28 ms·
American here "perhaps better known as the online identity verification service that many states now use to help staunch the loss of billions of dollars in une
by mistrial9 5y ago
American here
"perhaps better known as the online identity verification service that many states now use to help staunch the loss of billions of dollars in unemployment insurance and pandemic assistance stolen each year by identity thieves"
In the great State of California, billions in unemployment benefits were sent to the wrong people.. because their internal systems were designed to delay, deny and deprive, I say. Actual people with real jobs were repeatedly refused, while insiders who knew how to fill out paperwork, and apparently knew where the blind spots were, filed hundreds of claims in the early pandemic days. A newly appointed Director (young, tech savvy woman) soon stopped making public statements, and the situation nearly two years later, is not resolved. This is at a time when California has record income to the State.
Now, some people may jump on this and say "well, you see how photo ID would have helped that" and, with incomplete knowledge and personal opinion, I say no, it would not solve it. You see, people with real jobs, with every real paper filed, were denied benefits, while insiders were pulling checks with both hands, using certain kinds of identities that would slip through. How would ever more restriction, requirement and verification, have helped here?
I am deeply against the collective government making ever more demands on citizens for "papers, please" enrollment to massive money social services (edit e.g. govt unemployment benefits). It is not going to have the desired effect, despite superficial evidence otherwise. Additionally this represents a slippery slope where the ability to interact as an individual will be eroded, and opportunity for insider graft will increase.
- heavenlyblue 5y ago> while insiders were pulling checks with both hands, using certain kinds of identities that would slip through How can you slip through public key cryptography? * not american here
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- netr0ute 5y agoWhat public key cryptography?
- franciscop 5y agoI guess OP, like me, is from a country where we have a digital signature installed in our computers or a physical smart card+reader with which you can make many official legal procedures on our local governments. I just got mine from Spain, and I was "late" (but very necessary since I don't live there anymore) and I'm applying literally today for my card in Japan.
- netr0ute 5y agoThere isn't anything like that in the US.
- dharmab 5y agoAmericans have no national identity card. The closest thing is a Social Security number, which has no security or biometric features. https://youtu.be/Erp8IAUouus https://youtu.be/Erp8IAUouus
- csdvrx 5y agoAnd it's a good thing, and personally I would love it if we could stop having even SSNs.
- messe 5y ago> I would love it if we could stop having even SSNs Why?
- gumby 5y agoThe case that a universal identifier, or even some authoritative list of people, has a benefit that exceeds its cost, has never been made. It’s simply “one of those things”
- jdmichal 5y agoThe problem with SSNs is that places treat it like a secret, when it's an identifier. They were not designed to be a secret, and obviously are a pretty terrible secret at this point in time. What with the fact that probably every person older than 18 has had theirs leaked at some point in time.] If places would just stop treating them as a secret, it wouldn't even matter.
- Lammy 5y ago"The invention of permanent, inherited patronyms was, after the administrative simplification of nature (for example, the forest) and space (for example, land tenure), the last step in establishing the necessary preconditions of modern statecraft. In almost every case it was a state project, designed to allow officials to identity, unambiguously, the majority of its citizens. When successful, it went far to create a legible people. Tax and tithe rolls, property rolls, conscription lists, censuses, and property deeds recognized in law were inconceivable without some means of fixing an individual's identity and linking him or her to a kingroup. Campaigns to assign permanent patronyms have typically taken place, as one might expect, in the context of a state's exertions to put its fiscal system on a sounder and more lucrative footing. Fearing, with good reason, that an effort to enumerate and register them could be a prelude to some new tax burden or conscription, local officials and the population at large often resisted such campaigns." — James C Scott, Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed (Thanks shoo — https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29885742 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29885742)
- Spellman 5y agoI'm taking a leap of logic here and guessing you're suggesting a blockchain solution to national identity would have solved this problem?
- dharmab 5y agoMany European countries have public key encryption integrated into their national ID card system. No blockchain needed.
- Isamu 5y agoThanks for brightening my day! Honestly- I can use the laughs today.
