3 ms·
The difference between a "software engineer" and a real engineer like a civil engineer is that when a manager type tells a civil engineer to ignore safety or st
by mrguyorama 5y ago
The difference between a "software engineer" and a real engineer like a civil engineer is that when a manager type tells a civil engineer to ignore safety or standards for profit reasons, a civil engineer gets to tell them to fuck off
- conradludgate 5y agoYou, as a software engineer, should also tell your manager to fuck off if they are making bad decisions. No one is inherently above you. If they're the kind of management to never listen to you then that doesn't make you less of an engineer, that makes them shitty managers to ignore these important principals behind their systems
- ipaddr 5y agoYou get fired the real engineer doesn't. You are paid to do what management tells you.
- conradludgate 5y agoLanguage and phrasing is of course important. I have disagreed with my management on many occasions and I have never been fired.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoMany companies have a culture of continuous deployment that often means "bugs happen, its part of life around here". You would go against the whole mantra of the company and industry. Not easy to tell the boss to fuck off.
- chongli 5y agoIt’s even more strict than that. A non-engineer is not allowed to be a supervisor of a civil engineer. This is why civil engineers work in a firm structure: the entire chain of command is made up of civil engineers. Any company who wants engineering work done must contract with a firm. This makes any potential conflicts of interest external rather than internal.
- hardolaf 5y agoThis is also why most defense companies are run almost entirely by engineers. Even though they're not required to be, they organize themselves that way to ensure a culture of design excellence. It's better to fail to deliver a product than to deliver a product that will kill people.
- formerly_proven 5y ago> defense companies ... than to deliver a product that will kill people Isn't that the point?
- hardolaf 5y agoMost products defense companies produce are to prevent people from dying or to do completely tangential tasks.
- julienfr112 5y agoBoeing and their famous 737 max screwup where run by engineers with solid work and engineering ethic ?
- hardolaf 5y agoThe decision to sell a safety feature as an optional extra was pushed by bean counters.
- amelius 5y agoIs this what went wrong at Boeing? Also, how is Tesla structured? Are software engineers working on autopilot functionality managed by true engineers?
- hardolaf 5y agoBoeing ended up getting run by bean counters with the eventual expected results where the bean counters wanted to charge for a safety feature. Magically, the planes with the safety feature (every single plane sold to USA, Canada, and EU based airlines) had no issues. The ones sold to nations where they were trying to save money, had the issues that we all know of today. As for how Tesla is structured, well it's Musk at the top who delegates everything and spends his time on Twitter trying to boost the stock price to hit his quarterly stock price goals. As for if they're managed by engineers, I have no clue.