8 ms·
Is "acceptable ads" really a bad thing? I'm not opposed to seeing any ads; I just don't want badly behaved ones. And is there a less bad alternative to accompli
by josephcsible 5y ago
Is "acceptable ads" really a bad thing? I'm not opposed to seeing any ads; I just don't want badly behaved ones. And is there a less bad alternative to accomplish that?
- blibble 5y agoI wonder how many users install an product that claims to be an "ad blocker" so they can see different ads
- karaterobot 5y agoFor you, this might be a great solution. I think most people who install an adblocker do it because they don't want to see any ads, so it defeats the purpose.
- mcherm 5y ago> I'm not opposed to seeing any ads; I just don't want badly behaved ones. While I support this sentiment, a definition of "badly behaved ads" which is based on whether or not the advertiser paid money to some third party is just not a definition I can live with.
- criddell 5y agoThat's not the definition though, is it?
- SahAssar 5y agoYou have to pay a fee to get on to the acceptable ads list, right?
- criddell 5y agoYou have to pay tuition to attend MIT but that's not all you have to do to leave there with a degree.
- cowpig 5y agoAnd did you know that you need to add or remove hydrogen ions to change the pH of a solution? Anyway, back to the conversation we were having
- JadeNB 5y agoYou can explain why you think it's a bad analogy, but this kind of dismissive snark helps no one.
- cowpig 5y agoI agree in principle but I also feel like there needs to be a minimum threshold of effort or topical relevance in a comment or the discussion becomes a kind of Gish Gallop[0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop
- Kye 5y agoHow about a Gish Trot? Use flowery language to further confuse and it's Gish Dressage.
- vrc 5y agoI always have heard the “gallop” in this context pronounced “guh-LOP” with the stress on the second syllable.
- Kye 5y agoI've never heard it spoken in this context, but I'm also not clear on what pronunciation or enunciation has to do with it. Horses trot, gallop, and go to dressage competitions regardless of how you pronounce or stress the syllables.
- motohagiography 5y ago
- mundo03 5y agocheck acceptableads.com In summary, high revenue/traffic sites do pay, small sites don't.
- hungryfoolish 5y agoOnly if you're a multi-million dollar corp. Not for the small guy, for e.g, https://blog.readthedocs.com/ad-blocker-update/ https://blog.readthedocs.com/ad-blocker-update/
- diffeomorphism 5y agoNot really, no. You have to actually have acceptable ads (with a pretty reasonable list of requirements) and then may or may not pay some amount to have that verified. Seems pretty much in line with food labeled as "organic" or "fair trade". You can say you meet the requirements, but if you want to advertise it somebody else certifies it.
- roblabla 5y agoDepends on what you mean by "definition". They say[0] they only accept ads that do not disrupt the reading flow, can be distinguished from the rest of the content, and has a reasonable size (all clearly defined). (They also have more criterias, but those are the main ones). But the problem is, that is very poorly enforced in practice. Whenever I use ABP, I see ads breaking the standard everywhere. To the point where I can only assume the Acceptable Ads definition is just a deflection. And of course, there's the whole "you need to pay to get on the list" which creates some very awful incentives. [0]: https://acceptableads.com/standard/ https://acceptableads.com/standard/
- pgrote 5y agoI think that is a legitimate question. The issue becomes there is no standard or method to ensure acceptable ads. A static ad without javascript is acceptable to me. Maybe not to someone else. But ... the ad industry would never accept a static ad more akin to a billboard than a tracking device. Many times in the past malware has found its way into networks run by the more highly regarded ad systems. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malvertising https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malvertising If a content publisher refuses to let people read articles without a subscription or with an ad blocker, I am ok with that. It is their choice.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> the ad industry would never accept a static ad more akin to a billboard than a tracking device. Is JS synonymous with tracking? Why can't you just track server side? I don't see how removing JS from ads would prevent FB from targeting me on my FB feed.
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoWithout JS phoning home everywhere there's a 'share on Facebook' button, Facebook can only track your activity on their site.
- IX-103 5y agoDepends on the "ad product" being sold. For "I'll pay you to put this image on the page" ads you might not need JavaScript. For "I'll pay you if someone clicks on the ad" it might also be possible. For "I'll pay if the visitor sees the ad on the page" (which requires the ad to know if it is in the viewport), then JavaScript is 100% necessary. Likewise for "I'll pay you if you show the ad and then the person you showed it to buys the advertised item within the next 30 days". L The ads market is a very complex and competitive industry. This means that practically every display side provider has their own special "ad product" to differentiate themselves. Almost all of these require JavaScript to implement their key features. In addition there could be 4 or even more parties involved in showing an ad (publisher, publisher's supply side provider, advertiser's display side provider, advertiser, plus miscellaneous middlemen). These different parties may not trust each other, so they currently use JavaScript to send (via `fetch`) themselves information about the auction to check up on each other.
- radley 5y ago"Acceptable" for whom? After AdBlock made their acceptable ads deal with Google, they whitelisted stuff like sexy girls and misinfo videos in the Recommended Videos side-list on YouTube. Fake Ublock is probably the same way.
- qoi24u5xnlqeuq 5y agoprevious employer had a hush-hush-don't-talk-about-it deal with ABP. $1mi per month to allow a subset of our ads all over the internet. ...which all the tracking cookies included. It was a great deal for everyone, but people who installed ABP.