- csdvrx 5y agoYes it would. Repost of my comment from yesterday: (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29982395 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29982395) As technically interesting as using a card to sign stuff may be, I don't want that to be the government responsibility, as it then opens the door for it to be used in ways that limit our freedoms: a system that's too perfect can uniquely identify you, in ways that prevent disassociation (ex: the place of birth on the passport is of great interest to some totalitarian places, while only citizenship should matter..) So for me, the ideal ID system is decentralized, self-declarative, and the weight of the proof depends on the length of history, not on "who" says it's true: there should be many such services where you could declare a name and an address and anything else you wish (phone, email...) The value after a few weeks would be close to nil, so you could decide to "increase it" by having several people vouch for you (strength in numbers) instead of relying on a "who" (public notary). Or you could totally decide that you care about your freedom/independence/whatever and NOT ask for any vouching. It may be hard, but after a few years of reliably receiving mail and orders at that address, it would acquire some serious weight - a bit like you tend to trust online accounts that have been open for some year. Among many other things, this would also allow anyone the opportunity to "change" easily: want a new name/move to a new address/etc: create a revocation certificate for the old, sign it with the new, boom you inherit the credential history! It's just a quick idea, but it shows how IDs could be more like URLs (multiple competing services, and you could have a few at the same time, why not!) by moving away from the current system that's a direct descendant of the census (give the lord a list of people to tax them) and the passport (limit freedom of movement during the war) At the core, I believe people should be in control of their identity, not governments or states.
- syshum 5y agoAmerican Here... I have a major problem with calling the IRS a "social service", taxing authority is not a social service.
- mistrial9 5y agoI meant the unemployment benefits are a social service.
- landemva 5y agoFalse. UI is an insurance program paid by the employee.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gumby 5y agoWhy not? It’s part of the system of providing services (some direct, like EBT; some indirect, like roads and pollution regulation) that we elect governments to do behalf.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- whakim 5y agoThe IRS is a massive social service, because much of US fiscal policy gets done through the tax code via ever-more-complicated tax credits and deductions.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> because their internal systems were designed to delay, deny and deprive, I say. Definitely. I know someone in NJ who has not received unemployed benefits for 14 months. They call every month, and are told to keep waiting. No one returns their calls, snail mail, or emails. There is zero justification the government cannot respond via email, or give you a call back, other than they would like you to waste so much of your time and effort on hold that you give up.
- exhilaration 5y agoYou should let them know to contact their state legislator. From what I read on various state subreddits that's the only way to get a response from your overwhelmed state unemployment office. This is the equivalent to escalating your issue to a manager.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> You should let them know to contact their state legislator. [...] This is the equivalent to escalating your issue to a manager. No, it's the equivalent of escalating it to a member of the Board of Directors.
- giantg2 5y agoAKA don't expect any response because "the board" is too high up to deal with a nobody like you or me.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> AKA don't expect any response because "the board" is too high up to deal with a nobody like you or me. Well, maybe. Legislators are really variable on constitutent service, but many will (or rather, will allow their office staff to; direct, even by something going out under their name rather than a staff contact, is less common) at least gently probe on behalf of constituents on state service issues, and if a high enough volume is involved are more likely to get personally involved. But any response that does happen is likely to involve butt covering and blame redirection from virtually every step of the management chain, just like when an issue hits the news media, so on issues where you haven't exhausted other avenues short of lawsuits, it's probably not the step to reach for the way escalating to a manager would be. I’ve definitely been involved in issues where premature escalation to a legislator delayed and/or made the resolution less favorable than it probably otherwise would have been because of the degree of attention from management, legal, public and legislative affairs, etc., that the escalation triggered. It makes sense in the particular circumstances described, though, it's just the analogy that was flawed in a way which might be misleading as to how that generalizes to other situations.
- ledauphin 5y agoI completely understand the frustration, and I think I agree that there likely aren't simple solutions. But can I ask - do you have any positive suggestions for what could be done differently that would lead to a better overall result? Is your assertion that it would be better to make it easier for both legitimate claims and fraudsters? What sort of legit/fraud claims ratio should we agree upon as a society, and is there any way for us to influence that number, or is this just an impossibly hard problem? I know that's a lot of questions, but all of them are sincere. I'm legitimately unsure what I should think about this, as well as unsure what you would specifically propose.
- mistrial9 5y agothank you for asking, sorry for the rant-like structure. Whatever is to be done, needs to back off from "surveillance capitalism". In my own experience, failure in government programs is tolerated because everyone involved is on permanent salary.
