3 ms·
> Reality is, in a society with an internal passport system where you have to show papers for everyday movements, any constitutional rights or freedoms cannot b
by marcosdumay 5y ago
> Reality is, in a society with an internal passport system where you have to show papers for everyday movements, any constitutional rights or freedoms cannot be guaranteed
Well, theoretically they can, it's just a system that is so easy to exploit that it doesn't make sense to lose time talking about the unexploited state.
Anyway, the entire problem here is with the "show your papers for everyday movements" part, not with the government making your papers easy to use.
- motohagiography 5y agoIt seems so reasonable, but when you make something easy, people (governments) do it. ID cards are an attractive nuissance for authoritarian personalities, you just don't equip them if you want to live without abuse. I've worked in privacy, and unless you make an explicit and specific law against something, orgs are going to find a way to abuse it. One can absolute be in favour of identity cards and internal passports, but they should just not couch their authoritarian urges in "convenience," and try to make it seem like it's our own idea for our own good.