8 ms·
It's worth noting that the definition of "Native American" varies over time. In addition to people self-identifying for various political, social, and economic
by reaperducer 5y ago
It's worth noting that the definition of "Native American" varies over time. In addition to people self-identifying for various political, social, and economic reasons, the tribes can decide their own level of generic purity. One tribe can specify that you must be ¼ indian to qualify for their tribe, while others can make it far less or more.
All of this leads to the old joke, "What do you call 64 Cheyenne in a room?" "One indian."
The linked article unfortunately bases its conclusions on "self-identification," which is problematic. When the federal government sent the tribes billions of dollars in COVID relief money, suddenly there were newly-minted, self-described "indians" crawling out of the woodwork trying to get a check.
Also realated, there's currently a bunch of people on a reservation outside of Seattle who are being kicked out of their homes because they're not tribal enough. The tribe changed its definition, and because these people are from a related tribe up in Canada, they no longer qualify.
/Friends with a lot of indians. Subscribe to two indian newspapers. And yes "Indian" is correct. It's only white people and city indians who embrace the term "Native American." Rez indians call themselves "indians." Proudly.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI am not white or a city Native American and I use Indian for people from the country of India, because it results in less confusion.
- runarberg 5y agoIf you want to prevent ambiguity you can use "American Indians" and "People from India". But usually it is clear from the context what you mean.
- runarberg 5y agoWhoa, sorry, I posted this under the wrong post. This was supposed to go under https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29989643 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29989643
- unmole 5y ago
- izend 5y agoIndian is definitely not used in Canada nor is Native American as it turned into a very derogatory term. The preferred term is First Nations and Inuit.
- ravenstine 5y agoIn all seriousness, I wonder how long it will be until "First Nations" and "Inuit" become derogatory. I didn't even know "Native American" was bad, to be honest.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoThere are already people who consider terms like "Inuit" homogenizing and insulting. There are thousands of indigenous groups in the Americas and every person in them can have their own preferences and opinions. There isn't a singular term to refer to the totality of their identities any more than there is for "Eurasians".
- coldtea 5y ago>There are thousands of indigenous groups in the Americas and every person in them can have their own preferences and opinions. Well, the same is the case with Europeans, Asians, and so on, so? We have smaller identities, and larger group identities, it's not belonging or being categorized in one precludes the smaller more unique identity...
- HWR_14 5y agoLogically, being characterized at one level doesn't prevent categorization into finer or coarser levels. In reality, there is a finite amount of information that can be conveyed, and the level of characterization is often whatever you lead with. There are important trade offs to be made with fitting in with a larger group vs being characterized as the mixture of traits of said larger group.
- AlotOfReading 5y ago
- brag 5y agoWhat about the Indians from India? What do they call them?
- sterlind 5y agoI dunno, but I've seen/used American Indians before to disambiguate (unless talking about specific nations/ethnicities), and Indian-Americans for Americans from India. for (non-American Indian) Indians in India, maybe Indian Indians? subcontinental Indians? that last sounds wrong to me but I dunno what else to use!
- nirav72 5y agoAs someone of Indian origin - I just call myself South Asian. This seems to be accepted term by many of us who were either born or raised in the west. That could include people of Pakistani heritage, Sri Lankan, Nepal and Bangladesh.
- screye 5y agoI never disambiguate. my accent is thick enough to give away which type of Indian I am.
- protomyth 5y agoSlang wise, I've heard the phrase "beads not feathers". Generally, when talking on a reservation, its pretty obvious, but "Indians from India" was another. Depends on the crowd. You also have to remember that Native Americans talking about other Native Americans will use slang (not for outside use) or refer to the other's tribe. 1) I remember a band that I thought was called "Beads and Feathers" that had Native Americans and Indians.
- systemvoltage 5y agoIn the movie, Good Will Hunting, clarification is made with “Dot, not feathers” which seems more accurate since both a dot mark and a feather are forehead ornamentations.
- 5y ago
- seshagiric 5y agoOn a trip to the Monument Valley, our guide explicitly told us they hate being named as Indian. They seem to prefer their tribal name or if I remember correctly, First Nation).
