10 ms·
Binance kept weak money-laundering checks even as it promised tougher compliance
- svw1907 5y ago
- mikeodds 5y agoI’ve gone through corp compliance checks with Binance and through the same checks with various traditional payment processors. Requirements weren’t particularly different. If anything, Binance was more stringent than some high risk payment processors I’ve dealt with.
- mrkramer 5y agoSEC pls close this bucket shop.
- leifg 5y agoGeneral question: are crypto exchanges not regulated the same way banks are regulated (in the US)?
- smt88 5y agoNo. They fall under a variety of regulations because they sell securities, transmit money, and hold cash, but most of them are not banks yet. I think that will change soon, especially as the government equates stablecoin offerings as equivalent to banking. Also, Binance is not regulated in the US at all. It's banned from the US.
- kolanos 5y ago> Also, Binance is not regulated in the US at all. It's banned from the US. Their website suggest otherwise? > Binance is unable to provide services to U.S. users. Binance.US (BAM Trading Services) is a US-regulated cryptocurrency trading platform. In approved states, U.S. customers can use Binance.US to buy and sell over 50 cryptocurrencies with low fees. So it looks like Binance has a U.S. entity that is regulated.
- Tenoke 5y agoBinance.us is so much more limited and separate from Binance.com that it's easier to think of it as a seperate entity that Binance lends their name to.
- latchkey 5y agoBinance.com is banned in the US. If you are a US citizen (and KYC'd as such), you can't access their site services at all. Even if you do get in, you can't deposit / withdraw. As a US citizen, I tried to setup an account with Binance.US when it launched and for whatever reason, their automated systems locked me out and I didn't bother trying to investigate it further. So yea, despite what Reuters says, my personal experience is that their platform is pretty tough on compliance.
- WJW 5y agoNope. They don't have a banking license so they are not banks so they are not regulated like banks. (Whether they should be regulated like banks is a different question, and one that is still being debated)
- kolanos 5y agoWhile they're not regulated like a bank, nor should they be, since they're not a bank... They are regulated, such as by FinCEN [0] which imposes AML and KYC measures on all fintech (including crypto) companies operating within the United states. Additionally, since crypto is classified as securities in the U.S., I believe they are regulated by the SEC as well. [0]: https://www.fincen.gov https://www.fincen.gov
- miohtama 5y agoUnited States does not have regulation for cryptocurrencies. They also do not have classification for cryptocurrencies.
- gruez 5y agoSome of them are, eg. https://www.finextra.com/newsarticle/36582/crypto-exchange-kraken-gets-wyoming-bank-license https://www.finextra.com/newsarticle/36582/crypto-exchange-k...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- legutierr 5y agoCrypto exchanges are typically regulated as money transmitters (like PayPal, for instance), usually by state banking regulators. In New York a special "bitlicense" is required, which is issued by NY state banking regulators. Among the differences between being a money transmitter and a being a bank include an obligation that 100% of client obligations be backed by cash-equivalent assets or surety bonds (as opposed to <20% fractional reserve required of banks). Money transmitters are not insured by the FDIC, so there is no federal-level prudential supervision. State regulation varies between completely hands-off (Montana, for instance, does not require licensing to operate in the state) and very strict (for instance in the case of New York). That being said, with regards to anti-money laundering, all money transmitters are overseen at the federal level by FinCEN, and are subject to the Bank Secrecy Act with regards to all KYC and anti-money laundering requirements. Regardless as to the states in which they operate, they must register with FinCEN, and like banks must take proactive steps to detect and report suspicious activity to that entity. In other words, there is no way for Binance to operate legally in the United States without being subject to the same strict anti-money-laundering rules and requirements that banks are subjected to.
- vmception 5y ago> Binance said documents reviewed by Reuters were “partial and do not accurately reflect the full picture I believe that, having worked with many lawyers over a variety of crypto projects over the last half decade most of the information is with different attorneys under attorney client privilege. They know the law better than the public sector agencies do, spending months on a rationale from a variety of case law, journals, and less binding private opinions from the same regulators. and law firms may even accept liability on behalf of their client. Even if its not “better”, as it is inconvenient for a regulator to disagree with you at any point, it is more expensive for a regulator by orders of magnitude for two reasons: 1) The regulator doesnt know how you’re structured or what legal rationale you are relying on. They dont know what exemption or compliance you are relying on. And there are many possibilities, sometimes infinite permutations. 2) They dont get to know even because of the attorney client privilege. They cant assume you’re doing something wrong just because Reuters decided to use some negative adjectives for things likely currently legal. Regulators are stuck with a high expense to most likely just embarrass themselves. Its better for them to go after lower hanging fruit. Binance is accurate in that legislatures have not made a specific encompassing law. So regulators are flying blind. Legislatures also dont know what to pass since nobody will talk to them either, the firms most effected dont want anything on the piblic record because then an overzealous regulator will know about any weakness in the company’s regulatory strategy. Legislatures are also at a place where they could neuter the regulator agency, its not a specific anti-crypto future that people think “governments” are heading towards. So literally everyone is flying blind, while the well funded fiat-interfacing crypto service has the most comprehensive view of the law because of their expensive lawyers.
