3 ms·
> For too long we've let the supporters of inequality get away with arguments like ... They always have arguments, but history shows that we can successfully t
by wolverine876 5y ago
> For too long we've let the supporters of inequality get away with arguments like ...
They always have arguments, but history shows that we can successfully tax wealthy people. It's not hard.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThis is not historically accurate. Tax avoidance was worse in the past than it is now. Many of the loopholes were closed in the 1980s. But that's also around when we stopped enforcing antitrust, which is where the recent concentration of wealth actually came from.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Tax avoidance was worse in the past than it is now. Many of the loopholes were closed in the 1980s. I'm pretty sure the first statement is false, as IRS enforcement has been cut back and tax evasion is at record levels, which was the basis if a recent attempt to fund enforcement (rejected by the GOP who want to 'defund the IRS'). The 1980s tax law changes greatly reduced the portion paid by the wealthy, if I understand correctly.
- AnthonyMouse 5y ago> I'm pretty sure the first statement is false, as IRS enforcement has been cut back and tax evasion is at record levels, which was the basis if a recent attempt to fund enforcement (rejected by the GOP who want to 'defund the IRS'). The main problem with IRS audits is that they choose taxpayers at random to be subject to an expensive time consuming audit which the taxpayer doesn't get reimbursed for even if the IRS finds nothing wrong with their returns. Small business owners are generally the ones this happens to because they're the ones who exceed the income threshold to get audited and they're the ones with complicated tax returns that are expensive to audit. Democrats have figured out that if they encourage this, Republicans have to spend political capital preventing it or their constituents get really mad. This could be easily solved by having the government pay the taxpayer's time and expenses for the audit, but neither party really wants to do that because it would "cost money." (It costs money either way, but that way it would have to be formally accounted for and spread evenly among taxpayers instead of subjecting random unlucky ones to a disproportionate expense.) But tax evasion is different than tax avoidance. One is illegal, the other is restructuring your activities to minimize your taxes while still complying with the law, e.g. by arranging for profits to accumulate in a subsidiary in a country with a low tax rate. It's typically the latter that corporations and rich people do to have low tax burdens. > The 1980s tax law changes greatly reduced the portion paid by the wealthy, if I understand correctly. Before the 1980s the highest nominal tax rates were higher, but nobody actually paid them because there were so many loopholes. People were literally deducting the cost of their personal vehicle from their taxes etc. They closed the loopholes and lowered the top rates at the same time, which basically canceled out. Federal revenues as a percent of GDP have been essentially flat since the end of WWII: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S
- wolverine876 5y agoIt's a bunch of complicated empty claims to justify something, and the facts show that the something is rich people evading taxes at unprecedented rates, and the GOP preventing enforcement. People are so concerned with law enforcement reform - when it's against rich criminals. Where's the law and order crowd? Get tough on crime!!!
- imtringued 5y agoHow do you avoid land value taxes? Oh right, by preventing them from being implemented in the first place, because that is the only way.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThis is not evidence that land value taxes were commonly used historically and something changed to make that no longer the case. They were never common, outside of as a component of ordinary property tax which is still present. But also, the way to avoid land value taxes is to build tall buildings on a small amount of land. Which is kind of the point -- an incentive to make more efficient use of scarce land. But then the guy who builds a skyscraper in a small town is paying the same amount of tax as the single family home next to it. I'm still not sure what the Georgist solution to that is supposed to be. Like, alright, if you cover this town of 100,000 in single family homes you have enough housing for everyone, but with LVT there is a large tax incentive to replace 20 homes with a single building with 20 condo units in it. This continues until local rents fall to the level that they can't recover the cost of constructing more tall buildings, i.e. land values crash. By then the town is 5-10% 20-unit buildings and the rest abandoned lots. Because the local demand for real estate square footage is completely satisfied so there is zero profit in building any more buildings there, but you've still only used 10% of the land. No one can make money by building more buildings on the other lots (construction cost exceeds collectable rents), but if they still have to pay a non-zero amount of LVT, that makes the lot have a negative value. Which implies that the end result is a land value of zero and therefore LVT revenue of zero. That could still be worth doing -- it would eliminate rents attributable to land value -- but how would it generate any revenue? (And if the answer is "use zoning to prohibit construction of tall buildings" then you're just taxing the poor by making housing artificially scarce.)