4 ms·
This is trivially refutable by anybody who has voted for a compromise candidate, which is effectively everyone. 60% of Americans think that marijuana should be
by mindslight 5y ago
This is trivially refutable by anybody who has voted for a compromise candidate, which is effectively everyone. 60% of Americans think that marijuana should be legal for recreational use [0], yet it remains illegal at the federal level. You cannot claim plausibly claim this situation reflects the will of the voters. Rather, the voters' will is herded into a few bundled choices, who differentiate themselves on hot button topics while safely ignoring consensus on less divisive ones.
[0] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/04/16/americans-overwhelmingly-say-marijuana-should-be-legal-for-recreational-or-medical-use/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/04/16/americans-o...
- nradov 5y agoSeveral serious candidates in the 2020 presidential election explicitly supported federal marijuana legalization (or at least decriminalization). They didn't get many votes in the primaries, so apparently voters don't consider that an important issue.
- mindslight 5y agoYou demonstrated my exact critique - voters were made to express their preferences in an extremely limiting fashion. Having to prioritize issues directly implies not being able to express your will on some issues.
- TameAntelope 5y ago"America" is not the jurisdiction, it's the 435 districts and the 50 states. It's the will of each of those constituencies that decide who is sent to congress, rather than a straight popular vote. National issues do not impact the nation equally, and the US's legislative body represents that fact. Deciding how we, as a group of people, live together is much more complex than, "Let's just vote on each thing!" A system like that is rife with all kinds of "wolves vote to eat the sheep" problems, to a degree much worse than any system we might have right now in the US.
- mindslight 5y agoIf 60% of voters are in favor of legalizing marijuana, then legalizing marijuana is the will of the voters, period. The voting system limits the way the voters' will can be expressed, thereby making the outcome not reflect the will of the voters. If you'd like to make an argument that our national representative system weighs voters from different states unequally, I'm open to that. But that's the kind of thing that will generally get you a few percentage points, not 10%. Or translate the argument to medical marijuana which per that link is supported by 91% of Americans. That magnitude can't be explained away with weighting or quantization error. I'm very aware of the tyranny of the majority ("wolves vote to eat the sheep"), and would have included such a caveat that following the will of the voters is not always just and that it's an assertion to judge by simple majority, but that is not what we're discussing. Also on the topic of marijuana deillegalization, this isn't a majority wanting to aggress onto a minority and take away their rights, but rather a majority wanting to end such aggression - tyranny of the majority does not apply.
- TameAntelope 5y ago> If 60% of voters are in favor of legalizing marijuana, then legalizing marijuana is the will of the voters, period. How do you know this? I'm sure polls have been conducted, but without stakes, and understanding of the consequences, of the downsides, of the costs, there's no way a random voter would be capable of executing a policy decision as complex as legalizing a drug. That's why they elect representatives, and at a national level the people have not chosen to elect representatives who have made this an important enough priority to create and pass legislation making this view into law. At a state level, some voters have chosen to prioritize this, by picking representatives who value this view over other views, and prioritize passing legislation. The system worked, for those people. The point here is that if your favorite poll were accurate, and did indeed reflect the will of the people, they'd prioritize it highly enough to vote accordingly. However, it isn't important enough to supercede other issues, so it remains not the will of the people. It's a lot more complex, figuring out what people want, than just asking them.
- 5y ago