5 ms·
The US already has the highest incarceration rate in the world. Why do you think more, stricter punishment is the answer?
by klyrs 5y ago
The US already has the highest incarceration rate in the world. Why do you think more, stricter punishment is the answer?
- mc32 5y agoA lot of that was due to drug consumption "crimes;" there has been a reevaluation of the outcome of that and we've gone away from that. That said, anti-social crime should have deterrents and consequences.
- cameldrv 5y agoThat’s why some drugs are illegal. Addiction causes many people to generally destroy their lives and many of those to resort to crime.
- mc32 5y agoA better option would be the ability to "cure" people of addiction --we can't. It's hard work for most people and we don't have magic cure pills. I am for criminalizing the sale of hard drugs, but not the consumption. Criminalizing consumption is lose-lose. Recreational drugs like Alcohol and MJ and others, as long as they are regulated and not highly addictive for the majority of the population, I don't think we'd benefit from criminalizing (see Prohibition and War on Drugs results). We would benefit more from programs to treat addition as ineffectual as they are.
- scollet 5y agoThis doesn't explain a lot. Alcoholism and gambling both fit the bill. Even for those, adequate counseling and social support don't exist, practically, in the US. This is the infrastructure of society that bleeds when pressed, and many people could do with legal variants, or safe spaces to confront addiction.
- cameldrv 5y agoAlcohol and gambling are both heavily regulated. Gambling was illegal in almost all of the U.S. until about 50 years ago, and it has only recently become widespread. Alcohol was entirely banned for a number of years and even today there are counties where you can’t buy alcohol. Even where you can there are many restrictions on hours of sale, licensing, etc.
- scollet 5y agoI'm not following.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoHow are drug consumption crimes and anti social crimes not related? If someone on the streets needs their next hit, shop lifting LEGOs from the downtown Seattle Target is a fast way to get money for that hit (LEGO’s are easy to fence). Seeing what has happened on the streets due to meth, fentanyl, and heroin, if we are compassionate we have to pay for rehabilitating all that damage that drug use has caused. So…we make it illegal so we don’t have to pay those costs. Unfortunately, anything short of a Singaporean legal solution probably wouldn’t work, which isn’t something our society can accept. So here we are.
- mikewarot 5y agoThe US system is racist, and needs reform, let's agree on that. However, removing all punishment for crime isn't a sane response. It quite predictably incentivized property theft that was previously at an acceptably low level, despite the broken system. If things aren't rebalanced, vigilante justice might be seen as an acceptable answer, and it will probably bring strong racists themes along with it.
- mc32 5y agoI think this is what happened in the Philippines. Crime was out of control, people got totally fed up, elected a "strongman" and he personified the electorate's desire to rid society of those who went to far. In a psychological sense, he took on the burden of society and did the work on their behalf --they could feel good because it wasn't them, but rather the personification of their desire in the form of the "stongman". People want some peace --they will take a hit to civil liberties in exchange.
- kangaroozach 5y agoBad behavior should be punished with no regard for quotas. It’s a moral thing. Fairness dictates that crime shall be punished. Why should the arbitrary number of jail cells or beds influence how many should be jailed? They must have estimated the wrong number if needed cells. But criminals should not be let off the hook for this miscalculation. The better debate should be whether certain punishments match the crimes themselves or whether certain laws should be removed. We have systems for this. But it should not be selective enforcement of laws to appease a small segment of people who oppose jails in general.
- Avshalom 5y agoOpposing jails in general is in fact a part of the debate over whether certain punishments match the crimes. It's not even a particularly extreme part/position in that debate.