- cmckn 5y agoIt depends, these groups of people are not a monolith. US federal legislation and agencies often use “Native American” or “American Indian” on signage, etc. and some groups use similar, others don’t. I have found “indigenous” to be the most widely-accepted contemporary moniker.
- protomyth 5y agoFirst Nation is Canadian, and I would point out the number of reservations that have high school teams named "Indians". Those names are local.
- seshagiric 5y agoMy bad. Our guide told us the Navajo believe they were one of the first humans on the Earth, maybe I mis-remembered it as first nation.
- bluedino 5y agoCubans, Mexicans, and Puerto Ricans are all hispanic or latino but don't confuse them.
- AlotOfReading 5y agoAs an archaeologist for whom the topic of names comes up a lot, why in the world would you give general advice on "Indian" naming? It's obviously specific to individual preferences and you should generally prefer identifying people with nations anyway.
- rayiner 5y ago“Indian” refers to Indians as a whole, especially with respect to their political relationship with the United States. Indians themselves use the term in that context, and it’s the preferred term in, for example, the field of Indian law. It’s like the term “Asian.” Few people identify as generic “Asian” and it would be incorrect to equate it with a nationality or specific culture. But it does work at a high level to address a group of people who have something in common on a political dimension.
- mbg721 5y ago
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoAsian was a good label to use during the hate crimes, fwiw.
- mbg721 5y agoOkay, well, if it helped, it helped.
- rayiner 5y agoIn fact the opposite is true. 1) The label was overbroad, since the attacks were on East Asians, not south Asians. 2) The whole thing was manipulated by white liberals for their own purposes. They blamed Trump and “white supremacy” for the attacks, when in reality the attacks where happening in liberal cities like SF and NYC, and most of the attackers were non-white themselves. In fact, the “Asian” label and identity was used to undermine the interests of Asians. Progressive identity activists used it as an opportunity to attack white conservatives, while reaffirming the need for reduced policing. But that’s not what actual Asian voters in these cities wanted: https://www.slowboring.com/p/yang-gang https://www.slowboring.com/p/yang-gang. They wanted more policing and measures to control the homeless. In NYC, for example, Asians overwhelmingly supported Andrew Yang, who was attacked for expressing moderately law and order views. And in the general election, heavily Asian communities in NYC voted in significant numbers for the Republican candidate, even though the Democrat also ran on a law and order platform: https://www.thecity.nyc/politics/2021/11/11/22777346/chinese-new-yorkers-voted-for-sliwa-gop-republicans https://www.thecity.nyc/politics/2021/11/11/22777346/chinese.... The Republican candidate was otherwise a complete joke (even the NY Post endorsed the Democrat). But he got 46% of the vote in Brooklyn’s 70% Asian China town. Sometimes these broad, politically constructed group labels are unavoidable. But labeling a group and getting people to identify with that label is also a tool for manipulating people. Indeed the term “Asian” to refer to a bunch of unrelated nationalities—who often have deep animosity towards each other—was coined by Berkeley political activists: https://time.com/5837805/asian-american-history/ https://time.com/5837805/asian-american-history/
- protomyth 5y agoAlthough, if you are not an enrolled member of a tribe and you say you're an Indian on a reservation, expect some serious backlash. Harvard may accept you but the tribes will not. That being said, some tribes use their enrollment offices as a power play on some members. I do wish the federal government would step in some way. Its a tricky subject.
- coldtea 5y ago>I do wish the federal government would step in some way Yes, what Native Americans could use is more federal meddling in their lands, tribes, and affairs... /s
- protomyth 5y agoIts not like they don't interfere all the time anyway, might as well do something positive for once.
- boppo1 5y agoThe boarding schools sere considered positive when implemented. Not so much.
- ipaddr 5y agoIn Canada tribal offices get money from the federal government and they get to decide how to spend it. Some tribes equally share, others hire family and the money never trickles down. You can't take the easy way out and ignore the problem because you are part of the problem.
- throwawaylinux 5y ago