- ledauphin 5y agohaving experienced some Kafka-esque systems myself, I understand the rant. My presumably unreasonable imaginary proposal for these sorts of problems is that we would build off of real-life social networks. I think my mail carrier, for instance, would be able to verify that I am the same person who has lived at my address for the past N years. Which really boils down to one human being seeing another human being's face. It's pretty low-tech. That said, I feel like using video chats to do this is arguably a reasonable next-best alternative to IRL verification for people who for one reason or another can't ever meet their mail carrier. I guess what I'm getting at is - it _seems_ like there could be a good version of this system that is roughly the right solution in a mostly unobjectionable, non-surveillance-state way. I don't really know what boxes it would have to check to move from the bad category into the good category. But I'd love to hear more from you or others on what options we might have.
- jorvi 5y agoIn general, for social services the fraudster problem is extremely overblown. Here in The Netherlands in 2016 we had 120-150 million euros of fraud on 77 billion euros of social service spending. That's less than 0.2%. Divided by the amount of social service recipients, it amounts to 17 euros of fraud per person. https://www-rtlnieuws-nl.translate.goog/economie/column/41401/factcheck-het-onnodige-fiasco-rond-uitkeringsfraude?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en-US&_x_tr_pto=wapp https://www-rtlnieuws-nl.translate.goog/economie/column/4140...
- suifbwish 5y agoWhere is some data on these people who knew how to file things like you are saying? Perhaps an examination of this and bringing it to public light will bring some real change?
- trimbo 5y agoOne example: EDD employee using serving-life-in-prison boyfriend to sign up other prisoners (none of whom are eligible), and kick back money to them.[1] (Edit) Oh, here's another good one. EDD employee claimed to be Senator Feinstein.[2] [1] - https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdca/pr/california-employment-development-department-contract-employee-sentenced-25-months https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdca/pr/california-employment-d... [2] - https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-12-17/california-edd-employee-charged-scamming-unemployment-benefits https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-12-17/californ...
- 62951413 5y agoCalifornian here. Name one thing the state government does for normal people who actually finance the largess. Are you really surprised billions go unaccounted in a place where train robberies are a thing? But don't you worry, a photo ID won't be required in the next election though.
- bagels 5y agoBuild (some) and maintain (most) roads?
- trimbo 5y agoThat's ~5% of the state budget, and primarily financed by the gas tax, not the income tax. (Large projects funded with bonds) Source: https://dot.ca.gov/-/media/dot-media/programs/research-innovation-system-information/documents/caltrans-fact-booklets/2021-caltrans-facts-a11y.pdf https://dot.ca.gov/-/media/dot-media/programs/research-innov...
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThere is no purpose to delineating government revenues since money is fungible. Even though legislators might label or apportion some source of tax to some specific expense, in reality, they can always move it elsewhere (since they are the legislators). Therefore, it is always a question of which expense has political priority.
- kansface 5y agoI thought the problem with CA was that the state budget isn't fungible - 90%+ of the money is allocated via ballot measures or the state constitution and can't be touched by the legislature.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI do not know enough about CA budget's mechanics, but that would seem like a very inefficient and ineffective way to operate a state.
- numpad0 5y ago> Actual people with real jobs were repeatedly refused, while insiders who knew how to fill out paperwork, and apparently knew where the blind spots were, filed hundreds of claims in the early pandemic days. This is simply how every bureaucracy works at all levels. And Unix systems as well :/ Your system comes with cron and tar, you just have to know they exist and how can they be used. And to know that, you just have to read up relevant man pages, and to pull up man pages, you just... ... well I guess you can also hand couple grands to that dude over there mixing a peanut butter jar with fingers who apparently knows how to write a backup scripts and how to run it as a cron job. I guess it's some sort of unsolved hard problem to make systems that are self sustaining, fair, and easy, that works reliably.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> In the great State of California, billions in unemployment benefits were sent to the wrong people.. because their internal systems were designed to delay, deny and deprive, I say. That may be so, but it's at least in part because, irrespective of what they are designed for because their internal systems were notoriously broken and overwhelmed before the pandemic, and the department is a notorious nightmare hellhole work environment that almost everyone whose been around state service avoids and almost everyone who can get out of (within state service, if they have a reason for remaining there more generally) does, leaving mainly the people that can't escape; it's the most consistent source of workload and working conditions conflicts between employee unions and management, and the issues are usually at best temporarily papered over rather than resolved.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wldcordeiro 5y agoAll of American social services seem designed to delay, deny and deprive from some fear of "welfare queens."
- nickff 5y ago>" All of American social services seem designed to delay, deny and deprive from some fear of "welfare queens." " There's also a massive amount of fraud against the social services. Just look at the auditors' reports on the COVID relief money, and you can see the patterns.
