. Except that really isn't the case; most religions are non-profit only because you can specify quite interesting definitions for the word 'profit'. As a case-in-point, look at the Mormon church. Mormon families are supposed to give a monthly donation of ten percent of their income to the church as 'tithing', which is tax-deductible, and of course the church is a 'non-profit'. Church assets are estimated at over $30 billion USD, and they pull in about $5 billion annually. That's a lot of profit for a 'non-profit' organization. This money pays for a lot of business-like activities. Salaries for high-level church officials, construction of buildings for church and public activities, global recruitment and proselytization operations, investment, lobbying activities, etc. Some of it even makes it into humanitarian efforts, although that's part of the proselytization arm. I've got no problem with any of this; as private citizens, they should be free to spend money however they want. My problem is that these are all business activities. Nothing the church does is purely humanitarian; even their aid packages for disaster areas come with copies of the Book of Mormon, which I'd consider Sales and Marketing. As such, they should pay taxes in the same way that a large corporation does. Note that I'm not picking on the Mormons specifically; the Catholics, Methodists, Muslims, Jews, and pretty much every other major organized religion that I can think of do the same things. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finances_of_The_Church_of_Jesus_Christ_of_Latter-day_Saints#Use_of_funds http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finances_of_The_Church_of_Jesus...