- grey_earthling 5y agoPrivacy Badger may be useful to you. It blocks trackers, which just so happens to prevent some ads from loading. I've seen websites ask me to disable my ad blocker when I only have Privacy Badger enabled (on top of Firefox's built-in behaviour).
- __MatrixMan__ 5y agoI think so. You ask a server for something and it bundles that thing with other bits crafted to make you do something other than what you originally contacted the server for. It might exploit a buffer overflow or it might exploit a distractable human, but it's malware just the same.
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoYes, it's a bad thing. Because you can't choose what's acceptable, they do. You won't decide the topic, format, quantity, density, duration, nature or interruption type. Which is different for you, me, or your children. What's more, ads are not made for your benefit, ever, but to the benefit of the advertiser which may (but statistically more likely may not) align with yours. And also because: - the incentive gets twisted, which means you can't trust ublock on the long run. - unkown unknowns means down the road, some ads will manage to track you or serve malicious content despite ublock filtering. - ads paid content is a terrible business model which take a price people are not wired to assess nor realize they pay for something they disguise as free yet has an impact on the entire society. Not a great thing to encourage. And I say all that as someone who gets revenue from ads.
- diffeomorphism 5y ago> because you can't choose That seems like just an implementation detail. If users are able to choose/vote what is "acceptable" that seems like a concept worth trying.
- mundo03 5y agoRight, any idea on how to keep content accessible and people with paychecks maintaining it?
- BiteCode_dev 5y ago
- gorhill 5y ago> you can't trust ublock on the long run Why is this? Would you also say this for other long running open source projects which have never breach the trust of their users?
- tpxl 5y agoForgive me if I'm wrong, but wasn't uBlock handed over (changed owners? don't quite know how to put it) and uBlock origin started later precisely because uBlock breached the trust of their users?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoAs far as I'm concerned, all advertisers can go to hell. If a majority of advertisers had behaved themselves we would never have invented ad blockers[0] in the first place. This industry has proven time and time again that they are the scum of the fucking earth and cannot be trusted. I for one am tired of giving them any chances. [0] pop up blockers, originally
- dheera 5y agoYes this. I've had it with ads that pop up filling up the screen while I'm reading halfway through a sentence, spewing cookies all over the place, and loading megabytes of JavaScripts on a 2G connection. They can all pay the consequences now of me blocking them. If they had been well-behaved and stuck to inline ads with no cookies, I would have left them there.
- IcyClAyMptHe 5y agoTotally agree with this. Even if advertisers weren't tracking me everywhere (which is a whole other massive issues), advertising even at its least offensive is designed to generate a want or need I didn't have before. I don't need to be convinced to spend ever more money on the latest gadget, no matter how "cool" I might find it. It's all just advertisers revving that hedonistic treadmill. If you live in the city, advertisers manipulate you every waking minute of your day, bombarding you from billboards, on tv, on the internet, and are constantly shoving their disgusting garbage in front of your eyes in new ways; at petrol pumps, on your tv menu, right in front of you on a taxi cab. Worse still, the more you pay to avoid this trash, the more you become attractive to them as someone with money to spend. I can't remove the ads as a walk about the city, but for damn sure I'll remove them wherever I can in my home. Pi hole, ublock origin, sponsor block etc, all running to keep this crap out of my life. If people wont pay money for what creators are making, and they can't provide it for free, I'm fine with it going away. It probably wasn't worthwhile to begin with - only "addictive". Ads are a scourge and make me sick. There are no "acceptable ads".
- motoxpro 5y agoI'm happy to watch ads so I don't have to pay for Instagram, Google Search & Docs, Gmail, Twitch, Youtube and most of my podcasts. I wouldn't be able to afford it if I couldn't pay with scrolling of my mouse past such ad (or my data, no worries)
- notreallyserio 5y agoThe only ads I find acceptable are those served by the site itself. As soon as they load in a third party like Google, I'm out.
- celticninja 5y agoBanksy said this in relation to billboard type ads but it applies to online advertising too. Is there an acceptable rock you would allow someone to throw at your head? >Fuck that. Any advert in a public space that gives you no choice whether you see it or not is yours. It’s yours to take, re-arrange and re-use. You can do whatever you like with it. Asking for permission is like asking to keep a rock someone just threw at your head.
- bee_rider 5y agoIt seems complicated and pointless to keep an acceptable ads list, if I'm going to block some, why not block them all? While I only really care about blocking badly behaved ads, the easiest way to do so is to block all of them. Also, the fact that they are taking money to get on the 'acceptable ads' list looks a little shady. It could be (let's be generous) misinterpreted as a third party just elbowing in to get a cut of the transaction, like some kind of protection racket. I'd worry this sort of thing might draw unwanted attention in some jurisdictions, even if it really isn't warranted. Why bother going with the solution that is both technically and ethically more complicated? Just do the dumb thing and block everything.
- heisenbit 5y agoNot a bad thing as the word acceptable notes. BUT as the definition of acceptable is not in the hands of the accepting receiver but in the hands of the sender the word acceptable is used in a twisted manner. You are told it is acceptable but their behavior will be driven by forces yielding anything but acceptable. Ignore what they say - their behavior matters and incentives are stacked against your interests with no effective limits.