- pessimizer 5y agoAn amount of fraud that would be reduced by simplifying the processes or making them universal. Currently everything is so complicated that fraud is undetectable. A good part of fraud is bad actors with expertise in these processes leaping in front of victims who find those processes unintelligible so have no idea that programs exist or if they're qualified for them. edit: the best part is when somebody manages to fill out all of the forms, navigate the administration, get approval and help finally, then get another letter that says that they were retroactively denied benefits and have to pay them back. It's a minefield.
- ribosometronome 5y agoAre there other solutions to prevent the billions in stolen identity claims and returns filed each year? The IRS isn't doing this just to be a pain in the ass or make it more difficult for people to file but because there is an actual problem that costs tens of billions every year.
- landemva 5y agoAbolish the personal income tax would completely fix the problem.
- coffeecat 5y agoHaving used ID.me before, I thought their email was a phishing attempt at first, before I looked into the situation and found that it was legit. Government services should never ask users to provide personal information to third parties which lack .gov TLDs; it's very problematic from the perspective of a cautious user.
- smsm42 5y agoCan confirm, I know somebody in CA who had the rights to the benefits (not me), and actually getting them was a nightmare. Yet, somehow criminals managed to steal billions. I am torn between gross incompetence (always a good first guess when CA government is involved) and actual collusion with the criminals. And no, different auth system wouldn't help it. Probably would make it worse - the system would inevitably be buggy, deny entry for people who don't look like their out-of-date photo, glitch on hundreds of systems that are different from whatever the designers assumed, and would require a lot of manual adjustment - while the support workforce will be reduced, because we've got this shiny new expensive automated system, why should we keep paying for human support?
- max_ 5y ago> I am torn between gross incompetence (always a good first guess when CA government is involved) and actual collusion with the criminals. Believe none of what you hear, half of what you read, and everything that you see.
- yongjik 5y ago> I say no, [photo IDs] would not solve it. (...) How would ever more restriction, requirement and verification, have helped here? This almost starts to sound like an Onion article: "No way this can possibly work," Americans saying about yet another system implemented by virtually every nation in the Western World(TM). The whole point of a national photo ID system is that it's the government's responsibility to provide its every citizen a functional ID. Which has its shortcomings, but it's miles better than everyone implementing their own ID system anyway in incompatible ways and then all citizens trying to figure out which one to use where. There's a strong parallel with a national healthcare system, which is also objected by a lot of Americans on the ground that the mythical government will never get it right.
- fartcannon 5y agoWe're already at the point where I can deepfake a person from a single photo, I'm not convinced biometric data is useful at all.
- dragontamer 5y agoThere's this old idea (~10 years old) of having the USPS become a PKI-token agency, especially because USPS already has the infrastructure to physically deliver items to every house in the USA. These physical tokens can be as simple as a randomly-generated QR-code, or a full and proper PKI physical token / smartcard system (or anything in between). Furthermore, USPS needs more traffic / package deliveries (especially since its lost Amazon as a customer). Increasing the amount of goods flowing around physically in the USPS system is definitely a benefit, especially if its for ensuring the physical security of these hypothetical security tokens. ---- IE: The USPS is uniquely situated to become a premier ID of the US government. Certainly more situated than the current standard, the Social Security Administration. Or the loose confederation of ~48 "RealID" state drivers license.
- nickstinemates 5y ago> especially because USPS already has the infrastructure to physically deliver items to every house in the USA. Not accurate. I live very close to San Francisco, but I have to get my mail at a Post Office because the USPS doesn't deliver to my door.
- chrisoverzero 5y ago> In the great State of California, billions in unemployment benefits were sent to the wrong people […] > Actual people with real jobs were repeatedly refused […] I would also refuse unemployment benefits to people with jobs, real or otherwise. Which one of us is confused, here?
- logifail 5y ago> [..] government making ever more demands on citizens for "papers, please" Our 12 year old was refused service in a local stationery shop last week because he didn't have proof of vaccination or a negative test with him. He'd been tested three times in school that same week, but had left "his papers" at home. He was attempting to buy stuff for school. He was furious. Oh, and in not so many years from now, he'll be old enough to vote.
- cwkoss 5y ago> You see, people with real jobs, with every real paper filed, were denied benefits, while insiders were pulling checks with both hands, using certain kinds of identities that would slip through. What are the 'certain kinds of identities that would slip through'?