- Zerverus 5y agoWasn’t enough to fool Singapore’s MAS, who are likely the most capable regulator in this space. It’s no surprise the vast majority of companies who applied for a license ended up silently withdrawing or having it rejected, even Binance.sg who have significant investment from Temasek (state linked investment arm)
- arberx 5y ago> So literally everyone is flying blind, while the well funded fiat-interfacing crypto service has the most comprehensive view of the law because of their expensive lawyers. This is literally the case with anything. Well funded tech monopolies have the most comprehensive view on...everything.
- bushbaba 5y agoOf course they did. Crypto and NFTs are some of the easiest ways to money launder now of days. This represents some of their biggest clientele. Terrorists love crypto.
- Bombthecat 5y agoOr paying cash in germany for a house. Mafias love this
- tgv 5y agoThere are laws about large sums of money.
- Bombthecat 5y agotiert mit der Frage, warum der Immobilienkauf in bar nicht endlich verboten wird, antwortete Scholz: Bargeld sei eben beliebt. Und zwar zu Recht. Es reiche, dass Immobilienmakler verdächtige Bargeldtransaktionen bei der zuständigen Financial Intelligence Unit (FIU) melden müssten. Dabei weiß auch der Minister: Dort stapeln sich 46 000 unbearbeitete Geldwäscheanzeigen. Die Prüfung einer Verdachtsmeldung kann Monate dauern. Bis dahin ist das verdächtige Geld längst verschwunden.
- tgv 5y agoThat's a different matter. I don't think the money actually disappears, does it? In a real estate transaction, it simply changes hands. It might be harder to trace, but if there's no trace, it can be assumed illegal.
- raesene9 5y agoHouses leave a trail, and they can be easily seized at a later date if evidence turns up. Not saying it doesn't happen (obviously it does) but there's more to catch than with crypto currency.
- 5y ago
- young_unixer 5y agoKYC is already hard to deal with, I dread the day I mistakenly log into my Binance account from a US exit point, because my account could just get frozen. I prefer they keep being like this instead of things being even harder. And them doing everything to avoid governments getting data from their customers would suggest me that their loyalty lies with their customers first, and governments last, as it should be.
- tyre 5y agoTheir loyalty is to making as much money as possible. It’s simply greed.
- cblconfederate 5y agoI mean yeah, it's finance
- WinstonSmith84 5y agoYes, Binance are greedy capitalists unlike any other stock companies. Oh wait...
- Consultant32452 5y agoMy loyalty is to making oversight by regulators as difficult as possible. And if Binance makes a lot of money doing that in the process, I am happy to see it.
- efdee 5y agoThat's a weird goal in itself.
- Consultant32452 5y agoIt's no weirder than wanting to tattle on Binance to people who demonstrably do not have my best interest at heart.
- 5y ago
- cblconfederate 5y agoLooking at the list of "transgressions", none of them crosses the line of being illegal. They are concerns about lax standards and a request from the police (which as i understand they fulfilled). Banks in europe do worse stuff than this
- arcticbull 5y agoI'm shocked. Shocked! Well... not that shocked.
- Johnie 5y agoI see this so often with many FinTechs. First thing that FinTechs fail to address early is risk/fraud. They learn pretty quickly to address this. Second area regulatory and compliance (ie KYC/AML).
- MomoXenosaga 5y agoSelf-regulation in the finance industry is a joke I'd have thought everyone learned that by now. They'll do whatever they can get away with.
- bobulous 5y ago"For a corporation of its scale, Binance discloses little public information. It says it does not have a headquarters and does not identify which entity controls its main exchange..." I don't see the point of giving them the benefit of the doubt. Their outfit is clearly designed to avoid the kind of regulation that would discourage money laundering.
- thebean11 5y agoIf you believe regulators are out to get you, this is rational behavior regardless of whether you are breaking the law or not.
- cowpig 5y agoThis seems like a thought process that can easily rationalize any kind of illegal or immoral activity as "rational," given what you can get away with. Seems that if society at large thinks this way then we are all much worse off.
- thebean11 5y agoIs not having a corporate headquarters illegal or immoral?
- Animats 5y agoBinance, remember, is the company behind Tether. Binance issues insane amounts of Tether, backed by almost nothing. This only works as long as long as there is a net inflow of USD to Binance. If that ever stops, the bottom will fall out.[1] [1] https://www.coalexander.com/post/the-tether-binance-axis-and-the-great-crypto-crash-of-2022 https://www.coalexander.com/post/the-tether-binance-axis-and...
- miohtama 5y agoThe company behind Tether is Bitfinex. Tether was founded 2014, Binance 2017. This blog post has multiple of its facts wrong or as speculation, while it is still a fact that Tether is super shady.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoWhich facts does the blog post get wrong?
- i67vw3 5y ago1.) Tether and Binance have nothing to do with each other. 2.) The author correlates that Tether's market cap rose only because of Binance futures. Binance was a contributing factor, but it wasn't the only one. Tether was/is available on all exchanges as default stablecoin. All big exchages in 2018/19/20 used to only have USDT and still largely have. Recently more have startd popping up like USDC, BUSD, Pax, GUSD etc. 3.) Though, I might be wrong here.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago1) The blog post doesn't assert that they do. The rest is speculation- which is fine, it's a blog post.