- jrockway 5y agoStrict punishment is the "easy" answer. When people don't know what to do, it's the first they reach for. (From the dawn of human history, "an eye for an eye".) It seems like it should work (who would want to be in prison for the rest of their life over a $20 Amazon package), and it seems fair (if you didn't want to go to prison, you shouldn't have stolen). But, the "seems" comes from up in an ivory tower of wishful thinking. But watch this. If I told people I was a software engineering manager and I docked my employees' pay if they didn't complete sprint goals on time, HN would be outside my door ready to murder me. "Punishment doesn't work! How can you be so stupid? I hate you!" Ultimately, we have to treat the cause and not the symptoms. If people have a purpose and their basic needs met, very few of them are going to jump onto a derailed train and steal random Amazon orders. But in LA, people don't have their basic needs met. They don't have a place to live. They don't get to shower in the morning. They might not even know where their next meal comes from. Sadly, prison is probably an improvement, and selling your $20 Amazon item to someone on the street for $10 guarantees that next meal. So taking some packages off a train is a win/win. As a society, we can do a lot better than this. We don't need to sacrifice a $20 Amazon item to give someone their next meal. We could just give it to them for pennies on the dollar. We don't because... I can't even think of a reason. Puritan work ethic? A desire to punish people out of unfulfilled BDSM fantasies? I don't know. But it seems pretty fucked up to me.
- josephcsible 5y agoWhy are you treating intentionally stealing as equivalent to not coding fast enough? It's easy to choose not to steal.
- mc32 5y agoI think I see a few misconceptions here. Very few people in LA are doing this crime. This is a product of "fencing". The vast majority of people in dire straights will not decide theft is the answer. Ergo, its a special person who decides, "eh, it's just theft." Second, you may not put up with deadline punishments because you "have an out" (get another job). If we had 20% unemployment and you have 20 guys and gals in line for your job and there wasn't a social safety net, you'd be glad to have a crummy manager with crummy milestones and deadlines. So, punishment works --it doesn't work if it's subverted (i.e. options). How exactly do you think trannies and communist systems work, people volunteer?
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoThe US seems to be the most lawless of the places that have functioning rule of law. Highest murder rate, for instance. What are you going to do with that? Fix the society? Well, yes, that would be ideal, but we haven't found a workable plan so far, despite lots of trying. Failing that, what are you going to do? Let murderers go free? That actually can work, for those who just had a lapse of judgment. For those who are likely to try to do it again, though, that seems like a very shortsighted solution. Fewer people in prison, but more dead bodies on the street? That's not a good trade for society as a whole. So, given the lawlessness in society, given the visible problems of not punishing crime, less punishment seems unwise. Actually, less/more is not the correct axis. What we really need is more certain punishment. I don't care how many people that puts away, put away everybody who commits a felony. But even that's not the whole answer, because we need to revisit things like decriminalizing certain drugs. Would society as a whole be better off, or worse? The real answer is that we need a society where people restrain themselves, so that the law doesn't have to do the restraining. Lose that, and the only options left are anarchy and oppressive enforcement.
- rdtsc 5y ago> The real answer is that we need a society where people restrain themselves, so that the law doesn't have to do the restraining. Fundamentally I agree. Once we stop relying on people’s self regulation and basic decency we have already failed. Overflowing prisons is a telling sign of that failure. I guess one benefit of US being so large and states and municipalities having the ability to create their own laws, is that eventually we might learn what works best after observing results. How did the reforms in San Francisco or LA work? If they worked well, other states might rush to copy. If if didn’t, at least it’s isolated to a few areas.
- dv_dt 5y agoCrime is driven by unavailability of legal opportunities - often manifested by inequality. https://financesonline.com/how-income-inequality-affects-crime-rates/ https://financesonline.com/how-income-inequality-affects-cri... The contrast of what is actually available on an upward path is much more preventative of crime vs the marginal discouragement of more punishment below.
- Dracophoenix 5y agoHow do you explain shoplifting among celebrities? Winona Ryder, Amanda Bynes, Lindsay Lohan, etc.? Many had the money to pay for what they stole. > The contrast of what is actually available on an upward path is much more preventative of crime vs the marginal discouragement of more punishment below. Or, to put it simply, criminal intent is a cost-benefit analysis. And, despite you're implication, there isn't a particular level of income or lack thereof required to make that calculation.
- dv_dt 5y agoI see them as individual samples of mental health episodes, that are insufficient to buck a larger statistical society wide data.
- golemiprague 5y ago