- Animats 5y agoRight, Bitfinex, not Binance, is behind Tether. Tether is a lot like Madoff's fund. Everything is just great, until there's a net outflow, which happens during a recession. Then the house of cards collapses.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoHow do binance wallets work? Does everybody's coins go into a large shared wallet?
- miohtama 5y agoCorrect. It is called a hot wallet. https://ethereum.stackexchange.com/questions/84401/how-to-build-an-ethereum-hot-wallet-for-an-exchange https://ethereum.stackexchange.com/questions/84401/how-to-bu...
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoWould that essentially act as a tumbler?
- from 5y agoIronically, yes. Casino sites can also do the same thing (although obviously if you deposit 1.215179 BTC from one address and then withdraw the exact same amount to a separate address it's probably still going to be possible to link the two addresses) This is why some blockchain analysis companies increase the risk score of coins from exchanges with effectively no KYC like Huobi or Kucoin.
- cowpig 5y agoWhat's the irony?
- dustymcp 5y agoNot really binance would have a registry, and most likely comply with law enforcement.
- sgjohnson 5y agoGood. Crypto was not meant to be regulated. Good to know that there’s a crypto exchange that won’t ask stupid questions when buying or selling crypto for fiat.
- 8note 5y agoThat is to say, crypto is built for fraud, and shouldn't be trusted for transactions
- seany 5y agoWe really should just get right of AML laws.
- sgjohnson 5y agos/right/rid it’s not like AML even works. https://www.icij.org/investigations/fincen-files/ https://www.icij.org/investigations/fincen-files/
- efitz 5y agoBinance.us is a joke (as a “free” US citizen, I am of course not permitted [ed: by my government’s regs] to use the original site.) I recently tried to change my email address. I failed. It’s a customer support interaction, because who would want to change their email address, right? So they sent me back through their KYC verification Whig was unable to accommodate the fact that I have moved to another state since I initially registered and have a different driver’s license (because who would move, and who would get a new drivers license, amiright?)
- hammock 5y agoSame thing happened to SWIM when doing the binance.com one.
- dustymcp 5y agoThis is the same for most exchanges Ive used its really a hassle to change email..
- sgjohnson 5y agoActually there’s plenty of international financial organizations that just don’t want to deal with US persons because of FATCA. Try opening something more than a most basic bank account in any European country. There’s a fair chance that they simply won’t want you as a customer.
- glerk 5y agoKucoin with a VPN is the way to go until everything moves to decentralized exchanges and we don’t have to deal with this nonsense anymore.
- from 5y agoThe article doesn't come out and say it, but what they really want is for Binance to "de-risk." This could mean any or all of the following: - Banning users from 2nd and 3rd world countries ("high risk jurisdictions") - Banning VPN/Tor users - Banning users with funds associated with gambling, darknet markets, or anything the FATF complains about - Implementing opaque procedures to "deter criminals" -> Holding funds hostage until adequate "source of funds" is provided -> Note that even if source of funds is proven they will still cut off communication in about a third of cases for no reason whatsoever -> Randomly requiring reverification (of course with selfies and maybe even over Zoom) - Removing smaller coins
- silksowed 5y agoseems like a vested interest for them to launder here, then come back and say "oops" were fixing our gaps if/when it becomes a PR storm
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TheGigaChad 5y ago
- helloworld11 5y agoGood. KYC and AML laws are a travesty for basic individual freedom and privacy in modern times and a hypocritical joke in many contexts.
- 8note 5y agoThe privacy makes sense, but KYC doesn't restrict your freedoms. Just adds responsibilities
- propter_hoc 5y ago"in 2017 [...] Know Your Customer (KYC) technology was yet to be fully developed" This is laughably wrong to anyone with exposure to banking or securities infrastructure.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoSo called anti-money laundering laws, which are properly described as warrantless financial surveillance laws, are an absolute travesty and violate the core principles of liberal democratic societies. Historically, the state being required to obtain a warrant before conducting a search was seen as striking the right balance between the need to maintain reasonable checks on the power of the state, and the need to investigate crime. And in one summit, of the G7 in 1989, all of that was cast aside, as the FATF, and its global financial mass-surveillance mission, were instituted. What's important to know about AML laws is that they are redundant; any incident of actual money laundering involves some underlying crime that generated the illicit revenue. To prove money laundering occurred, you need to prove that the underlying crime occurred. In other words, any actual money laundering that is proven would land the party involved in prison, for the underlying crime. But existing 'AML' laws do not require proving money laundering occurred. They only require proving that a person did not comply with the AML-related disclosure requirements, i.e. not complying with warrantless mass-surveillance. The crime being prosecuted is not surrendering privacy. Ron Pol has written a paper that makes the case for AML laws being the least effective policy in history, and I strongly recommend any one who cares about maintaining a free society to read it: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/25741292.2020.1725366 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/25741292.2020.1...